Soni Alias Bobby Chappa v. State Of Punjab

&
    

    


    
&'()'#*#+ 

 




/$
 




 #+,*#,#*#-  

  6 


!

"#-,*#,#*#-
  .% , $
$



% 
+
0
/'

(
&-"


 
 

+
1'


&

, )(
2&3 3
 
+
3"


2 (
&-"

+
 
2


'

(
&




-"



 
"'



44444 

%/,0 1!2 $

 





) 

"
!:

 
  (





 ) 
 )





"


 
5 5*6




 !(
 
 
 
"


)
 "
#$ %$!$7

* 
"
 $#$ !$ 8

&'
&" 
(
) 

"

 
"
!#



*

)"



2 (
0 (
 

- '

 
5*6
 )"



"'


 )


' 




 (

&-"



(




! !

!
+
, )

, 
 '
)
,

'


,


"

(

, 
 
+


- ")
 
)),

'
*







 
""

"



 
 
- ")



))



 
"



") 
.'

 
"




#
"'


  
, 
 
"'


 "


 

, (
 

  ) 


 


 
 

 

)


') )
 
'
*



 



 


)
"


"'


 
),
 



 
, )
 ,
 
  

 






 
2 2 

"(
 
 




"



 
"'


,






 
"'

' , ,
'



"


'
 
 
, )
  ) 
" 
 
 





, 
  

)
 

*








'-(
")

 
5*6(


"" 

 
'

' )
 
,
 "'


,(
, 
 


) -

)
. 
 

 
"'


)
"

"


)
;
 


)

(
 
5*6

<
,  
-






0 
")






 


 



 ))
'

)"


 
 
5*6

<


)
,

-

 
"" "
0 
")




 









'

 
5*6

'  




)


)

 '




 
 



)'  
"

)) (
, "

") )
 ,



'

)"






 


 
)


"" "
 
&""

)  
")(
 

"




  

))
 
 
") 
 ' 

 
"7 ""




"
'


 ) )"


(
, "


 ')
 
-"

-,

 
 )

  

) ,
5 '(
 
"-


,

 

"(
"'

 ")



"
 '
 


-

3
'"

) 
"

 (



 

 

 
 


 """

*






'



 
 
 ))
,
 
 

 
" 
,

 

'

'

' )
"

 



" )







"


 

-

"

""
, 
"'

 


 
*



  
'







" "


-



'


")

 ""
 )


 

0 
" )


'

@


 

- -)

 

 
"""(

)



:



(
(
 (


) 

 


 - 


=- )
="
>



" 


)?
&"
&""


) 
" )(
 



 
"
"
:!



 
'


   

&) 


"

)) 


 

 
'




" 
,

-

"
%

-
 
.

'
))


0 
")


 
'


"
 "")

 )

) )
 



" )
'(
 (

)
 
,)

-

" 
"

" 

  
5 ' (




"






'



))
 





))
" 



'


'





(
"

")

 
,

"
-"

)" , 

) - 
"
, 

'

  
;
 
 

 
' (
 






 


!




) 
 
" )


- ')







  )

 




"




 


4



' 
'



"'

''
'
"






)


 
)"
 


 '
&""

) 
 
")(
 
'



, "


"'


, 
"

(
" 

)

 
") )
)"
  



 

"'

0 
 
")


  


) 


, 
 ' 

 
5*6(

-)-'


 "
 
"

-





 ""

))
' 

 


)'


"

)) 
 
 
 

'

 )
"))"

"

 
-



 " (
") 
")
 '

" 7 ""

 
" -
-" "

 "-

"

 

 
" " 
&""


) 
"

)(
 
)












'


   



"


, 
,



 
) ,)
')
,

"

."
 "



0 
 
"

")





 

)
-)-

 
"'

' )
"




 )
 
") 

") '

, "

") )
)"
 

- 
 "

) ,

5 '(
 -

 
"



-  

 
 "



 
"'


 
 '


-

 

 


'


,
, )


 
- ")


'

'

 
"""

0 
 
")


'

@



 )

"" )



'



"
,


 
.

' 
*
-,

 -
) )
,


(
 
 
)

) 



 (

 ) 

 )(
'

)"

'  
 
,


-

 
"
""
 )


 (
) 
 
")




'  )

 
 

+
!
0 
")

 
"'

-" )



 

  
 )

 


 '

 '
, ) 
 
")

0  
")

-
 




 
"

"""(
 
"'

 ')
, 
 )
 

 "7 ""




" )


'

))
&""

) 
" )(
  ) 


"


- ")
 
 
"'

(
" 

'


') )




'
-





, "

 ,

") 


"''

'
'
5 5 '(
 



"-

"



 
"

"


 

" 
" "
, "7 ""


 
"" "
1
)


 "
 
"

-




 
'  

 
 

")
'

  )
"))"

 
-



" 
* 
-,

 -
 


 
 



 (














) 

 )(


 
)"

' 
 
"

"'


 " 
, (
 

 
 
 )
;
 
(
)  
")

-


 
' )









*

-

) 
" )

 
-



-




- ) )
"

%


 )
 ))
, 
 
" 
'



"A
,-(
"

"
'

."


"

" ) 
'

(


) 
,
 ) 
)

"


 

"
B )
"

 )

)"

(
 
'

'
- ) 
  "
"


 
."
 


