← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8231/2023allowed

Rajinder Chopra v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2023-05-17Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal19 pages

!" #$%!& $ '()( *(%+( ( (!( * (#%

% ,  -   * .- -

   %/0 - 1 2/ 

,4, 5/  4 0/6/ - 1 , % ,2

-

, %( 7)8"%'$5! "( 895"!(% (8 ,

 *5 /://;5

 (- ./ ;:1 #/4/%/ /;(- ./ ;

 1 2

 %99/2

;(--(#; 4 0/6 

    

  

    

 



 

       

 



  

  

    

  

   





 

 !

"   

      



# 

  

   

    



     

        

 

$



% 

   





 

 

& 

''(  





"

) 

 

  

$

   

  

* +          

  )  ,

 (    







 # 

 & 

''(       

    



       

 

  ),

( 

   



 -



 



  

 

     

$

   .'

       

            



 

  

    

 

     

                 

               ! "

 

  

  

         

#$ %& )   

 

      

          



  



 # 

  

 

 

 

/



      

               





   "

'&   )    )   

   

 

      )



(   %

( (

  

  

   $        ' 

  

  

      

  

    

  0$ 1

    

       

  *2/

  

   

22 * & 

''(



    





  

 



 $  



    

 !

   



32 *   

 

 

.' '  (   "

        

             )     *     *&&  *        

 *&)

 * +  ()   *     *&*&  *&,   *   -./ 01 2  *&   3  *   

  )4 3  *&1,      *    01 2

* 3 *&1 / * /

 *&3   *   *   /

&  (       )   ,   

        



56&57&757897&55:&' 

 

      

 &' 

 

  

            (     



 1;

< ), *  0)

</21

9=65*&)

 * +  ()   *    *& &  *&1,    

*    01 2  *   3  *&1 / * /

 *&3 *  *  /

> -

        



               + & 7& *   *&,   *   -./  01 2

*& 3 * "

 )43 

  .

-     

-  .

 

 

   & 9%&57&7578%&9?)-&3, @  

* A !<$ 4



 

      %       & 

''(   



 

 ( ) 

 5    ) 6  0 

  &

  



32*

  

 

.' ?&  (                ,                



 

)

 * +  --  ( )* *&  *&,   *   -./  *&   3

*  

  )4  3  *&1,   

*    *   3  *&1   /

* /

 *&3 *  * /



 56&57&7578 

    

&  3               5%&57&7578    



 

   

       95&57&757897&55:     

 

  &( 

   

  

            

  

   

    (    

    

    B

   

   



      + B *&)

  *   +   -  -   (  )**

*&1,     *    *   3

*&1 / * /

 *&3 * 

* /

& 6&3



         -  .

 

  

  

  *&/&*&   .

-  *&, * 

-./01 2 *& 3 * "

&

;&  (          (  +&1   @   (/*

/     *  -     *  A   !

    <   

    





       7;&5=&7575  1; ), *   0)

  <  /2  1

 9=65   *&)

 * +  --  (

)** *&1,   *  * 3  *&1   /  *   /

   *&3 *  * /

> B-

               



        + $&$ 7 

 

   

                        

 

# 

 

 

  

 

  

     

  

 

$



%   

+



 



 

 

  

  

 & 

''(       8   

    

   "  9 

    (  +++  )

  ,  :/      "  9 

)

 (   %

( !

;

;< & 

)

 ,  2/ # 

      

=

  

  = 

 *  (   

+ 

   

     "  (  )

  "  >

 , :42



 ; :42, ;   

 

   







 - 

: 

)   





 





 

.'

9&C / 899    ( 

  B:  

   * &&&&&&&&     

 &&&&&&       

    B& :>(     

        

   

 

 

 

  



    &'   

   

    

         0

 2& 7&' 

  

0, 2  B(        

                           )

/ 899072   & 8&  C   1  =0D2    '  ),     * 

0)

 /21

9=65 

 B( 

B  

 

     

  & :>(



   

   

   

  , D&'

 

     

 



B ,B       0/E((2     

> B 

  



      * A 

!

    B     

 96 

>   

       

! 

