← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9078/1999allowed

M.C.Ludhiana v. Roshan Lal And ORS

2024-09-10Mr. Justice Mahesh Grover28 pages

 

    

 "!"-"

   "

    



' *((**;

'

((**;

  ((((((" " 4"!!

 !

     " (((((( "!  "!

   #$"

%&'



    ( #(5( 677 # - "

  " " "( ( #% )& 5!& # - 

 ( #(5( 5!& # - "

  " "!  " 8 "

 

" "!" "  ! %""

" "

%&  " " "      

 ) $$  " "

(*(

#"+"   !!"

%& "  ))!! "  ,-!    %"$ #"" #

& .

""%&  "

!)!!

"!  " 

! %"" !" !

! "   ! %"" ""

" "  "      . "!  " 8  ! :,# #!!!   ""!"  " &)"

   !"/" "!  !

- ( *( " %"

! !

-" %""  "   " "  "  

!

  "!  "  .!  "

! )   "       

  (*(  

!%!"/"& " .!  !"

! 

.0

  **(( ( 1 "" "

" .!  !"

.

0  "

( 2((

  "  " 3+"-" 3$ "" !" ""

 

*

 ."

) )  .

0   "  !

#!!!  :,#  !

. "-"( >"

!

" )) )"

"&  " 2 -") )"

 " 

!

#!!! :

:,# .("( *( ( ;   " &"  ( 1 "" " "!  "

"

 8 (=*

  %"

"  !    "$$ $  " "

( *(  - " .



" .! !0"

 ! 

.0

  < " 8 ( 

 !! "

" !

!

"$7

 ! #!!! :,# .("( ( ; ("(  "

) .



  %"" .

0$    & &( " "     " ! .  "  

0  " !  

!

#!!! :,# .!

 "+!""

"    ""

" "     % "  9!"

 "$7"

!

#!!! :, ,#( 1 " ! "  .!

 ! !"

%&  " ,-!  6"

!   - " "

*( *(  %& !!$ 

 .$

"'  

  

    

                    

          

          

      

    

                  



 ! : .! !

" %"

"  !     " ! . "     

 2 -")" - " )")

"

( *(  ""

!

#!!! :,#

 !"

 "

 ))"$ )

*( ( ;

=(

(  !"/"& 

" " " .!  !&   ) "  " !!"

%&  ! 

 "

*( *(    .!

 "

""

  " " " . ") ! 

.0  .("(

=

*( ( ( :  ! )"  !)

!(;?=( .! 

"!  "

  " "

)

*( ( ;  =(

( > ."-"  "!  " 8

   9 

  "  !



.0 (  !"/" &  "  ))!! " - " ""

" "

= ( ;

""

"!  "  "  

!

"! .

( 6(( # 9 3+"-"

3$""  #( > ."-" " "

!"

"  "!

 ))!!  " !  " ! "" .! !" 

$

"

(  )  ".  .

.

" "

 " ." *@=  )"! 

"-"  " "" 

"!  "  % " "

!"

"   " !)"( 1 "" "  ") . ! ) "  !" " "" %& "$!""

! .

 .!

""

.  " "  8(,(   

! )" "!  " 

" & & "

!"

"  " " " .

 !  

!%    0 .$ & ."  

" .!

""

%

"!

) ) ( 6(( # 9 ! 

.0 ( (  !"/"& "!  "  .!  "

 " !!"!  -

" "

?(;( ;( 3-" " ! " " .!   ""-"

%& "! 

"   " !)" .!

!"

 

!

!"( 1 "" "  "!  "  .! !!"

 $"!

"" "

?(( ;( :  " !

!  $"!

""

 .$  $"! ." "

)"

$! )'  "# $%& &'()*+#

 # &  #   

       & 

   ,    &           -./01#2234

'

  

234  

      

 



                 

     



;

 

6



7       687 

  

 "           

   



             

   

    

       (

 



       



   #05 & 

   &     ! !"

