High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRERA-APPL/48/2022allowed

Tri Star Hotels Pvt Ltd v. Curo India Pvt Ltd And ORS

2023-04-25Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu39 pages

! !"!

$ #%& !'

!("!

))

( * (+,-

) ./

%#3 !& 3"!

3(!#

"!#$ #%

%# "

) (*

( (

+ ( ! !,+- " !& 3"!

3(!#0 %

./0 %

& 23 & + , ( $%

- 4567,& . &45671- 8 &

8(!

!" #

& '&(")") !

* + ,- &

. ,

!! $ %

& % 0 12 !

* + ,-&

. ,

. 0 " $% # 3 3 45 ( $%%6 % % 3 17

8 "!9

" !

64654545 ,/ 9 - & + ( ! !

" ,& . !1- " + , ( $ %

456:,& .

&456:1-

& 9 .

/ "" : ;' 3 <

/ )!

=% ">/ & "7/

? 17

& @ & 4 3 &

;. ,

"""!

7 7 )!

1 - " !

"7/ ;

# &

"!7

- ")"

)

< &,A

- !7"

)

3 &,A 3 #

# 7

& & $;: 7"" ) 7

&,A 3 B 3 &

) !

& 3

& . !

& 3 &

@ & , &

. , & 3

# &

? ;.

& &

? ;..

# 3 17

& &

(

;

# &

? .

& 4C$%;*%*) ;:

5D&

? .. 4C$%;*%*) ; 1"15 0 ! 3 3

# ";7

6 =

E 3 0 ";7

#6 . %

;

# 0 ! &

! !

& !

8 !

& ( !

; ( &

9 (

6=5:4557 ,& .(

1- 8

;

> 8

8 !

& &!

& & &

& & &4567 ! " !

& 4567

! &

! % & (< %

# & "

& 66564553 &&

8 ! (

& ( &455 & 8> &

& 27 & 63:4,& . &63:41- (

& (

(

! & 2

& !( & < 8 (

! 8

& 53664553

& ( & 64654545

& ( & "

4:5:456:

8 8 ( 5364456: ! !

42 & (

& !

& )( & " $!( (

& " & $ 6==7 ,& ? & 6==7@- !

& !

& (

! > &

& 6=7A

& 64!

8 & & 6=7A !

( 8 !

( & 0(

(

(( (

& ! & +

" ,&

? @-

8 ! 8

(

;

1 3 9

&!$

$ -

,- ! 8

( ( & & 4567

& >

(

> ,- (

& 72

! !

B &

& 642

& 425

8 (

& &<88 862!

(

& 8

& 8 > &

8 ,- "

& & 4567 8 & & ( !

6=,6-,- & (

& # &

;! &4C & ;

8 ( & !

& ,- & C,4- & &4567 (

& &

(

! %

( 8

& & ( &

, - &

D 0

!&&

(

( 8

(

! 8 &

& 8 !

( ! (

& ! ! (8

:5E &

0 & $

! &

:5E & 72E

> & & (

! (

(( &

3,- & (

3 &

&456: (

,- F

0( & "( & @

!" # $% # #

&4567

( ( "

! D

! 8 8

8 ! @

( (

& & ! >

( 8

& ( +9 42654553,964- ,- F

& ( 8 .

1 ( C & &4567

8 !

& !(& ( &

0 8( !

6=,6-,- & (

! ( < &( !

! ! ! ,;-

' 9+ & , - ,&

.'+1- ;

( 8 & ( & "

8 !8 (

(

! & 8

A,6-, - &

&456:> D '+ ( ( ; &

& !

8 0 & ,;-

62,6-,+- 4 - !

(

& '+

& "

( &4567

& & !&

0 8

& &45678

( !

(

,;- ! 8! &

(

& & (

( ( &

0 8 & (

& & 4567 8

&!$

$ ! 3 ( 3-

& ( & 27 & &63:4 (

& &

& ' & 66564553,9:- !# & "

,A- & &

' & & ( &

455 & ,8- & 35 & 8 D & &

8 (& ( & !645&> &

(

( ! 8 8

( !

