High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5367/2004disposed of

Manju Sharma And ORS. v. Jatinder Singh And ORS.

2024-11-14Mr. Justice Sanjay Vashisth8 pages

$$ # $$ # $$ # $$ #

%## %## %## %##

# # # # # # # #

& $ "

# # %##"

'()(*+!

#,*-((.

,*),/ -012,+(

,..(//,*+)"

%5*1- 6.+,7 012,+(

*)6',*2( 19.,*:"

;;;;

# %##7

$ # %##7

* 0(':

16+)(+7 216*)(/ ,../52,*+),..(//,*+)

)6<95+) 5*,-0('+(*+/:7 4(,-*1+( 5"("

*,9( ,*=6

,..(//,*+ 1"7

'5+,9 #5*>4"

6'+4('

.15*+) ./(,-5*>)

?(// .',:('

2/,6)(7 21''(2+ *,9(

@,*=6 #4,'9,A"

4('(31'(7 4( .',:) *(2()),':

21''(2+51*)B,9(*-9(*+) ,../52,+51*"

//1?(- .',:(- 31'"

3352( -5'(2+(- 2,'':

*(2()),':

21''(2+51*) 4(,-

*1+( ,../52,+51*"

45) ,* '-('

6/( '(,-

#(2+51* 7 59./(,-5*>B<'5*>5*> '(21'- /(>,/ '(.'()(*+,+50(

-(2(,)(-B,..(//,*+ 1" ,*=6 ?B1 /,+( #4"

6++ #4,'9,"

55"

+ ,0(''(- -6'5*> .(*-(*2:

.'()(*+ ,..(,/7 ,..(//,*+ 1" ,*=6 #4,'9,7 4,- -5(- C"

/(,05*> <(45*- 4('

/(>,/ '(.'()(*+,+50()

)1* -,6>4+('

.,', ,../52,+51*"

+ 36'+4('

,0(''(- ,.,'+

+41)(7 +4('( *1 1+4('

/(>,/ '(.'()(*+,+50( ,*=6 #4,'9,"

,2219.,*5(-

,* ,335-,05+-,+(- "

((.,D #4,'9,7 ?41 )1* -(2(,)(-B,..(//,*+ 1" ,*=6

#4,'9,"

555"

1+52( +45) ,../52,+51*"

50"

%5*1- 6.+,7 -012,+(7 216*)(/

*)6',*2( 19.,*:7 ?41 .'()(*+ 16'+7 ,22(.+) *1+52(

./(,-) *1 1<=(2+51* .',:('

9,-( +4('(5*"

3+('

4(,'5*> /(,'*(- 216*)(/ .,'+5() .('6)5*>

,../52,+51*7 ?4524 )6..1'+(- ,* ,335-,05+7 ,//1?(-7 )6<=(2+

=6)+ (E2(.+51*) ,../52,*+) .,',

,'( 1'-('(- 59./(,-(- /(>,/ '(.'()(*+,+50()

-(2(,)(-B,..(//,*+ 1" ,*=6 #4,'9,"

+ 5)7 41?(0('7 2/,'535(- +45)

1'-('

)4,// *1+ 21*3('

,*:

+5+/( 6.1* /(>,/ '(.'()(*+,+50() ()+,+(

,..(//,*+ +45) 1'-('

.,))(- 1*/:

,//1?

,31'(),5- /(>,/ '(.'()(*+,+50() .6')6( +45) ,..(,/"

9(*-(- 9(91 .,'+5() 35/(- ,/1*>

+,D(* '(21'-7 )6<=(2+ =6)+ (E2(.+51*)"

3352( +,>

,..'1.'5,+( ./,2("

05"

)+,*-) -5).1)(- 13"

""""

'()(*+ ,..(,/ 35/(- ,..(//,*+)B

4('(5*,3+('

'(3(''(- @2/,59,*+)A ,)(

B 7 "

7 91-5352,+51* ,?,'- -,+(- C"

7.,))(-

1+1'

225-(*+) /,59) '5<6*,/7 1)45,'.6'

4('(5*,3+('

'(3(''(- @$-"

'5<6*,/A )((D5*> (*4,*2(9(*+ 219.(*),+51*7 ,2216*+

-(,+4 8@ '"

