High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1554/2019dismissed

Darshan Singh v. Central Institute Of Research On Buffalo, Sirsa Road , Hisar And Others

2024-09-02The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri13 pages

!"# $$%%& ' (&%)&"& &* *+ **%,-"& $&

& !"# , &*& $$%%& .( $, & *$&. /////

!"#$ ! %& & 0"$$% 1 "1"#"$* 0"&,& $$%"

&"* &"*%2%%3& %2* 42"*"%"# 2"*"%"#" (&"$* !! %& 5 "&& && && $$% (% 6 * & &&&& 1*"%12& $$%%&370"%"# & 4 $12 % "#%8 #"(9 : : &"&%

,3 12& 3$12& (&% ;0& ) &"% 5"1 %

01 ( &)), ( "# * &<& 5"1 %=,"* *& 370, 1&" +"** &*& & && $$%%& * &<& 370=3## 3"& & (&%)&"& &* *+ **%,-" *1"&2<()+,-"= 44 3 #& &0$2 && 3*

>, " &

"#&& 370, ""

3&0"& 4

3 $ & 0#0&, & 370 " & $*0 " &2# %%2>3"#%&& 1" & "0

$& .01,

: %&"0&%2 1 &2 3* 4

5 370 $& & & " &, ()+, -", %%#"# & & 3 1"# 7$& & * 37 " &" &

,& **"

) #,!

1(0$ ()+,.1 3 " && && 3701 %%*37"00"&%2

"#%2, & 3703 %% $&?" &2>

,3 ""&& *"!

1(0$

1 && 370"& & $ * 37 5 $&0#0& " & &0"& " "

,3 "

3&0$2"& @ 02 2 & && , & 370 3 & *0 "3 1 &3%&73*&1 & 42, &"

3 12 & 370 %%#"# &0"&" 5 (&% ;0& " &"*"

&" & 4

4, " A " * $3

! &"

1 &" *& ) &"% "$ & &, * &<& &=0* && 5"1 %

0$%&" * & $%"#, & $&" % & " " " $$& * & " $ &" " 3 & 4 A ,& * 33"* *& 370#"&& $&0#0& > )& "3"&3 &%21& && %& # %&" $$%"

1% & & 370 3 & <( % 1

;&*50$2!&& # %"&"!

0*;0& * )",

>= * & <

> # %&"= -3, 3 "% $ $&"# & & & & " $"", "&&%2, $"" *0 & <( % 1 ;& * 50$2 !&& # %"&" !

0 * & $&0& * 5% &", * &< 5# %&"=3$

"& 3, 3 "

& %2 & $$%"

1% 1 & % 0&"%%2 "**& -3, & 3 3 $ & & 1" $ & 5 # %&", &" $0""1% #"& 370 "# &0$2 && " $" # %&" .4 & *, 3 # %&"*&

># %&"3$$%"

1%"& "&& > 5 $&0#0&"%& 3$12 & 5"1 % 12 32 * (9 : : !"#% 8 # %%3& 3"&$&"&""?

#0&& 4B & *"3

##"12& "?

#0&,370 $*& $&"&( &$$% % * & $$%%& & " %2

&& & %& # %&" $$%"

1% & & 370 " & $&0&&1 & %"0

&& &"*& 3%2" 370 $$ "# & 5"1 %, & * # & & 1 3" "* ,&"

& 0& 0$&"3 #"&& 370,0&12& $""*! &" @*& &%" 3$% $ '%%()* !'%%( ! : &,% %*$&. 0&%2$$& $$%3 "%*"#& ? #0&$12 % !"#%8 # )& " 10"&& & & & $"" * 5 # %&"3%2$$%"

1%&& 0$%212 & $&0&*5% &",$ "*"

%%2$" # %&">*& 05 &3# %&"0&"%%2"**& %2 &

> # %&" $$%"

1% " & * & 370)&"* & 10"&&& &""3*& $$%"

1%$"", & "

* 3"& &0$2&& %1"$ 3"& 12#""#0& =&"

"3"&"#-3,& $& " & & * <10& * 37= 12 & 370 , &

! 370 & " & %"0 3"& " 1% $" . A$%&""*& 0"#*0& 3703"& #&& %2 *&$&"#* &2>

,$ &&& " &"&

12& " &,()+,-"& 370 "#1

%% 37 $"& " $ & 7 5 370 " & $&* &2& ,1 "?1 9 % %*& $&"$ & 3"& & "1%"& 4 )&3 %1$$"&&*&& # %&"#"#& ##0& * & 370 1* $$ "&"# & "% &&" "1* 5

># %&"

+ ,#,-./0 12 3/-1##34 564,7 /,38"#73- "#$

3#-,1#-'39..12 3/-1##34"#$/",#,#:

"-5"4 "615/3/- '/"#. 12 3;91/"/0 .".5- "#$

3:54"/,-".,1#(7<3;3 5 " 0 %% 1 %% C( % 1

;& * 50$2 !&& # %"&" !

0*;0&*)",

>C 5 " !

