High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1689/2005disposed of

Gurnam Singh v. State Of Pb. And ORS.

2023-09-2218 pages

" #$#%&#'() * + %(,(-#'()

('.#/0#12#%3 + ,%(41.5(67 #0505(#% 8.. .040#",(9424('07#%$ #$/('#(0$

%#$#(0) % 5(#$7:,14%3 '&-40#3"%07#/#0505(#% %4%4195040043 ''; ,(942 %.4(95&7453 '&-40#3 "%%#$/('#(0$( 0* <<<< 7# /#0505(#% 74$ 4//%4-7#' 075$ ,%0 "% =,4$75(6 07# 51/,6(#'%'#%$/4$$#'2>%#$/('#(0(+%#9#-05(607#-;451"%,0"0,%( 4;;01#(0"07#6&#%(1#(04--11'405(007#/#0505(#%

%5#""4-0$4%#074007#/#0505(#%?$"407#%#@/5%#'( A75;# 5( $#%&5-# 4$ .,/#%5(0#('#(0 %4'# " ,(942 5&5; .#-%#04%540

--%'5(6;>3 07# /#0505(#% 1&#' 4( 4//;5-405( $##B5(6 -1/4$$5(40# 4//5(01#(05( 4(,4%> 37A#&#%3(4--,(0"07#%#2#5(624(5(07# ,(942 &#%(1#(0 "% 0A >#4%$3 7# -,;' (0 2# 4//5(0#' 4(' A4$ ,;05140#;>4//5(0#'4$;#%B( * $(#>#4%/#%5'A4$&#%5( 0#%1$",;#"07#&#%(1#(0#$5'#(-#$74('564%7 '15(5$0%405(

#(#%4;; ;;01#(0,;#$3

7#%#5(4"0#%%#"#%%#'04$ ;;01#(0 ,;#$"

34$",%07#%41#('#'2>07#,;#$"

C3(05-#A4$$#(0007# /#0505(#%0&4-40#07#/%#15$#$34;;00#'075$;40#"407#%A75-7A4$5(75$ /$$#$$5(A4$-4(-#;;#'A#"+* +(07#(05-#'40#' +307# /#0505(#%A4$7#;';542;#0/4>/#(4;%#(0A#"

* + + 7#/#0505(#%4"0#%74&5(6$,21500#'75$%#/%#$#(0405(A75-7 %#145(#',(4($A#%#'3/%#"#%%#'07#/%#$#(05&5;%50#0505(2#"%#075$ ,%0#$,2150$07404$/#%/%&5$5($",;#+ "07# ;;01#(0,;#$ "

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

307# /#0505(#%A4$$05;;#;5652;#0%#045(07#7,$#4('"%,0"0,%(4;;01#(04(' 07#-4(-#;;405(%'#%5$;542;#02#'#-;4%#'24'5(;4A#",%07#%/5(0$,0 074007#/#0505(#%3(50$A(3&4-40#'07#/%#15$#$4('$75"0#'075$A( 7,$#( +4('07#/%#15$#$74%#4'>2##(74('#'&#%007# 74('564%7 '15(5$0%405( 7# %#$/('#(0$ 4%#3 7A#&#%3 /%#$$5(6 "% /4>1#(0"/#(4;%#(0A75;#07#/#0505(#%74$2##(/4>5(6(%14;;5-#(-#"## 05;;7#74$&4-40#'07#/%#15$#$

;#4%(#' -,($#; 4//#4%5(6 "% 07# %#$/('#(0

74('564%7 '15(5$0%405( $,2150$ 0740 07# /#0505(#% 74$ 5;;#64;;> 4(' A%(6",;;>7#;'07#/%#15$#$A75-7A4$%565(4;;>4;;00#'075$"407#% D#4%(#'-,($#;$,2150$074007#/#0505(#%74'(02##(""#%#' -1/4$$5(40#4//5(01#(0"%4/#%5'"(#>#4%"%A75-77#A4$4;;A#' 07;'07#/%#15$#$A507,0/4>1#(0"%#(07#$45'2#(#"5074&5(62##( 6%4(0#'37#-,;'(074&#04B#(4''505(4;2#(#"50D#4%(#'-,($#;",%07#% $,2150$07404"0#%

* +5##@/5%>"(#>#4%307#--,/405("07# /#0505(#%A,;'2#0#%1#'4$5;;#64;4('7#5$;542;#0/4>07#/#(4;%#(04(' 07#'#14('14'#2>07#%#$/('#(0 74('564%7 '15(5$0%405(-4((02#$45'