,++ #4,'9,A"

" " " "

'5(3/:

)+,+(- 3,2+) ,'( C"

7 ,<16+

""7 #4"

,++ #4',9,

-(2(,)(- ?,) .'12((-5*>

1)45,'.6'

,*244+,7 45) ,'6+5 ,'

<(,'5*> '(>5)+',+51* *1"

C 7 ,*=6 #4,'9,7

((.,D ((*, ?('(

31//1?5*> ),5- 2,'

,'6+5 F(* CC"

G4(* 2,'

'(,24(- *(,'

4(D,

,>5+.6'7 +'62D <(,'5*> *1" /1,-(- ?114,- ?'1*>/:

.,'D(- '1,-

*1""

6( ?'1*> .,'D5*> ),5- +'62D7 2,'

6++

-(2(,)(- )+'62D <,2D )5-( +'62D

'()6/+,*+ 59.,2+7

6++ '(2(50(- 96/+5./( >'5(016) 5*=6'5() ?,) +',*).1'+(- 505/

1).5+,/7 4,>?,', ?4('( 4( 6/+59,+(/:

)62269<(- 45) 5*=6'5()"

()6/+,*+/:7 "

-,+(- "

)(2+51*

B ?,) '(>5)+('(- .1/52( #+,+51*7 4,>?,',"

""""

..(//,*+),*=6 #4,'9

?5-1?

-(2(,)(-

((.,D

)1* -(2(,)(- ((*,

-,6>4+('

-(2(,)(-7

35/(- 2/,59 .(+5+51* #(2+51* 91+1'

0(452/( 2+7 CC

)((D5*> ,2216*+ -(,+4

,++ 91+1'

0(4526/,'

,225-(*+"

3+('

>15*> +4'16>4 '(21'- ,..'(25,+5*> (05-(*2()7

$(,'*(- '5<6*,/ ?45/( -(25-5*> 5))6( *1" 1<)('0(- ,225-(*+

H6()+51* 4,- 1226''(- -6( ',)4 *(>/5>(*+ ,2+ 1"

,+5*-('

#5*>4

-'50('

+'62D7 ,221'-5*>/:7 91*(+,':

+6*( )"7C7

.,:,</(

'().1*-(*+)

=15*+/:

)(0(',//:

5*+('()+ I J ,**69

-,+( 35/5*> .(+5+51* +5// 5+) '(,/5K,+51*"

..(//,*+)B /,59,*+) 4,0( 35/(- .'()(*+ ,..(,/7 )((D5*>

(*4,*2(9(*+ 10('

,<10(

'5<6*,/"

16*)(/ ,..(//,*+) )6<95+) 5+ ?(// ()+,</5)4(-

'(21'- ?,) .1)+(- #7 7 ,*24D6/, ?,) -',?5*>

)" C7 B.('

91*+4 2,'':

419( ),/,':"

'5<6*,/ (''(-

-(-62+5*> ,<16+ L (,'*5*>) +1?,'-) .(')1*,/ (E.(*)()7

,))())5*> )"7C

B1*/:

+1?,'-) ,**6,/ -(.(*-(*2:

-(2(,)(-"

6'+4('

)6<95+) '5<6*,/ (''(- /,?

3,2+) ?45/(

,?,'-5*> 1*/:

<,/,*2( :(,') )('052(

:(,')

91*+4)"

3+('

'(+5'(9(*+7 ?16/- 4,0( ?1'D(- 95*5969

:(,') ?16/- 4,0( (,'*(- 91'( .'50,+( .',2+52( +4,* 4( ?,)

(,'*5*> =1< +59( 45) -(,+47 41?(0('7 +'5<6*,/ 1*/:

)" 7

,2216*+"

4( ?,) ,/)1 .'59( 45)

2,'(('

?,) -15*> ?(// ?16/- 4,0( (,'*(- 91'( 2195*>

:(,')"

46)7 '5<6*,/ 3,5/(- +,D( 5*+1 21*)5-(',+51* +4(*

2,/26/,+( ,916*+"

""""

* 1+4('

4,*-7 16*)(/ ().1*-(*+ 1"

*)6',*2( 19.,*:7 )6<95+) '5<6*,/ '5>4+/:

+4('( *1 *((- 5*+('3('( ,?,'-

.,))(- '5<6*,/"

46)7 .',:(- -5)95)),/ ,..(,/"

""""

4,0( >1*( +4'16>4 59.6>*(- ,?,'- 2,/26/,+51*)

+4('(5*7 ,.,'+ 4(,'5*> /(,'*(- 216*)(/ .,'+5()"

4('(

*1 -16<+ )5+6,+51* ?4('( -533('(*+ 16'+) -533('(*+ +59()

?('( -50(')51*) +4(5'

1.5*51* ?4(* +4('( ?,) *1 2/,'5352,+51*

/,?

