← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/17566/2025allowed

Shyam Singh v. State Of Haryana And Another

2025-04-01Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil12 pages



         



      

   

     !" # $$  "      ! 

" ##$ %"     &&&&  $  "#% & ' ' (

()*+,-./   "!(

  "

)(" * %+ (

   ,-. /

+ 0  * #     1 )/1)231) .41.5.,   '5'..5.,$ (

  

 -$'6$ .7    $   #    )/$)"

" .  (  8 ( "     "% "9 #   (

 0 :

  

        

 ! "

 # $ %  &       '  (  )      )        *$  +(  

   ,-."   / /# 0     

!   $  

  12    

  

  21"3#"#"4#  56 7, ,-,     -35751737-5751"8

2"#5755 4#0 9   : '  $ %   &

'$    +9 0    +  0(:       ;$ "

;#

'$$ !

'!    

  $      $  

      5;<       $ (  )   )

*+ ,-. 7,55753 1    = <  =   $

!   *+  ,-.$>)  3    $  $  

    7,55753    677 0    ! '(!

   

 $!

  (?   <'+ <  @ $+ ; 0 

76

75++  > +9'

$

7,7,6" =? *'    "=?*#(!

$  A+9'   $(  ($ $B( +

(0!  . '

 

$  !

(    (  ! 

    $!  

 

  

 !(   



(     )   $  B( +

(0!

!    = <  =     $ ! '!$  

'  

0

  

    ( $    

C ;<     ")$ '$$ # < '$    "

'$$ # 0      ' 

    '< !

( ''

(";

  ? $ (# ' $*' 2   

(   < 0 

    ! $   '$$   "

#   

!$       ; !(   0( 7,55753  (

 $     ! !   )  !       ; < 

    6  

  $  $   

:  ( 5C7. = !

   <  $ 

   ;+8"

< -677312#  0(

';+8   0( !

( B!$ 9  $  !   !  ( !

$ ( $ B ( ;<            !(

($   ( 0  

$ !   $!

' ? <  <' + <  @ $+  

 76 

 75 +  +  > +9!' $ 

7,7,6" = ?  *'        =?*#       !   A+9'  $!

$ ( ($ $B( +

(0

1 )$  

(B !     $   

       ( !  '

 ($(!           71"-#   (

$"

#5751 -        !  $ !   !  '



72   !(  7C5.= 

7,7,6=?*    '



 72   !( D'   6!$ $ !

'    

    , $ $

:  (  '

     !

'   $ $'   ( $    '   

!       ? <   <' + ;  *$ A +9 !                <     @ $+ ; > +9 7                   '    ( !     ($  $ B(  +

( 0  ! ($      ' )     !  $  !

$  

$ B (        '   



7,7,6 $!  $$$&

     $!  $$$ 



 72   $$   

($ "  $(

#

  $ 

      $ $$$)$  

    

(  

      0 !'(  :

$      5    !  !  $'   $$ 



72   !( *$            !       

   

   ?  < D 

( $   !

 ?  <  

    ' $ $

   

 



  $**    $ !       !

'   +

( 0 B ( ?  < 

  $ !   

 $        !  1     < 

  $(

 

($!  

  "(

! !

#  (    ?  < D$&



$   $ !

  !   







       $  **  ! 

    +

(0 3 '( $  !(   $  !$$ 

 

    !     '   ;+8  

 + 

7   !(    )  .   $ ;+8   

    

? < D  



($!!$

!$$  !  -,57<$ ! + 

   

 

 < D$(



($!!$ 

  "!

#!!$!   2.27<$! + 5   (  

  !  !$ !  177<$7127<$ +

1+ 3  ' (  !$  $ ! 1-,57 <$  

       !   $       

 B  ! ( $  !

 !  0* . 

 !! 

  ; <      

         0* .

< '$    

   ! !

  2 $

! +

(0 ! '! !    $ 

B  $!   (  $      ! 

 

($"  

#!  A  !     

( $ "$( 

# !

A 5 $!  !     !!    ! < '$     6       !     (      $

    ; '(  )

 =      !      

   

 $       !7 @$   -      $ !

 

:  (7.5.0 

)

!'

 $    

 !  !

( 

(  "  35757E=.728#('$

( ,

   !:

        

515753 !$  -.5,  *+  57;<     :



'    26  *+  ? <  <'+ <  @ $+ (! '!    26  *+  755753 

! (      '

(   ( 

$    '$$   5 

( A +"-,77$# A +5"2.27$#A +1"177$#A +3"7127 $#  $ ! A   A 5 "!

