High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/907/2004dismissed

(O&M)National Ins.Co.Ltd. v. Nisha Devi Etc.

2015-08-04Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg6 pages

!" #"$%&%' ( ) !%' *'&+, '$"-. '/0%-%!"# .."** '! 1",&+& 2-!%&3 "1% '#!3",& "&.'#"'!& ,"&"'!4 ,"", 563 '' 7#1$ !" , .."** '!

'" ,!3","&.'#"'!&

%&3 "1% '#!3",& .."** '! 1",&+& 8"&36+- , '#!3",& "&.'#"'!& 93"!3",".,!",& 0$ *":&. .",&- /;" **:"#! &""!3"5+#<-"'!=

;","

",,"#!!3"".,!",&,'!= >93"!3",!3"5+#<-"'!&3+*#;",".,!"#%'!3"%<"&!= ,"&"'!4'" ,!3" .."** '! ,"", 563 '' 7#1$ !" ,'&+, '$"-. '/

?%#" !3%& $--' 5+#<-"'! %'!"'# ! #%&.&"

!%!*"# & !%' *'&+, '$"-. '/0%-%!"#1",&+& 2-!%&3 "1% '#!3",& #%,"$!"#;/ !%' *'&+, '$"-. '/ 0%-%!"# '# > )

!%!*"# &%&3 "1% '#!3",&1& 8"&36+- , '#!3",&#%,"$!"#;/!3"$* %- '!& ,"'3 '$"-"'!

$-."'& !%' < %'&!!3": ,## !"#) > . &&"#;/23,%2 3 '<7 !,$$%#"'!* %-&,%;+' *7 '$38+*

,%"

*/&! !"#!3"$ &" !3"$* %- '!&%& !3 ! %&3 "1% :%#:7 --%"1%-!3", '#, 83 !3 !3", #"$" &"#2%! - *% & ;*% %*"#$* %-."!%!%'+'#",2"$!%'@@ !3" !,?"3%$*"

$!-(($* %-%'<$-."'& !%'' $$+'! #" !3 2%! -!%& .*" #"#%' !3"$* %-."!%!%'!3 ! '"+'""!<< ,: * '#2%! -

#"$" &"#:",",%#%'<!3"%,&$!",;" ,%'<,"<%&!, !%' >AA )> 3"/:","<%'<!1%** <";3"/.+,:3"'!3"/:","$,&&%'<'#+&!,% * ," 7 '$38+%* !!3 !!%-" $ ,;" ,%'<,"<%&!, !%'@A>) #,%1"' ;/ 8"&36+- ,,"&.'#"'!$ -" ,-!3"&%#" &"$!, '#%!&!,+$8 !3"&$!", ,-;"3%'#& ,"&+*!7;!3!3"$$+. '!& !3"&$!",3 #

**"'#:' '#&+&! %'"#%'5+,%"&3" $$%#"'!!8.* $"#+"!, &3 '# '"<*%<"'!#,%1%'< $ ,#,%1",2%! -: &! 8"'!"'", *&.%! *7 '$38+* '# ,-!3","3": &,"

",,"#!:3","3"#%"##+"!!3"

%'5+,%"&,"$"%1"#;/3%-& 7 BA:","$* %-"#;/!3"$* %- '!& & $-."'& !%' > "&.'#"'!:'", '##,%1", !3"$ ,3 &#"'%"#!3 !

> '/ $$%#"'!!8.* $"' @ ) 3"!3", 1",-"'!&- #";/!3"

$* %- '!&:"," *&#"'%"#

"&.'#"'! > '&+, '$" -. '/ 3 & %*"# :,%!!"'

&! !"-"'! '##"'%"# **!3" 1",-"'!& !3"."!%!%' '#3 &! 8"'!3"

;5"$!%'!3 !,"&.'#"'!: &'!3*#%'< 1 *%##,%1%'<*%$"'$" ) ,-!3".*" #%'<& !3". ,!%"&7!3" **:%'<%&&+"&:","

, -"#A 93"!3",!3" $$%#"'!%'C+"&!%'3 #! 8"'.* $"' $$+'! , &3 '#'"<*%<"'!#,%1%'< $ , A@AA>) ;/,"&.'#"'!=

%&&+" %& .,1"#7 ! :3 ! -+'!