9,D(') -().5+( '(2199(*-,+51*) 1*A</( .(E 16'+7

9,=1'

5))6() ?('( '(3(''(- /,'>('

(*247 ,221'-5*>/:7 1*)+5+6+51*

(*24 ?,) 21*)+5+6+(- ,+51*,/ *)6',*2( 19.,*:

$595+(- ,+51*,/ *)6',*2( 19.,*:

$595+(- 0"

',*,:

#(+45 +4(')7 #(+45 +4(')7 #(+45 +4(')7 #(+45 +4(')7

505/

$,?

35*-('

M C

505/

$,?

35*-('

M C

505/

$,?

35*-('

M C

505/

$,?

35*-('

M C

46)7 .6'.1)( '(,245*> ,..'1.'5,+(

,-=6->5*> '5>4+) 2/,59,*+)7 >65-(/5*() /,5- -1?*

=6->9(*+ 1*)+5+6+51*

(*24 ',*,:

#(+45A)

)6.',7 ?16/-

4(/.

16'+)"

""""

+ *1+ -5).6+(

,++ ?,) )('05*>

#"""

*24,'>( -',?5*> )" C7 B.('

91*+4 2,'':

419( ),/,':

'19 (05-(*2( '(21'-7 5+ )+,*-) ()+,</5)4(- ?,)

,>(- ,<16+ :(,') ',*,:

#(+45A)

)6.',7 ,--5+51* J7

216*+ @36+6'( .'1).(2+)A 9,-(

(,'*5*>) 219() )" C7 N )"

7 B

J )" C7 O

)" 7 91*+4"

6+ ),9(7 D((.5*> 05(?

*69<('

-(.(*-(*+) 5"("

?5-1?7 +?1 245/-'(* B'- -(-62+(- ,2216*+ @.(')1*,/

(E.(*)()A7 ?4524 (E+(*+ )" 7 '()5-6(

?1'D) )"

7 91*+4 ,**6,/ 5*219( 219()

)" 77

1*)5-('5*> ,>( #9+"

#,'/,

#9+"

#,'/,

#9+"

#,'/,

#9+"

#,'/,

%('9, ')"

(/45 ',*).1'+ 1'.1',+51* *'"

(/45 ',*).1'+ 1'.1',+51* *'"7

# # # # 7

,..'1.'5,+( 96/+5./5('

,../5(- .'()(*+ @A ,3+('7 )1

,../:5*> +45) 96/+5./5('7 /1)) -(.(*-(*2:

219() )" 77

O )" C7 7

C"C"C"C"

()+ .,',9(+(') ,'( ,))())(- 2,/26/,+(-

,221'-,*2( =6->9(*+ +45) 16'+ +5+/(- #,*>+,'5 6/((9 #,*>+,'5 6/((9 #,*>+,'5 6/((9 #,*>+,'5 6/((9 0"

Q,'*,5/ #5*>4 Q,'*,5/ #5*>4 Q,'*,5/ #5*>4 Q,'*,5/ #5*>47

B-"

$,?

5*-('

B-"

$,?

5*-('

B-"

$,?

5*-('

B-"

$,?

5*-('

- M

C 7 ?4524 21*)1*,*2( )(++/(- .'1.1)5+51* /,?

/,5-

-1?* .(E 16'+ ',*,:

#(+4 ',*,:

#(+45A)

)6.', 5A)

)6.',7 #9+"

#,'/,

#9+"

#,'/,

#9+"

#,'/,

#9+"

#,'/,

%('9,A)

)6.', %('9,A)

)6.', #9+"

*=,/5 1+4(') #9+"

*=,/5 1+4(') 0"

$1D(*-', ,+41-

1+4(') 1+4(') 1+4(') 1+4(')7

"""

505/

$,?