-"
'

)"



"" (
 
 
-




"

 
-

-

) )
"
 
"-"
9 
'
)

) )  

 ""
"

 - 

"

) ,(

 ) 

 
"

  
  )

 



""
 
,
- "

)"
, 
&

)) (
 
"

"(
"(
 " )
' (
" )
  (


-

))
""

 ""

"" )
)
5 '(


'

'
,





 )
'

'



"

 


"
&
 )
 "

 




'



 
 '



 
1C)
 '

)



 

  .#
 

  )- 
, 
 
 








 
 




 






 


  







 
 
 
 


  



 !
 
 

 



 !

  







 


  !





 
 





 
!

 
     
 
 




! 
 


  


  !
 
 

 





 

 
 !
 
 




 

" 


 







/ )
  



  !"# # #!

 "$$!
"% !"

&  
' (
   

 !

 )" #  $&
   $ 
#

 
 

  
 

  




 








 




 
 


 

 
 

 






 

 

 







 
" 




 

   

 


#




  

  








 

* +  )
,   #- #- - !"# #!

 ".!

"%!$"

.&
&'$


















$
  

 
 
%
 

 
" 



 









 
$ 
 
 






 
%

'
  
 
  
 











 






 



 
 
 

 



 




 





 

 

  



 
 
/

 
 


 
 
 
 

0



 







  



 

 


  
  





 


!

 &

$



  

 





 

 
 





  

( 


  
 

 






 
  
 







 


( ( 





 

# # ')0)++  
)
  !" # # !

 " . !
" % !"

 .& ) )/    #   !" # # # !

 "& !
"% !1"

& 1
$
) 


 

 

&
 
 

   

*+ 

 
,

 




  
 *-


) 
 



 




 
. 
  

  
 

 

 


 
 
 

 



 



 





  

 


 


 



 
 






 

  


 
 





  



   





    

 
 





 
 










  

  

  



 


 
 




 
 

 
 



 

 
 
 

 
 







 
 



  
 

 
 


 

 

 
 



 





 



'

/(2 3 32.! "4     % .! " # #!

 " $  !
" % .!"

 

)  
&
$
" 

 
 








 

"  


 

 

  






 

 


 
  

 

  
 
  



,



 
 








 


(







, 
 

 
 






 
 

 



   

 
   

 

 

 


 





 



 
 
 
 
 






 1 #
* ) (





 

- 



9 
'

 )
, "


"'
 
"(



(

 





 
 " ))



"-
)

"""

"
9



 
5*6
 ")
7' 

 

 "

 
 
"'


9 
'

 

, "


"'


, "


 
)"
 (
 





'

 


') )




'
-



 

") )
' 



"

 

9


"





"


)"



 )

(

  

)
 
)
 
 
"'


' 


,
 
)




 )"
9 




 



- 

 
)'
 
" "
'
'
'  )
"

 

& &
 


(

"



 



)



 

  "


9 
 


 '

 
5*6

 
"

-





'
 "



")

 
 

)' 
"

)) 
&

" (

,



 
, "



"




 "

) 
, 
'


""
9


"
 
)"


 
, " 
, 
"7 "

""

, 
,

'


 
"""
&
 

(
 


< 

.

'

- 
- )

 
 ")
 '

 )
9  )
"

"))"

-





""
  
, 
"

" " 

:
*




'




"



)
 "
 #
* 
 
&'
&"


 
"'


 

 
 
"

"

-

 
'

"

" 
9 
 )

 

 




' 
 " 



"


""
, , 
 ""

 

"

 
"''

9

)

 
)"

"
,(
'


'

) )


,






 
)  '  )
 (
)
"







9 
 

 
 

 
 
"'

(
 

 

 '

 


 

 

 
" "
"') -)
"

"



"

"" 

-



 



'

 )
&
 

(
  


.

"

'" ))
.

'
 
-"
9  )
 
"


 
 

)



) 

 

 )

"
'

-)
"
  

 )

8


)-)


 

-

""
, "

") )
"


"-

"



 
"'' 


"' 
*
 
"
 

 
 
-
'



 

 
"'(
)
 

 
" 
) )

 )
& &
 


(

"" 
""

"' "

-

'


,

"

 

"

"'

))



 

 ) 
  )

  (
 " ))

)



 -




-"

"
*

)



 
'



"

 
  



-


)"


" )
"""
3 
  )

"

"


,)

)
'
-

 
"

'

&*

)
' )
 ""
5 (
  
.


) ) 




) 

 )
 
'

 "

- 
 )

'


)"( (
 (

' 
" 
,

") )

)


-
""

-
 

") 
") '

'





 -
 
 
"(
 
 ""
 )

 

 

 ") 


" "

 
) )  



) " "
, (
 


'




&"" ) (
  


 
"
 


 


-
 
"" 

 ) 
 )

 
 "  


"








*
-,

 -
  " (


 
 
>?





-

'


 
' 

>?
&
- 
'

$ $
'

  -

))


-

"

'

 
"



 
-



 "

)
 
 


))
"
 (

"" "
,
) ,(
, 

) )"
, 


>?



)"

>?(

(


))
)
 
 

 5 
/" 0$



%2   

   (
%
 


$  D$ 
 
  )
D$