0 3"%% 0 "& * 3 *

> > 5 " 0"$$%"

1%& " 0$%20& * & ""&"D $&0& * ;0& * )" & " && 1"&**"

,& &*" *& + & "& %% & 1 $$%"

1% & % 37 " "%32, $&0& * 5% &"

$&0& * & 3 %2 & " 3 0

) 50$2!&&

"50$2&& 3 %1 *%% % %1 3 "0$%20&& &*" * & " 3 &" "

*&%&2,3 "

0& && 20 & 1 ## * $" * & %& 2

: 2 " & * **"

1"# 2 37

"" !

*0& * &0$2 && 3 % 1 3"& &* && &"D"%1"%"&2*# % ; $E =$&

""" (*0& * &0$2 && % %1 3 % & "% 2 # " " &" $"1"%"&"5 ##0&3"%%1"%2 & * $2 1" - 02 1 $%2 23 3"& " & "&0& "&D&"&"% " % & 1"*"%1"%"&2*37

" !

% %1 3 " &0$2 && 3"%% &, 3, 1 1 # & & & $0& &1%" 0& % & 2 % & & # # %% &"$ *; $E =$& 50$2 && 3 % &"&% & % %1 && *%%3"#1*"&

"9#&"%2&3"& * && 0""0 0 *& $2 %* $"## %; $E = **"

"%" % "# ,-((

"" +*"& * " 0& & & 0 & $$%"

1% & ; $ E = 0$%2 3 % 1 &7 "&

& * %

%&"# $& 3# * 2 2*"

1? &&$*0 * &2* & %& 2, : 2 " 0""&&" **"

1"# 2 37 " & 2 *0 & & *

*0&*&0$2&&

"""&"&%0&3"%%1$&1"&& &* 2*2 2*37, % 2 & 7" * %, A $& 0&"&2 %, 3"%% &10""1%5 23"%%%1%%3& 2 *3& %&& " "&& "# %"&" 5 23"%%&1&"&%&& 1*"&* 0& *%&0"&"*"

*2 & "B "&&"#"

" &"&2 % & %2 % %1 0""1% & # % ; $ E = 0$%2 3"%% 1 %%3

F*& "

&0$2&& 3 %1 &*& $ $*&"0&1*"& *&& "# %"&"

" *& "# & 2= &" "

*& *0& * &0$2 && , & % %1 3 % 1 && $ 3"& &0$2 ; $E =0$%2*& $ $* &"1 &"& & ;%"&@ ,3 %%* & 1 %"#"1% * & #& * @&"% D@% & 0 "&" $$%"

1% & &0$2; $E =0$%2,$"& 2* " &3 &" *0 $0& ;0& & * & " $&0&

""G&"%& 2# %"H,& 23 %1&"&% &

&""&2 "7 + D 1 %2 & & &$$%"

1%& :.1*"&& & & $ "*"13"%%1 0""1% & % %1 3"& &0$2 && -3, "* 2 "&"% 1*"& 0""1% &

%3737"#") &"%&1%" 0&" "3 * $"" * ) &"% "$ & &, & 2

= %% &" & 1 0""1% &

% %1 * 3-9,.3 71#23/;3#. 12 .3;91/"/0 -.".5- .<3 -3/8,73-12"7"-5"44"615/3/;"063$,-93#-3$>,.< 60:,8,#:"#1.,73121#3;1#.<,#>/,.,#:7"-5"4 4"615/3/>,.<.3;91/"/0-.".5-7"#"4-1?5,.-3/8,73 60:,8,#:">/,..3##1.,73121#3;1#.<<3>":3- 21/ .<3 #1.,73 93/,1$ >,44 63 9"0"643 1#40 21/ .<3 $"0- 1# ><,7< -57< 7"-5"4 >1/@3/ ,- 3#:":3$ 1# >1/@ 4 **"%%"# $*; $E =$&

" 53 & * 2 & " " ; $ E =

"$ &"**"

3 & 1 37"# 3 % 1 *"%% $ $ A&& "&0& % "

3"& & "&

&" " 12 $&0& * % 5""#*00#& %373"& &0$2 && -3, # % ; $ E = &** $% * 2 3"%% $" %"0 * 1$&"#"&A"&"#D* & ") * "%%"&& & 3 *"%&* %*"%& 0""0 0 %"*"

&" $ "1 * $&, # %"&" 3"%% 1 " %2 #"& & $&"$ &*3 "

%"& 2% 7*0""0 0 %"*"

&"3"%%&1B ""&B %"*"

&"5 2 3 % 1 %%3 # %A&" B "%& & & $" * 3 "

& 2 37 &" %2

# %"&" * % 37 3"& &0$2 && , 1&"& & " " $% 3"%% 1 $$"& 3& %"#2$&'"%&"* & " % 1 "3 2 " %2 &&&" * & $$$"& & "&" % 1 3 &

* "&1% " "$%"2 &" #"& & **"

"%&"#& "&

&" ) * & , & # "%" &" " & "

$&0&= & :44 % 1 *%%3 &"

&%2 " & 0&& * ##0& * % 0$%2"(&%;0&**"

$&0&*%5""#3"%% & $3 & 07 00& %A 2 * & $"" " & 0 & & 02 1 " 2*0&"0&&"0

)& " & "$ & & & & $"" B & " & 3 $ 12 & 5"1 % *0 5 # %&" 5 %& $"" *0 & " # %&" A& & * * 5 " 0 %% 1 %% C( % 1

;& * 50$2 !&& # %"&" !