5*-('

- M C

"""

505/

$,?

5*-('

- M C

"""

505/

$,?

5*-('

- M C

"""

505/

$,?

5*-('

- M C

/,59,*+) ,'( (*+5+/(- )"

4(,- 36*(',/ (E.(*)() )"

+1?,'-) /1)) ()+,+("

$1))

21*)1'+569 +6*( )"

(,247

5*)+,*+ ,..(,/"

" " " "

),D( 21*0(*5(*2(7 ,))())(-

2,/26/,+(- +45) 16'+ .'1-62(- <(/1?

+,<6/,'

31'9!

#'"

(,- ) (,- ) (,- ) (,- ) 19.(*),+51*

19.(*),+51*

5>4 16'+ 5>4 16'+ 5>4 16'+ 5>4 16'+

*219( )" C7

6+6'( '1).(2+) J B'-

(-62+51*

+1?,'-)

.(')1*,/ (E.(*)()

1+,/ **6,/ *219( )" 77

6/+5./5('

$1))

(.(*-(*2:

)" C7 7

6*(',/ E.(*)()

)" 7

$1)) )+,+( )"

$1))

#.16),/

1*)1'+569

$1))

,'(*+,/

)" 7C

P 1*)1'+569

$1))

35/5,/

5/ 1*)1'+569

)" 7C7

1+,/ 19.(*),+51*

,5-

B1 )" 7C7

46)7 D((.5*> 05(?

,59) 1<=(2+ <(*(3525,/

/(>5)/,+51* .'105-5*> '(/5(3 052+59) +4(5'

3,95/5()7

.,:,</( ,..(//,*+)B2/,59,*+) (*4,*2(-

)" )" )" )" 7C7

6.(() 45'+:

$,2) 5>4+:

6.(() 45'+:

$,2) 5>4+:

6.(() 45'+:

$,2) 5>4+:

6.(() 45'+:

$,2) 5>4+:#5E #5E #5E #5E 416),*-

416),*-

416),*- 50(

50(

50( 6*-'(-

6*-'(-

1*/:"

4( )4,// .,5- ?5+45*

.('51- +4'(( 91*+4) -,+( +45) 1'-('7 ,/1*> 5*+('()+

"J "J "J "J ,**69 -,+( 35/5*> 2/,59 .(+5+51* +5// -,+(

.,:9(*+ ,..(//,*+)B2/,59,*+)7 +('9)7

?4524 4,0( '5<6*,/"

+ 36'+4('

2/,'535(- *1+

.,5- ?5+45* ,31'(9(*+51*(- )+5.6/,+(- .('51-7 )4,// .,:,</(

,/1*> 5*+('()+ I J ,**69"

*-7 ,*:

36'+4('

-(/,:

2,6)(- <(:1*- )5E 91*+4)

+1-,:7

?16/-

.,:,</(

2/,59,*+)B,..(//,*+) ,/1*> 5*+('()+ I J ,**69 -,+(

35/5*> 2/,59 +5// 5+) '(,/5K,+51*"

((-/()) 9(*+51* .,:,</(

,916*+7 ,/'(,-:

.,5-

,*: 219./5,*2( 59.6>*(- ,?,'-

?16/- ,-=6)+(-"

4('( 4('( 4('( 4('(31'(7 .,'+/:

91-53:5*> ,?,'-7 ,..(,/ ,//1?(-

31'(7 .,'+/:

91-53:5*> ,?,'-7 ,..(,/ ,//1?(-

31'(7 .,'+/:

91-53:5*> ,?,'-7 ,..(,/ ,//1?(-

31'(7 .,'+/:

91-53:5*> ,?,'-7 ,..(,/ ,//1?(-

+('9) 5*-52,+(- 4('( +('9) 5*-52,+(- 4('( +('9) 5*-52,+(- 4('( +('9) 5*-52,+(- 4('(,<10("

,<10("

5)2"

)7 ,*:7 ,/)1 )+,*- ) -5).1)(- 13"

# %##

10(9<('

",9

G4(+4('

).(,D5*>B'(,)1*(- ()B1

G4(+4('

'(.1'+,</(

()B1