Mam Chand And Anothers v. Karan Singh And Others

FAO-5606-2004 (O&M)


















 224 







 
 
















































































 
  FAO-5606-2004 (O&M)














!
"#$# %&'()( MAM CHAND

 










(((((**++ % $
, --
KARAN SINGH

 -
















((((($* %.% $

& /0
(
-

- ,
-
 

  
 
  





 
 



 
  !

""""

- ,
-
 1
(
2 03

  #
 
 

$
%%
&

 


'('




)**


+&


'

 %  

,

For the reasons mentioned in the application, the same is allowed and legal representatives of appellant No.1-Mam Chand (since deceased) and Krishna (since deceased) i.e. Mukesh Kumar and Smt. Sonia are ordered to be impleaded as legal representatives of above said appellants.

FAO-5606-2004 (O&M)


















 Amended memo of parties is taken on record, subject to all just exceptions. Application stands disposed of.

FAO-5071-2005 '

The record of the present case was destroyed in a fire incident in the High Court Branch. Learned counsel for the appellants/claimants has placed a copy of award in the Court, which is taken on record. Registry is directed to tag the same at an appropriate place on the record. %

#
 
 
)

* 


 
%- .- %../ 
  

  



#
'/0

%..


)!



#
1* 
2! 4
$5 4
64#78% +93





'44



5

'600





& '(....7
 
)

   


 7 
*




 

68





 

*

 


 9 



  


 !

:




 


;

 *

 
*


 
)!

 

#
  

     

     

    

 

 



 

    

!"# $ 

 %  & '((    % 

   

)% *  

 ) 

  ) )&'((

FAO-5606-2004 (O&M)


















)   %       

 

  

    

     

  ) 

  + *     & '(  

 /

# 

 






 

(


 *

 

**
*

 


  
#) 




& '(....7

  

  7




 


:

*

 :
68




 

*

 


 9

;*
**

 

 
 
)

#

 


 
)


 
 
)
 

-






 





 

 #) 
 
*
)






<*

= 




 
 

)



) 


 



)!
 #) 


 *


#
!

>

)
 



 
  

 

 
#


 
* *








>

)


 


#)   
 !



'
 


 




 


**
*


 


'

*

* 
) *
<& (' ? '4.0* 
)!

%


 


!
 
)

 )

 !
  
@!
  !


 

 )@
 
)

)!


FAO-5606-2004 (O&M)


















  **

 
*
*!
*


'


> 
)



+ 




*
 

 *
 

  

& '(....7
 
)


) 
 @

 


 )

)



 

   

)

+ 


 
 
  '-
! 

*
)

#) 
 


 



 
 
) 
*

& '(...7



*
'7 
 

 
 
A
#) 



'(






& '(....7

 
+ 

A
  
 
 



'.B'

 
'-
! 

*


  
 
)



) 

 *
)*
 

C
C
 
 

< !

 
#) 
* !

)!
 *

 
 
 )
& '(...7


+ 


 
  
 

 
 
)




+ 

 
 
 
 
'-
! 

*



'0

  )

 



'(


)!

#)    
 
)



 
 
 

  


 

 
A


 !
 
  )
 )!
 
In support of his contentions, learned counsel for the appellants has relied upon 2025 ACJ 1624 titled Karuna Parmar Vs. Prakash Sinha and others, 2009(6) SCC 121 Sarla Verma and others Vs. Delhi

FAO-5606-2004 (O&M)


















' Transport Corporation and Another, 2017 (16) SCC 680 National Insurance Co. Ltd Vs. Pranay Sethi and Other, 2018 (4) R.C.R. (Civil) 333 Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram alias Chuhru Ram & Others and (2021) 11 SCC 780 United India Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Satinder Kaur. '.

$


 
 




*
  
> 
  
 
)

)!

 
#) 

 


 


 

 

 
)
 

''

#

D@
  E
 
)
 ) 
)!
<E)  


23
 
2 #:#+3
;<
231
-=.
 $54
5 >.
%.

54$
,$(
 5.(
 >+
%.
% 54


 
)

 

*   




  
 

#) 

   

 

)
@
#
A
F
 

)
@G 





#) 




  
   








  
#) 

 

  
) !


*
 
 *

  

  
 
)


 

*




) 
* 

 

)


)









 







) 



 )

 !
  

 
  
   



)

) 



 

 

 )*

  )

A

FAO-5606-2004 (O&M)


















 )



)!



 
 
)


   
!  !
*!

)
 
)

**
 
  *

 



  

>

)
 )!
 C*

 
)  
  

'%





 



:

*
'-
!   