$-."'& !%' !3" $* %- '!& ," "'!%!*"# ! '#

,-:3-= >93"!3",!3"1"3%$*"%'C+"&!%': &;"%'<#,%1"' ;/,"&.'#"'!':%!3+! 1 *%# '#"

"$!%1"

#,%1%'<*%$"'$"%'1%* !%' !",-& '#$'#%!%'& %'&+, '$".*%$/= "*%"

@ ' ,#", ! .,1" !3" $* %-&7 $* %- '!& "D -%'"# &"1"' :%!'"&&"&:3"," &,"&.'#"'! %*"#! .." ,'> > '#3"

: &.,$""#"#"DA. ,!":"1",7,"&.'#"'!>"D -%'"# # -2%'<37 "$,#A8"".", &9A '# *&!"'#","#%'!"1%#"'$"#$+-"'!DE '#$*&"#!3"& -"

3",%;+' *7 !", ..,"$% !%'<!3""1%#"'$","!+,'"# %'#%'<& '%&&+"& '# %' 1+, !3"$* %- '!& '# &+- &>7 7 BA : & **:"#"< ,#%'<%&&+">7%!: &3"*#!3 !,"&.'#"'!: & '!3*#%'<1 *%##,%1%'<*%$"'$" '# &&+$3,"$1",/,%<3!&:","<%1"'! !3"'&+, '$"-. '/

( '&+, '$"-. '/3 &#%,"$!"#!3"

, ;&*1%'< !3" '&+, '$" -. '/ %!& *% ;%*%!/ ! . / :3"," & !3"

$* %- '!& 3 1" #%,"$!"# > )

, "'3 '$"-"'!

$-."'& !%' 2%'$";!3!3"&" .." *&3 1" ,%&"'+! !3"& -": ,# '# &&+$3 ,";"%'<#%&.&"# ;/$--'5+#<-"'! !

'!3%& .." *$3 **"'<"3 &;""'- #"'!3" %'#%'< %&&+"

>;/!3"%'&+, '$"$-. '/ 0" ,'"#$+'&"* ,!3" .."** '!3 &&+;-%!!"#!3 !&%'$"!3" #,%1%'< *%$"'$" : & '! 1 *%# ! !3" !%-" $$+,,"'$" '# & &+$3 %'&+, '$" $-. '/ %& '! *% ;*" ! . /!3" -+'! $-."'& !%' :"1",7$+'&"* ,!3" .."** '!%& %,"'+<3!$'$"#"!3 ! -+'!

$-."'& !%'3 &;""'. %#!!3"$* %- '!&3".,"&"'! .." *.," ",,"# ;/!3"'&+, '$"-. '/%& $ #"-%$%'!","&!'*/ & -+'!3 &;""'

. %# '#':!3","-"#/ 1 %* ;*":%!3!3"'&+, '$"-. '/!,"$1", !3" -+'! '#,"$1",/,%<3!&3 1" *," #/;""'<%1"'!!3" .."** '! 27 %' !3"&" $%,$+-&! '$"&7 !3" .." * #%,"$!"# ;/ !3" '&+, '$"-. '/%&:%!3+! '/-",%! !3",:%&" *&7 %' +!3,%!/ "#$%"& %'()"%*+#,-'.")"%$%/0"%, )' +1)#+,$%

2 31"/+44 !3"'F;*"."D+,!3 &3"*#!3 !:3"' !3","%& 1 *%#'&+, '$"*%$/7!3"'&+, '$"$-. '/3 &!%'#"-'% / >,#. ,!/ '#$* %-"#!3" -+'! ,-!3":'",B#,%1",%'$ &" #"

+*!

!",-& '#$'#%!%'& !3".*%$/

) > ' 1%": !3" ;1"7 !3" .." * .,"

",,"# ;/ '&+, '$"

-. '/&! '#&#%&-%&&"#

3"$ &" !3"$* %- '!%&!3 !#"$" &"#2%! - *% & ;*% : &:,8%'< &-"$3 '%$A:"*#",:%!3 B&23 ,- /$*"2!," '#: & " ,'%'<& BA.",-'!3 :"1",7!3",%;+' * !", #5+#%$ !%'

$ -"!!3"$'$*+&%'!3 !%'$-" !3"#"$" &"#2%! -: &&> BA .",-'!3#+;!79A ?%'#6+- ,3 &#".&%!"#!3 !2%! -: & "-.*/"# !3%&&3. '#<!& BA.",-'!3;+! $$,#%'<!!3"

,"!+,' +,'%&3"#;/3%-3%&%'$-": &&) BA.",-'!3 '# &&+$3 !3",%;+' *3 &,%<3!*/3"*#!3 !%!$ ''!;";"*%"1"#!3 !3": &. /%'< & BA!&) BA.",-'!33"%'$-" &> BA.",-'!3 ! 8"';/!3",%;+' *&! '#&

%,-"#:"1",7!3"#"$" &"#: & )/" ,& <" !!3"!%-" $$%#"'! '# &&+$3) G -+'!&3+*#3 1";""' ##"# ;/ !3" ,%;+' * ,"< ,#%'< +!+," .,&."$!+& 8"".%'< %' 1%":

+!3,%!/ "5+'0"%,#0+)'-'"56$)$%/0"%,#0+)')+1)#+,$%

4232$-$&31"/+4!

3","

,"7!3"%'$-" !3"#"$" &"# $-"& ! & ) BA.",-'!3 !", ##%'<) G%',"&."$! +!+,"

.,&."$!+& 3"," ,"!3,""#"."'#"'! !3"#"$" &"# '# &&+$3!3"

,%;+' *3 &,%<3!*/#"#+$!"#B>,#%',"&."$! .",&' *"D."'&"&27%'

!3%&- ''",7!3"#"."'#"'$/ !3"$* %- '!&$-"&!&> BA.",-'!3

!",#"#+$!%'<B>,# %',"&."$! .",&' * "D."'&"&3" <" !3"

#"$" &"#: & )/" ,& '#%'1%": +!3,%!/ 7#")&"8+)7""%, #0+)'-'9+&0$)"%'1)#)1)"#$%"%,%)

232$-$&3

@ !!!3"-+*!%.*%", (%& ..*%$ ;*"27;/ ..*/%'<!3 !-+*!%.*%",7!3" -+'! $-."'& !%'$-"&!&@7 (7 BA 3" -+'! +'", * "D."'&"&7$'&,!%+- '#*1" '#

"$!%'3 &!;"<%1"'78"".%'<%'

1%":!3".,%$"%'#"D !3"/" , 27 &+- & 7 BA&! '#& **:"# %',"&."$! * &!,%!"&&+- &> 7 BA&! '#& **:"#%'

,"&."$! $'&,!%+- '#. ,"'!& ," **:"# &+- &> 7 BA%'

,"&."$! *&& *1" '#

"$!%'27%'!3%&- ''",7!3"$* %- '!& ," 3"*#"'!%!*"#!$* %-& 7(7 BA 3""'3 '$"# -+'!&3 **$ ,,/ %'!","&!H )G. ,- !3"# !" $* %-."!%!%'!%**. /-"'!3"

*% ;%*%!/!. /!3""'3 '$"# -+'!&3 **;"!3"& -" &,#","#;/!3" ,%;+' *3","$1",/,%<3!& ," *&<%1"'!!3"'&+, '$"-. '/%' ,"&."$! "'3 '$"# -+'! +! !3""'3 '$"# -+'!&7) 7 BA &3 **;". %#!!3":%#: '#!3","- %'%'< -+'!&3 **;"&3 ,"#;/!3" ,"- %'%'<$* %- '!&%'"C+ *&3 ,"& ) '&"C+"'!*/7!3" .." *.,"

",,"#;/!3"$* %- '!&%&. ,!*/ $$".!"#!!3""D!"'!-"'!%'"# ;1" @ $./ !3%&5+#<-"'!;"&"'!!!3",%;+' * ,&!,%$!

$-.*% '$" 2 3 9: (/('#