← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1000/1999dismissed

Risal v. Alam Chand

2019-08-13Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary18 pages

       

  !"#"$%&'&#() 



   * +#&#    

     %, -....



   

 

  !  !

  

"

# !   

  $$$$$ ...(  %





 & 



'()*'+++ 

"

,-      ,- 

   0

   

1      

 



)*)2'+3( ,



 

 

 

& 

*))*'++( 

/ !

.  4

 / 1

    

   

  

 

)*)2'+3(

- 

   3 )))0%"



6'(7

 )2)*'+3( 

5  

 "

   " 

    

   0

    

%



  







  ,

  



    -

&





  

  

)*)2'+3(" 

  0

    "

 

"



  

 

 !   6  !   " 

  ,-     

0

 

   

      

        8)9 '*   





 





 

 *) )))0%!

-"  

  "

   "

:

9

  '* )))0% ;

"

,





 " ,

 , -

    

  '* )))0% , &



  

  -  3 )))0%"

 

   

&

   '* )))0% 

      '

)))0%"-,

   





"



 *=)('+3+   

-"



 ,   ,

%!    "   

,

!,% 

 *=)('+3+ "

 

  

,  

>

 





  # "

  





  





 "

  *=)('+3+ 

"





,

 

 ;

  

 "- ,   

   

#



"  

 

&



 

   )2)*'+()

    "

  

  

  

 

   ?))='+()  ,-

!

 !, 

  

@

+

'?

"

!

 '8'

 

 

"

A    *')('+(= 

" 

 &

*('''+(=  : ')8 '+(8  ,- 

 ! " "

    '=)8'++*A

 "



!

 !, /

 '3)3'++* ;

" 





 <   -

,-"

< 

A



'=)8'++*"  

  ,

# B, !

  !: ''3*+ '++*4

,

  A      "

  -   ,- 

 # B,  !

     *')+'++*  # "

 !    : ''3*+   '++*  "   

- 

# B, !

   '+)='++2 A



,

     

   !        "

  



 B"

   

 - ,&    

   , -                 %



 







)*)2'+3(  

 , 

,  1   "



 





-

 



, -



 

-   -;



"

       

    "

     !     

,

"  -

 "



>

    

  

,

  

%! "

 ,   ,1



 " "  -,-

   "

 , 

"  ;

 





-

  

,-

   

 

 

  

-  "

      -     

   A



-

  

;

 

" 

"

 





"  )*)2'+3( *=)('+3+

      "



,-    "



!,% 





  " 



;











"

-  

   -"



 A

 

     



" 

 

  1 ,-

4  " "



   

, 

 %  C

", 

*2'+3(,

  !   

D@

 C

 ""-

-"

     ,    

 

     

D@ C

 



  - D@ C

   , 

 

D@.

 C

   ,

D@.

C

 "



 !   

D@. C

 

, "    -  

 D@.

   E  "     ,-  ,

        

 0  

    

  

      

  

    -

   



   

# "

  ,

  

 

 





  

B(B

  

A





 ,

 

B*=)('+3+BA



  ,

,

1 - 



"

-"



 ,  A

  "

  

 ;

 

 



-"

,  ,

 

"



,

   

>

  - 

        

  "

,- .C%'

  C  -

   

 



 "

- 

  3 )))0%"



6'(7  "

,-,

 "







 &



'()*'+++

  

 

 

 "  

 , ,  ;  

   

 

"  

  



"-

  

A

  ,

  

4 ,  - '+()

 -

  



"





 "

  

 ,

 

   

%

- 

 

,- 





)*)2'+3(@  

C%?

  

 ,

 

"   C%*

- 



F 

      

   .

  -

 ,



 ! 

    

 



,

  !   "

1   ,- 

     

 

    >    "

  ;

 

 

 ,-   

 

  

 

  



 ;

 " 





  





        

      

   

   .

  

  

!

 *) 

!   

 ,

,



 

-

 



1- 1







 

  

 "

 - >

  "  >     "

     ,

    

  

 % ' C

 

  - 

    



)*)2'+3(

,

 

- 

/

 & 

'()*'+++D * C

   

 

 ,

     "

  

  



 ,

D ? C

    .

 /

   

 

   

    

    

   

  

 

    

)*)2'+3(D ;

,

  -



  





)*)2'+3(

  



- 

 3 )))0%;



 -

 ,  "

&

  

 ,

  ,  ",

   > -    ,-

 0

  



 

  

 

,

  ;

,



)*)2'+3( -

,-  

 4

     "   

     

-      

,        

   

   A

  

    

  <  '

)))0% 

  



)*)='+()"- 





 

  

G!  

 

  "

,

  

  

    "  

   A

 

 "  

- 

   *))*'++(

 .

 

 '()*'+++A

  "

 '='**)))A





-

 

  <   

          ;



 

 "





,

  

 



 



  - "

,-

 



 

 



 

-  



;





  0

 

 

    "  

     

 

 ,

 

 

 



  



% ! "

-" "

 "

  

" 

   ,

  



 -   !

  

 -

  ,  

& 

'()*'+++ 

, 

 ;

   

  



 

"

,  

 





)*)2'+3(   C%?

@  



  

 ,



" < 

 ,  - :" 

- "-  C%*  

"  "  <

A

  

  C%=C%?

-  

 

"

"

 '++8

C%?

 

B"

  

  -

 E<%?

E<%=





"

   

    

C%?

  

"

B



- '+33%'+3(

 "

 ,

   - A

 

-

  -



 E<%=

E<%?@  

C%? 