( 8(

8 !

8 (

!& < & & (

(

B &

(

/ &4 555 D& 8 > & 8

(

! 2 & !(& <

& 8 !

8 && +9

A5654553$56664553,96A$96C-

! 8 8

52664553

& "

& & 8 & G ,962-

53664553 ,967-

( & 8 8 ! !

& ' 53

& ( & 64!

8 &

64654545 & !

,- &

( 8 & &?

@ &4567 & (

4,- & / & & 4567 8

? + "

@ & 4,H- & & 4567 (

! ? + "

@ &

8 &

(

& ? + "

@ ! "

( 5364456: 5:5:4545

6=644544>

!& ( !

! ! 8

/ (

8 ;

6=5:4557 & &4567 & 8 &5652456:

0 ! & & ! ,-

(

0( ( & "

& & (

8 ( 8

( C & & 4567 (

@ 8 ;

8! 0 6=5:4557 !

( & "

8 8 & 8>

8 ,-

6= & (

< 8 8 & 4C 8 &

;! & (

45 & (

& 9 & & ! & (

(( !

(

0 & &

& ( ! & ,-

( & ( > (

0 & & & (

8( 8

( & & &

& &64 !

,- !& & & 8

! (

&& > 8 (&

( 8

! & 8 & (

& 8& & 8

9 ,- 8 & (

6=5:4557

( ! (

,- B

, G+9359

5545- $ ,- B

, G+9359 5767-I ,- F ( , -

! ! J J

(

I ,- F 8 & &

( & &

, - 0

: & I ,- F

( ;

! ((

( ! ! & (

6=5:4557>

!( ( &

( ( & (

' 6, 0 8 .%! 1- 8 8 99

&A= ( 66 8, & (=4 ( 65

* 8J0 ' 7:CJ:=6 :C7J37= A=5JAA:> " & !

4556954 ' AC4

(

* % '(

' 6 8 A5534552

& && & % &

&+ 8

(

6=5:4552 (( &( &

;92

;8/6 A

;

( & 8 8 0

?G@ ! (

' 6(

& &

( 62A

& 4 555 D & &

& 6425 K 742J9 D&( & ( & 645&(9

9G & 29

; 8( &

1 & ;

& (

6=5:4557

' 6

& 7

&8 9 ' D ' % G0 6 25 555J9 ,&&! 0- 537524 6=664552 G0 '( G G( 4 C 5375:: 5=5A4557 G0 '( G G( A 6 555J9 , &&!

0- ==667= 625:4557 G0 '( G G(

(

A & (

(

! & 72

9 '

6 F

;

0 D ' ==66=A 52534557 , 63534557- 4 F62!

& J & ( &

8 / & A 42 A FA5!

& J

,- 4 C F : !

& J & ( & ! & :2 0 2 B ( &

J !

:2 0 .

! & 25 0

' 6 , - 8

52J63534557

' 6 ;

& 72 &

(( & &

( <& !

&&! 8

" &!( 8

& & ( & 72

8 (& ( & 645 &> 8 & & 66564553

! # & " 8 9 &

& ( &

455&> &

(

8 &

(

8 &8 ! !

63654553,965-8 .@ @>")"

)

&$? :(

+ 45, "

** 30 F= : ? - ,3 C

;71

1 * > % " 1 B @ *

F 3

&,A

% " 1

< 3* =

:(@ & 45, *( 4

J , - 8 ;(

45654553 ,966 966J- 42654553,964 964J- A5654553,96A 96AJ- 56664553,96C52664553 ,962- 53664553 ,967-> 8 & 64 !

8 8

! ( & & 8 &

&& & ( ! 0 8

> D

;

( ( & ( & 64654545

( & 8

& (

6=5:4557 8 9

!# &'( ( () * +" $ ) 5 .

=.* % *$&?0@%

"! . B = 4!25

% =.* % G *$&?0@% G 5 .

