Nahar Spinning Mills Ltd.Ludhiana v. Commissioner Of Income Tax Ludhiana

  

  
 

 





   

 ! "## 
#$%"& ' (  

  !
 "
  !
#!
 $%&%'( 

$!)'*)+)'&),-!%'.$/01)(%2.(3

$4.($)&)/-/01)(% $(3%)55%,,)'(

$)*%&36)(13-!%'.$!()'/.'78'&%,)'/

&$./3.)&2.'/%$!)'/38-8'.$!()'/.'78'&%, $ (3%$%0%'8%  )** +,+
-, 3%)&&%&&%%.&.')55%),8'/%$!%1(.'  (3%
'14% ):1(-;9< $&3$(-(3%1(=)7).'&((3%$/%$/)(%/>;

5)&&%/ ?+  (3% 
'14%  ):  55%,,)(%  $.?8'),-  3)'/.7)$3  < $  &3$(-  (3% $.?8'),=,,2.'7&8?&()'(.),@8%&(.'& ,)23)0%?%%'1,).4%/

A"3%(3%$'(3% )1(&)'/.'(3%1.$184&()'1%& (3%1)&% (3%
3)&*8$.&/.1(.'($%0.&%)')&&%&&4%'(4)/%?+(3% ),,2.'7(3%/%/81(.' $41458()(.' ():)(.'

5$ .(& (3%
'/8&($.),'/%$()B.'78C&D (3%1(.'

$%&5%1( (3%)48'(& /8(+/$)2?)1B$%1%.0%/ $(3% )1(8$%/7/&%:5$(%/?+.(F

"3%(3%$'(3% )1(&)'/1.$184&()'1%& (3%1)&%)'/'

 )($8%)'/1$$%1(1'&($81(.' &%1(.'D (3%
1( )'/1$$%1(8'/%$&()'/.'7'(3%5%:8$(&/%1.&.'.'(3% 4)((%$ !(%$,.'7/&)&$%5$(%/.' G 
> ;(3% $.?8'),/./'(%$$.',)2.'/.&),,2.'7(3%%:%45(.'.' $%&5%1( /8(+/$)2?)1B23.,%1458(.'7(3%(): $%%5$ .( 8C&D (3%
1(F G"3%(3%$(3%)&&%&&4%'($/%$/)(%/ >D;

4)/%?+(3%   $  (3%  &&((  %)$  ;D;E;

 2)&  %$$'%8&  )'/ 5$%*8/.1.), ( (3% .'(%$%&(  (3% $%0%'8% & )& ( .'0.(% *8$.&/.1(.'8C& 9G (3%1(($%0.&%.(FH ".(3$%7)$/(@8%&(.' 1,).4%/-,%)$'%/18'&%, $(3% $%0%'8%$%,.%/85'(3%/%1.&.' (3.&8$(.'
> ;;;I "## 
#$!.

  /%1./%/ ';

 .' (3%1)&% (3%)&&%&&%%.(&%, /%1./.'7 (3% ,,2.'7 @8%&(.'.' )08$ (3%$%0%'8%

A"3%(3%$'(3% )1(&)'/.'(3%1.$184&()'1%& (3%1)&%- (3% /
2)&$.73(.',)2.'853,/.'7$/%$& (3% / 
<=(3)(%/81(.'8C&D E
.&)/4.&&.?,%%0%''(3% :5$( 
'1%'(.0%  )'/  )&3  45%'&)($+  &&.&()'1%  ' :5$(%0%'(3873(3%$%1%.5( 23.13.&'()(($.?8()?,%( 1'/81( )'+ )'8 )1(8$.'71(.0.(.%&?+(3%$%&5'/%'(H $(3%)55%,,)'(.&'(.')5&.(.'(/.&58(% (3)(@8%&(.' )&1,).4%/.&10%$%/)7).'&((3%)&&%&&%% %'1%-@8%&(.' /%),.'72.(34%$.(& (3%1'($0%$&+.& /%1./%/)7).'&((3%)&&%&&%%

G 3%  ',+  .&&8%  &8$0.0.'7  )'/  )//$%&&%/  .&  2.(3  $%7)$/  ( .'0B.'7*8$.&/.1(.'8'/%$!%1(.' 9G (3%1( 3% )1(&)$%(3)((3%)&&%&&4%'(+%)$.'0,0%/.&;D;E; 3% $%(8$'2)& .,%/';;

)'/5$1%&&%/8'/%$!%1(.'G<= (3%1( ' 9 ;;

(.1%8'/%$!%1(.'& CD (3%1(2)&.&&8%/'

D;;;

)'/.'58$&8)'1%((3%'(.1%-$%(8$'2)& .,%/';;;

3% )&&%&&4%'($/%$2)&5)&&%/' >D;;

3%)&&%&&%%2)&%'7)7%/.'

