← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/867/2022allowed

Ravi Bharti v. State Of Haryana

2022-08-26Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur13 pages

 

    

 

 



    

  !!""

#$    !

    

 

% 

   & '



 ) * & $& '( 

!!""

  % !

% * & & ( ,( '

....

 

 /

0&$1&



2(

3 $!(     456 

/(

    7$1( !

1 2

 !$ & 9" $  

:% 6

:%( !

*



$(

!

(

&$1&

!

 1  2(

3 +! & +(



 1$ +! +

 1 $!

+

( 9  +! & +



 +! 

$+

3(

5(

$"

'+





$1  1$ +! +

+  1 $!

 + &

11 

2 

8$

&2 

$! (



    7$1( !

""1

&+(

&$1&

$

!!

 9 



/  / 2& :

+( :& 1 %"  %

 ( !

2

 <$ %  ( !

&  *& &

= +!"

%>? !

+!"

 "

$  !

$ ""

>  4 ?( !

- 

  

*  @ +

3

%$<

) *(   ) &( "&  - 

1

* & 2 A$+ (

2&   9

& 

2$" 

$C  1

2*

+

9

  @ +

*

&"!

$

$

& (

1



$(

 )&

&  D$

+!"

+ "'

 

 

:

E 4   @ *2  ( 0 + !$( "&

!$$ 

(

"1

2

& 0&

&'

*2

 % !

& %! 

5 &'

0  1 +!

9



"

%$<

) *(   ) &( "&

1'

 1  

&  :

"

&+

" !  1

$

!! - 

"

&$1&  1

$

" !

5 &'

0  1 +!

2

*2 % !

& D$

"

&  1

$ 9

!! & +

* 1

& 2 A$+

 )&

$

" & +

% !

&

&  "



$

& ( +!"

$

&'

 

 $"1

"

9$

% !

&

   1

$

& !

9 (

& ( 2

&'

&$"

8$

$

$ 2 ""

""

& 1 $

"

 

 " !(



& (

D+

+(

+  1





/  /

9 " %& 4?6//636

9 " 4 ??/ ? 

9$

//

"*

8$

! 

"

% !

&

9

*  )&

 $"1

"

9$

% !

& +!"

$

!$ 

+

"+5!





 1

 (

"



1 1

&!

  :&2 $+ + ! $ $9

 :&2  +

9$

$+ 1 ! $ $9



& + +!"

2& &

  "

-!

"( !

& 9

& 0& ( 9$1&

9'

 <$ % ) 8$

"" - 

$+ ! $ $9



$

+

$

& 2 A$+ (  )&

% !

& D+

 $   6 :%

$

9 ++

 :

  $

:

+

%> / $ 1

$  

!*

"2



!" 

+ 

+

 )&

! ! 9"

&

$  

"'

+ 

$ "$

!(

& $+

! $ $9



!$

 1

$ $

$    $   9

D@  &$9



6 $ 1

$

+!"

!  !'

+!"

/

 )&



:

1'

2& 2

$

1

 @ +

  D$

$

/(/ (6(3

5

!

!  1 !!

 $

1$

5 &  1 :

5 &  1 :

1  $

!!

+"'

) +"& 

1  !! ! 2& " !! *!

+ 1 ):

) *

 1 "

/(/6(( /5

  ) +"&  0 "&  "

$+ !

 1

5 &  1 :

1$ 

1+ 

0 "&

!"'

$9+

) +"& 

* !"  !  "



%$<

) *(   ) &

-

 < 

% !

 1

5 ,$$< 0  1 +!

9"1 1

9 (

+ 2&

1$

$

""  $ 1

$

$

$

& 1

!  '(

!$!

  1  @ +

5 ,$$< 0  1 +!

$

*!

1 !! !

) "  <

$

&$1&  $ &8$ $$! /(/ (6(3

5(

&

&$1& &8$ &

/ D$  $

1 +!

 (

$ *!

1 !! $+

&2

1$

$

&

1

+

1



 $ *

!

$

 1

&

1

+

):

$

&

1 +!

  F$

5 &'

0  1 +!

'( D: 4/6

/ $ ( 6( 6( 6/( / )( 6 :% %" 

!

( "&  1  

 2&

""

*

< 

/  / $ !$

&2 $

 1  $

1

+(

$

 

++

$   $  )&

"

1  +

!