"  " !

,   "!  "  "-" "

  $"!

""   " !)" .! !"-"

%&  "!!

!$  

!

 !"( 1 "" " ( 2$ "" $   #!!!  ))!!  " .!  "

!  :/& & 

" 

 /& 

( #!

5) 3!%!

)" " " " .!  "

!

"!"$  

"( 1 " :/& 

" !! "

""  "!  " 

 *(A(  ? "$ )  " 

!

"

 /&  =( ()(  (( ?  " ! "" . ! !"  $

( 0  $  ".

.  .

" "

- ! "

"  "

*(A( ?   "!  "  "

!"

""-"  " "

"" 

" .! !"-"

%& !$  ""   " )

!

!"( : "! !"  ""  "!  "  ""

 (( ?

%"

"  " :/& 

"( " :/& & 

" !0"

"!  " 

!  .

" " "  )!  ) 

 $"! "-""

$! ) ) ""!  " !)"( >"

!!"

 " $  "  $"!  !"

" 

"( 1 " :/&

" "

""

" 3!%!

)" " " "  "

   $"! 

"!  "    .

) )  " !" 

"(

?

"" " "!  "  .! !0"

) )0" !")" . "$

"    )!! 

"  $"!( >"

& "

!"

$" !

!")"  "  ) "&  "  $"!( 1 "" "  "!"$ 

" .! !0"

%$  ")" ."!!"!

 " "+  " ("( (( ?  =( () )(  "!  "  .!

""

!$  "  ""

$!   "

.  " "+ " .



" "

!"

!$( >" .! $ !"-"

.   "" "

;(( ?

"$  )  "  (( ? %"

"  " :/& 

"  =( ()(

."-" " "

!"

" 

" ""  0  $  ".  "

" "

 "" ! %"" ! "

  " ) $"

!"

"!  "  (  ((  ? "!  "  $ ""

  !")"!

")" ."!!"!

( ,9 $  (#(   ))!! "B (  )   ".   ))!! "C!

" 

)( 2!

 5 ""

"  ,"! "0  ))!!  "C!

" ."" " ( #

" " $  " !")"!

"!"  ""

")" ."!!"! "!

!  "  .! !0"

 !!"+) "  "!" ."!!"!( : "! !"

" "!  "  !"



" .!  .$   !!"+)" 

!"

."!!"!  " ."

$" ! ! ")" " ( "!"$  

" #!

0 5) !"

%"

"  :/& 

"   

" ."!! ! "/"

%"

"+)"

  "" " *?(( ? .!

+ +"

 %$$  ""

."!!"!

)"! %&  "" !

"( "!  "  "

!"

!$   ""

$!( #$  ""  "

(( ? .! !" 

"!  "  

)$ )    " )" ."!!"!

-" 

%" "+)"



" ! $-"   & &  "!" ! ."!!"!

&

) )"  *?(( ?  =( () )( > ."-" " "

!"

""-"  ! ""   !"/"& 

" !)" .! !

!"

 " )

!

!" %& ( 0  $  ". (  *?(( ?  "!  "  .! "!"   $ . "!"$

"( "!  "   !"

    .

.  "!" & ""

."!!

  "!" & ""

)"!( ( >" !

!"

 

  . !

!

. !")"  %" "  

" .

   0"  !$ &  ""

$!( 1 " :/& 

"  "

"  ! "$  " "- "" - ! "

"  "

*(( ?  -"

"  $"! %"& 

% $! "!  "  ( 1 "" " "!  "  .! !!"

 !

.!"

"  "

"

;(( ?  $ $ .  &

" /& "  ! 

.

& " !

   %"

!)!!"

) !"-"( >" "

!"

" "-"  " ! !

.!"

 "

"

;(( ?(  !"/" &  " "

*

 ? .! !!"

 !)!!$ "!  " 

) !"-"( "!  " 

"

"  %"

"  "  ))!! "  ,- -!    "$$ 

"

!