*;%

=.* % *$&?0@%

=.* % G 7

(;4=,3 5 *$&?0@ % G =.* % G

. B 4!25

=.* % *$&?0@% G 3 % =.* % G

(;4=,3 5= B *$&?0@% =.* % G =.* % G

*$&?0@% G

++" . -/012/0$. -%1/ . *$&?0@% G 4!5 4/5 425 * &/

*$&?0@% G

3 7

4=,3 5 475 415 * &/

*$&?0@% G "7

4 3

5 7

(;43 5

% . *

=.* %

*$&?0@ % G

4 ?

5 =

1 *

% B *$&?0@ % G *

((

;

B 3 3

H # D+ +& & #

& % "1

0@ 6

(

6=,6-,- & (

& (

& ( &<

,<- &

9 ! 8 64 & &

(

;

L &

;

& 64 8 &

( & 4C & & (

6=,6-,-

8 ( L

& <

864

L &

; & (

& 64

! & 25 555

( <

1 /

8 (

(

& 4C & (

L &

( (

D ! & 25 !

6=,- 9! !

& !( & ,4- ,A- ,C- &

, -

& !

!! ! & 25 555 8 & &

,2-,7- &

! ! & 62 555> & 25 555& & (

. 8

(

& &

& ! & &

(

& ( & 6 555J9 ,

B !-

8 (

8 ( &75 !

& ! & &

4 (

45 & (

! (

& !

& &

! & (

! (

0 & & (

( ;

& 0(

! & (!

42 & (

&! 8

& (

& ) & " $!( (& 8

8 & & 6==7 8 &

& (

& 63654553

8 & !

((& & 6 !

& 53664553 & ( & 64654545

0 & 8

( 8 0 & !64 !

(

< (

(

! &

8 ( & !

(

( (&

(

0 8

((

( 8 & & L

L& ( ( "

A & & 4567

!8 & >

& &

(

8 ;

& (62A

8 & & " $ ! ( 6==2, & ? & 6==2@- < 8 9 D &

& A & &6==2 !

& (

& ;

( (

6=5:4557

' 6

(

> < J

> (

! "

&6==2 & < 8 ( & &

' 6 & ( ( "

5A5=4562 (( (=:6A

(62A

& (

& ( 66664567 &6==2

& &

' 6 8 ( 5364456:

&4567

/ &

(( &

((<> & ( & +

; G

70 -%101.41.56$.

1%/ -+7

8-2

-29-5- :194..% 0$1.%:

--7-%

:(&

. , *&?0 7 ;7"

;@ & : 0 2!//;& 4C5(*;2/! @& /;;!

"7 * >

# :(&

. , : ' 4: 0& 5 4% "

") 5 > < ! <

") : ' 4: 0 & 5 '

# '

% 21 < ':%@%

+ IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII *(; &

;7%0-10%.9-+-%0-00.

01- 19.%+1/ --7-% $0%1+4+$-10.4%07+1%-1+.- %..10% <%= ">

& &

. , *&? 0 7 ;7"

" =

;@ & <

(7 # %

% "7

# >; 45 & # ':%@% 5 &

< # % D

% "7 45 &

!1"

"1 !7"

!" 45 &

':%@% ( 3 # ':%@% 45

# 3

(

> 5

5 #

;

5 %

, &

*(; -$9+04-++1%-1.% 4$B

& %

5 0. %" !:= (?!!!! !:

, 0 !

""(

""4

5 * @&

? :

3 %

%0-01-10%07 -1.%/- 19.%+1/

8-2

8-2-+29-5- 0$1.%:3,- --7-%

.9-+" : 0 $%(!

" ("2"2 @> )"!!

:(&

. , *&?7 ;7"

:: *

;@ & 4& 0 " !;7 )

5 $.@>

* > $

#% "/%

# 4'

+ 1!2 7% & !/ )!7% 5 4 &A?5: ' A 0 & : J

@ *%*0

# >; %)( ( ?

2%0%-,-@ ,

# < , .

$4 @ 5% !

