High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11641/2020allowed

State Bank Of India v. District Magistrate Ludhiana And Another

2024-04-18Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra23 pages

!"# $%& '

!$%$(%)# $%& *

! "

! +& ,- +

. .. /

,- +

. --

#!$%& '!( ')') !*+' ,( -./'0 '!#( 1'$ '(( '

!*+' ,( *' !-$((+'. .. /

+$((4 -.- '.

*)*+55 6,,'+'!)'4 ( (%''5'$)$!+!!

(#('+55*!+ "

(''5'% (,'+,$((4 -.

- '.'%6!$ '')%!)'! 1)2 $3 (' ! 78+5 '%$+'5#'!*' +!,'+) ($%()!#++!

$'#'

*' +! ' '++ , 8'!(+ ,'+') !+ ) $% ! 7 ( ( ' !$ 4' 3"

"93:

(++)',!',5# :

( '0!+79 9;

"93<! +37-".,(+=''!++, '+') '!,+5,+% + "99"-(', +'))!'(> +>.($%+'))# ! 7 '! !+ '! #'' !+('# ,)) ,'+') $4#$4(<9!'%,5(!',(+-?8 3.

@ (' ! 7,)!($1+! +37-7., ('!$1+4!)% +!!$$+'51+!$%( 8'0 (#(' !!'4(37 "93<-?87.

< ('+!+37-:.,( '!4()A'!B,(+% ,+5)

"99" 4' ! '! ( '0 0 %5$)+ , ( 5#'#! ;

(', (4()''0,0''!C' 5#!4((''0, !'

,5# ( 8' '0, !''#'! +!+37-:., ( ( 8'05'!' )+'!+3:, ( 39 "93A 4($%( ! 38

+'#' !(''

4'6! *!''+, ('0#*, ,(+!' ' !+$!( ' )+'

! 7 ,)! $1+ ( '! ' )+' ( '0 $5! )% !'! "A "93A ! 3'#'($1+5'!$% ! 7 ! 3(#((5 #!!-? 839.!5!(' )+''$+'5 ,!!+3: ,( $%()!#++!

( 8'0,)!D8"77BB,"93A$,( 4(+(4'!5!'4(!'4*!!!'!3: 9B "93A 4()$%'*')')'*5!''*')'$)'++!'+ 4()'4 3"

( 8'0#+%#!4( ( ') #% ! + "<8 , ( + $6)% '"!' )+'!+3:,(

+4'5*!$%('0$, ! 3 ! 3(#('!!'43"

"93B -? 83@ '#' 1+! ( ' ' )+' , ( 8'0 3:

(', ('0!,(+!+37 -:.,( (#(#! 4(+($+'5 '!( 5++!

* ('!+4'') $)(!4 ' $('$*+ 4 +*)% '!'! $)(!$)%',4(!'4')$#5'!,'))( ')+ 3@ $6)% ',(' )+'+'!+3:, ( 4' ,!$%()!#++! $,( +'#'++!

3< 4* (#('!!'4(79 3"

"93B

-? 83A.

( ! 3 '( 1+! ( '!

' )+' (#!('('0('+5 )!4(( *,+37-78.,( '5+(' ( !1+#($4>$1+$+5#$ '! 4(3@!'%,5(!',+ , '$1+

'5'! $%($4 (+!$%()!# (!+37-".,( 3;

(!'4#,(!- '.-?839 83@ '!83A.('+'! '( 8'0 '!

(')! ('#'('4 1)2 $3

3A ! "/5 '%(#((''0,

!''+( !(''('!$'+!*'+!)5

($%()!#++!

$'#'*'+!

' '++ , 8'!(+ ,'+') !+ ) $% ! "

(( ' !$ 4' ""

"93: (+ +)',!',5# 3B ( '0!3< 9< "93<+! +37-".,(> +> (+'))# ! "!+('#,)),'+')$4#4(<9!'%,5 (!',+-?83.

"9 (' ! "85 '%,)!($1+ !+37-7.,( +3"

9A "93< ('!