02#5;;#64;%,(9,$05"5#' C 74&#7#4%'07#$,215$$5($

85'#%'#% '40#'+ 3075$ ,%0 6%4(0#' $04>(07# -4(-#;;405(%'#%'40#' + (07#%A4$"5;#'2>075$/#0505(#% 0%#$0%45("%1-74%65(6/#(4;%#(04('&5'#%'#%'40#' 307#,%0 /4$$#'4(5(0#%51%'#%%#$0%45(5(607#%#$/('#(0$"%1-74%65(6/#(4;%#(0 7# 5(0#%51 %'#% '40#' A4$ 14'# 42$;,0# &5'# %'#% '40#'

* C7,$307#/#0505(#%-(05(,#'0--,/>07#$41#6&#%(1#(0 %#$5'#(-#A75-7A4$4;;00#'075$;40#"407#%05;;7#74$&4-40#'504"0#% -($0%,-05(675$A(7,$#5( +75;#7#A4$4//5(0#'4$4;#%B37# A4$--,/>5(607#7,$#A75-75$1#4(0"%4.,/#%5(0#('#(0A75-75$"4 1,-77567#%;#&#;4('A4$,(4,07%5E#'4$/#%,;#$#07404$5014>34$07# --,/405("07#7,$#A4$5(0#%1$"5(0#%51%'#%$/4$$#'2>075$,%03 07#=,#$05(A,;'4%5$#A7#07#%07#/#0505(#%-4(2#$45'02#--,/>5(607# 7,$#5;;#64;;>%,(4,07%5E#';>

0A,;'2#4//$50#0=,0#,;#$4('+"07# ;;01#(0 ,;#$"

3A75-7%#4'4$,('#%)

! "

# $

% &

( & ( &

& # & !

) )*+,- . /

0-*- "

,, (

! !!!" !!"#$%% %&$%% '

( )

*+ , +- "

# &

( ( !

(

)

( .- "

# & (

( !

*+***22.

). !1

4/ 5 6

)

( .

, /+- "

& % ' 8 6 9 4 69 & % !

( .

& /

: 4 ; 46)*,<*=0-** > 4 ? :

)

( .

1 (

+ + (

% & 1 2 +3

* 4(( + %#$% +

++ , .

( .5

39 7

, ' ' ' (

#&&57 ."$%! ,

)

( .

7 8+

" ",+ ."

, "

( "

+ 9 + :

' ; </+=(

4 / A

% )

%B $ ) ;

6 &

@ $ = +

, .+

+ " +

%>++

' +

" += " ' ((

(

0<C0--C

*,0--C!1 5 **

3 ' 7 # *

5 ** 3'

7 ; (

D 4 (

$ % 0 4

& &

( @ &

( (

+ 0- #

:EF*= #

4 ( $ #

@ &

C) = 4 ( (

*-G 5451C*<1%1 **0 5 5 *22+ +

' *-G

** *-G ) )02< 0+2<9 *-G

,-G @

@ @ ,-G

; @ '

4 # (

5 # H $ ;

& &

) )02< 0+2<

(

!1 ' 0 10 ! ; ; !

#1 C

;

?<@

5 5 4 $ B F% 4'

; 4'

F 6 5 F5.+ F # '' ! 8 ; 9 " 9 F # 8 9 '

( ( $

% & $

4 / H A

9 ( C-+0--0 % )

$ %B $

; ) ; 6 &

$ & <=0-0* '

I' 1

0 C @

& C "

0 C 0

' ' = * 1 0

$!&" $$%%! 9 + '

$!&"

$$%%! + ' /=

=+A, %&$%(

<9 $% B + + 6 *+ , +

- +3 C'

( * ;

" A, %&$%(

<9 $% ++ 6 *+ , +

= + + '

' + ;

& % #

& % ' 8 6 9 4 69 & % 0 10

B (

& % ' 8 6 9 4 69 & % # B ( <

0 ; 49 H; 4 ; 4 ; F4 !1 9; 4 4 4 ) I 5( $

)

I 5 % % )

%B )

I 5(/ A ; 49$ $ B ) ;

6 &

A 9; 4 4 % %B

% )

0 4 ; 49 4 1 (

) )2< *.02.

