High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/590/2003allowed

Buta Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab

2018-12-20Mr. Justice Satpal,Mr. Justice Raj Mohan Singh15 pages

!""

# $"

%& & ''(( # $ )# *+ '

!"# $%&'( )*+,-( !.,/01! "!

$%&'( )*+,-(! ,$2( 0,$310,21) )

$ *$&,-! - &''(( *& &.*-$ '# /! 0 (-)# *+

!.,/01! "!4 1&' ''(""

" # %"

&*#%,

- +/" " ($" 2#%&!-3 1!4 # -) "(-"

$" 56

-".&"!&!!# # $"

%&-$#&,-$ /7 " $ *"8#,("$ #-.!&% ." & " & !'# "&+(# $! " 6

659) !!# $ / 7 " $ *" 8#, (" $ # . "! ! # $! " 65 9) # % (" ",'" , '/"

6-!& !!# # $"

%& $#&,.! "! !# $! "

9)." & $! " 9) # %("",'" , '/"

6- !& 9 #( '/, "

-!&!!#."! # & # %"%#",'" , ":, & 1&! &'!# " "

# &((" & ;

- $#+9 '! 7"((",2*"-$<-)("!$ " -*'#-( %." &$9 ).

8#, &'("!"!"(.' "

0% &.4- *'# )7=0#(& 8#,(%!,'("

." &&", !!"

&",-*8"& )# & ) " " &&"

7( +&. & &"."2%"& ">, (# !( .&" + &"

(. ,8"& . "" "

% , &&#8&, & " &&**#*" $#&, "#%& 8&,& .'"#(/," ?#&"

$&."! 1& &/ % ,"%$#&,." &,8"& -.&"!&.(, "@"

1& ( " + . , 8"& $#&, . "

A / +#

) ,8"& &!, &", &"&' < (&", & &.%"

% &&#&", &"

(. &"

1& /" ;

+# ;

-&.%"

%# " &",(.& &&#!4#"

& +/, . (/"

'( *"

% &&#$ /" <!& & ' < # & +/ , 8"& , 8"& . ,#+/,# .

' <"

,8.($&, $ # $&,+ &,8"& $ , "B: )0 )("! 4"

'" &!( & &! 9 C# ' .''" B: ) ) , ,.! #! &+/,8"&

)& %'&.( 4 9 "% " .!,'( !&(( . '# #' !,'( " (( &!(,(" " 1&'!# " :,"

#,+."

#'' &! 1& , &!!#.(!# $! "

) 1&/& " &! &'!# " 1&/. "! !- "!+ < !- &' ''( ? !# ( ''"

% +&( & ''(( &, (/%# & &'!# " &"( '" ! ? !# (''"

% &$ &, (/%# & &'!# " &

'" !+/ +(#+ #'' &*#%, & ( # +(. = 7&&( !# ( &' " % &#%& &*#%, !/!#((/ ;

)7$9).

8#, "" & ;

- &/. ' 0% &.4- *'#- .& !,'("

. (% +/ 0#(& 8#,." &$97"((",2*"-$<-)("!$ " " /*'# , .,+/$#+9 '! 1&' ."" +/ & '("! 1&!( &. 4 "

)7 *" $"

%& & ! #! & ' , , :,"

" !!"

% &",-!.! % + &((

%(, "+( ,4("% #.' & !4 % .' &( & +# ,,# "(.' "!4"

% &'(, "

%( & "! " !4"

"( " +(.' "

&(/' &!"-'!"((/# &

#!#(+# ( &(( &/"! "(% ( " 1&/" ! "(%.!!4"

&,"("

</"+ .! #*# & ( &,"("

<'' , ,' -B: ) 1",+ .

& ' , ,. 5&# 1&!# &!!" % &! .# %#( " ("

% ",'", +(#''(/ &+"

!#"

%'&/:" '" . ! "

&"! '!&,"!( (/"' 9 &"!:,"

" -&," & "

%,4.# & !4 &+/ 1&. " !(!&("

&' !&,"!( (/" 1",+ . & "

*#/ &!#(+.,"

5 )7=0#(& 8#, "" & =

,8"&

!&!, &", ( & &.%"

% &" & " !$#&, ;

+# =

-.& &.

