← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/978/2019disposed of

Ashu Singla v. Rama Chawla

2022-04-26Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj8 pages





   





 !" #$%$!&'()*)

++, 

 -,

  

'

.

,

) +/ +)

        

     / +)

1 ) ,

            !    "    #   $     %&%'(%&) 

!* !+ , "  -  $     !           "  " 

    $* *

.%%%/   *     " " 

         &'0 "!1

&00&  $     "  #     &%%2(%&3  

  !*    

 , " " $ !*  !*  $  *$4 

 $    *  "  $* $ $ !* !

+ , "  -  5$     $   ! 



&0%%%%/              !    !"  ""       

 # 

!*6 !$ (             "  !     6    ((%2(%&3$        $ "     *  74 

 1$       !!$   

&0%%%%/         

  

$  8$"!* #*" !"          ((%2(%&3 7    9     

           







  !"#



    

%  % 

 

 



       

        

 &

%     '

       

         %  ( )")*+)   ( ))*+   

 

    %  ( ")*+ 

         

   

   



)

    %   '  

 

 

         , -

.

   ,

)

         



 /  



)   /     '           %   

    

   0 $    % %)              %



 )

-  

  &    

 

 1,*2 , 

3 ' * 

 "        4  * 

   !      $ 

!

 * "  #

 2 :   "               !      $    !  6             ((%2(%&3      !       !

!*   "*    

*  6    ! 4  ! !*  !$   .   

    "    "      "! 1

 " $     !     $ ! 5;!   6 *

$  &2) "!1

!8* " "

 "     #   ! ! 7  "

$  . 5;!   6      



!

" #

6   ((0& (%%3%(&((%%3  

40 

    ), , / ( )

   

)        

   

#

 5

$   )   

 

  

%

  %    )    % '

$

   

 %   ) 

     5

%   00

 % % 

%      %  6  7

)  !)           

                %   .



)  5!)  

    

  

 6 , ( 

    +



)           5      



     

 

 

 )     ! .

    

   

         



   5#

 5 , ( 

% 

  



 

 

 )



 

8.2 /   '

9  :;< 56=)  

           %       %      

  

    % 



%    -  

  !" #

  $

      

)    ' >      

 %

 ) 

 

 

    

)  

 ?  ) 

 

  

   

 !" 



% " 



   

;< @

'

 9  / A 

9 :;< !66=B;<C   C#

( :;< 0= 

 1 C B;!<A 

7

@

 9D  9 :;< =B ;<@  @

1@ 

 :;<!

  =B  ;0<     

%  .

/

  C

:;0<      6=B  ;6<  @  A



  A  9 :;0<5 0=B;5<@1C(

( 

  9 :;0<   6!=B  ;"< 

  $ &   ,     

  #



%:;0< =B;<E

2

#

/

(   /

C /:;"< !0=)    %

     B

  ;<    @

  ,

//   ,@ @ 

9 :";<@1!=) 

  2  C @

'

)    



                   

        

 

       5      #

)  !"

    

$ 

E

2

#

/;

<)



 

/       ! .)



 %  

 



 %   

  %  C /)      

 

&     &   )         

  



 

   

& 

 

& %   -    ! .)      %     

#

)"") 

       %   

     



 )   

)   

    -

      

  C      

+    ;"<)   

  

  /       

      

       

     

&   

*   

%      



)  %

 -  %      5

   #

)"")

% % )

 %

  

 

             

 

F

    !;"< .)  )

%

   F

%    %        5 

   

   %   

)    

    



%      

    

       

+    ;"<    ! .  

 5  

 )  -

 

 !   

    +

 

       5""  )""

   )     5 

     

               



, (   

    

    $ 

  

 5

 #



% 



          7

%' )   5 

       

   

  %    

  !"        

  )  

  -  

 5 

               !6         <

  ! #     '!

( "

)  

 *"

  ) +!"



#

% , $#   ,-!!

  ." /  !"

0

)//!#

  , %#$      " 



&2) "! 1

                4        *   !" 





   $ "$ !                   *     !  "     * 

 ) 1$     1  ,

-  ,0

2)) (#    , -)0 3 !



/4 #

  , %#                 $   *  "    "  $*     "   

  !$  $      "    7  $ ! $   &2) "!1

 0 1$   !$  

  # !*5;!   6     

  !* 6 !$       $       *  "!*   3 5$ "# 

!* 6 !$ *"  ! 

      *$ &% =  > ?*  > ?   "* >/ +)

   ()*) .

!

? / *

  GH *# ? 

GH *#