← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/35948/2015dismissed

Monika Garg v. State Of Punjab

2017-09-08Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri8 pages



   

   

   

        +, $-,  ./,0+,1,&#2%&'3 +, $-,  ./,0+,1,&#2%&'3 +, $-,  ./,0+,1,&#2%&'3 +, $-,  ./,0+,1,&#2%&'3  45  45  45  45  ,++ ,  ,++ ,  ,++ ,  ,++ , 6 / / 6 / / 6 / / 6 / / /++, $ 781 /++, $ 781 /++, $ 781 /++, $ 781  ,0 -,+  ,0 -,+  ,0 -,+  ,0 -,+ . . . .  9:  /    9:  /    9:  /    9:  /  

/.,,0455;2-<

+,2$ +=,0,++ , =7<>2/, ,07+>-<

+,,,2

781 /<=/  =-/7>?

=2-<

+,2$  +=,

0+  '@=,+=,  ,0 +,  $  

  ,;00,  >  1,  ;,-+ ,,+=,87-5,+A/B % 1,,$,,-+ +=, ,0 +,  +A/B @=,+=,  +=,  87-5,+ = 7-  1,  ,0 +,-   +=, -5,+A/B 

,=7-=

,=7-=

,=7-=

,=7-=2 = 7+=--,-+=,1 <,0,++ $,-1> 0,++ ,  452 5;+=,0+,0,++ (  

 'C %&' *$,-1>=,=71- =5;2$ +=,,  ,

-,-    -,  -+,-  &%&C%&'3   =,  0,,+  0,++ ,

 45$,-/0, :,<, ,++ 1,$ ,+=,/70,, 7+2;= =-,+=,$  ;5 -,.

 D:,,-

7,$ +=,0,++ ,71++,- D:,,-

7,$ +=,0,++ ,71++,- D:,,-

7,$ +=,0,++ ,71++,- D:,,-

7,$ +=,0,++ ,71++,- +=++=,$-5 $+=,5= 7+2+=++=,0 0,+> +=++=,$-5 $+=,5= 7+2+=++=,0 0,+> +=++=,$-5 $+=,5= 7+2+=++=,0 0,+> +=++=,$-5 $+=,5= 7+2+=++=,0 0,+>  +55,-;

<,,-1> ---5,2 +  +55,-;

<,,-1> ---5,2 +  +55,-;

<,,-1> ---5,2 +  +55,-;

<,,-1> ---5,2 +

, +=,= ,+$ +,-$$-<+ $+=,

, +=,= ,+$ +,-$$-<+ $+=,

, +=,= ,+$ +,-$$-<+ $+=,

, +=,= ,+$ +,-$$-<+ $+=,

+; 

 ,,-    +=  ,5-  ;= =  =  1,,

+; 

 ,,-    +=  ,5-  ;= =  =  1,,

+; 

 ,,-    +=  ,5-  ;= =  =  1,,

+; 

 ,,-    +=  ,5-  ;= =  =  1,,

1+,-71,E7,+>

1+,-71,E7,+>

1+,-71,E7,+>

1+,-71,E7,+> +  ;  1,    +=,  +,,+  $  87+ ,  +=+  +=, +  ;  1,    +=,  +,,+  $  87+ ,  +=+  +=, +  ;  1,    +=,  +,,+  $  87+ ,  +=+  +=, +  ;  1,    +=,  +,,+  $  87+ ,  +=+  +=, 0,++ ,$,$$-<+ 5;+=-

7,+1,$ , 0,++ ,$,$$-<+ 5;+=-

7,+1,$ , 0,++ ,$,$$-<+ 5;+=-

7,+1,$ , 0,++ ,$,$$-<+ 5;+=-

7,+1,$ , +=,5= 7++=,5-2$ ,

-,+  $ +=,5= 7++=,5-2$ ,

-,+  $ +=,5= 7++=,5-2$ ,

-,+  $ +=,5= 7++=,5-2$ ,

-,+  $ +=,++, @,,++=,++,+ +=,5= 7+ +=,++, @,,++=,++,+ +=,5= 7+ +=,++, @,,++=,++,+ +=,5= 7+ +=,++, @,,++=,++,+ +=,5= 7+ $ ,

-,+  $ ,

-,+  $ ,

-,+  $ ,

-,+  =,0, ,<,0,++ -0 ,- $F =,0, ,<,0,++ -0 ,- $F =,0, ,<,0,++ -0 ,- $F =,0, ,<,0,++ -0 ,- $F 0,7 $+=,1 <,0,G 7+ -,= ;+=+ +=,++,=1,,,++,-$ ,

-,+ 1>+= 7+ 1, 7,+=,0,++ ,++,-1,$ ,+=,/70,, 7++=+

,+$ +,-$$-<+ $+=,

 ,,- +;;,, 1+,- 71,E7,+>+ 17++,+=,  $+=,0,++ ,+=++=,  +55,- 0 0,+> ;  +

<,,-  1>   -  -  -5,  +5    +=,  -  ++,,+2  +=,  0,G   7+  ,++,-  +=, ++,  +  +=   7+  $   ,

-,+     

-5>2  +=, ,,-

7,$ +=,0+,;,,=,-+,5+= >  ;>  $  $,=  +,2  +=,  0,++ ,  =  $,-  '!!"