!)!! "

*

?( ( 1 "  ))!! " - !

" "

*A(

A !" ! " 

"

!)!!( 1 " !

" "

*A(

A .!

 "$"

%&  " " "    %"

"  !     ?*

( 1 " ! . "

 .!

! !"

%&  ,-!  6"

"

!   - "  "

*( (   "

"

*A(

A .! !" ! "  " ) " .! ")"

%0   ))!!  "  ,-!   .

.  "   " "



" "

"

%& "!  "   .    "

"" )  !( " !

" "

*( (  !!"

%&  !   " ! !  "'  ,    &  

   

(9 15.2

3 233:      2        

 &

        

    (  : &  

" $ ( (9 152 

?5 ;"     

     

 

     

% 

  "  

          9   

          

   

     

 



 

 9   

       

      5 

   9      

    <     



  

     9    

  

    

    "            .22233=

 & 

 ,   &           

           



     ; , >   

            

   



    

9    

 

       2             

5 9   

 (  

         

         & 

  1  8   1     

          

                

          

 

   (9 152 <    & 

  1 8  1           

2# @

  9    & 

   1  8   1      

                         )   

      9

   

           

     1 



      & 

  1   8   1    233/! "" " " .!

" % %&  "  ))!! "  ,-!     - " "

( *(   " " "

""

%& "! 

" 

! %"" ""

 "

!)!!

"!  " 

! %"" !" ! "    ! %"" ""

 ))!!  "       

   . "!  "

 ! :,# #!!!  ""!"  " &)"

  !"/"  "!  !

- ( 1 " !

" ! %"" )$"

%& "        " "!" . " (



=( "!  " 

!

"

 ""

." !")" 

 "!"

" )

" " " 

 ( : ! %"" !"

 " ." !")"   "!  " 

.! .

0$ ! #!!! :,#  ""

" " .! . $& ""

  "  !



.0  

" !!"

%&  "  ))!! "

"  ,-!  

"

(* *( #"+"   ! " "& "$  -  !

%"  %"

 " ;( " !

"!  " 

! %"" "

"

%&  " "     %& $  "    " ." !")"

"

%& "!  "  ?(

""

 !"

  " "  " .

" "

"$  )$"

" "

(*( #"+ "   ! !%)"

 " !!" % %"

"  " #"" #

& ("(  ))!! "  ,-!    .! !  .

" " 

" !

)" .

"!  "  .! "$  -  .

""!  " ! 

& !

$ "

 



""

$ %& " $   $    "

!

)"  !!"

%&  "  ))!! "

"     



  ! $!  " !

" !!"

 =*

 ( >"

 " !%)"

  "  !

)"

!)!! .!

) !"

  "!  "   "

 . $  "  "

"

.

!  "!

%"

 "! ."" $ "

"!  " 

"

) )!"   " /&  ""

$!

!

."-" "!  " 

" " "

& "&  "  $"!

""    "

& "" "- ""

%"

"  :/& 

"  !"   " /&  ""

$!   $"! "- -""

  "  $"!

""

-" %""  -"

$!

"!  "    ""

"  "

!

!)!! ! %"" !!"



" !)"

 ! . $& %"" !" ! " %&  #"" #

&( A( 1  ""

 !" 

 "!  " 

!

!%)"

 !"  " " " .! .

.

0$ ! #!!! :,# ""

"

" .! . $& ""

 "  !



.0  

  " !

"!

 "!  " 

 

 "   " /&  ""

$!

!( ( :

-"

" ""

 !"

  " "!  "!"

" " ( ! .



-" ")"

"$"

)  " % -"!

" $!  "   "!  "  .!  &  "

! ) 

( *(   "" " " .!  !"

!

! 

.0   **(( ( >" .

0"

! #!!! :,# ) *( (  ;  =(

 

!

!