"1 '

# G '*

B '

. (*'

, & ,!

%0%- &

8 & &

8 <J &

J ( 8 !M G$N, - (

! &

& ( 62A

&&! 8

8 &&

B & ! "

( &6==2 &4567 ! >

L ! & 8

& ;

& (

' 68 ( !

D <J ( &6==2 &4567

! &( (

& (62A

& & ( ( "

A & &4567 8

4,- &

&456:

D !

! ! & &

& !H( 8

(

( 64654545 8 8

!&& ; &

0 8

(

& > ( 8 ( ! !) )D

63 !

(

( && (

. (

& ( & 8( & (

& & > !

(

! & 64654545

D !

6=5:4557

(

& "

,- B , G+9359

5545-$,- B

, G+9359 5767-

,- ( !

,- & (

6=5:4557

& !!

( "

& 4!

: & (

5:64456:

( "

;

2%0%-,-@ ,

A8 & 8

( &

H 5:5:45458 ; 9 ;

8-2%0-01-10%07 -1.%/ - 19.%+1/ +4

= 2 B2 ' )

!@,- $ ()

5&( C&) (0(?

DC&) ( 1

? !E,3!=#@ %0%- F> ( (!

%(%)( (

:(&

. , -: ' 0 & ?C

@ *%*0 4:

5 # ;"2

" :

0 )"211;)

" $.

& 8

* #>%)( ( % 0

C ;$

. ,+ $ (A ;

8-2%0-01-10%07 -1.%/ - 19.%+1/ +4

= 2 B2 ' )

!@,- $ ()

5&( C&) (0(?

DC&) ( 1

? !E,3!=#@ %0%- 3> ( (!

:(&

. , -: ' 0 & ?C

@ *%*0 4:

5 # ;"2

" :

0 )"211;)

" $.

& 8

* #>%)( ( % 0

C ;$

. ,++ %((A

( )( (

( )( ( $

# >; $

# >;

C ?$

. ,+ $ ( () 7 (&

$ ()

1 ( G

( ( - ) ("

C& 1'

C ?(H 1 - ?!#E ==!I

( 1' J'

(1' J'

C ?$

. ,++ %(( () 7 (&

$ ()

1 ( G

( ( - ) ("

C& 1'

C ?%((

9 ()" 1 - ?!:@=F#I 4 J'

" *&?

2 * % "/1

1) 1.1- =F %)( ( ?

2%0%-,-@ , % :!: ( ? =!, , 3

# <

$ 4 @ 5% !

# G '*

B '

. (*'

& ...4* "" ")5 $ 4 @ 5% !

G < ? ;+ (( '

( )( '

C&) (" (

(

( -

)( ( (( ( A , ' %0%)

C&A

! * "!

7 ?

/ % :

1 %

7 1.1- F %)( ( ?

2%0%-,-@ , ( ? = ,8, =

# <

$ 4 @ 5% !

# G '*

B '

. (*'

& ...4* "" ")5 $ 4 @ 5% !

G < ? 1 ( %( %)( ( ( ( ( ( %)( ( %0%- !E!F!F @! !E + (( '

( (

(

( -

)( ( ( ( ( ( ( = '

( ( , ' %0%)

C&A ;%0-01-10%07 -1.%/- 19.%+1/

8-2

= 2 B2 4( 4

!@ ' ) $ ()

,!: !@

? !E,3!=#@ C&) ( $0%1+4+$-10 .4

%.80$1%07+1%-1+. * 7 $4 @ 5% !

# 2%0%-,-@ , % :!:

#0>$

. ,++ %((

# >%(( @ "1)/2/) < &

? -: ' ?C

0 & * E %# * 0 4:

5 #

" "

K 0> $

( (( (

? : ' 0 ?C

0& * E%#* 0 4:

5 # ;"2

" !

# >; 45

L% B %K # $$4 @ 5 !

