High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2064/2008disposed of

Makhan Singh And ANR. v. State Of Punjab

2020-02-27Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

! "

# " $"% #%&'

( #" "

)"%(*%+",-. "

#"%+,-.

"( "

/"&( !,-0,#%&'

! 2(!," * 2 , # 2 ",32,"0%"(%")"+ !

" !," *+ 4!2,# 2 ",32, " 0%"(%", ' + '!% 56 4 7

%" #%&'89-

" "" "" -"!":# 2 3

"2'; %'. 2<%2!",3'3 2

-("(" % "; "( "2'2" "+ ,"%=' ( 2 ' :

"+256:" ",( :26"'"!

"!" 4 #3 /:( +! " +<2"

6: "( 3 %( " "% :; '% ; :" ((" '!=%",;2 "+)"+ ! !

#" 2" : : % ' 2 :22,' 2 ;2 !>' 2

#, 27 ' 2 8!2::"" ." )% %2 (" %;("+ "2 "( %=%;

2=% "

+(2(:" % ' 2 )+(2( ' 2 !"+!2=% ":"2 ) :" ( 2( )":2 ? (2 (2

" .";:("(" + ::"" " -% :" "+22;"" %"! %" .! +(2( :"

+289+",!"("

"( "". :" % ' : ;

- " +(2 .! " "+2, 22!%:("(" 2 %"

(" 22 %" %'. 2 <%2!",3'3 2, ( %+"2%( 22:"%((2 % " (" .%"

7 @" %'. 2<%2!",3'3 2

!"! "

%" -: 2 !%,"!+ "!2;, :, ;(2 !%2;2+"2 ): 9 "

. (" %

) '"! + !%2 %, (" % 9++; %": #A 6 :" !,#A /32. !,#A7 '2-." !#A '" !

A(" % . 2%

+ % :" " " %" 77 "

# ,:22"+!"%+(("!! +:"(% +'%;22! ! ;" ' 22;. 2. -% 2;.

) "2 %" "+%2 22 :! ( "

"+ A" " + " ."; A ; :

" + ( %B A"(::& +

" ."; 2=% " " +%B A"(" (";:(" % %"

"+B A"2 .'2B - ""!2" %2 "(","2 %" 22( . %" (" % !%

.&%!+

.' % "

%" -+ %"!

"! " %+(" + " ;" (; ,7C %2 + ! (;+ ,;22 %""

%"! "! " %+(" + "7;

52! ';%&%!+ . ""

,%(" ""((2' " %" , -+"", : : ! 2" - 2 <%!, -+"",: .&%!+

+((2

22 2!!!".,%C .(" "" ". ( ' " %" (";! + ' (&%!+('; %"'2 :!+' ;'=% "! "+!+

4 ". ( :% "( D ,:(%(("" %! %2

6."2" %2 "("'! !

" %!" "

- " . %%"

-,:"!2; ';"2 %"%(2';2" - 2 <%!, -+"" (" % 2 %

"2:22 %+";."!"

#A 6 :" ! #A / 32. ! %(( "(" % "; +"2(:"!" " ."; ' 2 2=% " " +( % -2 %!

' #A:"" 9+2! '2 %

> '%;% "!% %2 '" ;+"2 ( - :+ " " ." "+ ! " +" "' % %"%

" ( :" ("( , '". " . ." % (" 2 % 2( ++ ";% (! +

) '2 !

"(" .! ."'2 ++ "? . "2;'%:2(( :

(2"!"!+%2 ! (%=% +"

." "'2; "% %2 ) + " ." " ""! ::.( %"2"% %2+"%2 % ":: ( ("" 2 +"

6 ("( ' : ' 2 2;(" ''2 %!.';' + ': ";

"2 #A7 -." ! #A '" ! 2 "" ' " (" % ." 5%"" '! 2;? +(2(:" % ' : ;

)" ",22!"

-:" %2 22" " "

":&%!+:"!" . ("

- "(" ",%' %"! "! " %+(" + " ;"

,7C %2 + ! (;+ ,;22

%""%"! "! " %+(" + "7; -("% ;" 2'; %2' %.%"! + E; 2 2%!"+ );" : '. 2.; "

"+2 )" ","=% 2" %2 "".

"!.!+' (" ' ' "

)" + "( 2 !; :"" "+,"" ""'% -"+2"2 (,: "'2 ;22 "

""+ ::;"+2 " + ( "+ + + "( '2 ++'" ;

#" ' + (%"+2%" '". ' "' ;! " % 6 %"!

(" '". , ( "+!,' %2%((%''" %"!

3 ( "" '!" %>;"

" 4 (". % . !+22! "(" . %""" ! " " : "%(

"""2! '2;.%2!;"+

) ;"' %;"2(" " +

F" "%+, ' (" ' ' 9 +:"";%2!;"+2, ' (" ' !" +22'2'2 ':":

)" ", ". ( ( : + (" )+(%!&%!+"+ 9 ". " "" '"2 (" ' ! % " (" ;",%'& " %"!(" 2' %+

>,C: %";2 + % );"" (("' ""2 %" ".:22 %( '; %" :(" 9 ;"

+:2 ( ( ' ! '. %"

); " 2 '%": >,C )' ' %" '( "2 %":(" ": " + ;, ":". ( : %2' .'+ 2" <%2!",-+"": %2%""" :""!". !"""

;' &2 %"! "+!

4";+ ' =%"" "

3"&

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#