Bimla Sharma v. State Of Haryana






























































 
    
 






































 ! "#$ %
&'('() 
  

 

































 

 

 

% * +,
 -  







!"


#


!"


 
 


$ 
  %%%

 



&


 

 




'







"






'
 !"

& (
)*
"



+


 
,!
 !"


) "

*
 
-./
)








0
-./
 1*
'


/2 -+-
)*

"



""

 








)"*
)*

 4&
,!
 !"

 
)
5*

5

"&




 
)








0 1*

)*

6


'

-.7

3 3
)2*

 ,
 


 " 8 
&  9"


"

& 


4 



$   


: "
 
):*




&

3 2 -;

'




























































2
 





"
&
!

 
2.

-.7

  
 
 !"


"

< /+ --+

$
 !"


 "8




8"



=5

< /;

-+2



 "


 
, 
&

,>
? ;.+

--7



"


22/=3//

""



8"  

 

"
 
&
 
, 



!

 
/2 --+
 6

=3


:@  1





4
4&


  
 
2< /+ -7+
'

< /;

-+2 5

&


!


 
' 


:

! 


"

 1

'
6 
' 

 & 

 6
"



/2 -+-

&

+

 -./
 <
"

"



+

& 

 ""
!



 
 



 1
4 
' 
'

'




-+-

"



 


 


'
6 


;;/





"


727=/7/

-./


" 

 6
"

'

/2 -+-
!



 
"
" 

 
+

 
' "
!


&


  
&






  

"




4 




!





? ? $

4 $

"


:

 
"










22/=3//
! 8 


5

$
?

2+ -;.
- -+3

5 
A  
7 + -;-
</ ;

-+3
< B
 -;.
7 ;

-+3

:

 / 2 -;.

2/  -+3


A' -;.
2/  -+3
  




























































<

4 
'



 272@=


 -+-


"

 22/=3//
'



'







 2;/@=


 -+-





4 
'




'

6 

 ;;/@=




"

 727=/7/

 
 
-./ 1
 "
"





"



""

 





3
)"*
)*

 ,
 

& 




 
 

 


& 


'

8



 "


" 



"
6


"" 

 


'

'

 
! 
2///)3*
,
/<.
 " 

  

  
"


6


 3
)2*

 

'
 
 

 




'







"



/ -.7



'
!







" 8

6



 " 
'

:


 6








  

'
 




 '
!

&



 

"


'
"
 
-.7

 
"" 
"
&
# 
'

""






'

2.

-.7 ;

& 



" 

"



+


-./
 

"



 








)"*
)*

 
&





& 




6


 3
)2*
' "
'

""


 < 5
 
"
&"#


 
" 


& 
 







"
 
"




























































3

&

""

 
"


" 
 
 1
4 
'

'


 



 


 


-./
 

'

6 









"

'





 


+

 -./
 
"
&
  




" 
 

 "
"


&


"

 






&


 

& 

 " 

" 



"
6

  


3 3

 ,
 
" 
! 




"



""



& 

!"

'

 



  
&
$!
 "

 
, 
!
4





  

"
)

*
C
 " 

"  
 

  
"

"
&
  

 

 3
)2*

 
' "

 




'
"







 









"


'
/ -.7

 
'
!




'

2.

-.7

6


&
"

"


'
&
!





"

!


  

" 


" 






 '

 
 
 

& 





" 
 



"

'&





"


 +


-./
 
'
&


  
' 
'

' 


"


&




"


22/= 3//
'

< /;

-+2


 
 


"8

8"



=5


'
6 


;;/





"


727=/7/

;


-./
 
'
 6






























































7
"



/ -.7 


"




6



/2 -+-
'

&

"


'
4 
"






 

@


&


6 

 



 


 



"

 
'


"
'
 




&


 '
 

 
"
 

"



&



"




 

"


'
'



 
 


"8

8"





 "
"

'


"


'



 '


"
 
 



" 
 

  
"
"


&
""


'



 
 !

 3
)2*

 



&


 '


"
 
&!

(


6
'


8


 



&


  



"


"" 

 6


"





'

&
6 
 3
)2*

 
!"


&
 
" 

  
!

&


"

;

 
"


" 


4 

:


3 2 -;

'


:


' "
'
8! 


 1



22/=3//
'
"
 
< /;

-+2

"8

8"



=5

 


 
 2< /+ -7+

'
  




'
"
 
2.

-.7

" 


'


&
 
!
-./
 
'
"
 
/ -+-




!
 1
4 
'



:

!
8"



=5

'

 '
 


 


272
'































































;

'
 '

 


2;/


!


" & 


'




4 
'

6 


;;/



" 

727=/7/ + 5


 



" 

 6


"







"
 
/2 -+-

 

 +
)*


-./
 
' "



 .