" 6 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 45

7 451 45

( (!

/"("!(!

!7 $

* 1 % 45

% 6 45

# / .

3 % @> 7 !!

!" *(; >&

$ () "

( & & B

2%0%-,-@ , % :!:A 8 &

6=6445448 9 ;

8-2%0-01-10%07 -1.%/ - 19.%+1/ +4

= 2 B2 ' )

!@,- $ ()

5&( C&) (0(? DC&) ( 1

? !E,3!=#@ %0%- F@!,F@F>"("!(!! %(%)( (

":(**':

@ D

,, '+*;/ .

& %

*%*0 4:

5 # ;"1

77 :

0 >)"2 ;/1"2 !:(&

. , -: ' 0 & ?C

@ *%*0 4:

5 # ;"2

" :

0 )"211;)

" $.

& 8

/:(%

C,, MJ;!) '

3$B

0@;""

"1 2:(' 0 3@ = &

? : ' 0& ; # ;"2

" * #>%)( ( %0

C ;$

. ,++ %((A

# >;

C ?$

. ,++ %(( () 7 (& $ ()

1 (

( ( -) ("

C& 1'

C ?%((

9 ()" - ?!:@=F#I 4 J'

1) 1.1- =F %)( ( ?

2%0%-,-@ , % :!: ( ? =!, , 3

# <

$4 @ 5% !

"1 '

# G '*

B '

. (* '

& ...4* "" ")5 $4 @ 5 % !

< ? ! 1 ( %( %)( ( ( ( ( ( %)( ( (( %0%- 3 E E ?,1

(( '(

(( (( %0- - % ( (

((

C ( &' (

(( , ' %0%)

C&A

&4567>

& 456:

& ( ( "

> !

(

( 8 (

6C & &4567

! (

& !

( ( ' 2%0%-,-@ , % :!:

8 J #

#9A !

, - " 8

' 6 8

&4JA

, 6C & &4567-

! '+

& , - & ( & "

, - !& 8 8 9 ,0 & $ (( $ (" ;

J# + 0 /!!

*%* 0 :

:( &

. , : '

@ *

+ 0 !

) *

"7;& & >; ,0 & $ (( %(("

. :( &

. , J;!/ '

3 $B 0 @

@ *

+ 0 "!

2 ;C & 3 : ' J

@ *%* 0 : ' 0 /2!

@ *%*0 >; * 0 0 D+ 0 J 0 % % 2! "" 3 0 17() 7 )7/(11 3 0 !!/1("(" 4";"15 !!/ ("(47;!5 !!/)(" 47;25 !!/("4/; 5 !!2)4);25 !!2("(4);"!5 !!7 (! 4!;"!5 !!/(!(" 4";""5 !!21(! 4/;75 !!2 (! 4!;")53"

2! "" -: ' 0 /2!

* ;

:# J

@ *%* 0

"7"

! "2"

% 2" ) 3 0 "/()"!

17"( 2) 3 0 !!/1("("! 4";"!5 !!/ ("(47;!5 !!/)(" 47;25 !!/("(! !;)5 !!2) 4);25 !!2("4);"!5 !!7 (! 4!;"!5 !!/(!(" 4";""5 !!21(! 4/;75 !!2 (! 4!;")5 3 2" )

0 /!" "!

" 3 !!2) 4);25 "

("12 7 3 0 !!2(" 4);"!5 1)(" ! / ) 3 0 !!7 4!;"!5 "(7!

" 0 !!/)(" 47;25 2"("

2 ! " 3 0 !!21(! 4/;75 ")(17 ") 3

!!2 (! 4!;")5 (7) "!

2 - : ' 0 /2!

@ *%* 0 :( &

. , ':%@% A@%C *

*%*0 ") !1 /)"(; 4 $ &

*B , = 0 5 ! 2

* 0 0 D+ 0 J 0 % 1 ( ) (

' 1 ( (( ( &() ( &( (( ( &' (

&' ( () ( ( (&

( (

( *(;

* ;

:# * 0 0 D+ 0 J 0 % -

0 / !" "!

