High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/717/2002dismissed

Jagdish Etc. v. State Of Hy.

2019-05-24Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu18 pages

!""

$%"&'

'''(()) *+

, '''( -

, '''(()) *+ "/-"'

'''(

0 '1'%& ' ! 2" & '-""%& &(()) ' '*"&)3% " "

)3 ,'

'("%& ! '45"& !

4()" '

666

"!!

7+ "

)2 ! " )" &

"(() & 8+( % &"(

/+%4 '

"4")(()- '

&9 ")9 & (()) %" &"!

"! "

!"/+%4 :'

&)" "

$+%;< 1!8

+ == <"9""

:2&9 &2 !&%2" & "

!(+"&9)+! "

#> #

&="0) "& ?=0?) % 2" & "/-" &"9+5&'1&(()) 2!

"! !+ -4

"! (()) ! $%"& "% +"4(" 4

+ ! "

# =0 0 ==

+ ! "

#> =0 "@ 4 & +A .

.A#

A+A.

:A# =0'

= +)

(4 "

+% + &=

&4 &'

&49" *"/ & 4 5"& 0 4

+ )9" 04& =4(" 4

!&+A#>=0 "@4 & !&+A.

.A#

& !& "

A +A .

:A# =0'= +)

" +% + &=

& & !&'

1& !2 +!

!+ )' "/-" &"9+ 5&2!7+" '

"4")(()- '

.&9 ")9 &

&!4

"! )

!&))%"% &!7+" )

"/-" &"9+5&'

1&!

&( !+ "

"+ &))" & :'

: !"(

4 "

9 + 7+) "))%5&49"=A,0 )"! "

,(+!&3), (" )0)2)2&&!

& 4

"4A &"5"&'"4 & &" " !&'1 "' :'

&"5&4 &&!

4 &"& +8&"4"4 !!

4(&"4

&&+()' &

+ & 8 8"))

) 4 & (!&

& "))%

A' , & ) ( " ':

A2" & &! '"4!!

4("9 &

+ !& &&+()2& ) !8) (4

"! 0!& ! (!&4 '3 "2( ',2!"%'#: :

A2" & &"4'B&")&2&"% &4 &(!& 9&)

+ &!!+4)$%"& &49" "/ & 4

5"& 04 + )9" &"9+ 04&5& !4 &42" &

@" !8 &4'$%"&&" &"4"42" & &"&'& 4% @9) 2 4" 9)+ " &") )%'04&% 9) 2 &""%& )%'1&!!+) " )"! "/+" 45"&

4& 3&&4 45+4 C@4- &"C)'$"5"& 3++ + ,""%&49

&0!& 2& 2( & ( !+ &4 &2" &2 +)&98"))'1&

& !82 & &)&)"9%"

'.#

& 4'1&2% !!))945"&94 "% !

4()" 9

&'"4 & 9

& !8&& %" 44 &0!& ! ' 44 2 "))2" & &"4'," 8 2"

&4 2) '

&9"

& 4 D@'0

4)<=D@'0A 2 !

+! "

#> #

=0 )"! "

,(+' 45"&"

:' 1&

!+! "

=02) '

1&( !+ "

@4"+49

2" "" +(( '

1& 4

&!!++! "

..'0''2!

" 1&" &))% "

)))%" &4' 1& & & 2" ! '1& !!+!" 8()!" &4))%9 & ( !+ "

' 4

! & !

4()" ( 2 & %% '& 422)"9 (

4()" (

4) 3&&4 %&+ C!&&"4 45+4 4+

4& 9&4 "4

) &++ "&"2& & 4")4 &*"/ &"99+ )9" 5"& 04 184) !4 &'1&!

4()" ( " !+ "/+" "@( 4)& 4 *"/ &"99+ )9" 5"& 04184'= &""%&

(" ! &&

)" !+"/+" &449

4()" ( '1&

+ & & ! !2) ("%%" &

449

4()" ( '1&) )"!" !' '

1&(()) 2!

"! !

9 ',! &"(()' >'

B&&)!

&( "&% & +%& &/+%4 !

0B''5'&4 +/%, (" ) -2)&"

&&!