%&'3   5  ;+=  -

7,+  -    0 32  +=, $  ;5,+=,<,,+-,.

D3 3 3 3  



                     

  

                         

    

         



        

!                  

 "

## $## % &'&

&&                      (       

 

 (   

 ) *+, -

 

      

 

            +        

     

 

   

     

    

      .

=,

+,+5,0 -,+=$,--,+,-,0> + +=,-00 + 1>;> $$$-<+ $68>?72 /, 5,2,+4 $-+;

7-1,00 0+, + E7 +,+=,$  ;50 + $ +=,,0>B$$-<+.

/$  0

  

"  

 1 

 &2!

!&##3  ,     0

  ,         &2!

!&##3          ) *1  *  "

 4    &$5 &$,    

5

, +4  5 "

%'

!3!& 6&&(#7+%'$!

!'

6&3(& 7+5"

'

!&$'!&3%8   &##&(#    

     

 &$5&$,+1 *     3 ,      

"

3

6 (& 7+3

(&#&!

7+'%2'6 (&%7+ )  *            

 

"

33 26$(%7+3 & (#7+3 &%6 (&3&!

7+ $'6&(3&!

7+3 %36 (&&793 #36 ( &!

7: 

       

              %5 #;,                     

   

     1 *

<

    ) * , - +  

=(

  -   *  "

## %    &'!& !

&&    <   ) *      , -  

    - "

## $ &'!& !

&&+<1 *    ) *!

"

 4      , -  >1      

      

<

 "

## $+

 , -           

 -  *"

## $     

   ?

:  

 

         <   



1  %       8   &##&(#  ) * 1 *          

   ,            

  ,                      

 &##3

 

                  

 ,       &##3) *         

  '5 '&!

, < 5 $( &!

 ,        @ A   4    B    8   &##&(# +     

 ,      C

  



 ) *

          3    ) *   1  *         <&!$   %5 #&!

, +         ,  &$5 &$, +   &##3:     

 0D*:

@       

      1 * ) *     

           +  )   *   1 *

<   

 

       '

   

 

     :0

  1 *        +> 



     )+   <1 

                <

    "

  ## $    &'!& !

&&+  

,  -                 

      ,   ) * 

        %5 '

&!

,       <     $&!

,         

"

## $&'!& !

&&

                

       4 (1             

              )   -      )   

                @ A                      

                 

  

"

## $ &'!& !

&& 1 *  ?     1     ) (  -              

 

 

   +  

  



      )   0

  :

     

   

   

             (     C

     

   



       &##3   

             0       : 



      8

0         

   

      

 

   

  E  

  

:  ,0

5 

 ,   01 +                   <          

        

     :

          

 

     0 4    (  

   

.

  0,7  $  +=,  1 <,  ,0>  = ;  +=+  +=, <,,+-,1>0,++ ,  45252,1,-  9700, <,755,+ $9=,0,++ ,5+>5+

0>=-,-,,4=<55 ++=,++,,++,-$ +=, 0,G 7+0,7 $+=,,0>$,-1>+=,4= ;+=+ + 5<,    , ,>  -,+2   7-5  +=,  ,G, 7+  $ 5$+ -,,-- - $ +=+ +, ,>+ ,0,++=, ,> ;;

-+=,,+,,0> ,>= ;+=++=, 0,++ , 5;+==,=71--70,-+=,4 $  , $ 70,, +> +1, 7+ $0 ,+ ,+ =,,+=++=, 4 $$ ,;= -< ,-=75, + +=,0,++ ,+=, 7 $H%3&  ,,,E7>,0 1,$  ++45 ,

$+=,071  ,> /71   -,  1>  +=,  ,,- 

7,  $   +=, 0,++ ,+=+ ,+=,++,; -5,-1,$ ,+=,,1+

,

<,>172+=,0,++ ,= 7-1,5+,-+ 0+ > 1@=+,,+=++=,0,++ ,=- 75=+=75,  $ +=,14- 0= ,-+=,071  ,>1> $7=5 $,  -  1 57  -

7,+  $  -2  1>  ;>  $   +55,

/7$$ ,  +  +  >2  =,  0,++     >  ,+  -  7+  1, -,- +=,,7+2+=,0,++ -,- /,0+,1,&#2%&'3 /,0+,1,&#2%&'3 /,0+,1,&#2%&'3 /,0+,1,&#2%&'3 (  * (  * (  * (  * ?5 ?5 ?5 ?5