/0#  "#1# 02 03##425#$,"/6#7 )*



 6
"





' 


&


6 

"" "

'


;
'


 
-+-
 
&

 
-./ 9


'







 





"

6 

 





6 




"

 '



'



 



 6

"
) ! 










"

*




 6
"






"
'
&

'
 
 )2*

)<*
666
+ "




 



 

-+-
 1
4 
'

 '



'



 

:



!


 








"
"






!D 

;;/

 


4 "" 

 


+
)*


-./
 
 " 
 6
"







"
 


'  




/2 -+-
5
! '

"


 !



&

 
 


&





 
 


&



"






 
 




8"
 

& "


 
"





























































+

" 

 1
4 
' 
'

 '
 


  

'


 '
 




:

'  '


"



:


+ E

" ""


 
, 
!
4 
 + /+ 2/23

 

,>
? 72-

2//
 



!

      

'
" " 
 


# 


! '
&


 ;


"



&


 

&
'  '




 

'
 

& !





' 
'
"
' 6
"




'

8


& !



6




 

'




'
8

 


4

"" 

'

&


"



had been given to him as a personal measure. The reasoning is flawed since the Rule makes no such distinction. Further, it has been specifically averred by the petitioner in para 8 of the petition that his juniors wi

8"

 



 
"

'

 

 
(


!


" 
'

/ -+-

4 
'

 


'






 


"
!







+


-./
 

'




"


'
"
 
/2 -+-




&


!


&


 .

 

 





"





)"*
)*

 
' "



 28/02   202/6/9




&!





' 

 
&!







 ="




 

'=
)*

)&*
666




























































.
)"*
)*
?' 
 
" 

  
'








  
 "
""

  

 


&!

 

"
""



"


 

& 



 "

 
 
"  



&







"




 
&
6 




 6
&!



 '
&



'


 ! 


"

 
&

 


$   

 

F"

'


   


 "

,
555
G
5


' "


'

'


 

'
!

" 

"
'


&


 @ 



 )*


 !

&= 
)2*

 3
 

& "&


"
'




6 

 
"

5
" 
'




  
&


 

 





 ' 


6



"


'








"




 
&
6 





 ! 

&="
)*
&!


H






666




























666
0#0'
666




























666
.

"



&


" 

&  




 
:





 


 


& 


'

8



 "


" 




"

 

'
& 

"



 


'

'

 

" )

*
 


 
&
 
" 



&
"

! '
# 
&
 
, 

 

"
)

*

" 



# 
&



, 

  
!

 
    
2//;
)/*
,,
27
'


 4 

 
, 







 

"
'

 

&




























































-

 
& 

 @ 


"


&



"

5
"

"
 


&





' 
'


'


@




 

"
 



"



'

'


 " 
 
/


4 
' "


 / 





"


"


 








"


 1

"

"8


"
8"
 

"
 
'


  





5
 #
A


"



I


"

 2///=<7//
'



"& 

" 

7
 

 !"

5
 "


, 
 " 



6




9
22)5*)*)*



 




"

> 



'





"


 
' 
'

:

'
 
!

&


  



"






"



6


' "
'


& 

 
' 





'


:"

"
"

 

 



 "


'

'


 

 

 
4 



4&

 

,
'

!


'  !





"

!


&



'

&

"!




'

& 

6
 3

 ?



" -

 

 

 


6


  3

 
' "



 /9 

2"2/02 :4# 1# 01;69##5

& 888 888 

 
&4 "

 !

 
3 <

3 ;


' 

 

"



 
 '


!



 





























































/

(
F

 "




&!







"



 '


"

 
&

=6 

&= 
)*
 



"

 "





'
 

"

 


 

'

"

=6



!

- 
3 3

 


6

"

&= 
)2*

8


 

"
&!



&

 "







"



 '


"

 
&

6 

&= 
)*
 



"
 "


5





 


'
&

 

!


 
"

 






6
 ! 

'


!


'

!




&


"




'

!




:

& 



8"




&

6






& 8 
 








9



 "



&!


"






&






"

 3
)"*
)*

 

"

&!

"

"



 3
)2*

"
 

""

!

"
"" 


" / 5
! '


"

 
"



""

 






"



+


-./
 
'
"
 
/2 -+-
'

" 8 
& 







" 


 


'




 
@  
& 


"

& 
' 

'

#


"

!

"

 
"

 



'
'

!


& 




 
  = 
 




 
' "
 
& !


'




 

6

"




 

 

"
 



'
"































































"



""

 







 3
)"*
)*


6


 3
)2*

 


"  
"" 

 






 2


"

 
")*


)*
 

!




 " 
























 -      < 2/27

 >
 # @

 J >

 & J