+! ( 4 4@4" "

& 9

45"&A 4) %::

+ &

)) 2"%"/+" &"(

!" #!!$ ! %% $$ !"

# ! " &

# ' # ! "

( ) ! & * + ', ' " )@4" "

&!)( &"!8

2 &' 1&8+))2(!

44+ ! + " &"

(" )%"

' 1&2 &"!8+9+)&4 4)) & &!9)&4"(&

9"' 1&2!

&4 4 & )9"' + "

9 2 &( 4 4@4" "

&2 & +'1&!+

&2&"/+!+99)+

! "4(! ' =/+" - ' 2 """+)) !

))! ") +

"!" !+ &" "!

' 0B:'+/" & 3), (" ) 0)2) &

&&"

) %"!))@4""4A 5"&C)'

(&"E( D@'0 &

+ ! +

) ( )'

' &4 &&"

) %"!))@4"45+4 A - 4'(E( D@'0D&

+ ! +

"%& +) 2" & ! +

# &: &4 !()" &"%& &'

.' ,& ) "

) %"!))@4"- &"C) &4 '(&"( D@'0<&

+ ! +

"%& "9+)'

#' 3&&42"

) %"!))@4" &4' (&"( D@'03&

+ ! +

"%& ( )'

:' &4&"

) %"!))@4"C@4'( E( D@'0,&

+ ! +

: &4 !()"%& &)

! +

"%& ( )'

' 0B>'$%4 &" ) "!)

"! 3), (" )

0)2) & :'

&&4"!

)%))@4""4'

$ (( D@'0&

+ &

)) 2"%"/+" &"( - $ $ ( $ $

- $ $ ( $ " &

- $ $ .

! $

$ .

- $ $ .

" $ $$

$ !

' -!

$ , =/+- '.2!)%" +'=/+- '#2"4()'E 2""(!

&4""%"/+"')) &"/+"2 !+99)+ 2( 2" &( 99)+ "

"@& +'

' &4&4"!

)%))@4"45"&' (&"( D@'0$&

+ &

)) 2"%"/+" &"( # $

) !$

0$ ! 1

" ! $

# !

$, =/+- '#2!)"4()2&")

&"/+"2 8( +E 9 "

')) &"/+"2!+2" &9)+ 2( 2" &( 99)+ "

"@& +' >'

,@4"3&&4 &4'(&"(

D@'05&

+ &

)) 2"%"/+" &"(

$ $ 2 $

$ " & $

0$ ! % .

# !"

$ , =/+- '.2"4()2&")

&"/+"28( +E 9 "

')) &"/+"2!+99)+ 2( '

' 1&4"!

)%)@4" "

4&A 45"& & 4"!)

)) 2"%"/+"

$ $ $

0$ ! (

$ 0$ !

$ , =/+"- '.#2!)"4()" +'1& 2 8( +E 9 "

' )) &"/+"2

+ &9 !+99)+ 2( 2" &( 99)+ "

& +'

' 4"!

)%)@4" "

45+4 &

)) 2"% "/+"2

+ - $ $ % $ 4

- $ !

4 $

$ $ .

$ /

' /

$ , =/+- 2!)"4()" +'1& 28( +@ 9 "

' )) &"/+"2!+99)+ 2( 2" &"( 99)+ "

"@& +'

' ,) 4"!

)%))@4"- &"C)'(&"( DE'0-&

+ &

)) 2"%"/+" &"( - $

$ .

-! $

& $ !

! !! $

5& *

& * " $ 4 !6,

' 1&4"!

)%)@4" "

C@4(&"( D@'

0) &

)) 2"%"/+" -! .

$ !

! $

0$ !

$ $ # !"

$ ' /

$ " & $ ( /

$ .