)1(8$% 7)$4%'(&)'/%:5$(%/(3%$% -)&),&%:5$(.'7 ($)/%/ 7)$4%'(&<.%58$13)&%/)'/%:5$(%/=3%&&%&&.'7

.1%$),,2%/(3% /%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.'D E
',+@8)(3%4)'8 )1(8$%/7/&%:5$(%/ 8( 
'/.)55%),2)& .,%/1,).4.'7/%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.'D E
'

(3%%:5$( ($)/%/7/&8$(3%$1'(%'/.'7(3)(,)?%,,.'7)'/5)1B.'7

(3%7/&?873( $44)$B%(()'()48'(&(4)'8 )1(8$%)'/(3%$% $% /%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.'D (3%1(?%),,2%/3%&( 55%,,)(% 8(3$.(+$%,+.'785'(3%/%1.&.' (3%5$%0.8&+%)$.'(3%1)&% (3% )&&%&&%%3%,/(3)((3%)&&%&&%%.&%'(.(,%/(/%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.'D E
'(3%7/&4)'8 )1(8$%/)'/%:5$(%/77$.%0%/ (3%$/%$-(3%)55%), 2)& .,%/?+(3%$%0%'8%?% $%(3%$.?8'),)'/(3%)&&%&&%% .,%/1$&& ?*%1(.'&
'(3%4%)'(.4%-';G;;>-'(.1%8'/%$!%1(.' 9G (3% 1(2)&.&&8%/'(3%7$8'/(3)((3%&&%&&.'7

.1%$%$$%/.'),,2.'7 /%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.'D E
'/8(+/$)2?)1B$%1%.0%/'4)'8 7/&3%1'(%'(.' (3%)&&%&&%%(3)((3%&)./.&&8%2)&&8?*%1(E4)((%$  )55%),?% $%(3%&(55%,,)(%8(3$.(+2)&$%*%1(%/0./%$/%$/)(%/

GG;;G3% )&&%&&4%'($/%$2)&&%()&./%/.$%1(.'7(3%&&%&&.'7 

.1%$(2.(3/$)2(3%$%,.% ),,2%/8'/%$!%1(.'D E
 '/8(+/$)2 ?)1B'7/&4)'8 )1(8$%/)'/%:5$(%/8( 
'/.)3%)55%), .,%/

 )7).'&((3%$%0.&.'),$/%$2)&/.&4.&&%/?+(3%$.?8'),'>;

- 3%'1%(3%5$%&%'()55%), $(3%)55%,,)'()$78%/(3)((3%$%0.&.'), )8(3$.(+3)/'*8$.&/.1(.'($%0.&%(3%$/%$ )&&%&&4%'()&(3%.&&8%

/%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.'D E
'/8(+/$)2?)1B2)&&8?*%1(E4)((%$

)55%),%5,)1%&$%,.)'1%85'%:5,)')(.'(!%1(.' > (3%1(-(3% &)4%$%)/&)&8'/%$ A
 


'/.&5&.'7 )')55%),-(3%44.&&.'%$ <55%),&=4)+1'&./%$)'//%1./%)'+4)((%$8( (3% 5$1%%/.'7&.'23.13(3%$/%$)55%),%/)7).'&(2)&5)&&%/- '(2.(3&()'/.'7(3)(&8134)((%$2)&'($).&%/?% $%(3% 44.&&.'%$<55%),&=?+(3%)55%,,)'(H 8$(3%$:5,)')(.'<1=(!%1(.' 9G<= (3%1(.&$%,.%/ 85'3%&)4%.&),&@8(%/

A
 

 23%$%)'+$/%$$% %$$%/(.'(3.&&8?E &%1(.')'/5)&&%/?+(3%&&%&&.'7

.1%$3)/?%%'(3% &8?*%1(4)((%$ )'+)55%), .,%/'$?% $%$) (%$(3%&( /)+ 8'%-;DD-(3%52%$& (3%$.'1.5),44.&&.'%$ $44.&&.'%$8'/%$(3.&&8?E&%1(.'&3),,%:(%'/)'/&3),, ?%/%%4%/),2)+&(3)0%%:(%'/%/(&8134)((%$&)&3)/ '(?%%'1'&./%$%/)'//%1./%/.'&813)55%),H $(3%$%0%'8%/% %'/%/(3%$/%$&&()(.'7 (3)((3%.&&8%?% $%(3%&( 55%,,)(%8(3$.(+2)&'(2.(3$%7)$/( /%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.'D E
'/8(+/$)2?)1B-$)(3%$.(2)&&%.J%/ (3% .&&8%A23%(3%$/%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.' D E
.&)0).,)?,%'(3%7/& 58$13)&%/ $44)$B%()'/%:5$(%/8( 
'/.)F

