High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/38881/2013allowed

Anto Devi v. Ut Of Chandigarh & ANR

2018-10-11Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma10 pages

"#$% &% '(

'$ "%) %$$ '% )%* +#'&,#+ ' %- '&%'$ ( ./0 0

,*%&12( 00 #*#3 &) #$% $+%-%$$ '% 0

3 &&

+#'&,#+ "'%+4*5# #',#3 &) #$% %- '&%'$

"!3 !

# $% &" "'() * + & & )% , -* + *+ + & $ % .

/ ))+0 #*0 / 0+/10 '

# # "

.0 0 2 0+ / * #+/+2 + 2 )+0 0 ++ / / 30++ 4/ +0 *0 0 / 24 )+0 #)%4 / & 0 24

3 ,0+ 2 2- 2 +0 4 0 / 0 1 + 3 0 02+ # ! 0 + // 524 3 3 6 2 +5 2 /+4 2 & 0+24

2 4 4 # ' 04 + + 7 2+* 4 + + 0 / ))+0 3

+ 0/++4 4++4 24 2 # $#* 4 2& 0/++4 /+0++ +40

4 +0 + 2+ 0 + 0 /+4 6 2 8 204 2 0 / .

/++ + + / 9 2/+*0

+ +0 / 2+ 30++ 4 +* / $* '*' :) 0 /+ 9/+ *+ 0+ 2 ; 0 * +* / /+ * /+ 2 + 30 0+24 2

//+4 / 0 2 * /+ + /+ 0 / + * /+ + + 4 + 12+0/ /+ 0 0 + <+ + /+

2 )+0 5 ++ 4 + & 3 0 / 4 + /0/ / + 0 + ++ / 0 / 4 0 2 +4 + ++0 + ++ 0 /+30 2 / 2 +4+24 /+*0 0 *20 0 /+ / /+0 * 2/+ /+ + 22+ / +2+4 02/ 0 / *0 4+ + 30 ++ 2 02/ 0 4 +0 24 ) / + 0 0++ + 0 / 4/ 0/ 0 40 0 2/ +4

3 + 0 + ##5#' #%+ 6 0$#$% 789 89 ::73 0+%+#&%'# 60$#$% ':8:90:;3 0*-%'$%'&%'$

%36#-#'40',+3 8989 3<'&#' - #$ '6< '&#/$& ;

989=:30*'$#4*5#4#+2#-60$#$% +# ' 0>:305$0*?#$#*@+%?%%6 #+#'$4*5# *@+%?%%AA=8 989A3#'&%%-0',+60$#$% *'?#13 AA=89897:3 $#50',+60$#$% "%+8:9 897;;3 #,&+ 60$#$% #?#$+#' 'AA=/ 8#?#$+#'9=A3 *'4#-* 6+%0$#$% "%+ ' 8 9"7 *5*@+0',+6"#)'&%4#*AA89 89 + + )2 ++4 .

0 2 &$ % 2 5 0 &"(#

/ ))+0/+ 3/* 0 /+ )/+ + 2 24 5 ++ / /+ + / / %%$#%+ $# '60$#$%

'8:989* 6=2+ 5

2 2242 >)

" "

4#'#?60$#$% *'?#1 389 85'#9;A78093 6=2+ 5 2 4 + ++ +0 4 0 *0++4 ++ '$# 6 0$#$% *'?#13 8:9 85'#9 3 0 / 0+24 0 &"'() " + /+4//2 2* 5 0 &"(# 2 0 4 + ++ + 20 +

20 2 02/ &/+ +4* #?'&%4#* 60$#$%

*'?#13:8:985'#9

3 /+/+0+ &"'() " 2* !

0 ++ 0 2 5 / 4 + 2 '%+4*5#60$#$% +# ':8 9 897=3 6=2+ 5 2 &"'()

12+)2+2+ +2+ / 0 + 24 +0 /+04 2 + %%$*-$# '60$#$% +#@+#'&

' 809

;

6=2+ 5 2 + &"'() 00 24 ++ 02 5 + + /2 /+ 4 /++ + 4+ /2 6=2+ 5 /+ 2 2*+ +4 2+4+ / + ++0 / .

+2 0 4 + @ +0++ 2 / #)%4 / *

0 4 + / .

0/ $ 4 .

+ 0 ++4 22+ ++ 4 0 ++40

+ + +4 //# !

0 00 /4/+ 0 /+* + 0 24+ + /+ 0 4 +0 / + /* / .

+0 24 / +*2 0 4 / /+ * 0 / *5 +0 / 0 02+0 0 24 2 /+ A * # $ 0 0 3 /0/0 / 0 24 2 0 24 3 A * / 0 24 2 /+0+++0 + 2 / # $ %, -

2 + ++ /+4+ + & ' & ( , -*2 0 0 / 0/ ++ +4 /+ + / 0 +

+2 &++* + +4 / +4/ +4 0 0 +4 ++ * 2 /+2

B5 * 2 2 <+ ++

2/ 30 2 4 + 2 / /+ *24/ 3 /+* 22 + 00 ++30 ++0 + ++ .

2 ++ 0 .

4 ++ 4 + .

*0 +4 2 4 +0 0++2+/

C =* + 6 2 0 ++ 4 +0+/+0 + 0 * 2 * ++

+ 0 24 5 0 &"(# 0#$+%+#60$#$% "%+ ' 07;3 22 >) D)*&

' $

, ' $ &

")2#B#1 60$#$% #2#'#3 ;8:989 3 24 2 4 ++ +0 4 0 + + 2 + ++ / / * 0$#$% #2#'# 6+ +#?#'/# AA8989 8093 6=2+& / 2 0 0 + / 0 ++/ /+ 2 / 22+* 0+20 0 /+:

* ++/ * * 2 / 22+ 0 / 3 2 /// 2/ 2 24 + + 3 0 /2 * ++0 .

/ * + 2 2 0 3 /

"!9

$%'

" : E: 2+ E: