Atul Goel v. Central Bureau Of Investigation
! " #
"
! "
#$ %
! " ! $ %!& ' '" # " # & '!% ( % ) ') "
()*
'* "
()*
'%( " & '%+ " ,#
- " *
.....
" # " #+ / $ ( ( ) "
0
()*
()*
" 0 "
"/ 1
(
2! 2!*!3 4 %
45 6 ) % 4565 6 "
788 % 9 ) % & 3) +
0
(()*
# " " 0 % 98 1
2!*!3 4 %
45 6 ) % 4565 6 " 788 % 9 ) % &
0 1 "
%
: ( 0 0/ " ' !% (
" & ()*
0( " /0 (" )
0 0 (;
" 2!
( /(
2! 0 "
)<
0( ( " 2! /
(
0 (
# 0/
( "=* (
( (
( 0
/ ( 0 (" 0/ "
("
<
0( (
& " (/ >)%
()*
, 2! 1 ( 0 1 #
-
) ) " ?9 9 ) (" 0/ @ ; "" (" / ("
( 8 A) " " 7 A <
0(
0
)=
" ? #
0
( " ) )" / ) ( = ) ( ) 44 ?% " / 0( "" 0 " /) 0"" "" "
0( "" /
4# "" " ) "" 0/ (
/
A#
) "
/ 9 ""
%
A 8 " $0 5 "( ! 6 7A 5 & & 0 B C6 2!
" 001 <
" "
$ ( 3 C0 "= *.**./* '/*/0 0 / /1 "/23/ ) (4*)1 &(/05 *)5 *) /.0 6 "*/* '7/ .80*&(/05*)5 /.09:'340(0 3/*0,;+'< *8.6'/*/0 //* *50.*)5 /.09:
'340(0 3/*0 +*=35'*1056'/*/0 3>**/*)5 /.09:
'340(0 3/*0+'3)!.*///*60)/*!30*3 )60/8*/ ) 9 :'340(0 3/*0;+53()5*00 (&(/056 / * ) 4 */05 *)5 /.0 9: '340(0 3/ * ,+ .0(*?&(/05*)5 /.06< .)1*)5 /.09:-'340(0 3/*0 $ ( 3 6).!*>*>
6'/*/09: "9"0.:-+ ""
()*
0( " /0 (" )
(
(# "" " 2(BD)
( "
! 8 7 $0" "( ! "(
) " 0
<
0( "" " )
" " )
"( <
0( )
/ 0
( " "" " 2(BD 0
)
(" #
(
)
"
" /
=
( ' "=) / "
"" ( (
(( ?8 #
!
4A4 -& ) " 7 9 5 !
9 A 94-& ) ) / " "
6 # (
)
!
?94-& 5 9 A 94E 4A
46 # (
) ?7 9 )
" # / 0 0/
(
""/- )
=&9 <
0( (" ! A "
) /" ( 0
"" " 7? ?#
)(" 0/ @ ; "" (" /
("
!
A 8A-&) ( ) ) "
" 7 A
"
0( 2!
1 "
001
)"
% 8
F0
( # " ") & <07* ')8.". )
) ( 2! /0 1 0/
!
/ "" 0(
( 0/
" 3 0( % #%
%;56
% $'
@
% % "% ( (
(
" / ) " & >)%
/ ? &#$ %
%;56 = )
0
"
" 0/ 0/ ""
<) 0/
-(" )
% @= 1 (
0/
" &#$ %
$ %;
( 20/ ? # " (
" / " % $ ' % " % ( 0/ (
-0
"
+
" 8778 )
)
!
?
8 4A-&
( 0 $
0 ) - 0
;
("
)
= "
" " # = (
(
00 (
"
0 + 0/ <
0( " & ( + ) ( 0(
" % 4* /
0
" 0 )
(
0
0
" "
0
)
)
/"
(
"
)
"
"
"
#
' "=) (
" /
) & (
" / 0
)
0
"
0(
0
" 0/
(
0
) /0 # 0
) " 0/ (" /)
" 1 !8 * /
) + 0 0
0 (
=0
0/
0 )
& 3
0( &" ) 0
""
" # 0
)
/" 0/
) "
/ ) 0
0 " )
)
,
"
) 0 / ( " '%+ "
, # /
0( # ' ($
)
/ '- < ( 0/ * (( 5*6' ($
) ) 0 1 / ( ) ' ""
,#
/779# ( ) ( 0/ ' " "
,#
" / "
(
) (" "/ " ) + "/ #
)0" 0/ ' ""
0 " ) 0 )
" ) 0 ( 0/ %/ ' " "
(
7
(" 7 "") 0/
"/0 (
,#
)
"
$ 3 (
" " ("
2! ( 0 / ( " & >)%
) "
(* (( ' ($ ,#
( ?78#
) "(
( # " )
8778 % ( )
/
(
( ( 0/
+ ) G' "= #
@=
( ' "= # % ( H"( (
( $ " 01 / (
"
'-
< ( ( ) @& / @ ( 5 6 < (
" )' "= # + ) B2 !"0 D) " A/
( )
) %0 !
"(
0
)
0
"
'- @& /@ ( 5 6 < ( % (" / ) " )
(
)+ (
0
"
@ (
' "= # ) =
) ( ) 0
) 0
0
1 (
"
)
""
"
( ( "/(
-("
' "= ) "
0 / @& /@ ( 5 6 < ( # 2!
)
) 0
&% >)%
'- @& /@ ( 5 6 < (
" & #$ %
$'
@
% " % ( ( #
)
(" / ) %;
# )
(
" / ) "
)
" / "
"( )
;
(" / &>)%
()*
, 1
2!1 (
)
0
" ) ) (" / ) /" /3)
( 0
3
)
/"
" / # 2! 1 >) %
) 1 44 : )
" 0/% >)%
""
( / ( )0
0/>)> 0
) '- @& /@ ( 5 6 < ( ) "
0
-"
2( BIC B>C # " 44 " &
!" !"
#
$
%
%
#
$&
$ '
()
#'
()
! "
!"
# ! "
!
"
!
" $ *
$
$
'
()#+,+,
$
!" (-./0../
0--0..1
2
#
+2#, )30..3
(/30..3$ 330..4
(()0..4 $
'
()
#
$
!"
5
& '
4.. $ $
5 "6
7
(/30..-
$
89 7
$
$
9
$
7
5
$
$
$ $
2
:
;
< (4 2
;
+
' ,#$(-40
() #
< ()2 89 =
: >
#
& $ #
> < $ 32 $
$
30.2 #
$ &
%
< /
) ( 0) "
& ) "
0
((
0
""/
" (
1 0/ (
) "
0) " # " ) 0/
)
0
" 2( BC 7? ? )
/ 0/
;" 8778 ) )
;"
'- < ( 0 (
0/<)
)
2
("
0 %)
) " 0/ I@ ? "" (
4 ?
($
=
0
( / %; 5
6
"" " 2( BC 7? ? ( ! 8 7 *"(
)
" 0
"" "
2(BC% " ) "" " $
% #%
%;
560/ "" ( 89 A
(@ ; "(
2 "( @
,# 0 3 @
"(
(
( " ((
(" ("
/ )"" 0/ 2 "(
@ ; ) " 0/ " (
07? ? 0 " '
0/ " "
"
" /
=
( ' "= "" (
) 0 "
"
!
4A
4-&)" 7 95
- !
9 A 94-& / " ! " 6# (
) " ) @ ; 0/ '- < ( # (
)& ?7 9) 0/
(
4A 0/ % >I
%;5
@ ; ,#
# " ("
( ?9 9 0/
@ ; '-
< ( ?7 9 ( " ("
!
8-&)
( '- < ( "
)
% * 79? ( " (" /
" !
9 ?8 A4-& " 99 ? 0 1 ( (" /0/ @ ;
,#
?
?4 ?
44 ?# "" "
) 0/ " /
""
(" !A
" ?9 9 ()(" 0/ @ ; "" 0/ (" / ("
!
A 8A-& ) ( 8 A # ( ) " " 7 A# ) "
0/
@ ; #
0
) +
) "
"" " 7? ?
0
"
"" " 7? ?
) " 0/ I@ ( "/ 0/
(
0/)/ 4A # 0$
? 0/I@"
( & 0
0 )
0
) 0
)
"" " # " " & G7 ' 6*"
(.(0../ &
:
& $
# $
(1?0../ = *
< ' "" " ) "" 0/ (
/ A "
/ 9) ) " 44 ? %
A 8 ) " " & (4 2
;
+
' , # (-40
() #
8
()2 =
: >
#
& $ $ #
> "
$ 32
$
30.2 < #
" /0) "
& 0 @ " % 4
" /;
/
0$
) (
" # ( )
( (
% A 0 0
! " " "/ /0
/0
( %0% 5 6 % A " 0 " /0 ! /
0 (" / &
!
(
(" 1 0
0 ( 0/
) ) ) " =( ( 0
(" " "
% A (
(/
1
( (/"
0/)/("
/ ( (/ (""" % ( / % 8 " 0 " " " " 0//
) +
F / "
0 /! ( =" (" " (
0/ (
# "
( / ) / ) & -
""" 0 + 0/ ("
" /0/ +
"/ " #
" / ="
&(" ( "
"
)
0 (0( 0
"
F
0 ) ) ) ""
0$
/ " )) " ) ) #
/ & " ( 0/ +
&
)
" "
" ) /
0( 0/ F
/
/ 0/
"
0
(
" /0
/ ( 0 (
0(" )
, " / ) 0 " " ) 2!
*!3 4 %
45 ) % 4565 6 " 788
% 9 ) % & 0 1 "
%
0/ 1 3) " 0/ (( " ) - /
-& 0
) (" 00/ )/ " " / ""
) "#$ %&#%'$(
)&# *
: "+
- J -* : !"0 J -*