High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRWP/5281/2021disposed of

Shamsher And Another v. State Of Haryana And Others

2021-06-10Mr. Justice B.S. Walia3 pages

! !"#$#%& ()*$)!+%,% )!+ -! # #%!+$ ( ! +.%/+$ -!$0%,!% $

+*&

%123!4+5$ #"!(3# +!$!% & 4+( 53 #6,7" !

+ )!0! # #%!+$ 888

$!#$2!#%9 :!%50 +)!+#%9 )+59);#,! % !+!%"#%9,5!

7#,<0%,!*#" +.!+ #% )! +#*#%3 +# ! # #% 5%,!+ + #"3!$ '=> )!

%$ # 5 #% %,##$ + )!#$$5%"! ?+# #% )!% 5+! 4%,*5$ + ,#+!" #%9+!$0%,!% $ @ 0+ !" )!3# !%,3#2!+ . )!0! # #%!+$ )!)%,$ +!$0%,!% $A '$3$ +,#+!" #%9 )!

#"#3+!$0%,!% $ +!$ +#%+!$0%,!% $A '+%. )!+0!+$% +*#% !+ !+#%9#% )!#+*++#!, 3# ! @ B!+%!,"5%$!3"% !%,$ ) 0! # #%!+#$.!+$ 9!$#$ !7#,!% +*,)+ +,%%!C5+!=?)!+!#%)#$, ! 2#+ )#$+!"+,!,$

6?)#3!0! # #%!+#$>.!+$ 9!$0!+,)+ +,6%%!C5+! =?)!+!#%)!+, ! 2#+ )#$+!"+,!,$ A

AB!+%!,"5%$!3"% !%,$ ) )!0+!% $ 0! # #%!+ #C!,)!+*++#9!?# )$*! )!+0!+$%

<< 9#%$ )!+?#$)!$$#$!7#,!% +**++#9!"+,6%%!C5+!=@6"%$!D5!% 3.6 0! # #%!+$%""5% *5 533#:#%9 +!") )!+9 *++#!,$0!+ #%,5 +# !$%,"!+!*%#!$% 6$#$!7#,!% +* )!0) 9+0)$ *++#9!6 %%!C5+! =A6 ?# )5 %. +5,6 +"!6 0+!$$5+!6 "!+"#% + 5%,5! #% 35!%"! )59)9#%$ )!?#$)!$ +!$0%,!% $A '?)+! )+! !%#%9 )!* ?# ) )+* )!#+ 3# ! %, 3#2!+ .6 )!+!

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

+0+7#,#%90+ !" #% )!3# !%,3#2!+ . )!0! # #%!+$ )!)%,$ 0+#7 !+!$0%,!% $ ' ""+,#%93.6#%7#!? )!,!"#$#% %123! )!(50+!*! 5+ #% ! ! "#$ 25 ?# )5 "**!% #%9 50% )! 9! )! 0! # #%!+$6 73#,# . )!#+ *++#9! + )! 5 )!% #"# . )!,"5*!% $ ")!,?# ) )!0! # #%6 )!0! # #%#$,#$0$!, 2.,#+!" #%9+!$0%,!% #! )!(50!+#% !%,!% 3#"!6#$ +#" !)2,6

<@<

+.% "%$#,!+ %, ,!"#,! +!0+!$!% #%6 %%!C5+! = , !, 6 $52*# !,2. )!0! # #%!+$#%""+,%"!?# )3?$!C0!,# #5$3.$0$$#23! %, :!$5")" #%#%+!$0!" )!+! $*.2!?++% !,:!!0#%9#%7#!? )! )+! 0!+"!0 #% )!0! # #%!+$ ?!7!+6# #$*,!"3!+ ) )#$+,!+$)33 % 2+ %. "#7#3 + "+#*#%3 0+"!!,#%9$ #%# # !, 9#%$ )! 0! # #%!+$ #% ""+,%"!?# )3?

" ! "