Mahinder Singh And ORS v. Chief Canal Officer(Bws Unit), Irrigation And W.R. Department And ORS
!"# &#'()($*
+,-, !.(*&#/ !2(!) $.(*&#/ $".#/) ,,,,,, #"("($*#/) 3#/)4) .(#%
%%('#/
0 *("5 //(1!"($* ,, #6!/"7#*"5 !/8!*!
$".#/)
,,,,,, #)6$*&#*") 9 : ,
0 0
/#)#*"
/, 0!*&##6
#/;!25
&<$'!"#
6#"("($*#/, /, !*&.(/ 0(*1.5
&&("($*!2
,, !/8!*!,
), 0$*(!
0.!/7!5
&<$'!"#
:#1!2
(& $4*)#2 =, , , 0
5
,
, #"("($*#/)
!.(*&#/ !2(!) $.(*&#/ $".#/) .!<# (*)"!*"
'(<(2 ;/("
/"('2#) + $*)"("4"($* *&(!5 )##>(*1 ;/("
*!"4/#
'#/"($/!/( )#""(*1 !)(&#
A!(".!2 ,,
5 2#!/*#& .(#%
!/8!*!,
,
/(#%285
%!".#/ =!.!<(/ 0(*1. )4@7(""#& !* #64"8 $22#'"$/5 4*&/(5 ,0, (<()($*5 )##>(*1 !7#*&7#*"
;!/!@!*&(5 ;.#/#46$* &/!%"
!7#*&7#*"
;!/!@!*&( 6/#6!/#& 6/#)#*"#& B(2#&!/5 !@!/(5 ".#/#!%"#/5 *$"('# ())4#& '$*'#/*#& '$).!/#/),
.#
)"!"#7#*") '$).!/#/)5 ;.$ '!7# 6/#)#*"
!4".$/("85 ;#/# /#'$/&#&5 ;.#/#(* ("
)"!"#& $4"2#"
6/$6$)#& B(2#&!/ !662('!*").;!/
%!".#/ '$//#'"
!1/##!@2# !22 !22$;#&5 .$;#<#/5 )$7# '$).!/#/) $4"2#"
+ ,0, ;.$ ;#/# /#)(&#*") !)(*!5 )"!"#& /#)(&#*"
!)"!2( .() 2!*& !2)$ )("4!"#&
!)"!2(5 @#(*1 (//(1!"#& %/$7
!)"!2( ;!"#/'$4/)#5 .$;#<#/5 !''$4*"
&()64"# .() @/$".#/.$$&5 ;!"#/'$4/)# '2$)#&,
''$/&(*1285 ".#8 &(& #?6/#)) ".#(/ '$*)#*"
6/$6$)#& %/$7 ;!"#/'$4/)# '("(*1 /#!)$* 2!*& )2(1."28 .(1.#/ ".!* ".#(/ 2!*& /!(*8 )#!)$*5 ;!"#/'$4/)# ;$42& &/!(* ".#(/ 2!*& ".#(/ '/$6) ;$42& &#)"/$8#&5 7!8 %4/".#/ 2#!& &()64"#), , $*)(&#/(*1 %!'") '(/'47)"!*'#)5 #64"8 $22#'"$/5 4*&/( 0 (<()($*5 !%"#/ (*)6#'"(*1 )6$"5 /#C#'"#& !*& 0(*1.5 +,, -
5 $@)#/<(*1
, "/!*)6(/#) '.!22#*1#& +,, -
5 #64"8 $22#'"$/5 4*&/(
=
0 (<()($*5 %(2(*1 0#'"($*
!/8!*!
/!(*!1#
'"5
).$/"
9
'"95 '!7# &#'(&#& (<()($*!2
4*&/( (<()($*5 -,, -
5 ;.#/#@8 )!*'"($*#& 64''!
;!"#/'$4/)# #'", A(22!
+
6/#&#'#))$/ =5 $@)#/<(*1
!
!
!! "! #$%""&'
(
!'