%""   " !&

  " ! !   !"  "!

"

*( * *(  !!"

%&  !      8 (=*

 ( 1 ! "   .!

! !"

%&  !   - " "

*( *( 

%& "  $  " !")"

"  !"

 "!  "!  (*  =

     .

""%&  .!

!"

  "" !  ! -%" ! )  "

" %& "!   "  $! .



)& %"   ))

"

 !  

""

"     

 9!  " " "!  " 

""  $  ! !

! !  .

" &  ! !)  "

" %& ) !

-( 1

"      " $-"   "0$  & "!

.$"!   & "  "!  "    "

" .

0"

!

#!!! :, ,#( 1 " !"  

" ! %""  )"

. %&

" "  "    %& )0$   &)"

!(;?=( !

"!

.

.$"!

  " "

) *( (

;  =(

 .

" .

0"

! :

:,# #!!!( > ."-" . "$ ! 

" .

""

"%&  !   ""

"       9! "!  "  

$  ! ! !  .

"  &  ! !)  "

" %& ) ) ! - !  ""

 

! %"" !"

  "  !

-$ ! "

) "   !( @   & %" ""

%&  -")"   !" " " & !

! ! %"" ""

%&  -")"    "!  " 

! %""   9!"

$!  !) !

:,# # #!!!  ""

" "!  "  .!

& % 

"

) !

!

&   " !%!-"  !



.0   .

" .!

""

"

)  "!

" 

!



.0  - " ""

"

= (

;

#"+" ; "!   "  "

!"

"-" "  !

"  "" " !

  "

)"

"!(  !"/" & " .! "

 " !!

!"!  - " "

?(;( ;

 ."

%&  $"!

"" "

?(( ;( 8 "&   $"!

""  .!

"

%& "!  " 

 " "

  /&   ""

$!   "

"-" )" ! 

"" "- "" .!

"

%& )  

$

 "

 .

!

!

 " %"

"  :/& 

"( 1 "  $"! "-""

 "  $"!

"" -" %""  -"

$ ! "!  "    "

 .$  "  "

"

! %""  !)!!"

) !"-" -

" "

*

?( 8

  %"

 . " /&  ""

$!

" $! "!  " 

*

( " > C%" ")"     #   

   ! $ !

"  

" >$   !     

" .

 "+)"!  )"!

 $! "   ")" /&  ."

9   "-". !   "

B .

.

" "  " /& .!

"

%&   )"

"" 

&B  $ 

"  "

" "!%"



.

" "  "!

 9!"

-" %""

 ."

( " > C%" ")"     %& # &   

   

   !

!" .

"  ! "$  ! "

 " """  " #"! **A@ @**

"  ! 

:  !

" !  "'  2 8  

   

      

          '

' &

        

            5     <   

   & 

 "            

 

      & ( 



   "        ' &

           



   

'&

 9  

 

 (  :0- &   "  

        5      '&

    ? <       A   <                 A     

        

      A

=

                 



  9

      A         

       

    

9

 A 

      



   

 

 

 



A    

 

   

    A           

 

     

  A         B( :0-

&   "  '&

 

  ? 675   A 67   

   <               A 67   <    A 67      A 67  

   

    67     

  A A 67       

 

 

   24 "           #       

    

 ! $   

    

 



?

;

;-   ' &

            (

: &   

        

  

 <        

?           <                                

  

     

  @  

       

  

       

  <             

  

  

 <              '&

    ( :

:        

 ' &

 



     

              <         

  

    

     

  

 <                          



  9

             

    

  

 

        



   

 

 

      

 

  

  C             <  

        



         

                    <      

?

          

    ' &

        

( :  &   ; 2= "  #        

 !&  '$

!!