 

( $#  !   0* .!



 $$  ! 755753!   $  ! $ (

 515753   $  !   755753!( =<  =       $   >  !  $%  & 55         

 515753 !  '     < 0 

       '$  '

 



8

?

  %&8 515753  755753  ( = = <  =    $

'$

' !

 $ ( 51    ?  <  !     

'    26  *+ ( <0

  $            $ (   '   ! $  ? <        '( +

(

2      0 '

 (    7555753> < -7@ $+ '

   ! = @ ! ;9 

 +

(0(  ( $   $  +

( 0 

     ($ 77777   (  $    9 (  A '  = ?  *'  "=?*#

 7,7,6

  ; !(  !   

    '  B     $  !  $$$ &

  $  

($ ? <      

    $ -,77 $  +

( 0      !

    '

(      $ 

  !  ( 

 755753  -.5,  *+   ,-. 0 !     $  

!   53@  !  @  

 !         D B    ! '(   ( 

$!    5.      <  !     

'    26  *+ ( <0

  <     

 '( +

(0 0'

 (  7555753? < '

 !=@ !;9 (+

(0 0 !? <   (  (  (  $ 

 !

 (

   +

( 0   ($ 77777 *$ 9 ( =? *'"=?*#

 7,7,6   

      ; !(  !     '

3 B  $ ! $$$&

 $ $(



($  <      

     +

( 0    '

(   $

!

755753  -.5,  *+  ,-.0!  $  

!   52@  !  @ 

  !         D B

   ! '(   ( 

$!    56   ? <  <       :    755753  55753!   A  @=

&= *&F;4=$  !0 D 

$!

(    5-     

( !      D A  @=

&= *&F;4=$    55753 $! $ '  )  



(     21"3#"#  (((  

!  

 $

 !!+ +

+5 +5 +1 +1 +3  +3 "  $7.77$ +

(0#

 

 D  @=

&= *&F;4 =$   5, 

A + A +5A +1 A +3!

$      ! $

 D<<D 

  

  ! !   A  +  $  

$ ! ' (!  !$ 

A

 

+ +5 +1 

 +3  ! D<<D '  '$$ "A#    ;A ! *  $ 

A +A +5 A +1A +3

  

 +  +5  +1  +3   

( $ A   A 5   !   

  D<<D !      

  = $ 17

 

  .6  *+   $$     ) !   ( ;<          



 $ 55753 1

 

  .6  *+   $$      !   (   < 0         

$ 55753G 4+4/(4/ +4 45(.& )+)/.((/ / +4(   ;  (

#"     

"     %8

"    " * # #8 9 #  "     "*



# ( 9  (  < =(9

 #=(9 9>"9"##  4-7.5+ 

8"( +" * % $>" "

099 # (>(# (*9  ""  ("*8"

      "  " " 9  (  

    

 " %8 *

9"(  # " *  

  *"#"    ""  8

> ## ! " %   

 > "" %          9  

CRM-M-17566-2025 -11- 45(.& )+)/.($/&/(    " + ")($/ < +$ $8      *"#"

 0 $>"  (*"#$

 #(*#  (    *"#)/$)"

"

(*9  ""     9  9 (

# " *

$*( (#  % ("##  

>"   

9 #%  

% #*# "   9("  

  ?(8$"#  (

#"    >(# (*9 "" #   %#%  8 "  $ >" " "  #  *    ##8 #     *"#  "

    >##

"

 #     *8"

 0  ,4& 6* *  /"  98$

 """##   *

% 90(  < =(9

 #=(9

" 9

099 # (   9  #8 "

 9    * % 9"    "

  6 (

()    "# "*%$

"%   " (*9

9  *"#"

 %(

#$"

)( "

 

""(  #    "     ?(  $  "

"> "



 8 > "" %    $"

     *#      8* # (*!"

!

%    > "" %       > "

     >+9 8$ (

"

  #1 (8*

"

    "     "### * *8"9 



 

  %   (



  ,-.@.A/

$>" "  ( *#> 0

CRM-M-17566-2025 -12- BE0$              "#  (             $        (  $ "#    

  '     $ (

   !BH "#    

   (   (

 (     

   (    B!      

 $      (

   H "#    

  ' ! 

'      H "'#     (

    "1#   3-7 !$  I  >%$  9 #"  "       9 #8 > " "      !

 " %     > "

 

   >+

9 #8> "" 

  (

   ,-.@.A  /

$ .5.4$ "  

  *8 "

 )(  8 "## (9 ##8 

 ##    " 9 $"       

##>  %$  "' 

   !80' C""

+ 1     1 C""  *#   1