>

C
 

.'

'% %..%
<
  !*

'.B'
  

 

)
 *
& 4... -...7


)!

*


C


) 
#
#) 

*

 




5



 
 
  

)
& '(...7

 

'7 

 
  A

!*


'(

  


A 
& '(....7

 
)



 

'

<E)
 


?

48%
 4> 4@$
"

$
2$8*4 3
 !*

@* 

)!

<E)
 


%.%/
 $

46%
 7=
- A$5#
4 +
,$(
 %B 4
5> .
-#> %1
 

   
 *
 !

)


C
C



 
 

)  C

 

*
 


 

 


 ) 
 

)

 





 
 


 *

*

@!


?

48%
 4> 4@$
"

$
2$8*4 3

*
*
4 ! 
 


 C*

 

 
 *

C C


! 
%.'/

)
& %%

 !
 
 
 



FAO-5606-2004 (O&M)


















< & 0.%0.7

 






!* 

'0

  
 


'/




 
 
 
'-
! 

*

 

 
'.B'
  


 

)
 


C

#

   C
 


! 
%..%


 
)
 
 


)
 * & %(..7





 
 *

C

  
 
!  *!
 

 

 C

$(1' 
*4
> % '(


 
 
'-
! 

*
/.8

 

)

 
!
 


 
 





 
  
4 % =
- 5#@$
"

$
2$8*4 3

 C

 

$()1' 
*4
> % 2$(1' 

$(1 3( '4

#
 

 

)!

  
 
)


- 4+

,4> @$
"

$
2$8*4 3
 
!







 
 
 





  


  




 
)*






  A



 
 '-

 
 


)




 
  

- 4+
,4> @$
"

$
2$8*4 31
(.8


 *
 

)
  
 

*
A 
*
(.8


 
   
A

!
!
 


& '-(.7



 
!
 


$(1 
2$(<' 
C
3(

FAO-5606-2004 (O&M)


















; '0


 
 
'-
! 

*


'0
 

)
 



*
 


- 4+
,4> @$
"

$
2$8*4 3

?

48%

 4> 4@$
"

$
2$8*4 3

!*

 

 


!

 


$()1<;1 ( '6





 
%
2 


 3

 




$(<1 

 
 
 
$(1   


 
$('1 

 


 

$('1 




 
A


 
 


4 % =
- 5#@$
"

$
2$8*4 3( Likewise, claimant No.1 (father of the deceased) is also held entitled to a sum of Rs.40,000/- on account of loss of filial consortium, in view of law laid down in 2018 (4) R.C.R. (Civil) 333, Nanu Ram's case (supra) and Satinder Kaur's case (supra), which takes the compensation to Rs.4,88,000/- (Rs.3,78,000/- + Rs.1,10,000/-).

%.

*!

  

)




7 



 S.No.

Under Head Compensation awarded by the High Court 1.

Monthly income of deceased Rs.2500/- per month 2.

Age of deceased 17 years 3.

Future prospects @40% Rs.1000/- 4.

Total income Rs.3500/- 5.

Number of dependents 6.

Deduction towards personal expenses of the deceased Rs.1750/- (50%)

FAO-5606-2004 (O&M)


















 7.

Monthly loss of dependency Rs.1750/- 8.

Annual loss of dependency Rs. 21,000/- (Rs.1750/- X 12) 9.

Multiplier 10.

Compensation on account of Loss of dependency Rs.3,78,000/- (Rs.21000 x 18) 11.

Compensation under conventional heads to claimant No.2-mother Rs.70,000/- 12.

Compensation to claimant No.1 for loss of filial consortium Rs.40,000/- 13.

Total Compensation Rs.4,88,000/- 14.

Interest 9% %'

& !

 

 

 !





7 
'

%
2
*
+&3






 Rs.4,88,000/-

 
#
 
  

 

 $()1);1 
2Rs.4,88,000/-

$(1'1 3

)

 


)!

#) 
 !

)
*




 

68

 

 

*

 

 
./ .

%..


 9 
 !

)
)!


@!

 !

)
 
> !
)!
)
+&

  along with proportionate interest.

%%

&*!



 

 
!



 

 
  !

 



)!

<E)  


H

23
( /

%.%.

 D
++# %B

%4 +
%$84 %"
>* %=
,4$8$
%# %
!
%.# %.
54$1



FAO-5606-2004 (O&M)


















 '4 .

%.%'
 
  !
 
 !




 
 
2;3


 
@* 

%

*
  
23

!
 

 



2- ,
-
 3









 4"5
'1
 5 
5   H
 C*7 
I7 H
& )
I7