$1+ 4 !)% +!! '! 1+! $% 8'0 (#(!!'4("B 9A "93< "3

'*! '' @,( ' $0(' '+,+!+37-".,( (

'0*!)!'!3< 9"

"93<('!+*%! ! "

('6,+#,)'' *!$%($'0 5'!+!'5!( 4* ! '!

+55+'$#5'!( ! "'!7 (%* +'5,4'!,?+,!+5 ""

('$,('*!('(', ! "

$5!' )!'!9< 9A "93<($'0,,# '% 3+',))'!,') '%5'#'''!#'5, 7@ :;

"""E8'37 9@ "93< 4* ('!)4' 1+!'!!)%+*%! ! "'!7$%('0 *!)!'!3;

9A "93<-?8B.

"7 ('+!+37-:.,( 4'!37 9:

"93;'!('00%5$)+ , (5#'#! ":

(', ! "/5 '%!'+*) '#'( 8'0 4* ('54'!5!$% ( )'! *) *! ! !'! 3B "93;

' ') ('#' 4' ') 1+! $% ( , )'! !!')

+C!# !(''

"@ ( 8'05'!3' )+'!+3: ,( 4* ('!' )+'4'1+!$% ! 38 +'#' !(''

'++, '# ,'%!(+*)$%C'#! #(() 4(+)'5!

$'(! ! 5 "< (', ('!+*),)!$%C'#! #(() 4'!5!*!!!'!79 9;

"93A )')% ( 8 '0!"!' )+'!+3:,(

+ ! "85 '% ,)! ' $, ! 3'#'(' )+','0# (%+') ('! '4!)% )!$%('0 ";

+ ! 3!!'0'%'+( ++!#)% ('0,)!D 337A@8"9"9$,( 4(+(4''))4!*!!!'!9;

9A "9"9 '!

'!+4' 5'! ! 3 *!''+( 8'0 ,'0# (%+') ,(+!' "A (', ;B9A8D , "9"9 4' ,)! $% ! "/5 '%(4 - '.

(0# (+'))#,(!!'!9;

9A "9"9 (#!('( ' )+',( 8'0'$+'55'!!+3:, ( '(4'!+)!$% ! 3*!! !'! ""

"9"9 -? 8"3.

( 4( D - '. 4' $1!+$,( "B !!!'!3@ "9"3 (!5'!$%( 9;

9A "9"94'+'))!'!( 8'0#( 5 4(!'4(4 4()$%+('))#(!!'! ""

"9"9-?8"3.$,(' ''(% ( !'4# , ? 8"3 $% ! 3

4($%(' )+',)!$%( 8'0!+3: ,( (('$1+!

('+'! '( 8'0'!(')!('#'('4 .(456 6$% $3 81!%# )$(% 8 3$!

92626$%!: ;

( *,+37-78.,( '!+%'!$)#'% ',(+!+!

!+37-78.,( '(4(3@!'% ,5( ,5,(' $1+ ( !('!

$1+ '$+'5$5!$%($4 4* '!)% ( +5 )'! ( ! , 3@ !'% ( , ( +!

+! !#($4>$1+E ' $,5 (!',+ ,+($1+ '('$5!$ 5'!'%$'$5!$!+% 7"

,('#5 ()'!+),( 8'0(' )'+!)'+ '1!#5 '!$%( +')!'699$ $$# "

.212 $3 (%<14 1%# $27! 0 !9$!2# 6% :*;

:6"68;

)*' '' A4(,

?'+!(',

! $

% & $

% !

( )'+('$ )'+!'1!#55'!$% (>$)5$'%#(+')!' +=

81!62> $8# !6"12 -2# 1%# %$27!

"! ( .212 1%?

$3 %#61 1%# 27!

!"933-37.*):""

()*' ''#' ( 3"

'!37(,'?'+!(',

( & #

$ !

$! $

( ) % !

! %! &

! + $ !!

(

! . )/ ! %

! !

%! & $

! $

! !!

& *

$ $

0 %

$ !

( & $

!' 7:

)'+(#'!('')$ )'+!'1!#5 5'!$%(>$) )(#(+')!',+= /1%%( #62>1 %#61 -2#

.212 1%?

$3 %#61 2$ A76)7 :;

$3 *$+'5'#!

()*' ''#' ( "7"@ (,'?'+!(', ( #

2 $

$ #

$ !

! (3% $ %

1 ! *

3 456

(7& / !

456

89 1* &%

%: ;/< (= //7 /

456

+ / ! <, >& ! ! %

% % !

$ % + !

= (==3 !!

<, >6+ ! ,5 %! $ $ !

$ $

!*!

$ !!

! ! $

?$ 4

% &$! $

' 7@ ()'!+),( ,($5 (' +3:,( !+,'%'!1!+'% 4( +'#' ( +'#'!+

3:, ',)'44( 4'!1!+' '% ' )+' ! ( '! + * + 3: , ( + )% ' ?+% * '! ' '!1!+'% * ( + '#' (' 4 '!1!+'(5,(' )+' ,('#5

()'!+),( )'+)'+ 1!#5 !!$%(>$) ?+')!'>+=

16% 1%# $ "! ( 196218 6! 2 -2# , : . * ;B ,181?!6 7%1 151 1!8 :

;

27!$(C7 -.

"! ( 7$%6D !) !6"12 -6562#, : . ;

,.21%#1!# 71!2!# 1%?

"! ( @ $48 /(51!, : ';

. F'!1!#5!!$% (+')!'> 2 )$% 2!()26$% $591%> %#61 -6562# "! ( .212 $3 1!>1%1, * :;

- '

7< ()'!+),( ')$5(' %,('#E+6!$#*($4 ( )%E4'5E$1+,)!$%($4 ( $,( +'#'$,(>$)#(( -.

+'$# ()%5!%'*')'$) ($4+('))#(' !(#('*')#( 5!%'+5 )'!!+3;,( .(456 6$% $3 81!%# )$(% 8 3$!

! 9$%#%2 $591%>

(#(('5'!'%65 !+37 -7.,( (,(' $1+$+5# 5'!')% )!4(3@!'%,5(!',(+ $ ('+' ('!5'!'%+5 )'+('!'% *'(('$!$%( 8'0

,('#5 ()'!+),( !85 '% )'+)'+ '1!#55'!$%( >$) ?+')!', -2#

8( $1 2 $28 -2#

1%# $27! , !9$!2# 6% : *;

4($% ( +! (' ( * - '. ' 5'!'% ' ( )*' ''#' ( "A "B'!79 '++(*!+- '.' ?'+!(', ( :

% % %

2 $

% #

$ $

% !

! $!

!!-

! 0!

# ,

& %

! $ @

A- % / :/ ! B % C &

% C ; %!!; D 0 B %C -!

% % %!)/ (E $

) % %

! 5 % * / !

$ $

$ !!

9 (F= (=

(

!$! F= 9 (=7(=

! ! $ * ((=(= ( %

! !

9==F(=

! +

(=7(=

9 (==F(=

3 & * %

! $ ! - $

! !! $

% 9 + ( =F(=

*+ !

# 4

* %

& #

% 9=3=E(=

$! "

! $0$!

=E =(=

% 4 3=

% 5 !!

E=E(=

* !! !!

!! $

((=

! $

! $ ?4&

% 9 = =(=

! $ $!

% 9(E =(=

! $ $

A !

= =(=

! +

!! ! !!

! 4 E $

((=

) %

!+ $ 7,(=

+ 9(7

C *' % $ $

!%$

(E =(=

* !

!! !

$ % !

+ &

== (= $

A # !

= ((=

' 7B ('+' -D8;B@"8"9"3. !#$, ( ($%))(!+('!55'!$%(

++!

( ()!#++!'(4' )*'#! 5* ' ' )+' ! + 3: , ( + , ($% ( + '#' ++!

*%#''+()!#++! '( '5 (%+') ,(+!'++! %18> 6 $3 (456 6$% $3 81!%# )$(% 8 3$!

91!26

:9 '')%=# ( '$* 5'! $5 '!!! $,($%()'!+),( '!

$%( )'!+),( ! (!5, ('( (',$'')6,)'46!$,5)'! '!

')6!$'4!

:3 D((( *+' )'!+37-78. ,( *4(,'?'+!(',

4((''%!%+' ()!# ++! !($1+++! (4(3@!'% ,5 ( !' , ( + E ,5 ( ' 5'!'% !+%

6 G

FE & 0

( 3 ( %

$ %

$!$

( -$ !$!

* !

$ !

! $

# $ $

!! !$!

!! $ !

+ !! $,

3 H0 % G

# ! $ , $,

$ $ I

% !

$ !!$ !

+ % $ J

( !!% ! $!$ $

$ $

% , $ $

!" # "

#$ %&'"&( " &

& "" &( #)

" ! !

"&** "

! " " &

&! " !!

%" * "

& " " &

" &

&#* &#* "&** %% & $

!&("+

" " &

&"" &

& " &

#$ 0 %

!*!

% &$!

/ ?

G %18> 6 $3 )$%2%26$% : (9!1;

$3 81!%# )$(% 8 3$!

! 9$%#%2$591%> 41 # $% "!#6)2 91 # 6% )1 -2# : (9!1;

4> $%,48 9D $(!2

'!#,('$*?'+! ''#' ( (#(') !+)(' +*,('$*' !+)''$#5'!

$%(>$) ? ('(' '% * ( '5'!'%' %(>$) ?,(++)!!

('(45!% (,!#('!$'+('(' !+'%5!% '!

('(4$+55 4! !%),($4 ,(++5'+4'' (,

4( ''#' ( 79 4'++)!!('! (+! )%#(!$ ''!($%$'+($#+'! ( *,+37-78.,( $%( '!' ++5'+ ' '# ( '! +' 4(+( ' 5$!! ''#' (79 379 ')$+'5$5!$% (>$) ? (++)!('(+!+,( !$ !!4'''%,+(+'- '. '!( >$) ?5'! '0#( ('(!$('!$ 5)%0#5 '!

!!! '%()'' 5! $ '!*')++' :7

('!+'! (,'+('(4' )%$% ()!#++!

(!$> '($% % ( >$) ? ! ++)!# (' ( ' '% * ' 5'!'% ' $ +!! ++)!('(),+)'5!$%($4,!#('! $'+('!+'%5!% '!

,('+)! ''#' (- '.

)5')%!+)'!('('!!+'% ),$#'!(!$ (, ,(>$) ?

)'!5+(5 ('(!$+!+'!')!+)'!(' ( ), +)'5! $% ( !$ , !# ( $'+( ( !+'%' )')%(5'0#(,('$* 85 ''5 $%(>$) ? (($%(

$'+('+'!(5'!'% *- '. '(?,'+ $+'5+) !$+'5+6') +( (,,+,( ++)5'!$%(>$) ? ('(+'#>('))> ++#(' * ((''5'!'%*

'($'!)#(,(,($*'-.- '.'5'! ( ::

(5 4(('!+'! ($# )%(!$ ' '!)%(4!+'% 5!%$+'5!+)!(!$ 4(' ('+'-.

(('$'55')!)'%'(()!#-. !#(!$ '-.

($%('!55') !)'%$

+!$

5'0#'

$)'''#(5'!'%'% *++! :@ ( ' $# (' ' '! ''#' ( - '.

++#(*!+- '.5'!$%(>$) ? ( +#,(+'#>('))>++# ('% * - '.

('5'!'%' '(('$ )( )%')'+% ()!#,(' 4* + ( *!+ - '. )% ( !$ '4'5'! (%'!)%(>$) ? !+)#(!+'%5!%($4'!#('! ,')('+!+,($4('!+' 4('

('+'-.

('*!4))5'!',1+# (!$ '-.

:< * 4( ( !-. 1+# ( !$ '-.E$1+-. ' 4)) ,5! ! '!E +% +'))% +!!

