High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/35977/2015allowed

Ram Niwas v. State Of Haryana

2017-03-02Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan8 pages

"#$ $%&'&()

"*&+"'

$#&#&($, -$,'.'

/#"#$ ",0"("

$'1(2$(#

,$'$(#) , 34"(526%"#$ ,#4$1$#&#&($, ,/"7'4&52285",0"("

$#&#&($,"8(:+&#4%"%%.'$2&' "%&(:#,&"8&(%"'$ ;2"#$2

.(2$,/$%#&(';

5;<5;<=5;5

"(2 /$%#&('55;5== ,$6$(#&( ,,.1#&(%#5,$:&'#$,$2"# 8&%$ /#"#&(5&#0&(2 (>,&$ 5 +"',$:&'#$,$2"

#$,"(&( ,*"#&(+"',$%$&6$2 ,$:",2&(:2&'%,$1"(%&$' &( #4$,$:&'#,"#&( 6$4&%8$'>0#4$

&%$

5/"

&2( ("118&%"#&(+"' *6$2>0/*#/.(&#"&$+& $ #4$ 1$#&#&($, .(2$, /$%#&( = , , 482&(: "( &(?.&,0 "(2 1'#1($*$(# #,&"81,%$$2&(:'(#4$:,.(2#4"#4$,4.'>"(2@"%%.'$2

"*&+"'&''.

$,&(: ,*"1'0%4&"#,01,>8$*"(2"''.%4&'.(">8$# '$#.14&'2$ $(%$ 4$&('#"(#1$#&#&( &8$2.(2$,/$%#&(;= , &'2&,$%#$2 ":"&('# #4$ ,2$, 2"#$2

(($A.,$ ! 1"''$2 >0 8$",($2 22&#&("8 /$''&(' .2:$5&(25+4$,$>0#4$"118&%"#&( *6$2 .(2$, /$%#&( 4"'>$$(2&'*&''$2

"11,$%&"#$ #4$ '4,# %(#,6$,'0 ,"&'$2 &( #4$ &('#"(# 1$#&#&(5&#+.82>$"11,1,&"#$#,$1,2.%$4$,$.(2$,/$%#&(' =5 "(2 , %(#"&($2&(4"1#$,BB-) C

# $!

# # !

! # !

! !

)

# #

* +

, !

! !

- ( !

+ ' #

# #

! !

# #

- . ( !

+ ' !

- /

0 ( 0 % # 0 !

# 0 # #

# 0 #

! #

' (

# 0 % #

! 0

! )

* +

, !

! !

( 0 !

+ ' # 0

! !

# #

( 0 !

- - 1

# 0 # ## ! "

)

! !

! + !

+ !

! !

! 2 !

( # 0 # ! #

# "

% &

)

% &

3 ' #/4./4

# 0 # ##"

$ !

)

+ ( !

# 0 #

! 2 ! , ( 0 #

5 /$%#&( 1,6&2$' ,#4$1,%$2.,$ ,&(?.&,0>0"

":&'#,"#$&(,$:",2##4$ "%# .('.(2($'' *&(2":&'#,"#$5& 54$ 4"',$"'('#>$8&$6$#4"##4$1$,'(>$ ,$4&*&' .('.(2*&(2"(2 %('$?.$(#80&(%"1">8$ *"7&(: 4&' 2$ $(%$5#4$(54$ &'$(D&($2 # &(?.&,$&(#'.%4.('.(2($'' *&(2"(2'4"88%".'$'.%41$,'(#>$ $A"*&($2>0#4$&6&8/.,:$( #4$2&'#,&%#,'.%4#4$,$2&%"8

&%$, "'#4$/#"#$6$,(*$(#*"02&,$%#4$&6&8/.,:$(,#4$%(%$,($2 $2&%"8

&%$,&'#4$,$"

#$,#>$$A"*&($2"'"+&#($'' $(2&(:'.%4 &(?.&,05#4$":&'#,"#$*"02$"8+&#4'.%4"1$,'(&("%%,2"(%$+&#4#4$ 1,6&'&(' /$%#&( , 5+4&%4$(6&'":$',$8$"'$ "8.("#&% 1$(2&(:&(6$'#&:"#&(,#,&"8 #4$":&'#,"#$&' #4$1&(&(#4"##4$