# " &&# &",(- &.#!4# < "! & +/,8"& .(/"

'( &&#$ / " ' .(% 9 &"!:,"

" -&," & , 8"& $#&,& "

( " 9 &":,"

" "

!&"-& & & $#&,&"("!' " " "

)7;2+"$"

%&" &, "(."

<' & & .(("

% "!( !/!(

" $# /-&. !,"

%,"((% &''( <. 4"

&.4-*'# # $"

%& $#&,. 4"

%,("

& +&"

&", # $"

%&.# &"

(# !("C# <./"

% $#&, & &"'( &#!! 1&/&("C#" ,8"&

1&"("&. $#&," & . "

%.#(+" &, 1& - &/. # " <(' & ./'" &"- &.#, & ,8"& .,# 9 &"! :,"

" -&," & &" "(,.& && & " + . # $"

%& $#&, +# & ,# 1&" "

, " .%" &'("!

)7 ($"

%&" &, "(."

<' & =

) ,8"& &, &","

&"&' < .," $#&, <4,8"& &'#'&""" *'# < ( & &&!, &" ;

-&.4#'

+# =

<& & " < "! & +/ ,8"& (/"

'( *"

% &&#$ /"

-$ /"!, &"&#"

& "

% $& (&", & "!!$#&, " ,8"& .' "

% $#&,& ('"(("!" ( " ." & # $"

%& =

-,8"& & !, &"&#

) ,8"& &( ($ /" & & $ #&'"(&", ", "((" <. # "

% $ # '#&,8"& &%# $ # &"!& $ # $ / " %#( ,8"& $&('(+&", & $&+ '#!+ &'("! < ($ /" !, , ", 9

&"!:,"

" -&," & &. " &$'

!& ) !& &"((% <&' &, &'("! &" ",

)7 $ #$&," &+ & &! !!" % &",-$#&,('." & # $"

1&'!# " & :,"

&9 "% "

%"! 9 . !/ &'!# " :,"

&9 "% "

%"! 1& !"+ !"!#, "(" ! 9 ' &!+

!"!#, "(" !- &!&"

,# +!,'( 5 &"

!-' &" )7=0#(& 8#,- &( " + . $#&, ,8"& . "

$#&,& "("!' " " %"

,8"& !!"

% )7=0#(&

8#,- =

,8"& & (&", & &.%"

% &" &" !&", &"

(. ;

+# =

- .& &. &",(- &.#!4# 1&+/, 8"& .(/"

'( &&#$ /" )7;

2+"$"

%&' &

.& &. 4"

0% &.4-*'#- # $"

%& $#&,. 4"

= ,("

& +&"

&", <& # $"

%& $#&,- &. &!.(","

<&!!# # $"

%& $#&,

+# ' &, &'("!

!&&& # $"

%& $#&,+# &,#, 8"& -&&#(&",," (/' &, &'("! "(, & &

1& , &'!# " ."

)7 ($"

'"! " ! <. " &$'

!& ) !& &"((% <. , # &" / 1&. !!" $#&, ""

&",

-$ /", : *#"!"(! +&", <&," "

&"!:,"

" & &"

, &'("! (/

9 !$ /"&,: *#"!"(! +# & ,# , 8"&

+ &",- & &#( & ",," (/ ' & , & '("! " ." "

% "((

B: *#"!"(! ".4" ! 9 "C#" + !+ +/ &" ! = 1& !# & . # %#( " ("

% ",'", +(#''(/ &+"

!#"

%'&/:" "

% ,4.# & !4 &+/ ')7 *"

%&- '" . ! "

&"! &! ;

1&!"+ !"!#, "(" ! 9 ' &!+ !"!#, "(" !-!&"

,# +!,'( 9 & ' !- &!&"

" !,'(

1&"?&"'< >+( &$#',# "

&! -9

5$= &&( & ((."

%! " " ,# +#("((+!%"

;

!!# + !"!#, "( " ! !

