High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3592/1999allowed

National Ins.Co. v. Moti Lal Gupta

2019-03-07Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi3 pages

! "!#$%$&'()(( $&*&%+,&#! -.&/0 " 1..!**& 2!,%+%

$0* +. &" 3!,% 1!%.&"!& % ' 40 5

560 ,!%!& '

,7$&"!, 3&5+,$8"7# ! , 3!..!**&

, 5&8"7# ! ,,!%.&"!& &! ,,!%.&"!& 999

:; ..!*3%<!!& $*!"</ 3!&%+,&#! -.&/=$&% >," " !"((?.%%!"</ 3!*!,&!" ,##$"!& % *$-%,$<+&*8 ,$"<"3!,!$& !,,!

!,,!" %@ 3!,$<+&*4>,"$&=#-.!&% $& 8(8?ABCD & ##+& B(E .!,-&!& "$%<$*$ / %+

!,!" </ ,!%.&"!& $&- ,7!3$#+*,##$"!& &((?)#+%!""+! ,%3&"&!=*$=!& ",$7$&= ,+#F<!,$&=,!=$% , $&0D D(( :; 3!-$&.*!.+ , 3</ 3!&%+,&#! -.&/ 3! $-! - $&3!,$&=&()((?>% 3 3!&%+,&#! -.&/3"& <!!& =$7!& & !

!# $7! .., +&$ / .,7! 3 3! ",$7$&= *$#!&#! **!=!"*/ $%%+!" $& 7+, ,!%.&"!& G ! , *8 ",$7!, 3!

!&"$&= ,+#F >% & =!&+$&! & 3! #$,#+-% &#!%8 3! - !, >% ,!-$ !"</ 3$% +, 3!*!,&!",$<+&* =$7!&.., +&$ / 3! ., $!% *!" !7$"!&#! H+ =!&+$&!&!%% 3! ",$7$&= *$#!&#! $%%+!" $&

7+, ,!%.&"!& ! ,*&" 3!,!

!,8 %+<-$ $ %,!., !, #&%$"!,$&= 3!!7$"!&#!*!"</ 3!., $!% :; +,%+& 3! ,"!, 3$% +, " !" ()((?8 3! *!,&!",$<+&*3% ,>,"!">,"C,!., " !"?((?3*"$&= 3 3! ",$7$&= *$#!&#! IJ % ,!*$!" +.& </ ,!%.&"!& D>&!, $&

7+, ",$7!,D! , * >% F! ",$7$&= *$#!&#! % $ 3" & <!!& $%%+!"</ 3!+ 3,$ />3$#3$%.+,., !" 37!$%%+!" 3!%-!&" 3 $& 3! #$,#+-% &#!%8 3! &%+,&#! -.&/ #+*" & <! % !&!" >$ 3 *$<$*$ / ./ #-.!&% $& & 3! ,!-!& $&!" <#F=,+&"8 3! *!,&!",$<+&*>3$*! F$&=$& ##+& 3! # 3 3!

!&"$&=7!3$#*! >% $&%+,!" 3! ,!*!7& $-!8 ,"!,!" 3 !, -F$&= ./-!& #-.!&% $& 3!#*$-& 8 3!&%+,&#! -.&/>+*"37! 3!,$=3 !

!# ,!#7!,/ ,- 3! >&!, &" ",$7!, 3!

!&"$&= 7!3$#*! ##,"$&=*/8$%%+!>%"!#$"!"$& 7+, 3!&%+,&#! -.&/ &"=$&% ,!%.&"!& %&" :B; &! 3% .+ $& ..!,&#! & <!3* ,!%.&"!& 8 "!%.$ ! %!,7$#! &" ,!.,!%!& $& !,*$!, </ #+&%!* ##,"$&=*/8 ,!%.&"!& $%.,#!!"!"!I., ! :; 5$&#! 3!..!*$% 3!/!,8 3!,!

,!8-& $&#*$&!" "K+,& 3!- !,&/ +, 3!, :A; & 7$!> 3! >,"C,!., " !" ?((? </ 3! *!,&!" ,$<+&* 3*"$&= 3 3! ",$7$&= *$#!&#! IJ ,!%.&"!& ",$7!,D! , * % ,!*$!" +.& </ ,!%.&"!& D>&!, >% F! ",$7$&=*$#!&#!&" 3!&%+,&#! -.&/>%=,& !",!#7!,/,$=3 % !, -F$&= ./-!& #-.!&% $& 3! ,!%.&"!& C#*$-& 8 & +, 3!, ,"!,%,!#**!" ,##,"$&=*/8..!*"$%.%!" $&7$!> ,!%3>,"

:; " !" ?((? 3! !I !& 3 !, -F$&= ./-!& 3! >,"!" -+& ,!%.&"!& D#*$-& 8 3!&%+,&#! -.&/ >+*"<! *$<!, / ,!#7!, 3! ./-!& -"! ,- ,!%.&"!& D>&!, $& ##,"&#!>$ 3*> 56*$ +"=! ()(( -$ 63! 3!,%.!F$&=C,!%&!" ' !%C 63! 3!,,!., <*! ' !%C