"
"
"
)*%*)%$+
, - ./
=,
#(*1 !11/(#<#& !1!(*)"
-,, -
5 6/#)#*"
6#"("($*#/) 6/#%#//#& !* !66#!2 0#'"($*
+
'"5 '!7# &#'(&#&
.!>/!
!"#/ 0#/<('#) (/'2#5 =,,
=5 ;.#/#@8
"!>(*1 6$(*"
6/$<(&#& 6$(*"
5
!)"!2(5 $@)#/<(*1 (
0
(
"
1'
"
#!
(2 -3 !
(
"
4'
0
!
'!
5
2$$""$' ( 3 6
'
)+%7)%$+
, 8 '
- . / '
=, !66#!/) =,,
= '.!22#*1#& !*8 %4/".#/ #(".#/ $/ = .#/#(*, =, "/!*)6(/#) = )4@7(") !*$".#/
;(".
/#D4#)"
'$*)"/4'"
64''!
*!>>!
2(*#& ;!"#/'$4/)#5 !22$;#&
$@)#/<(*1
! ""! $%""&$9
4'
! ""! $%""&$9
:
'
! ""! $%""&$9
!
"
; ;
- ./
!
!"
/ 8
'
,
#(*1 !11/(#<#& !1!(*)"
6/#)#*"
6#"("($*#/) !* !66#!2 0#'"($*
'"
.(#%
!/8!*!5 .$;#<#/5 &()7())#&5 ,,
5 .(#%
!/8!*!5 .$2&(*1 !66#!2 7!(*"!(*!@2#,
+
, * !%$/#7#*"($*#& '(/'47)"!*'#)5 6#"("($*#/) .!<# (*)"!*"
'(<(2 ;/("
".() $4/"5 /#2(#% )5 *$"('#& !@$<#, +, :#!/*#& '$4*)#2 6#"("($*#/) )4@7(") '$*)"/4'"($* *#;
$4"2#"
;!/!@!*&( '.!> $4"2#"
+ !@!/( 04@
/!*'.
)4@7(""#& 6/#&#'#))$/ = (,#, .() '2!(7 /#C#'"#&5 .$;#<#/5 $4"2#"
;!/( = %(?#& %/$7 6$(*"
5
!)"!2( )!(& .!) !""!(*#& %(*!2("8,
)4@7(""#& %/#).
)4@7(""#& = /#2(#%
%%('#/ &(/#'"28 ;$42& @!//#& 6/(*'(62# #)"$66#2 !*&5 ".#/#%$/#5 (7641*#&
A!(".!2 ;#22 ,,
5 2#!/*#& .(#%
!/8!*!5 !/# 2(!@2# )#"
!)(&#,
%4/".#/ )4@7(""#& #<#* $".#/;()#5 #?#'4"($* $/&#/) ;$42& 6$))(@2# <(#;
%!'"
2!*& = %!22) .(1.#/ 2#<#2 ".!* ;!"#/'$4/)#5 %/$7 ;!/( )$41.",
*#?"
)4@7(""#& #<#* (% 1(<#* = %/$7 ;!"#/'$4/)# ".#* ;!"#/ ;(22 1$ 46"$ %(#2&) @#'!4)# .#(1."
.() %(#2&)5 .(1.#/ ".!* ;!"#/'$4/)#5 ".#/#%$/#5 2#!&(*1 $<#/%2$;
;!"#/5 /#)42"(*1 ;!)"!1# ".#/#$%,
''$/&(*1285 ("
6/!8#& (7641*#& $/&#/) )#"
!)(&#,
, #/ '$*"/!5 2#!/*#& '$4*)#2 = .!) $66$)#& )4@7())($*) 7!&# @#.!2% 6#"("($*#/),
)4@7(""#&
(7641*#&
.!& 6#/7(""#& 64''!
'$77$* 2(*# #'", A(22!
+ *$ 6/#C4&('# .!) @##* '!4)#& 6#"("($*#/),
%4/".#/ )4@7(""#& $4"2#"
;!/( 0(*1.5 %(?#& 6$(*"
5
!)"!2(5 #?#'4"!@2# /#!)$*5 = .!& )4@7(""#& !*
!22$;#&5
,
''$/&(*1285 6/!8#/ &()7())!2 (*)"!*"
'(<(2 ;/("
.!) @##* 7!&#,
-, .!<# .#!/& 2#!/*#& '$4*)#2 6!/"(#) .!<# 6#/4)#& 6!6#/@$$> ;(".