0 * & $&0& * 5% &", C 5 " !

0 3"%% 0 "& * 3 * 3 > 5 " 0 " $$%"

1% & % %1 0$%212& $&0&*5% &" AAAAAAAAA 4

$"& *0& * &0$2 && , & "

* 021"$3"& "

3"& & %& $"" * & ) &"% "$ & &, & # * "%1"%"&2*37 3"& &0$2 && B "&"

12#""#0& I&"

)* %1 3"& &0$2 && 00"& 0"

&& 0"$"B "2*& #""# "01%$$& "&2, ""

3"%%1 "$3"& 5 23"%%&1&"&%&& 1*"& * 0&*%&0"&"*"

5 $&0& * 5% &" 3"%% & $3 & 07 00& " & 0 D & " "&

&" " &"% 3"& " & *037*& 0 , " "3 * & " $"" &"

1 & %!"#%8 #, "# &%2 %& &* &# %&" * & 5# %&"33#," # %&"*&

> # %&"3&1$$%" .3,3 %% "& $%#"#%2%& "$$ "#& " &"%?

&"&** &)&""&*0 & , 3 "

& 1 && 12 & 370, & & & 370=%&2 &23 : 4

3 &"% *0 4 4

& 4

*& 4

02 $$%"

&"*A&"# "%$&*37-3, 0&"

%2"& 2

,"*&%$*1 & 4 2 * & & 5"1 % 3 0 4

4 5 370" " %"0&&0&1*& 5"1 % %" $& " &"" 12& " &,()+,-"," &"&

$& 370=$&&"& :

%% & 370 * &2 -3, $"& "# 1 %% 37,& 370"&$&* &20"1&3*

)&"&& *& 370& & $$ 2 **"

"% "# **"

*& $&0#0&*&

2 $&&" 3 0 " & & # . A$%&" " *& 0"# 1*& &&&&+ & && 3 & $& "0 *0 ""# " &"% "$ & 3"& " 1% &"0 *0 & & 3 %& 37 3 %% * 37>

)& 1 *2&"* &2A$%&","& 1 "# &%2 "*& && 370 1 " " $"* 42" **"

"&%2%#%$*&"0*& $ 0$&" &1"# 5 " "$ & 3"& # & & %3 %" 3 " $-3,& " " &*2&#&& 370,"& $& & &"*"# %&"$$%"

1%&& $&0#0&,#"# & "

* -3,

# %&"3& &"

" " "1" $ & $$%"

1% # %&",& "

* 1"$3"& 12 #""#0& =&"

> , & $&

" & & * 10& * 37 & * &0"&" $ % * & 3& && %% %%" #$&& && 370 37 *,>,, , 42"& 0& *8 2,@1 2, , $"%, 2, 8 , $ &"%2, " 1"& % & 0" 1&,

" & &" & 4

& & 3705 " %%#"%&& *""# 12& % !"#% 8 # & & > 3"# %&& 1 " & & 37020&"%&& &2 1$"& &*0& ) "3 * & 1, &" * ! $"%&$$%"

1%&& "&& ) #$ % & &' '%!(! & $A( & %& &"*& "$ &" "*&%#$","& &1&3 &

"$ & &"%%A"&5 ,&3"& &"#& * && &%3*%"0"&&"& $$%2, "& " & 1 3 12 & 370 & & & " "$ & " @ & " $ $, & 0&& & & "*

"1% $" %$ & % %2,

%2 & %&"&07"#& " &"%"$ & &A"& 5 *, "* & 370 " 1% & #" &"* &2 A$%&" * & % %20&&& && "

0& " % & &" "&"%%%",%23 %& 0" "321

*& & &%3*%"0"&&" $$%"

&" & & ,"* 1

%2"$ &%#0"%""&1&& JK, & "& 3 % 1 A"&& "$ & 3 "

& 1 *)&3* & %& && 3J&2&"0K "! &"

&0"&*2%"0"&&""07"#** %3 * %"0"&&" & $$%"

1% & $ "# & & -3,& $%"

2*" &"%?

&""& &2&% %"0

%&1#%%2 #%%3"0

%& "&"* &2A$%&"*%2 ) & %"# & * & 1 "

", "%%#%"&2 $"&2 1 * 3"& & "0$ # ?

#0& 3 " "& " 1 & & ""& %2 " ""# " &"% "$ & "

$& * & 5"1 % & * 3"# & * " * *& 370,& # & $""*"0"&&" &, :>&$$%2&! &"

*& &)& $& , &"

1, A$%&" " *& 0"# *0 & 370 0&%2A$%""#& ""&%2 & &2,& 0&"% 3& && 3703&"&&"37"#"&" *10&*37 : %&&%2, *""# 0"& " & "&& %&& $&& $$%,& 0"

"#%2"0" .& & ' ( '

( !$&01 ,

9 & $7"#D LD. 9 & $&1% LD.