:>*   

   

   

      

      

 



   

 



    

  

     & %&'  

  /    * 

            





  7%&57&9==7

= B!    + 

  *    ),     

        * / * A *  -*C * 

       

         +   

                &  '        

     /   *   9% 9?&57&7578

     & ?&  '               

      

 

           +   

   

0720 2 17&702

 * 1F 7& :>*   +  &    95&97&7575

 )   *  *&A&!&&  -       

  +  

 

 

   

           

   &'

   +  

             & .    17&70

9 7   0E2>



"##$% 092*   

   

     

        

          

    

       

           & 

  

 



      G 072  *      

   

    

          

    

   2    

    + B& 6&'      

    

  1,         7%&5?&7575    

                 

    

            



   1,                   &'  

  

   1,    89&5;&7575  

   B 

 

     

     

          

 

   



17&7  * 1

F 7&/





    &  ( 

         

B& '              

    

  

 7&702

), * 1F 7&$ 2 #     



  

 

.'

'              1  79    ),     * 

0)

 /21

9=65   

  4H+

                

 4H+&. 

 179

   > 1  092  :

          1  2+ 

2 

 

E 

                    G

2        

    

      +        

  

 

  

                    >



 

     

      

       

  17% 



    



    

 

    



 

 02

 

 &" 02

   

 

   

    



 02

                     

  

    > 0 2

     

> )         



           

 

+            

             

 

   

   02 E2 1%(         



     

    

   E       

 1; E   

 

    



&$ 

     

   

 





 

$    











       

  



   

    ?    

  



  %     

 

 







      

$  

 #     

 

$

   , 

 

  

          

  

   

 

  

  %  

  

 

  %   

$  





)



    

    

  + 

 

    

 

  

 



  

   





 

          

    

   +  

      

    

    

  %

 ?

   

   )

 (  &!$!"

' ()#$ *++,-*.//0 +         

  

 

%    $ '         

      

$ 



 #   



$

 

 

   +  =     

)  

$

=

< *



   

 

 

 

   

 =





        & 

''(  -



   

 

 

   

      

   

   

 



=  3

  *         





  / 9



   - 

 

 

   

 

 

 4



   3, 2 ,    !

  " ::

  

) !

 

=

  



 // (    + 

 

.'

12 3&$4   

   

       H

   

    

   

  

      

  

   -  

                 

 +&

)   

  

 

  

  



 

    

   

    *

E

   

          

 

 

 &$ 7     



   



   

    , 7 :  ,    !

   "  ::





 ; ::

, ;   & 

''(    ) 6  0 

  &

    

    

 

  1







 & 

''(  

 & 

''

(  







 

 

 ( ) 

  =





, 7 ::

, 

  & 

''(   

    % 

     

    



  1   & 

''(     

 

    8   

     

      

      

$

  



  

  

 ?    

  



 



 

8







 

  

 0$ 1

       

$ 



        +    ) !

 

 ( ) 

  

    & 

''( 

 





 ( ) 

    



     





  

%  & 

''

(  +    

 





 





  

 



 

 

 

   =   

 

      

 

  

 





  



$ '  

   





%  

    

  



: ),@@



 

 !

"  

 

  

 & 

''( 

, 7  ::

, 

$   





  



 ( ) 

   



#      



 ( ) 

  32 *  

 



2 1



 , 7 ::

,  

   & 

''( 

  

    "

, 7     & 

''(   

 

   

    

 

=   

      

  





     # 

  

 

  & 

''(   

$  







  



 ( ) 

        



   5     

     

 

 

 

 



$ 

   

   %$  #    

    

 

     

 

  

  

 , 7



                  



  )

 



  

 



 

   

 1







 & 

''

(  

 

 

 



  

 

  

  



   

%  

  

     < 

   

           



 

 



$      



  

0$ 1





     



      

         

  

  



 

  

 



$    

    

#     =

  



 

  =

   %

1

  $  

 $

$ '  



 

 

$

    

     

$    + 

    

$    

?

 

  

 

           

      0$   1

     





     *3 

    



    





    

  

 





 



  #  

        

   / 



 

   





  



    

    

     

   #         



 

   0    4

 

    



* +

 

  

)   

    





 

  





1



 , 2 :42, 

 

       &

  

      



        & 

''(  



 ) 

    

    

,  :42,  

    

        



&

   







-  #   



 '  % 



 

 

 

9

 

% & 

''(   

   





 & 

''(  -23 *22

= 

        & 



   

3 @

         

      

      9  



& 

''(    

 ( ) 

  

 



% & 

''( 







  

      

    

 %

  

    









  



  

/ ) 



          



     

= & ,

(   



# 

  



$

 





   





4

        



 

 1/>; ( 895"!(% (8

'$*#"

1 1 ,2 /? @A /,

- +"5A 1 1  /6

+"5A