*<+

*-,22 C=, 2.22 +C- *,<0--0 ,-=

=.0--= 7 ( ! "#

3.,/%#1#,%0 74$7#;'4$,('#%)

3,C @

& &

4/ 4

4 ; & " & 1 7 ( $

"%# &

"07# /#@,%074$7#;'4$,('#%)

3, ; # J48D A & 45

& CC # 48D J7 (

" # '

07# /#@,%074$7#;'4$ ,('#%)

3=*

E? 8 / *

!4 +=2 C= 3C= ;

;

9 )

K # 4

(( B

# 9

@ @ &

; 4 & 4

;

*22<5 *2.*

7 + 7,$3 ( /#%,$4; " 07# ,;#$ $,/%4 4(' 07# 4"%#$45' 9,'61#(0$3075$,%0"5('$0740A75;#4007#051#A7#(07#51/,6(#'%'#% A4$/4$$#'307#/%&5$5((;>4;;A#'(#>#4%%#045(#%$75/4"0#%'#407"07# &0$#%&4(0075$"415;>1#12#%$2,0;40#%($#&#%4;41#('1#(0$74&#2##( 14'#4(''5""#%#(0$50,405($74&#2##(-($5'#%#'A7#%#5(07#"415;>-4( %#045(07#4--11'405(4;;00#'0&0$#%&4(0 * :##/5(65(&5#A07#42&#/%5(-5/;#$3075$,%05$"07#"5%1 &5#A07404--11'405(-4((02#--,/5#'5;;#64;;>%,(4,07%5E#';>4('5" 505$",('02#5;;#64;%,(4,07%5E#'3(0(;>'5%#-05($74&#02#5$$,#'0 &4-40#07#/%#15$#$2,0/#(4;%#(04;(6A5075(0#%#$014>2#51/$#'($,-7 --,/4(0

15(6007#"4-0$"075$-4$#34$(05-#'42&#3075$,%0 "5('$074007#/#0505(#%A4$#(050;#'"%,0"0,%(4;;01#(04"0#%7#A4$ 6%4(0#'-1/4$$5(40#4//5(01#(0#"%#7#A4$6%4(0#'-1/4$$5(40# 4//5(01#(037#A4$#(050;#'0-(05(,#--,/>5(607#7,$#4;%#4'>4;;00#' 075$;40#"407#%2,0504//#4%$0740A7#(07#-4$#-41#,/2#"%#075$,%0 5(5054;;>350A4$(02%,670007#B(A;#'6#"07#,%0074007#7,$#02# 4;;00#'007#/#0505(#%A,;'2#"4'5""#%#(0-40#6%>07#(07#7,$#7#A4$ --,/>5(6#$,;04(0;>37#-(05(,#'0--,/>07#7,$#5(0#%1$"07# 5(0#%51%'#%/4$$#'2>075$,%07#/#(4;%#(051/$#'A4$4;$$04>#'2> 075$,%04('07#5(0#%51%'#%A4$14'#42$;,0#7#$45'5(0#%51%'#%A4$ (0-74;;#(6#'2>07#%#$/('#(0$5(D (%4(>4//;5-405(A4$1&#'0 &4-40#07#5(0#%51%'#%7#/#0505(#%3(07#07#%74('374$&4-40#'07# /%#15$#$4"0#%7#74$2,5;075$A(7,$#05$(007#-4$#"07#%#$/('#(0$ 074007#/#0505(#%74$(0/45'07#;5-#(-#"##4$4//;5-42;#007#-(-#%(#' 7,$#4;;00#'075$;40#"407#% (07#$#-5%-,1$04(-#$3"%107#"4-0$A75-774&#-1#( %#-%'4('4$(05-#'7#%# 5( 42&#3505$4//4%#(0074007#/#0505(#%74$ -(05(,#'0--,/>07#7,$#A75-7A4$(04,07%5E#'07514$/#%$040,$ 4('/$04('7#-,;'(;>--,/>7,$#"07#-40#6%>4&45;42;#007#/$0 2,0(4--,(0"07#5(0#%51%'#%$/4$$#'2>07#,%037#-(05(,#'07;' --,/4(->"%1%#074(C>#4%$:##/5(65(&5#A07#/%5(-5/;#"()*+ *,-.

//0-1/0!,.2.

0-;451;#64;',#$"%107#/#0505(#%07#%A5$#,(4,07%5E#';>--,/>5(607# /%#15$#$ 7#%#"%#3145(045(5(607##=,50>41(6$0207"07#13075$ ,%0 '5%#-0$ 07# /#0505(#% 0 /4> 4 $,1 " $33F 0 07# %#$/('#(0G74('564%7 '15(5$0%405(4$4(#051#-1/#($405(5( ;5#,"/#(4;%#(07#$45'41,(0$74;;2#/45'5(#=,4;5($04;1#(0$ 7#/%#$#(0%'#%74$2##(/4$$#'5(07#/#-,;54%"4-0$"07#-4$#4(' ,670(02#0%#40#'4$4/%#-#'#(0 C (&5#A"07#42&#307#A%50/#0505(5$/4%0;>4;;A#'

;;/#('5(64//;5-405($5(075$A%50/#0505($74;;$04(''5$/$# " " # 15/6)/03/, ! 14104 7#07#%$/#4B5(6F%#4$(#'

!#$F 7#07#%%#/%042;# !#$F