$ % /

$ $, =/+- ' .:2!)"4()" +'1& 28( +@ 9 "

')) &"/+"2!+99)+

& 2( 2" &"( 99)+ "

"@& +'

.' , & & +7D@'00 0 )"! "

,(+ " "4 "%9 + &4""

&"/+" && (" )' & (()"! "

& ( )"! & +94" (""

D@'0 0 0 & 4& - &"3&&4(! ")2 " 48 4 '

"4") (""

D@'0F 0*0B2%"%"%C@4 4 5+4"49"% "

48"% 4 ' ,+94" &"

(""

D@'019 + 45"&9"% "

48"% 4 '

#' 0B "4 & &" " !&' &

+ A

5&4 & & 8 5")) ) 4 0!&

"))% 5&49"' :'

: 9 +

+ !4 &"4 8&"4 !!

4(&"4 &+()2&&& 48 &9)! (4

'#:

A' 1& ) !8) (4 0!&

0!& ! (!&4 '3 "2( &' &2&"% &4 +

'#:

A 9&)

&(!&4 '3 "

&.!!+4) "/-" $%"&

&49" "/ & 4 5"& 04 + )9" &"9+

04&5&!4 &'1&242" &$))"

C &" @" '1& " !845"&2& 2 ( &

&!+" 4 + ' $%"&" )"! $)) 9) 2 &" & & &""%& 8' 45"& )) 2"42 !89 &!!+'$%"&%/))9) 2 &" &'& 4%@9) 2 4 &9)+ " &") )%'04 &%) &"9) 2 &""%& )%',) )) 2'1&!!+ ) % "/+" 4 5"& 4& 3&&4 4 5+4

C@4- &"C)'1&"!" 2) 2" 93+++ $"

5"& ,""%& 490!& 2& !+ &4 4 & !)+ !&

&!!+'1&

&"!" 2 & &)& )"9 8 )9& 4

'.#

A'1&" 0 2% !!))945"& !'9( "%!

4()" 9

&'1& 4 D@'02% !

9&"49

& )"!"0)2), (" ) &4 9 + '

:' 0B.3&&4

45"&+(( &"

"4', & :'

: 9 +

& &" &4 5"& !&"4 C@4 45+4- &"42( &&+()'$"5"& 3+++ ,""%&&) !

4 &'

3 "(!&2) ( ',"9 &4&2) &'

1&&!!)) &)" +

& 4!!+'1& 2)2@!+ " +

+ 2& &!

4 &

("% &)4 ' & "4)) & &" !!+!4 & 42" &) &" @/))"'<"

))$%"& !8&" & 45"&9%""%/))9) 2) &"2" &"& & &" "%& )%' , )) 2' 1&$%"&!+"/+" &&

4&'$%"&%) &"9) 2 &"3&&4?& &

&"9!8'1&!!+) %"/+" 3&&4 45+4

C@4 - &" C) " 4 2" & &" (! " 2( ' , 3&&42%") &"9) 2 &""%& 49+'& 4 ) %9) 29"

&@ &""%& 8'1&2 !+9$"5"& 3+++ ,""%&',"3&&4? & +!!+49 &"/+" >'

:' $%"&) !& &9% !

""% 4

&)4 "4& )) 2'

& 404

82 &"4 '

' 0B 45+4A - 4 & :'

0!& )2 9)" &!& +()'1& 0!& ! (!&4 '3 "2( &' 0 2 )" &4

+ 'B&"4 !&2&"% &4 +

( 9&)

+ &.!!+4)!4 &42" &/))" ) &" "@'$%"&" )"! /)) 9) 2 &&

45"&) &"2"',% &9) 2 &" "%& 8' 45"&& )) 24&3&&4 4( !+&"4'1&!!+( &!+ &4"/+"'

"42) " )"! "/+"' "/-"%) &"9) 2 &" 45+4?"%& 4' )9"%) &"9) 2 &""%& )% +%) &"9) 2 &"&'C@4- &"2) !+ "/+"9 &!!+( ' 44 + &9& 9"

4( 4 '1&9)!4 + 2 829!!+0 4'

' 0BC@4) ( "4"))" "% & &2 ( " && +() :'

: 9 +

2&(

0!& )2 9)'1&!!+!4" )"! "/+"

4()" ( '

>' 0B = & "%& & "(++!

"!) + 4 D@'0E49!!+5" &(!

,4 0& 9)$%"&0&) &"2!

4&"4 2&"!&&&8( !

