Shyam Sunder Aggarwal And ANR v. State Of Haryana And ANR
! "
#
#$%& '& ()*+ ,-.$/,0('& 11$2$$('$( %-& &%% (&34 5&0 ,%$%& $.$($ &6 ('&(%34 ) 7 8, , #"
#"9
" %&&
'
# ( $ !
#
) *+ $ !
, # -
-
#
, #
" . . /,
$ 0 1# $ !
#
"
"
2" &3
" .
4
" #
" .
"
4
"
"
"
."
#
" .
" " #
#
..
1 ..
5 /,
$ 0
". 4 !
.
.# (
" , . 66 78 *767 2" &69
"&
! "#$ % "#
!&
$ # !& ! "#%
'
!
( ) % *+,+-% .& ! / % 0% 1 2 %2 3,/4
"5.6 7 . 18% % 1#9% "
!
! * ! ! *-8:
"!# !
# :"
!
# #
" .
" 2" &*
"
.
". " ! "
! .
#
" . "
"
#
.
(
".
(
" (
".
*7& " 1" "##
" !" #
(
".
2 #
&
! # (
".
!"
-! 2 1" #
+3* 1 1 "
;
" # $%&'
( ! $ $ (
< "!# !
( . 1#
+3* 1 1
:
!
#
!
". " #
) %" '
( %2" &3'
! 1= $ !
"& ;-& /6$($(%$
'(6& % $66 (%&'0('& %-&$ % $%-& $$&$ #%%<,0=#><&- $'$=$'
>'& $.$($ >%
% $% (
<+< #$%&'
?(6& %&'%-&6&/& ,- ,0&-$1 ( : $% :) $% @$(&2$$
' >% 8%' ('
0(',-,0&-$1-$>(1(-6 & ( $= 0% 1$/ $'
2'& 0= ,$& (%$(&'(%2 ( '0/$(''&/$('&'$$/6& $'
2'&=.1>(1-/ ( % &(2%(1 ( /56& =&'0('&%-&6&>&(% (
' '0%&$% (0&+
9 1$/ $'
2'&2$ 60 -$&' $%& /A(1< / 1&(& 0<-0(<%-& 2- &
(%&(%6 6&%.$('/$'&0( / $($. /,- ,0&-$1 < $.$ $$2- -2$'>'&'(%
%-&&6$%= %%&'<6$ @&'(%-&&'. &$(9&/6%.= %%&
/$( 6& /<1/ 2&& $''&' $ 6&&>$%>& ( &$ - = %%&-&= %%&<6$ @&%2&&% 66&'%1-%.$('&$&' ( %-&(& @2%-%-&$' &' $ &-&= %%&<6$ @&% 2&&$=&&'$('2$66&'(% (1%- @6$6&-&&(' %-&6$6&2&&6$%&'2%-10/ 6$6&6=&$(1 '&
,< < $(' ,1 $ &$%- $0%- %.
$'$=$' 2$ 6$%&' ( &$ - = %%&<6$ @&% / % 6 %
= %% /$ -= %%&6$ @&%2$& 0&'=./&$( % (1
%2(&$('&$&'= %%&<6$ @&% $.$6$% -1($%0& (& &$&' = %%&<6$ @&% $ (1 2%- $ /&/ $('0/ ( / 5 2$ &(% % %-& 0= ($.% $.$($-$('1$- $($.($&$&'6$ @&%%- 01- $2$. 6$ & -& %-& %2 &$&' = %%&<6$ @&% $/6& $ (1 2%- %2 6& /&/ ( / 5 2&& '&6 %&'2%-%-& $&$%- 0%- %. (*:>'& ( <:<($&$&'6$ @&% 6. %-&/&/ $('0/( /5$('6& /&(/6& ( &$0&'% &$%-& $/6& = A 2&& &(% % %-& 0= ($.% $.$($<-$('1$-&6$$%&.=.&1%&&'
%>'&6 % && &6%
??