(, 4( ($% ( 5'!'

'#!(+'#>('))>++#( ('$5, ( ''#' ( "A,(*!+- '.

(+5 )!4( :;

)')%')($%(!)'%$%!3@!'%( +! +! !# ( !$ ++! +' $ ++)!!$('$))%$'+(#(5'!'' +)!+37-78.,( +'))%4( ($%*! 1!+(''++!($4 :A (''5'% '!!'))%+')0(+!+, ($4+')!' -2#

8( $1 2 $28 -2#

: (9!1;

(+!+,($4-.('+'-. '0' ,+('(%'5 )%#!)'%'++'*'!( )6!' , $4# ( ,'+') ++! )')%4(($%(%' '$!%#(()+ ,('% *+)!(

(? !)%$#$'!!$5!' )')%($% (')!!5,'++!(!+'%), ($4>++!

(5 4(('!+'(>$) ? !!+!( *,+3;,( 4(!''%5!% *%!($4 ( * , $'+( $# +'! ( ' 5'!'% '% * (+('!'%5!% @9 * 4( ($% ( 4' ' +5 ) !8 5 45 ( + '#' ++!

5'0 ' '!1!+' ('! $1+ #* ( +'#' ++!$#)%'?+%,+'% '!

$#' '!1!+'%,5 4(' ('!1!+'%,5,!#(

#*'+,($4'*)! $'+($#+'!( '% *++!

4'(#(''%' ')$# '! ! + 3; , ( + ( $, ( ))'(%++!

(!27!

1%18> 6 4> $(!2 @3

('$'#!(', (, ( *4 (' ( )!# ++! ! '% 5'!'%'%$)#' !()*'$1+

'( 4( 3@ !'% ,5 ( + , +( ' $1+ )($%!5'$)#'* 1!++'!( $1+ '!E('!'%5'!'%$)#'+! )%($1+ '-.

$#!+!!'((#('

4)),5!+% +! $!($'+( ,'% +'! ( '! 5'!'% * ( 5'% $ ! $ )% *!+##,( (##*('('+!+ ( ',($4#(5''+,,'+') !+ ) @"

6)% ('! *('$*+? 5'!'%''(!+%' 6) ( 5+55+'()*'!+($1+ ( 4(3@!'%,5(+ ,+( '-.$1+

! +' '% +'')% ( ' )+'-. 5*! $% ( 8'0 !+3:,( +$,(

+'#'( +'#'4'6!!5 ('!' )+'-.

+'))%4(()%+5 )'!$ ' ?+# ,+'% '!

5 4! 5'0 '% '!1!+'('!' )+'-.

!5')%4('(

'+'-.

' ',5('$*'#5 #!$+'5 '!($,( +'#'++!$,( (!*)*# (,'+5 ('( ' '% #!+'!+3:,( (*!)% $+'5$'+(!

@7 (''5'% ('),(''#!

(', ++)!('+(5!%+('))#(1+, (' $1+$%()!# ((#!

('4'+55+'!4(3@!'% $4'+55+'!

'(4("3!'%- ;

'!4(:B!'%-

;0 ( ,5 ( !' , + , ( '! +55+'

(#(('!'#'$#)'!$,(

+'#' $(#('' ')('#'$+5# ,)!!+3;,( ($,( ))' (%++!

( ' , 5'0# ( '! ++) $+5 $'0! '.

(1!#5-.)! $%()'!+) ,( 5'0#+)''!+'!!!)#('('! *5)%!+%''!5'!'% (,

4((' !+-.$+'5+*%!($1+-. 4( ,, !'% ,5 ( + , +( '-. $1+ $ 4 +55+'! (',> ( $1+-.E$4-.

$! 4( ( !5'$) *!+ (' ($% 1!+ (' ! ( $1+-.E$4-.

)')% ($% ( ' +55+'-.,45'!'($%('04(,,

!'%,5(+ ,+( '-.$1+ (,

( +55+' , ( ' !+ ( $1+ +*)%4("3!'%- ; '!4(:B!'%-

;0 !''))!*'!