$      

   52   4      

? ;2 

  (   :       <        &



 

   

   &

# 

%        

             

     



  

          

  



 

 

   &

 

 "

        <  ' &

   

 (  :   &                

     <     ' &

      

  

 (  :

        

  <           &

         <                          







  

 #     

       

    

<             

 

 

  <   

    '     

&

                      ' &

  

                  <    

 

  

    

    

 <               



 9

            

      

    

  

   



   

  

  

     

         <           



    

   

    <  

                

    ' &

 

  ( :  (   &

  &,*. /    &(  %&  # & )* +,&

)& - &(  '&

     

      

   

        

 

   

   "   #     &

     ' &

 9  

   

   

          

  5 

   

  

 /2=  &

    +<  , 2  23=:   &



&     



       

   



  

 

  

     

 * , 

+< & 

     *   ,        &

        * , 

  

 

        &

    

            

   ' &

 

       

  

    

     

( : 





     &

 9        



           

    

         <      (  

             

    

         "        

 





 

    



  

           

   

        

   

   (       

   

           

    (         

 

   

     

      

<  

     <  

                        9



      

 .01

2

 &  4 '&

    

     

  ' &

  

  

 (         '  &

           

   

   <                        '

' &

 

 

   

      



              

    

 

"  

   '&

   

 

  

 ' &

       

      

            

 '&

 9  

      

    



  ;

   

  

5 

  D

 E)> "

#3 .

 &($$ 

!! 4

 <

 



    9

? ;4        <     

   

    " + (    (



 

 

   

      

    

   



  

  9

  "         (   

 

  

  



     

     

   

    " + (  %   

    

         9 



  

  5 

     

     

   

 

         9

9



      

  

  $

                



  

  

   

  

          

;

" !) "

" !  9 $)"

" > C%"

")"     ! ,   &, 6 6 &. 7 6  

1  ,&

$  !"5 .

""  !

%"" " !  "'  /&    8  (    '&

 

)  

 

           



  

 "      8    B       

       )    



   



 "

"        <       

   '&





      

  5   "    5       

    9   

    "" /# ( : &  

*

/& 8& 

)&!

!),*&.  &



!

 $5  9

   6 : 8(  5 9

  4 !!

! 54    &

    

? ;-" 

  



   



 

      <    

        

      "<                     <  <               

    

          <     



        <  9  

                        

               

  

   



         





                 

  

  

    

        

       

   

    9

 6E/

!

! &

%&# &  

!

  $ 9    !! $4 9  !!;< 5 9   "!44%&# &

   .  $4 

!

4 9 $ $ !!49 $ !!;< 5 / #&

+(,  .

. . 

!

9  !!$  9 !!;<    3&( !  # 8 8&6   /1.

 &

&, ;

*

" ! -".

! ""& %""

" """

%&  " > C%"

")" 

  +. ,=(  ,, &.  

  -& 2  &   

 !"    " !

9 $)" 

! %"" " !  "'    



          <  9      0

      

    &

  ( (  :  (   ( 2: &  

"   

            

  

 



    

     

    

  

 

     9    &

  #   "&, )

 "

'

',4  !!

, &   #"

)  

 - &   !!     9    D  C    &

/ !

! &

% %&#&>     !!$4    ?5 ;2   

  



    @   

     

   9  

       

     "     <       

    

         (<                   

    &

0    " %& # &

!

,?4 4 !

!$5@ &

  -/

                    

    

**

     

   



; 4"   

  

   &

  3&6,     A,6 &6&. / ;&&

= + &.

$  !!$5   D C    &

  & 2 

%&#& > 

  !!4$ =" 

 



   &    &

   

   5 

      "    

 

         

 

  & &

0          <       

 

 



     

  

<  

          "

  

      

  

 



           

               

  

    





  



       9     9

 



 

        : @      <       



        &

   9  ? 6 7   <        

A 67  

 

      A 67   

 

      

 



         



*=

-"

   <             

      <     

  

                          

         

         <     

             

 

9  

     <     <

 /"    

         <   '

   <       

      <  

      

    

   

   

   

  

          

       <  "     

   

          <     3  &     &

   9   

  

  

( : (  2:   &  

                 <     9     

                  

   





 

 

   

  

 

 

 

       

!