+ " + #((/ +("& D !( (/" &"!"" .#(&. & &((."

%! " " ,# +#("((+!%"

!!#!

+" +#((/ +("& &!"!#, !,.&"!& &! !(#"

%#"( " +.

&#(+#((/ +("& 9 ,/ + & & &" # "

"! & & !"!#, !! ! D,# &#(D D,/+D +("& 1& " (/ %,, "!( +# (%( " "

! " + . D,/+'D D,# +&#( +'D.&(+/ &"# "

$&"*"$&+

+ $ && .& &+ " . , E$' -'

;

$"' 5;F D "

(/- " " '",/ '"

!"'( & & !!#,# + ,(/,/+%#"( /+ !# !

! "! &, (" !+ . >,/ +> >,# +>"( % ""%#! *! # ,#! !(#" D &! +("&&#(+! " (/ ." & &&/' &" &%#"( &!!#- & " /- &/ &#( + :'("

+( / & &/' &":!' & &!!#"%#"( /- &!"!#, !&#(+! !(#" #

!/- 5 &/ &#( :!(# / '"+( &/' &" :!' & +'- &,# +!&"

" !!,'( ( / +( %# & ! !(#"

" ." & &"

! ! &!!# ,# &. & "

((&#, '++"(" / &! ,# & + +/ &!!#

1&"%( '"

!"'(-".,//- " # &'

!&&( &'!+

!"!#, "(" ! D

1&" ?&"' < >+( & $#', # "

$5 -&&( & & # & (4"

&## "

%!"!#, ! "

.& & &: *#"!"(! " "

'"+/ /",''!(( ( " " !"!#, " &(.#%% "

% & " ,/ + # 3 &"'#'- &# ,# !# "

"@(( &( ! #!& &' - .&, &! ",- & ", '(!,4"

%" - &!"!#, !"

.&"!&" ., "

((/- &! #(.# +/ &!!# 1&"?&"'&# &&( & : *#"!"( ,+/ &!!#-.&"("

'("!!# /-!#( + '%"

&!!# 1&"?&"'&&(# D;

1&C# " & ,%- &-".& & &'!# " & +("& & &!"!#, "( " !&"(/+ 4#' +/ &'!# " "

' &%#"( &''(( 1&" !"!#, ! " & &! &''(( .(

% &+/)7; )7 3, &" !" "!( & &" '""

",!/ &''(( & ! 1&/&'' , '!& ! BC#((/ , &" !" "!( & )7;- &("C#&'

)7 .&&("C#." & &''(( &!(+(# % &!

&''(( ," (/ &" " ""! "

' ! #! +/ & '!# " " "/ & ''(( +/)7;)7 1&''(( . &'"

# )7; & & ( &("C#

)7 ! #, " ." & &", & !

1& " " +(/ '"+( !!' & ", /)7; )7 .& &/' & &/& &''(( &! % & #,"

% &("C# 9 "&"%&(/ ""!"( '' " ! ,4 +(" / 1& : '"! " !" &((%: *#"!"(! ,+/ &''(( )7 # ,+"%##: *#"!"( ' &"%&'+ "(#!"

, , &' .&!,," &!", " ,""+( "

" ! '" " " , #'"!" #%% " " (" / # "

&'! &' &((%! &!# & + "" & " "(# / '' + &#( "

#!, - & '," "% # $! " 5 &B" !! .+#%& +# "

#'"!"#!"!#, ! !"!#, $! " = &B" !! 1&- &!# & (4"

&## "

%!"!#, ! "

.& & &: *#"!"(! " "

'"+/

/ ",'' !(( ( ! " " !"!#, " &(.#%% "

% & " ,/ + # 3 &"'#' &!# ,# !# "

"(( & ( ! #!& &' .&, &!

" ,- & ", '(! ,4"

% " - & !"!#, !"

.&"!&" ., "

((/ &! #( .#+/ &!!# B: *#"!"(! " # +(# /-!

+("#' +/ &!# ( %." & &" ! ! 1&- & : *#"!"(! ."(((& +'("4

/ & ! 1& (# & " ! & ' #' &!" / &."