!)" &?

%?&(

'= 2"G "44 D@'0EA' , + & & "(++!

"!) + 4 D@'0H49!!+04&) &"8( ! !)"&"

")2!

"G"44 D@'0HA'

' 0B0+& +9=(!

& :'

:& 2( "0 )"! "

,(+' !"(

4 "

2") & 4) ! "

& 8()!""))%5&49"&!& &',) & &"/+&9 8 3), (" )0)2)'

, &2 3), (" )0)2)' 9 ""% (""

& !

%"% "

"4&!

&" 4 D@'0', ) !

& "/+ 4) 4& - &" C)

3&&4 45"& C@445+4'1& 4

4 5"&!

+) 9!

&2 !) " 48 4 '

, &2 "))%5&49"(( +%&" ()D@'0I, !

3+++ ,""%&')) &!!+@!( 04&52 9&"4

: 4"))% 5&49"'C &"( +!9!!+&"99+2"G"44 D@'0'

1& ) &"( +!9!!+5"& )9" 042"G +44 D@'0 D@'0D@'0(! ")'$))( +!9 !!+ $%"& 2 8 " ( "

" 44 D@'0DD @ ( +!9& 4"44 D@'0<<) &"( +!9!!+ &49""44 D@'033'!!+04&52 9&"4

:' .

' 0B3"& ! 0!& 2%"+(&"% 92 9 &!!+'0B4& - &"

,40&

3+++ ,""%& $"5"& 4 '3 "(!& 9) $%"& , )2%"+(9"%+!' .'

B '''& & >'

: & & "

) %"!))@4"& 4 "! ! +

+ &4 !() (&"( D@''

! .

'))+"&4 & :'

:&& 4"!

)%))@4"&"& 184 & 4 5"&C)

"/ 04 )9"' ,

+ &

)) 2"%"/+ & (

&"& - $ $ 1 1 !"

!$, 1&"/+2

+ &9!+99)+ 2( !)"4()" +'

..'

184& &

)) 2"%"/+ - $ $ 1 6

, 1&""/+2

+ &9!+99)+ 2( 28( +@ 9 "

.#' & 4& &

)) 2"%"/+ /

$ $ 6 $

$ 76

$, 1&"/+2

+ &9!+99)+ 2( 8( +@ 9 "

.:' 5"&C)& &

)) 2"%"/+"

$ $ 1 1

$ $ 1( 1

76 & , !!

"% &"4 &"/+"2

+ &9!+ 99)+ 2( !)"4()" +' .

)) 2"%"/+"2

+ &(

" - $ $

1 1 ' !6 $

$ $ 1 1

6 $

# ! 1

$ $

6 !"

4 !"

! "

&, )) &"/+"2

+ &9!+99)+ 2( 2!)"4()" +'

.' 1&

)) 2"%"/+"2

+ &(

04 # ! 1

$ &

6 !"

&, 1&"/+"2

+ &9!+99)+ 2( !)"4()" +'

.>'

)9"& &

)) 2"%"/+"

$ $ 1 1

0$$

$ $$

, 1&"/+"2

+ &9!+99)+ 2( 2!)"4()" +'

= &" ! @4" "

B 4" & 4

""/+"2+( "!")" +', (" & & ! +

4 !()9 !

+)9+

"!!" ) ))) # < 4 &9 " "!) & &"(+ ( " & )

&0!& )'1&)&)"9)" +

# & 4' !

4()" 4945"& & & !!)) "

&)'1& &)2)" +

+ ' &

+ !!

4("9"4&% &"))%& +()

( &9)!4 +

&)4 &(!&

&"))% 4 '3 "' 1& ) !8 ) (4

"! , ) (!& 4 '3 "

&0!& ! 449

0!&

&2( " &"))%& +()'"42&"% &)4 &"))%(!& &!!+"

+)42" &

@ " !4 &' $%"&%$))9) ) &"2" &&

45"& &9) 2 &""%& 8'

45"& )) 2' 1& &2 !89)) &!!+ ( '& 4%@9) 2 4 &9)+ " &) )%

"4',) % &@9) 2 4 &" &"%& 8

3&&4'04&%) &"9) 2 &"%& )%

4')) &4 "2 &(

&!!+ &2

( &!