" J 0 !!2) 4);25 "

("12 7 3 0 !!2(" 4);"!5 1)(" ! / ) 3 0

!!7 4!;"!5 "(7!

" 0 !!/)("47;25 2"("

2 ; ! " 3 0 !!21(! 4/;75 ")(17 ") 3 0 !!2 (! 4!;")5 (7) "!

2 : ' 0 /2! J

@ *%* 0 :(&

. , ':%@% A@% C *

1! *%* 0

") !1 /)"(; 4 $ &

*B , = 5 ; ! 2

" 1!

"1 1!

1 ) ()

(

( ( (

1 ( (( (( &(

(( ( 1 ( ( (&((' (&((' (() ' B( & & (

' $ '

( (

()(

( &

2B *(;

* :# "1 1!

1 / & '+

A &

& 456: 8 8 8

0( ( & "

( ! !

A '+ (

( 8 !

; & !

8 0 &

'+ L 8

( "

(

; &

A$62 &456:

8 9 =+

( & ( &'

)( (

C ,,4"5

* 2

45 45IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 45

6 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII = " % %

# =

K%K

$910%+ 01-+1.20

.-0.190502+10.4190 - 19.%+1/ !3 ( & &(;4"5 %

% >; % @IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII $ @

; 45

6 4&5

3 (3

# 6 4 5

#6 45

3 6 45

< 6

45 6 45 ; 45

6 4&5

6 4 5

B 6 ,5

6 45

( 8

& &4567 8

0 " &

53544546

! # & " % &

$% ( &

& '+ & 9 "%

+< ;

4H 5

! H

/ &?

;

& 1

'+ (&

> & & ! & & ( &

('+

0 &! & 8 ! 8 '+

' 6 & & &4567 8

&456:

! &

0( D & 8J B&&

& !

'+ !( & "

( % > & &! !%

!( ( J

( 8 ( &

(

4 8 8

(

& B 1 9 :,

( 4

( 8 ! &

! ! ?; /<= >,, ?

<) = )), @ &

8( 9 .

1 &

"( & @

?&5 :@, :,

& + * ?A0

666 3 08 8

9 *

& & ; & (

! ! 8

& ( &

& '+ 8 8

(( ( J

( &

(

62 &

&456: ; !

L (

(

( '+ 8

& !+ !

(

( >

& ( 8

! '+

& & ((

, - !

& &

; ! ! !

(

3,- & (

8 (

(

! !(

! ( 8! ! (( D

( "

J 8

! ( &

(

(( &

3,-

( 8 ; ((

! !&

! (

! && ( &

8 & (( &

3,- & (

8 ! !

!> &

( 8

!8 (

& ( &

' ,- ( !

& ( 8 8

: & &45678 9 ; ( E% ( )( ( ,,4"5 %

7 N 45

6 5

6 45

$B N =

>N 4%5 3

N 45

6 45

6 45 3

6 4C5

6 45

4!5

7 3 %

4/5 %

3 ; 4"5

# 3

425 %

N 45

* A

4 5

)6 45 3

# 3 ;4@5 45 ; 4!5 2 E 3 < ; E

)6 45

& ;

& (!( D ! & 4567

J ( & ! 0 ;

& & ( &

( (& 8 & ! '+

! ! ! 8 8

8 & ,- & ! ! 8

(( ( 8

( (( "

B , G+9359

5545-$ B

, G+9359 5767-

! 8 &

( ! & & & ( (( "

0 & ! !

8 8 ' ,- ( !

& ,-$,- ;

(

' ,-

D !

> (

> 0 !8 0 ( J

( &

,- B , G+9359

5545-$,- B

, G+9359 5767-

8 8> & A6 ( 454A

8 8 & &

( ( 655A4544 &

!( ! && .

;

&( ,-

( , - &!

) ./

!& 3"!

3(!# 3

%#("

F 0(J O

' F