< 



3 

+!"

!!

(

2(

$ /

%(

 ++

&$1&

 2(

// / ++

!! D:(

 

 0&$1&

 2(   /

  

1

++  

 !$ & 9" $  

:%( 6

:%

+$"

(

+$"

1 !$

$( !" 

1$ "

'(

+

"  $!!

!$

(

!$ +  (

! 1 2 $ /

%(

+

"  + 

&$1& &

$   (

$98$ "'

+



$

  8$ "'(

!!

! 

!$ (



7$1 !

*



8$

&2  

$! ( +!

  $"

!!""

 1$ $9+  

+!$1 



8$

&2 

(

9+ ! "'

(

+!(



7$1 $

1 ! '(

9$

1 +  !!



!!

   8$ "'(

1$

+!$1 

&(



 

?   "'(



$"

1$



""1

2""

+ (



 &(

/  !$

G;%>5 ! %>  "

$

 + 

$

$+ 1

"$+ $+ !&!&

 // )

'( 

;

+ 

%>(

D@

!!

 1

 "

$+ &'"

"&"

+ (



$+ 1"'

+  $

$

 $+!

&'"

"&"(

5( $!

$

$+ 1

"$+ $+ !&!&

(

!$

 9$ 

$+!

+ (

 1&

(

1 

++

$   !"

*

!$

( 9+  (

$   "'

$ &

G; %>?5)

 1 $   

!$ & 

         

   

   

         

 

       



 

     

    !    

     I /   !$

$   (

5(

' 1 "

!!

$

+  *

& 

+9





: G  

 !" 

$ ! 

 

++  

'

 1( $"



!

$ &

5(

 1

$

&

! 

2 G;!

9"1 1



/

9(

9+ "

""$

2 G;!

G;%J

 1 0&$1&

& (

2 G;!

* 1

!! +!

  

!  (

$ &

' 1 "

$ +

 

'

2$"

 1

& ( "'

!"'

+

2 1

!"'

2 +! $"'

2 1

$   "'



1 (

!$

2 G;!

 "

+

2 1 "'

2

!$'

2 G;!

+  1

2 1

&

 $"

&

!$' 1

2 G;!

$&

+

2 1

2 +! 

2 1

$  

 8$"

*

+!  

2 1

+

2 1

&

2 1

$   ( & +(

+$& !

1

$ 1

+

2 1

  "'

 9 1

&+( ! ""'

 (

9+

 

$  

G;%>?5)

 1 :

(

 

!! +!

  

 $  9+

+ 9"

"

 9 1 !"

&

/6 )

'(

&$1& %> *

! + 

 & 

 1 

& 1

"

!" (

& 

* !    G;%>5 -2( :

)   1&

2&+

$+  ( + 

 & 

!*

9$

 +  + 

 & 

 1

2 G;!

+

2 1

  G;%>5

G;%>5 0&$1&(

2 G;!

2& !!

 9;

%> !

9$

  1 G;%>5

G;%>5(

D@

+

8$ +1( 2& &(

& 1(

%> + 

 &   

+

2&

""

&+(



&+

D@ 

"'

+

2

 1&(

  %>

:

)   1&(

&$1& ++ G;%>5(

(

D@

&$!(

"

"$  9

+(

$9<

!  (

!! +!

  " "'

 -2(

$ 1

9+

*

"$ (

$! (

:

)   1& 8$ 

* 1

!

 1 G;%>5

G;%>5(

2 G;!

++$

+ 

 &  8$ "'( 

%>

+ 

 & 

&(

G;%>5

G;%>5(

! "'

  +9'

& (

+

2 1

  9+   & +(

D@

 

$

&  "" %>/?(

2& &2

*

!

&$!

 +!

 

 %>

+ 

  & 

 G;%>5

G;%>5(

' 1 "

9+ $!

5(

$

&  !$'

2 G;!

+ $

"$

$!  

8$"

G;%>5

G;%>5(    +9'

& (

+

2 1

8$

!! +!

  +!" "'

"(

1 "( ! $"'

2&  &2  %>

!*

9$

+!

$+

 +! 

2 1

+!

 $+  /3 8$"(

2 G;!



+!$

 D$ &+( %> 2&

2 G;!

;

+ 

+

$11

$"

+  1 4/( (

3/

'

!!