< 1$,'(&' .('.(2*&(254$&'#,$%,24&' &(2&(:##4"#$

$%#"(2#4$( 1'#1($#4$1,%$$2&(:'&(#4$%"'$ /$%#&( , 1,6&2$' ,1,%$2.,$&(%"'$ 1$,'(

.('.(2*&(2>$&(:#,&$2>$ ,$#4$%.,#4&'1,6&'&(*"7$'&#%8$", #4"#&("#,&"8>$ ,$#4$":&'#,"#$,.,# /$''&('5& 5#4$"%%.'$2 "11$",' .('.(2 *&(2 "(2 %('$?.$(#80 &(%"1">8$ *"7&(: 4&'

2$ $(%$5#4$(5#4$.,#'4"885&(#4$ &,'#&('#"(%$5#,0#4$ "%# '.%4 .('.(2($'' *&(2"(2&(%"1"%&#0"(2& '"#&'

&$2&(#4&',$:",25'4"88 ,$%,2 " &(2&(: # #4"# $

$%# "(2 '4"88 1'#1($ .,#4$,1,%$$2&(:' /$%#&( , &''&*&8",#/$%#&( "(2#4$(802&

$,$(%$ >$&(:#4"##4$8"#$,,$8"#$'#"(&(?.&,0>$ ,$"":&'#,"#$+4&8$/$%#&( , ,$8"#$'##,&"8>$ ,$"":&'#,"#$,#4$.,# /$''&('( "(0%"'$>#4#4$'$%#&(',$8"#$#.('.(2($'' *&(2"##4$#&*$

&(?.&,0,#,&"8"(2(#"##4$#&*$ %**&''&(

$(%$ (#4$ "%#' #4$1,$'$(#%"'$#4$ +"',$:&'#$,$2(

4$"%%.'$21$,'('&(%8.2&(: "*&+"'1$#&#&($,+$,$ ",,$'#$2(

4$ &("8&(6$'#&:"#&(,$1,#.(2$,/$%#&( , +"' .,(&'4$2 >0 #4$ 1,'$%.#&( &( 6$*>$,5

4$ "118&%"#&(.(2$,/$%#&( 4"'>$$(*6$2"##4$&('#"(%$ #4$ +& $ #4$1$#&#&($,("*$80/*#/.(&#"(

'#"#&(:%8$",80#4"# 4$,4.'>"(2&''.

$,&(: ,*1'0%4&"#,0*$2&%"81,>8$*'&(%$"(.*>$,

2"0'"(24$&':$##&(:#,$"#*$(# ,* /5 4#"7'&(%$ <

,* #4$ '0%4&"#,0 $1",#*$(# 4$ "118&%"#&( +"' '.11,#$2 >0 " %$,#& &%"#$&''.$2>0#4$$2&%"8",2"(2+4&%44"2"''$''$2"E# E*$2&%"82&'">&8&#0 #4$"%%.'$2

$,.'"8 #4$&*1.:($2,2$,+.82,$6$"8#4"##4$"118&%"#&( .(2$,/$%#&( *6$2(>$4"8 #4$"%%.'$2@1$#&#&($,4"'

>$$(2&'*&''$2(#4$,$"'(&(:#4"##%8"&*>$($ &# 2$ $(%$ &('"(&#0 "( "118&%"(# +.82 4"6$# 1,6$ #4"# 4&' %:(&#&6$ "%.8#&$' +$,$' &*1"&,$2&(,$8"#&(##4$#&*$+4$(#4$"88$:$2

$(%$+"'%**&##$2 (#4$%('&2$,$2 #4&'.,##4$&*1.:($2,2$,%"((# '.'#"&("'#4$,&"8.,#4"'6$,87$2"6&#"8"'1$%# #4$*"##$,4$ 1$#&#&($,+"'(#'$$7&(:#4$2$ $(%$ /$%#&(=; ,$A($,"#&(

,* %,&*&("8 8&">&8&#0 >.# +"' +"(#&(: 1'#1($*$(# .,#4$, 1,%$$2&(:'&(#4$#,&"8.(2$,/$%#&( 4$2&'#&(%#&(>$#+$$( &(%"1"%&#0"##4$#&*$ 2&(:#4$"%#%4",:$2"(2&(%"1"%&#02.,&(:#4$ %.,'$ #,&"8&'+$88 ,*.8"#$2(%"1"%&#0"##4$#&*$ %**&''&(

$(%$&'2$"8#.(2$,/$%#&(=; /$%#&(=; &'"'.>'#"(#&6$ 1,6&'&(+4&%4$A%.'$'#4$

$(%$5+4$,$"'/$%#&(' ="(2 , $

$%# #4$ 1,%$2.,$ "(2 1'#1($ #4$ #,&"8 (2&#&( $''$(#&"8 , "118&%">&8&#0 '.%41,6&'&('&'#4"#&#*.'#"11$",##4$%.,##4"##4$ "%%.'$2>,.:4#>$ ,$&#&' .('.(2*&(2 5&#2$''"11$",5#4$(5#4$

"%#4"'#>$#,&$2"(22$%&2$2>$ ,$%"88&(:.1(#4$"%%.'$2#'#"(2#,&"8

,#4$

$(%$%4",:$24$'$1,6&'&('",$*"(2"#,0"(2.:4##>$ '#,&%#80%*18&$2+&#44$&''.$ &('"(&#0&'#>$%('&2$,$2(80+4$,$ "%%.'$2 "11$",'#>$&(%"1">8$ *"7&(:4&'2$ $(%$2.$#*$(#"8 &( &,*&#04$,&"8.,#%"((#"%#(&#'+(1&(&(4$,$*.'#>$ >$ ,$#4$%*1$#$(#%.,#"'#"#$*$(# $2&%"8

&%$,5+4*.'#>$ $A"*&($2F4$,$#4$%.,#2$%&2$'#4"##4$"%%.'$2&' .('.(2*&(2"(2 %('$?.$(#80&(%"1">8$ *"7&(:4&'2$ $(%$#4$#,&"8&'#>$1'#1($2

= F4&8$ 1"''&(: #4$ &*1.:($2 ,2$,5 #4$ %.,# 4"' $,,$2 &( 2$%&2&(:#4$"118&%"#&(*6$2>0#4$+& $ 1$#&#&($,(#4$1,$*&'$#4"# 2$ $(%$ /$%#&(=; 4"'>$$('.:4# "#4$,#4$"118&%"#&(+"'

.(2$,/$%#&( "(2'.11,#$2>0"%$,#& &%"#$&''.$2>0#4$ $2&%"8/.1$,&(#$(2$(#5 #/4",*" /5 4#"7"''$''&(:4&'

2&'">&8&#0 # >$ >$#+$$( E # E "(2 ,* #4$ $1",#*$(#

'0%4&"#,0

,#4$,$"'(',$%,2$2">6$5#4$1,$'$(#1$#&#&(&'"88+$2 ,2$,2"#$2

(($A.,$ !5&''$#"'&2$4$*"##$,&',$*"(2$2 >"%7##4$,&"8.,# ,2$%&2&(:#4$"118&%"#&(*6$2>0#4$+& $

1$#&#&($,"

,$'4"(2&(#$,*' #4$*"(2"#$%(#"&($2&(4"1#$,BB-

#4$2$ ,&*&("8 ,%$2.,$"(2"'1$,/$%#&(' =5 "(2

, (,2$,"

,$'4>$1"''$2+&#4&("1$,&2 #+*(#4' ,*#4$ 2"#$ ,$%$&1# "%$,#& &$2%10 #4&',2$, ,&"81,%$$2&(:'?."

"%%.'$2 "*&+"''4"88>$7$1#&(">$0"(%$#&88#4$2"#$ 1"''&(: #4$ ,2$,"

,$'4"(2+.82#4$,$"

#$,>$'.>D$%###4$.#%*$ '.%4,2$,

$#&#&(&'"88+$2&(#4$"

,$'"&2#$,*'

8.%70 F4$#4$,'1$"7&(:@,$"'($2) $'

F4$#4$, $1,#">8$) $'