*(  "

&  " " "

    ) " - !

 ))  !

 "

"$ !"-"    "!  "   .

 "

*;

 #"+"

"! ?  A !

" .&! "

 !"

""-"  " ""! "( 

"!!"

)    "  !"

/ /& " 

"



 )"" 



"   " !)" "

"

"

!  "'  (+FB)+15= +) 82=434 $)8+ $?2301#  #)

 &

    

 -./01#223 34<    # C# (

  +9  +  @##(    ,    &           &

+     

      # &             234           # )

 &



0   #)

  &



     (   

        

  



        

 

 

  

   

          ;8; B      "      

        

              

 ,   &       %      # )

  &

         

   

    

 

     9   

          

 

    &    '

       

  

   

 #05 & 

  ,   &     24434

*?

(+FB)+15: $ $ 40* 88?2=434 & 

 

24434  

 #)

  &

 



     0$   -./01#  2234   

 

          

   

 C C 

          (         

         

     #05 +  #  ,   &       +

9 9 9 9! """ ! ) "  #

 - "

*A( (

#"+"

 * $-" %& "!  " 8 "  ))!! "       

  " 



)" .

""%& !

"/"!"

" " "     "!

!"

) ! 

.0 ( D: B

& 

  ,   &       #   ?)<     ##&  & ")

 # ) C

  44.  )   

    ?5

 "

 ,     &      2.-- $   

"E

(  &  " 23/4  " -/.  "      &

*A

  +9 + 

"8( 1

  %  22.23/4  .22233.

  #

  ( ( "< "   (



            (

 "  

     //    '

G  ' &

 

    222332      22.23/4 4 .22233. " 

     (

       &     



 

   

   (

    

     " 

  

     & 

    23 334 

   6

 "  



" 

     &    +9  +7

   2=434  "

    

  ( <  "

 

       2223= " "       8  & 

 1     2223=    8   & 

      :22 23:         

    (     :223:   ,   &        & &@1   2=3/  233-

              8   & 

 5     8   & 

  1        /33 "  ,   &                 '

G '&

  /33

    2=3./ 2333         





"

 "<  "< "   "

*

      

  &    

   "

 <       &

"E  2.--       

"  

 " "



  " 

    

  

   "



        "   

  <  "



    &

    

         "  < 

 "    " 

         

  &@1   2=3./  233 33    ,   &               8   & 

  1       



 

 < "   

     

              2.23-- 

"E     /3. 

 8   & 

 1  

    

"



 "   

 2333      95   %  22233.  "        

  &  

&  

 

  

  &  '

 "     

 



         "  " 



   " < " 

" 



         



 

 #05 6)

 7 $I,&

 ,   &      !

*

"!  " 8

 %""   .$"!

  " "

)

*( ( ;

=(

 .

" " .

0"

! #!!!( 1 -")"  

""

+  " "!  !%&

!"  ""

.

 ""

 " 

"  !  !  "  !!

-$ !"

) "   !( @ ."" "/"

%"

""

%&  " 2 -")"( # "" %" $ 8 ?

;@ , "

( ( ; !!"

  

!  ) )" ! :,# !   %""  "

 " %& "!  " ( 

""! " "      ! "  ! "-"

""

"+!""

! ""( >"

.!  !!:4 ") &""

.

0$ !

! 

.0   "

%"  ) "

! #!!!

"&  & .

" " 0"

/" 9     " !" & !(

=( : -".

"$ $  !!!   " "!" . "  !

 ."

 " )$"

" "

(*(

#"+"

  !!"

%&  "  ))!!  "  ,-!   ! /!

  !" ! "(

;( " $   !  & !

! !"

 

 

((**;

((  " " !"0$@"!

"

'

E"!@8

 " " " %"

'

E"!@8