 1



2 1

 

& 

9"1 1

 0& (

"'

!! (



+

G;%>5

G;%>5(

2 G;!

!! 

$+

& !* %>( $!

$"'

&  + 

%>

&  $  9"'

 1 G;%>5

G;%>5 / G

$+ 1(

+

2 

+9  G;%>5(

"" %>/?(   %>

2 1 G;!

$+ 1



  +!

 (

& + 

 !$ 2 1(

+

2 1( 9 " (

 9"(



$ "(

$"

& 1

!

( !

*

(

' 1 "

G;%J

 1(

; 

+

2 1(

9

&$!

"

2 G;!

& 2 1

!  

9$

++

$ && !



+

2 1(

 !$ 2 1(

 

' 1 "

2$" 9+

+ 9"

 1 1

$ +

 

'

"$

&  /

1 

& 1

 ( ! ""'

+

2 1

' 1

"+

*(

5(

(

 

' 1 "

"'

9(

2 G;!

$"  *

!! 9

+!

  

+

2 1

(

*(

 

' 1 "

"'

$ &

 / $ &""

"$

!9

 1

 1

2 G;!

 /? @  1

 

9(

+

++  

$  

 (

! ( 2& !!

 9;

%>( 2&

& (

 1



++

$  (

  1

9 1

1$

92 1 ( % !

&

!!



 1



%>(

!$

!

!!""

"1 ( 2 A$+ , 1(



" 8$ 

92 1(

( % !

& -2(

&$1&

<$1+

2 /3  /?(



7$1 



 2 A$+ , 1(

9 !"





$"( $11



9 ""1

8$"



$! (

8$  "$ (

9  1

( 2&

"  + "

2 A$+ , 1(

 9$

!

!!""

&$!(

 9+ 



9 1

& +(

/   1

!

%>/ $ "(

!! 

5 ,$$< 0  1 +!

'(

" 1 

& 

$

 1 4 ??/



//??(

$ & 2 1 ! "'(

&$1& &8$  1 4/ 3?

 ?

&$1& &8$ 4/ 3?

 ?3

&$1& &8$ 4/ 3?

 ?3  (

!!



 1

;

+ 

%>/ (

9 ( "'

$ & 0  1 +!

'(

$ 5 ) < 

'(

& 

(

$ !

92 1(

& 0  1 +!

'(

2  % !

&

" 8$ 

92 1(

9( !

& 0  1 +!

'( 

!!""

$

!$( & +(

" 8$ 

92 1(

% !

& 0& (

!! 

1  1(

 (

& 

 9$

!$

$( 9 $"'

$+  "

   %>/?

;

+ 

(

"1

!!""

& * &



&

&  < ( ! 7$1(

%  

): $   *

 

42 "& ( !

 $ / ) 6( 6/

:%(

/  / / 

%

$!



&$!

!! (



8$

&2 (

+!(

++

$  (

"

 9$

(



 D+

 $ 

""2 1 !  !"

+1



2 G;!

<'

 

'

 1 "'

9 1 !"'

!$'

"1

 !$ 2 1(

!"'

+

5

 2 1

!  9

+

5



!! 2 1 9 1 !"'

2

+! $"'

2 1

 !$ 2 1

! 

 $

""

 2 1

! 8$ 

$ " & 1"'

!(

!$

"'

!"'

5 +

2 1

! !$'

2 G;!

&$!

"

9+

 $"'

 9"

*

2 &'

!! +!

 ( &2 

 

 9$

$"!

(

' 1 "

"'

$ &

!!

 1

++  

$  

*(

!!

 1

! 

'

"  

 



 9" ( $"

$$ 1  $+

(

 

$11

$&

 9$

$ $"(

5(

 

$

" '( &2  6 $"

 $ 

+!$1 

$



1

1 +  !!

9(

8$ 

9 1

$""(



  3 8$(

& +

!! "(

""2 +!$1 

2

    7$1

&(



  ! "(

$ 9

 

&2

""(

 & 1

$ '(

8$ 

(  

&2 "

!  "  

 1"'

!!

 D 

'( !

&2 $

& +(

  2 

9"2(

2

&2 &   !! '(

'(

8$ (

&(

 '

;! '

! 

" +

  % 1 + ""

$

!!"

(

'(

(  ! 

 

 !"!

      #$%#$&'($)*+,-.&$)'/,$01 $'./