> $(3%)55%,,)'(1'(%'/%/(3)((3%.&&8%2.(3 $%7)$/(/%/81(.''.'1%'(.0%)&)23,%2)&?% $%(3%&( 55%,,)(% 8(3$.(+)'/18,/'(?%()B%'85.'$%0.&.'%5,)1%&$%,.)'1%85'(3% /%1.&.'    8*)$)(  .73  8$(  .' "##   
#/$  !     "/   0  1'  2    %

3&  43

$# 35%-'6& 3%1'(%'(.'$).&%/?+,%)$'%/18'&%, $(3%)55%,,)'(,)1B& 4%$.( 3%$% .&  '  /.&58(% '  (3% )1(  (3)(  (3% &&%&&.'7  

.1%$ 3)/ $%&($.1(%//%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.'D E
',+@8)(3%7/&4)'8 )'/%:5$(%/
(.&)4)((%$ $%1$/(3)((3%&&%&&.'7

.1%$ 23.,% $%&($.1(.'7(3%/%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.'D E
),,2%//%/81(.''/8(+/$)2 ?)1B.'$%&5%1( (3%7/&4)'8 )1(8$%/)'/%:5$(%/3%&(55%,,)(% 8(3$.(+'(%/(3%1'(%'(.' (3%)&&%&&%%(3)((3%/.&58(%2)&(3)((3% )&&%&&%%1,).4%//%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.'D E
'(3%7/&?873( $4 4)$B%()'/%:5$(%/3%55%,,)(%8(3$.(+3%,/(3)((3%)&&%&&%%.& %'(.(,%/(/%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.'D E
 5$5$(.')(%,+'(3%7/& )1(8$%/)'/%:5$(%/3%/.&E),,2)'1% /%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.'

E
'(3%7/&58$13)&%/ $44)$B%()'/%:5$(%/2)&853%,/ 3%$.?8'),$.73(,+?&%$0%/(3)((3%.&&8%23%(3%$/%/81(.' 8'/%$!%1(.'D E
.&)0).,)?,%'/8(+/$)2?)1B'4)'8 )1(8$%/7/& 2)&'%0%$&5%1.

.1),,+/%),(.')55%),3%$%2)&'11)&.' $$).&.'7(3% .&&8%)&(3%/%/81(.'2)&),,2%/?+(3%&&%&&.'7

.1%$ 3%$%.&'@8.??,%(3)((3%44.&&.'%$<55%),&=)&5%$(3% %:5,)')(.'(!%1(.' > (3%1(1)'1'&./%$(3%4)((%$)$.&.'78(

(3%5$1%%/.'7&.'23.13(3%)55%),.& .,%/.$$%&5%1(.0% (3% )1((3)((3% &)./4)((%$3)&'(?%%'$).&%/?+(3%)55%,,)'(3%$%.&),&'/.&58(%

9 (3)()&5%$%:5,)')(.'<1=(!%1(.' 9G<=-(3%$%0.&.'1)''(?%/'%  (3%.&&8%23.133)&?%%'1'&./%$%/)'//%1./%/.')55%),
'(3%5$%&%'( 1)&%-(3%.&&8%23%(3%$(3%)&&%&&%%2)&%'(.(,%/(/%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.' (3%1('/8(+/$)2?)1B2.(3$%7)$/(7/&4)'8 )1(8$%/)'/ %:5$(%/2)&'%.(3%$1'&./%$%/'$/%1./%/.')55%), 3%$%,.)'1%'1%$().'5)$( (3%$/%$?+,%)$'%/18'&%, $ (3%)55%,,)'(.&'(2%,, 8'/%/3%&)./?&%$0)(.'&2%$%0.&E)E0.&(3% 5$5$(.')(%/%/81(.'8'/%$!%1(.'D E
 @8)(3%7/&4)'8 )'/  %:5$(%/  3%  $%,.)'1%  '  (3%  /%1.&.'    8*)$)(  .73  8$(  .'

 "/ 01'2 7%'

&/%& '(%'3)'1%(3%1)&% (3%)&&%&&%%-)&),$%)/+/.&18&&%/-(3%.&&8%()B%' 85.'$%0.&.'2)&'(&8?*%1(4)((%$ )55%), 3%)55%),.&/.&4.&&%/ %)** +,+
-&%,8*9(
& ,2 -*,2 -*



4B "3%(3%$&5%)B.'7C$%)&'%/

%&C "3%(3%$$%5$()?,%

%&C