4()" 4 8"% &) )' #'

18"%

&2( 2" &2&"!& &!!+24 &4

&"+ &)1") + &"%& )!

4 & !

!)+"

& &2 !

9/! !+ & &

& 4%@9) 2 4 &9)+ " &) )%

"4'

,) % &@9) 2 4 &" &"%& 8

3&&4'04&%) &"9) 2 &"%& )%

"4'

1& +%&(()) $%"&242" &$))&&+ &4 "2&")" )"! "%9) 2 &&

45"&!'

& &!!+!+ &"/+ &" )(

4 5"&2&"!&2 +)9+

"!" !+&" &',! &2

$ !

9/! &9 &!!+ !+ & &

449

& !

4()" ( "!)+"%

4 5"&' 1&" " "

) (( 9 " )"! "/+"!+&"!" &)

)

+ ' # 1& +%& &" "

$%"&) (( & 9 !+ & &

45"&&" " )"! "/+"2" & & &(( " "

&/))9+ + &/)) )) &"', 2 &9) 22" )"! &&

45"&2&"!&"" )(

& '( & (""

0B''5'&4 &!+

&2 + & "/+ !+ 9 9)+

! "4(! ' =/+ - '

"""+))!

))! ")2+

"!" !+ &" & " !

+'(()) $%"&& 9"4(+ 2" & &8 2)% & & "/+" )"! 9&"4 &&!

+)!+ & &

&"! "4'

,! !!+$%"&2"%& )!

"! +! "

#0 == =0' #.'

1&449

4()" ( &+

%" + "/+""!)+"% ! +'(0B:'+/" & &2 ! +

) 0 )

"4 ! +

"%& +)2" & ! +

# &: & 4 !()" &"%& &

45+4 ! +

"%& "9+)

- &"4 ! +

"%& ( )

3&&4'C@4&+

! +

: & 4 !() "%& &

"%& ( )' ( 0B> '$%4 &" ) "/+4))! 2 +':@A.!4 & ) )%

"42%" +" +' !!

"%)

!+ ! "

.A# =0

!+"%"4()"/+"+! "

:A#

!+"%%" +"/+2&)( %" &!!+' ##'

! & "/+" 2 " )"! & !

4()" 9

449

&!!+( &29 + 9 )" "

4 & !

4()" 2& 2) ( ""G9)+49' 1&C'1") + "%& )!

!)+ & &"!" & 8 &&(

"%& "2&"!&9 & &( "+ ""/+"'1&"/+"+ "9 & !

4()" ( 2%" + 9+ &"/+" &!!+2 +( )+ +' #:'

1&4

!!+ "/-"2 4 "

" &<='

D( & 4

0B 45+4&"))% & " )"! ) &"9) 2 &""%& 4 )'- ) &"2!

9 & ( )"! 4 &( "

"/-"'12 !!+&&"9+5&

42& 4) &"!&2))% &9!

& 9 "9+ &"%%") &"9) 2 ' ! & 9 "9+ & &!!+ &2!7+"

&!&%' # 1&!&%+! "

!&"%4

4"42&) ( &!!+2!7+"

& "!&%' #'

1&( !+ "

&( &!%" &(())

! &&9!

"! 9 9) +9 '1&" " 2" & &2))!

"/+%4

& ")!

+ '

"%) &" 4" " &"(()

& 4""4"'

#>'

(()) - 4)&49" *"/ & 4

5"& 04 + )9" 04&2% 9")

4 &9 &1") + & "4

&"!

"! "

!" :'#'

'*" '

& !

&(()) - 4)&49" *"/ &

% 4 5"& 0 4 + )9" 04 & 2

9+( ")) &(()""(

' (()) - $%"&2% 9") '

.'!!

"%) &( )"!""!

8 &(()) " !+ +% 4""% !"4( 9 & ") + "/+%4 :'

'1&(() ( 9 & 9"%

.""4"'

( '

(

)* "

& %" B& &(8"%A H B& &( 9) HA-