 E<%8  *()('+3+



.

"

,1

E<%2E<%3E<%?E<% ="

F 

 



 



 





 

    

 



 

  

  <   "

C%* 

"

   :" .

C



" !

 1 " 





>    *) )))0%"





 ! 



-   '* )))0%"

:

9 C%*

 

3 )))0%",-   





" 

'= 



 "

  

  '

)))0%" A

 





   E<%? "   !   1     

     

 

   

  C%*  

-  

 

 !        

, 

       " 

 "   

 

      



  

A

 E<%= 

" "%,-:" ! ,

1 !  )*)2'+3( ! 

 

,

  







 

   

C%* "

!  1   



C%*

  !  1 C%* 

 1 "F 

   

A

C= -

     



 >  

 , 

 1

  "% 

;

  

- 



 

 

 



   < C%8H&-  4

 

 #"

E<

 

,

  

  



 "

 

,

 

 ,   

     

 @

 +    '?    

*')('+(=  ,-! C%8 

,

  



 "



,

  

   

*')('+(=

   



 

 1 ,-

0









)*)2'+3( ;

 



 

 !  

 

 "

  

    ,

  !    

  !    ,

 1  ,-! 

  ;



1    

- 

-  ,  

,

  



,1 

1 



   -  ,  

,

  



 "  



 

 - C%'  

 !  





-

  

  ,

 



  

  ,-  !  

  , 

 

  .C%'    "



 

  

  ,

  



 .C%' 



   

,

  -  



>

-  -

" 

 -

 

         # "

      % <    .C%'



 

  " 

   ?

8))0%

- '+3).C%' -

   ,-  

>  "

-   

"

 

:

 

% %



 ,-

 



  >

 >      



 -

" 

  

 ,

 

 "

  

     ,   

      



 ,



; 

    -

  

   

  "     

>

 

1 " 

 

 

  , 

   

 C* -

 

 

,-

  

  -

  

C?

  

 ,  

 B A



   ,

  ,  "



-







)*)2'+3( -

 

A

  "



"

   

   

   "



  "  

 



 ,  

 



 

 "  

 "

 

 







 





 ;- 

  

  

-



 

      ;



 

 

  

<  '

)))0% ,

 ,-

 

;

"

 

   '* )))0%" , 

 

  *) )))0%  

 

 

 "

,1%

 



 





 

 

 

;

  





*=)('+3+A

 

 

B(BA

 



  ,-   

" 

"

 -   "

  

 

"

 ,

 !,% 

  

  

  

 



 "  

-  

 ,  A  

 

 



   ,



 >

  -

,-

 





;





"





  

,

 

"



-,-

  "

 



  

 %



  



  

    ,-     



      -

A



  

  -

  

 "

  ,-

  ,

:    

 



 

  "  C%*

 "  

:   



,



 " 

 

   

 B(B""



 

   A        "    C%?

 @  

 



 

0

B(B





 , 

  

-  "





! - ,



 

   

  

*=)('+3+





 C%'/  

"



  

*=)('+3+

"

- 

< -   - A



   

  

 ,-

!,% 

 E<%'E<%*A   ,



- 

   



- 

 



 - 



  , 





  

 

 

 . , -



,

   

   - 

"



- '+3( !   

 " 

  )=)*'+();



 

 "  

  <%

 "

 

     &  

   

 "

  



      ?))='+()  ,- 

    !

  !, 

 /

  

@

+ '?

"

!

 '8' "  *')('+(= 

" 

 *('''+(= A         : ')8   '+(8

 

 

&    

  

@

+ '?

"

!

 '8'  - 



 - - 

 "

 - 

"



 ;

 ,

 

 

  '=)8'++*         :   ')8   '+(8 

  

 "

   "

 - 

 

"-

   

1 " 





  A "



 

< 

" 1 "

"



" -

A



"



  

!: ''3*+0'++*" 

-   '+)='++2 

  A



" 

   *))*'++(,-

/

    '()*'+++  A

 

    "  

   '='**)))A

 



" - 

# B, !

   

   

 !"# 





   

   

   

- 



 

->     

 - 

  ! 

 " <

 

  $%& 

 # '(

) 

  % 

   ,/012,) 3(4 !"4 4$)1 )  (

  

   

 

- '+(*   



 "-

  

  "  

 



 

 " 

;

  -





     





  "

 

- 



 "  

  

*2')*)') ,



,-# B, !

 

!

 





    



             ,

     A

  

         



  

-

   

   , 



   

  ,-   



>

 "

;

 





-

 

   

 

- 





-



,

  

  





,-



 ,&

  

,-

 ,

     - !  ,



 



  ,  "

 

  

    

     -

 ,

 ,

C%'   

 

!       

- 

  



-"  A



 ! 

-

    1 -

   

    

 





-4



   

   





-  

 

  %>



- ;



 

  ,

 "



  > -

 ;    

 B

,



   

,    

 

 

-    "

  



   

< 



 







  

-   - 





 ,



 -   

-,  



      ;



,-.C%'

"

,

  

>

  - 

A



 !  

-

 - ,&  

  

-,-! ,

     %

 ;

      



 

  "

-

 

 

   

  



)*)2'+3(

,  >   "



"

  

 0

  

 : 

 ,

      

,     -   -     - 

 -      &  

 

'()*'+++ 

  -

,-

     

   -

  / 

'()*'+++ 



 

 -    



>

,  -     -   *)'+ ... !  

 10

   I 0:

,  I 0: