High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17076/2005allowed

Parduman Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS.

2016-06-14Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

!"##$%&%'()

!*+,-!'.%'/0 #"%"%'#* 2#*&,& ."!"# ,'3!4!'+"0#*& #&5'+#'"&

*#&#'"(1 *60!""%7+8$!"#*"0#5#"%"%'#* &.%-&%0%*!90"*!77 ,'3!4 :::

0!99#'/#%'"0#%'&"!'";*%"5#"%"%'%&""0#*+#*+!"#+ <= ''#>,*#

1) 75!&&#+4?"0#.,5#*%'"#'+%'/'/%'##*7!"#* .,559? .!'%"!"%'7 @,+0%!'! 8%+# ;0%$0 "0#9!&" 5!?+*!;' 4?"0# 5#"%"%'#*0!&4##'$'&%+#*#+!& A1 #"%"%'#*!9&%-5,/'#&"0# $'&#B,#'"%!99#""#*+!"#+ = ''#>,*# 8%+#;0%$00#0!&4##'

%'"%-!"#+"0!"!*#$8#*? A1%&"4###$"#+!&0%&5!?!&'

C ) 0!& 4##' %>#+ !" &<C A1 !'+ A1;#

,*"0#**%"!'+!-,&%&&,/0"+%*#$"%'/"0#*#&5'+#'"!,"0*%"%#&" %>"0#5#'&%'"0#5#"%"%'#*'"0#4!&%&9!&"5!?+*!;'%# &= A1 *%#!$"&"0!" -!?4#'"%$#+!*#"0!""0#5#"%"%'#*;!& !55%'"#+!&!9#*D,'+#*"0#!"#*.,559?.!'%"!"%'#5!*"-#'"7 ."!"# ,'3!4'C= 0#*#!"#*7;0%9#&#*8%'/'"0#5&" .#'%* &&%&"!'" 5#"%"%'#* &,/0" 89,'"!*? *#"%*#-#'" ' C<

9#!+#+ $!&# "0# 5#"%"%'#*%& "0!" "0#9!&" 5!?+*!;' 4? 0%-;!&

&= A1!'+&,$0!-,'";!&*#9#$"#+%'"0#5#'&%'5!5#*&"0!"0!+ +,9?4##'&,4-%""#+;#8#*75&"*#"%*#-#'"5#"%"%'#*;!&&#*8#+;%"0

"0#%-5,/'#+*+#*+!"#+<= ''#>,*#

1) 8%+#;0%$00%&9#!8# #'$!&0-#'"*!5#*%+C+!?&;!&$!9$,9!"#+'"0#4!&%$5!?!&

A10#*#!"#*7$--,'%$!"%'+!"#+ = ''#>,*# ;!& %&&,#+%'*-%'/"0#5#"%"%'#*"0!"0%&5!?0!+4##'%>#+!" &<C A1!& 'C )!'+$'&#B,#'"%!95!?;!&%>#+!" A1!&' ."!'+"!D#''4#0!9"0#."!"#%&"0!"&,$0%>!"%'5!?!" "0#$**#$"&"!/#;!&-!+#%'5,*&,!'$#"!'43#$"%'0!8%'/4##'*!%&#+ +,*%'/"0#$,*&#!'!,+%"#>#*$%&# ,'&#9 !55#!*%'/ * "0# 5#"%"%'#* +,*%'/ "0# $,*&# !*/,-#'"& "+!?&"!"#& "0!" 0#%& '" 5*#&&%'/ "0#5#"%"%' !/!%'&" "0# #>#*$%&#"0#."!"#8"!&*#/!*+&%>!"%'5!?%# &<C A1!&'

C )!'+ A1!&' ,*"0#*&"!"#-#'"0!&4##'-!+# !""0#4!*"0!""0#5#"%"%'#*;,9+!9&'"4#%-5,/'%'/"0#%>!"%' 5#'&%'!&5#*"0#*+#*&+!"#+<= ''#>,*#

1) !'+==

''#>,*# ,'&#9&,4-%"&"0!"0#%&$'%'%'/"0#&$5#"0# %'&"!'";*%"5#"%"%''9?!/!%'&""0#*#$8#*?!-,'" A1"0!"

0!&';4##'+%*#$"#+ 0%&,*"0!8%'/0#!*+$,'&#9*"0#5!*"%#&!'+0!8%'/ 5#*,&#+"0#59#!+%'/&'*#$*+%&%'$9%'#+"!$$#5"!9%-%"#+5*!?#**!%&#+ '4#0!9"0#5#"%"%'#*;%"0*#/!*+"*#$8#*?!'!-,'""0!"!9*#!+? &"!'+&5!%+"0%-+,*%'/"0#$,*&#0%&#-59?-#'" 0#'E49#.,5*#-#,*"%'

!!0!+$'&%+#*#+"0# %&&,#*#$8#*?*-#-59?##&7;0#*#5!?-#'"&0!+-%&"!D#'9?4##' -!+#4?"0##-59?#*%'#>$#&&"0#%*#'"%"9#-#'"!'+0!+$,99#+," $#*"!%'&%",!"%'&;0#*#%'*#$8#*%#&!""0#0!'+&"0##-59?#*;!&0#9+

1C1 "4#%-5#*-%&&%49#%'9!; !*! "0#3,+/#-#'"%'"$!&#

&,5*! ;,9+4#*#9#8!'"!'+%&*#5*+,$#+0#*#,'+#*(1

$ % $ %& !

' ($( ' ()( " !"

(

+ '"0#!$"&"0#5*#&#'"$!&#"0#5#"%"%'#*&,/0"89,'"!*? *#"%*#-#'";0%9#&#*8%'/'"0#5&".#'%*&&%&"!'"!'+&,$0*#B,#&" ;!&!$$#+#+"!'+0#;!&*#9%#8#+*-+,"%#&'C< >$#&& 5!?-#'" A1'!$$,'"%'$**#$"5!?%>!"%'0!+4##'-!+# 8#*"0%-+,*%'/"0#$,*&#0%&#-59?-#'"!'+;0%$0%&';&,/0" "4#*#$8#*#+5&"*#"%*#-#'".,$0*#$8#*?;,9+'"4#5#*-%&&%49#%'

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

#"%"%'%&+%&5&#+!$$*+%'/9? 9,$D?

0#"0#*"4#*##**#+" #5*"#*F