".#(/ !@2# !))()"!*'#,
, &()64"#& !* #!/2(#/ $''!)($*5 %!".#/ =5 *!7#285 0(*1.5 0#'"($*
'"5 )##>(*1 !7#*&7#*"
;!/!@!*&(5 &()7())#& #64"8 $22#'"$/5 +,, -
1/$4*& 2!*&
%!".#/ .(1.#/ 2#<#2 ".!* 2#<#2 ;!"#/'$4/)# !2)$ ".#/# 6!))!1#5 7#!)4/(*1 + >!/!7) @#";##* ;!"#/'$4/)# 2!*& ".#/# *$ )(6.$* )!(& 62!'#,
2".$41.5 +,, -
5 #64"8 $22#'"$/5 '.!22#*1#& 0#'"($*
'"5 !22$;#& (<()($*!2
-,, -
)!*'"($*(*1 #'", A(22!
+5 .$;#<#/5 %4/".#/ !66#!2 6#"("($*#/) 0#'"($*
+
'"5 -,, -
5 (<()($*!2
7$&(%(#&
=,,
-
=5 ;.#/#@8
"!>(*1 6$(*"
%!".#/ %(?#& 6$(*"
5
!)"!2( !2$*1;(".
6!".
@.!/!( C.!/!( !22$;#& 6#/ )("#, , $*'#&#&285 =,,
=5
@#(*1 '.!22#*1#& !*8 %4/".#/5 ".#/#%$/#5 )!(& .!) !""!(*#& %(*!2("8, !66#!/) !*$".#/ @#(*1 =
!.!<(/ )$* 0(*1. &(/#'"28
64''!
/#'"!*12#
>(22!
+? .!) @##* !22$;#&,
(*&('!"#& 6/$<()($*) 2!;5 )!(& =5 #*"#/"!(*#&
A!(".!2 &(/#'"28, ,
# ("
7!85 $*'# 7!""#/ /#1!/&(*1 6/$<()($*(*1 2!*& = $/ );.!/
%!".#/ '$*)(&#/#& &#'(&#&
=,,
=5 ;.#/#@8 6/$<(&(*1 "!>(*1 6$(*"
!>>! 2!*&
%!".#/ 6$(*"
5
!)"!2( )!(& .!<(*1 !""!(*#& %(*!2("85 ("
;$42& C4)"
#?6#&(#*"
6#/7("
())4# @#(*1 !1("!"#& !1!(*,
.#
A!(".!2 &(/#'"28 #*"#/"!(*(*1 = 6!))(*1 (7641*#&
.!) 4*)#""2#& )#""2#& 6$)("($* /#1!/&) 6/$<()($*(*1
"!>(*1 6$(*" 2!*&
%!".#/ =5 .!) $*28 6/#<#*"#& %(*!2("8 &#'()($* .!) @##* /#!'.#& !"5 =,,
=5 @4"
.!) '$*<#8#& ;/$*1 7#))!1# 2("(1!*"
7!8 1$
%(2(*1 !662('!"($*) /#2(#% '2!(7#& #<#* (% &#*(#&5 ("
'$42& 1/!*"#& )$7# )4@)#D4#*"
)"!1#,
.() '2#!/28 !1!(*)"
64@2('
6$2('8 !&7(*()"/!"($* C4)"('#,
0(7(2!/ <(#;
"!>#* ".() $4/"
'!)#
(<(2 ,
#)42"!*"285 (*)"!*"
'(<(2 ;/("
!22$;#& (7641*#&
A!(".!2 ,,
5 2#!/*#& .(#%
!/8!*!
!/# )#"
!)(&#,
, #*&(*1
)5 (% !*85 ).!22 !2)$ )"!*& '2$)#&,
0
+,-,
)C>) .#".#/ )6#!>(*1 /#!)$*#&
#)
$ .#".#/ /#6$/"!@2# #)
$