(,' ' )+'+'!+ 3:,( $%( )!#$,( +'#'++!

+!')% ,(++)!('('!

*'+?'))%!+%' 6)% 4( ('$!+)'!1!#5- '.('('%5+('5 +'!!+3:,( (5 4#(

+'#'++!

*%('0!,''+-. ()!#++!

'5 (%+') ,( +!' '()%'?+%5+('5,? !)% 5!%# ' $'! !$ )')% ( '! )5! 1!+ +,! ( +'#'++!

4'6! $)'#!? '!!

'' ))''!1!+'%5+('5 ' $+'5'$)%!$%( +'#'++!

(#( (1+#('!' )+' ',++)!#('(4', '!(+ ( '% 5'!' +)! * - '.

+'))% 4( * ( '! !+ +5 ))% ! ( !5',(? )',)'4- '.

'5'!(*!+ - '.

(!)% +('%5+('54($%( $1++)!!(#*'+)'#()*'$'+( (5'- '.$+5#+'!('% *- '.

(#(E('*')#(5!%+!!+3;, ( (, ( +'#'++!4'

') ($% 6! $ 5'0# '% '!1!+' ( $1+- '.'!$,(5'#'( *!#,''+ ()!#++!'5 (%+') , (+!' ')% (4'6!$ *%#('!

'0!,''+$ +*,($1+'!$%( !$ '*)!'((58,!! 5- '. !.

* ( 4' ') 6! )#' ( $1+-.('%5!%+5 )'!+3;,( ,($%($1+-. '#'#' 5 (' (' !$'+(+'!(5'!'+)!+ 37-78.,( ((#!('('% !'!(+(5'!'+)!( )'# (' +55+'-.$# +*)%5'!'(4( "3!'%- ;

4(:B!'% :6%

;

'!('!$#5'!4(('% +$! !,3@ !'% @@ (#(()'!+),($1+E !-

;

(',+,))%+!!$,( ('+ ($1+('('!$,( ' )'

4($%! +('))#(!5'!$%(,'+')++! ( 1+# ( ' ') 5''# ,5 ( +! ++!

(, (#(($%,(+!!('))' !+('!55'! ( ()!# 4'6!$5*#'' )+'!+3:,( +$,('#' '(')',)5%'!

'#5'!6!$1+!

@< (',1+#('!'#5 ,!!

( 5 ('(5,)'#,' ') $%(+! ++!

)+5 )!4(!!5'!$%( (5,5',,!(!($4 ++!'(')6!'!

(,'+')++!

)')%4(($%($45'%+)'5(5 )%5*8 '8*E(E(5 (( + ), 5% ))#5' ? +' 4* 4(*!)%(55$!!( ' ,,5'!$%()!#($4 '( 5'+5 )!4( ( 4((( + ), )#5' ? +' ( 6'$) !+ , 5% ) (40'$)*8'8*($4++! @;

)')% ($% * , '5#)% ( ' $1!+ +('))# ( ! 5'! $% ( ,'+') ++!

(1+#( '),($4 ,( '!+('))#!!$5'! '(('!,'+5 ! ( +)! 85 ( 8'0 + ( 5'!',+3:,( @A , '# (('+)%+!('(

+'#'++!' '!)%$'+(#(5'!', )'4'+)!('*!+ (, (#%,( !5'(!+! *%'+ %,( *!+'))( +'#' ?+#1!+'+( !+3:,( ('+5 )'+( *!+,*!'5!$%'))( +'#'++!

- .

',5'( (,!#5$((4 -.

( (% ' 4( ( $*'-. ','! (+

'))4!

(5 #!!'6'(!'!'! <9 ( +'#'++!!+!,(4( 5'0 ' ! , ($% ''+-. $# *%! ( 8'0'5 (%+') *(+!' ++!

<3 +(5'+'-.),('*$!+!! ( ')) ( !#' )+'-.

,'% ')'!-.! !,

:.. /;

:-- ;

* 0'*#( D(( '0#E'!

& HE D(( '$) & HE