.&," ", &!"!#, !"

.&"!&" !, +, &! #(.#+/ &!!# $, ", " ,/ + '"+( & ."

'#! &! #(."

.&"!& &! .

, 3 & &(."

" !"

% & , +/2#"!"(%" ,"

" "

%((

!/. "

% &!!# & " .#(+# " !%"

&", ," (/)7 &''(( +( % &,"((% 3, & " &'!# "

/" "!( & )7;- )7 !, % &

''& &''(( ,&""((% . 4 2#" ""! " &." "" +/)7; )7 " . & &.+#%& +!4 0%%("((%)7 .4' "

&"!,'

)7;( # &"

"% " $! " &B" !! '" & ! , '("!"!&((+'%"

' !!# / ! $! " ='" & !

,+/ /' .&"(&"# !# / & '("! "!- # ( " + , "

& ",," ' !,%" -&((+'%"

#!& ' 1&- &! ,+/ !!# ' '("!"!""( +/' " $! " " &(("! +'%"

& ''(( ?"4." &! ,+/ &''((

.&"(&""

&!# / &'("!&(( + '%"

&''(( # (" ","

& ",," ' ! &,%" -+/' " $! " = & ," (/ & ''(( " ,4 /! "

&' ! &,%" 1&C# " - &-".& & &''(( , &: *#"!"(! .&"(&."

&'("! !# / 9 ""

!"+( +(" & &'("!"!- )7;- &"

%% " "" &''(( +/)7;

)7 & ( "

&!,'

/ & !.#(&( &''(( ." &# 4"

% &","

!# / 9 "+"#- & ." &". "

& "%# $! " =- )7 ; !

""!"(! "&"("

%# &"

"% "

4' &''(( "

&!# /)7 - & )& ,4 : *#"!"(! &"

% ' )7 ; 4 & ''(( 2#"!"( %" &&"! !'" # $! " =5 &).&"!&'% '+ "(# # "

%# ! & !# 9 " "

!#(# +(" & ,4"

% (( & # & &''(( ,(# "(/!

)7 & " "

& ( 1& &'

.&' !" . &+ ,.

:,"

'" / !+ " & ", /)7 1&-" .#(+(%" ", !(# & &''(( . 4 "

&'("! !# / .&"( &!!#."

&!# /- & : *#"!"(! .+ "

&#%&)7

.& !!,, & '!# " "! ''(( 1&+/.!

(/!& "" "+(! !(#"

& &((%: *#"!"(! , . ,.&"( &''(( ."

&'("!!# / 9 " .(( ( (. & $! " = &(( + # "! (/ 1&-+/' " $! " = & B" ! ! - & ! , +/ & ''(( )7 .&"(&."

&!# / & '("!"!)7;&(( +'%"

& ''(( 9 &""." "#

!/ %"

& (# / # &! ! D

1&"?&"'< >+( &$#',# "

;$;

-&&( & : *#"!"(! ".4'"!" ! 1&"?&"'&&( # D 7,/ .(." & &" !%"

& : *#"!"( ! & . !!# &,,",8& )75 &!/ , +( %"

% & ! , & . !!# 9 " '","(/ #' & . '"! '!# " " ! & &! "! " &!!# &+ + $ &! & ", 8& "! ! -."

& -!!"

% &" ."

- & .!!#!, &", &"&#"

$4# '# #%# 5- = (&",+# &" &"

% ' 4"(( & #%& ,* +/ %#( "

%&.((%"

% &,(& , &,,",8& +( % & "((% 1&. &" /'"#!" "

+ . &."

& .!!#,/*# "/ &"

! & &!!#!#('! " !"

&", 9 &!"!#, !-" ,&"%&(/",'++( & & .!!#.#(% &,,", 8& +(# # ! 9 "( !( .&/ & .!!#&#( / # ./ "

% & '("!' /!,"

%." &&,,",8& " &,,",8& &% &'("! & C# &!!# !!"

% &,,", 8& -0#$.4)7.." & &'("!$#+9 '! .& &$#+9 '! !,." &&,,", 8& &"&# ''& &!!# 1& " !,*)7-&.-&. & 0#$.4 )7 . ." & ,* & , #/ & "%& + . 5#%# - = & #%# 5- = $#$.4,"

." &,* &#%&# & / (" 9 . #%# - = & - !!"

% ,*-& 0#$.4 # &" "((% &."

% &+/8&8(""

" 9 .#( &#'' & ,*)7.&-+" % & & &!-& ' "!#( ,% &'!# " ! #'' &!!#

&! "! &,,",8& &'"

& 0#$.4)7.." & &'("!$#+9 '!

#%# 5- = 1&! & &,,",8&

&'%"

% &' !0#$.4." & & '("! $#+9 '! ." & ". #'' & '!# " ! &#%&-!!"

% ,*)70#$.4. ." & &'("!$#+9 '! &. & &,,",8& &!

% # & 1&" !: *#"!"(! ".4'"! " ! 1&" !"

&"'! #!+/ & '!# " "

&' !" (/"(

#-" "(!4"

'++"(" / "

'" " ! D 1&"?&"'< >+( &$#',# "

!! "

# $

; $

-&&( & " "#(!# " & &# .#(% ((/(4 "

' ("+(!+ "

+ '(!"

% / ("

! #' : *#"!"( ! 1&" ?&"'&&(#

#("&- ( !# ( &

& " ".(( ( & &" ! : *#"!"(! ".4 /'" ! "

"(/ &!# .#(+(. !!' #!& /' " ! < &-#% & B: ) +( # " " 7 # +( !!' &" + ''" " '# & +&( &''(( 9 ".(( ( & " "#(!# " .& &!# .#( % ((/(4 "

' ("+(!+ "

+ '(!"

% / ("

! #' #!& : *#"!"( 9 " #+ # & : *#"!"( +/" / #" &.4 /' " ! " " &" & # /"! #'

&!# (4!+ " , &("+(

5 " ! ! $#!&" !C#"''!" "

." &% (! !# " 9#!& : *#"!"( ! " ## +/ #'"!"# !"!#, !- ( & " !"+"(" / +!, #+ #( ! C# (/ " ( " ",' ! 1&,'"

!"'(&+ # !" +/ &"# "

(."

%& $ )# *+ 9 & ! !"!#, ! &"!-.&( & & !# +(.!,," "

(/"

%#' B: )

&,"!+ ,( &' !"!#, ! D 1&"?&"'< >+( &$#',# "

$ -& &( & : *#"!"(! ".4'"!" !-( &#%&"

%" " # " ("

+'(! &#' 1&"?&"'& &(# D= )7=," & '" &,4"

% &",-!!# (4 &", 7&/ &-"

&&#+ -.#(! ""

)7=-" +/ (( !,'& " 9 & , " " # " - &: *#"!"(! '#' & + ,+/!!# )7=+!,#+ #( B: *#"!"(! ".((4 .

".4 '"!" !-( &#%&"

%" " # " ("

! &#' !

+'(! $$ G ) 8 & /-$' ;-' $ * & 8&",-$' =-'5 D 1&"?&"'< >+( &$#',# "

# $ =$5 -&&( & "

!!"!#, "(" !- #("#' '!# " ' & !,'( !&"

.&"!&,# # #+ (/'"

.%#"(

!!# 7& '!# " ("#' : *#"!"(! - & # & :,"

&,." &% %! !# "

1&"?&"'&&(# D 1&" #+ & "

&' ! & " / ."

9 " ! + #'

!"!#, "( " ! 9 ! !"!#, "( " !- & #("#' &'!# " ' & !,'( !&"

.&"!&&((# #+ (/'"

. &%#"( &!!# 3# &,-" ! !"!#, "( " !- .& & '!# " (" #' : *#"!"( ! - & !# & :,"

&,." &% %! !# " 5 1& '!# " & "( ' & ! %" & ''(( +/ +(#+ !!"

%(/- &''("((. &*#%,

- " 1&"+"(+ "!&% *"$&, 2#%

%&$"&# 2#% 7& &'4"

%6 A6 7& &' +( A6