*+'$%&':-&$/6&2$ %$@&( ( %-& 6&&( & %-& 2%(& 2- & ($/& $('
$''&&$&1>&(=& 2 -& &% $%& %-& 0= ($.% $.$($ -$('1$- $'/=& 0('& ,& % ( 3 4 %-& $ % $%%$ -&'-&&2%-2- -- 2%-$%%-&$/6& 0&'
2%-6 -=%&'/$%&$.& 2.(%-&% 02-&&$% - 0'=&&& /%-&$/&$$''
2( $'
2'& 0('&%&/
0&+
34-&$/6&$
- 2%-&6&&( & &,%$ -3 &1(%$ -4(> $% (
0&::34 %-&
0&9+
34-&$/6&( %( 6$ @&' (%$(&< ('% (2- - (%$>&(% ( 0&:
%-& %$(':+ %-&
0&9+
&( &%-&$/6& $'0%&$%&' -&$ 0&'-$$ (%$>&(&'%-&0& %-& &>&(% (
' '0%&$% ( 0& +
$ -& 2$ 0('&(12%- 0% &( &
* -& /6$($(%6$.%-$%$,-,0&-$1 -$@&6%%-&$'$% &
'(% & $&$(' 2$ &(1%-&<%-&.-$<-$>& //%%&'$( &( &0('&,& % ( &>&(% (
' '0%&$% ( % + :9 $ % ( /$.
@('.=&%$@&($1$(%-/<%-&/0('&,& % (* %-&$'
% (' 2-&& $ $/ B-$( "$'$>
'
(6& % #%%<&- $'$=$' -$>& =&&( $0%- &' %
(%%0%& 6 & 0% ( //%%(1 $( &( & 0('& %- % >'& $.$($ >% &$%- #&6$%/&(%
% $% (
<+< :
'$%&''
-&&=.0=/%%-
/6$(% '6 $$ '(1% &$2 %0%-&6$.&'%-$%$%-& /6$($(%$ >%,&>$(%$('&C0&'% $%%&('&>&$ 0%$('-$ $ % 6 / %-&/0%$ 0'0%&(%-&2- & %-& #% %<,0=<#> (<&- -6&&( & (&$ -$('&>&.
'$%& -&$(1/$.@('.=&'6&(&'2%-D
"
!
"
.
#
*9 7> *77+
+77
/,
$ 0
" .
"
#
.
#
#
! ,
,
##
#
1"
. ! && !"
" 1# ( #
.
! " !" 1#
"
#
# .#
# "!# !
(
"
1 " +
6> ##
1# ##
.
.
< 1# !.
#
"!
*
#.
"
.
" ! (
# ".
##
.
1# 2" &6
2" &* "!# #
#
" .
. " *7 7* 6??+ "
!
?
( " 1
;
@ ; . < %6?39'
6 ( " 1
! .
..
##
85> "
#
% '
" " 1# " "! ! (
.
"&
.
1#
"
.
! " !" 1#
# #.B ""
.
## /"
. 1" :"
.
+3* 1 1 ."
(
/ < %6??3'
9+9
" !
!.
"
##
#
#
.
! # " !"
# ! "
# # " !
! :"#
, # ! 1
" !.
.
! # " !" $# :"
2
!
+ #
" "
.
. #
! # " !"
!
! #
".
" #" . !" 1# ! 1# - !"
.
" #
;"
*7& "! "##
" !" #
! 1"
*7&
"& ,& % ( (-& &>&(% (
' '0%&$% ( %9+ :
C*7 " # " " DE
# ".
. ##
!.
" " !"
"
" ! " " " !"
" .
.
*F"!& %9'
96?
1 1# " 6?>9 %* 6?>+'G *7
#
".
" "
# *7 H
/
. ,
*7 "
! ! !
.
# # (
+3* 1 1 2
1" # "
.
. "
"
!" 1"
" :" . " :"
( @, /#
*77* %9'
0 = *+IG
. =". ." / /#!
. 1"
+3* 1
"## " 6?8+ .&
B99 (
2 1"
!
+3* ,
"
1" 2 #
.
#
"! " .
#
#
B
:"
!
#
"
#".
6I 7? *768
#"4 "
#