Savitri v. State Of Haryana And Others
"#
!$%&%"'( ) * +,+& -
( . ./ 0
. 1.
"
## $# ## % &
2/ ./ +2 3%4* 2- /
( # # )## ! %%*#* + , -.-. " # ## 00## # 12# ## 00## 34!#* ## 5 "
0) ' % 6) % * # #/ " ## %# , * # 7'
(8 ! 7-.(9 ! "#0)# 0 "
%#"#: " %%#" :# '0## ; !
"
""! !# <.- <=< (-.>? # % / #
=-@ " -.(= *# %#! ?
:
- 7 * 7' % !
% "
## *# # #0)* + , -.-. "# ## 00## !
' % :% # :7'
)0/ #
:
70# # !
% :#% #* ! #! ## :
% 7 #% ' 0## " ; "
0) ' % 6) %!
% 7" * ) # ## !%' % 7 :
" ) * )!% :#)## : ## 3 *) #"
:#! *) %"
"
:$ < $ # % ## % &
7*# :# ) # ## * % "
)# " "
:$ * ) # #;:
" 7% !# <1(41 4 " &
/ ! # 10) '% 4! (@9912!34 :# %91###4 " &
/ ! # 10) '% 4 % -..A12%34") # #0 "%= % ## %% 7 #% ))%' "
) %' " 0)%#* ' "#0)# 0 "!
"# %* !0## 1&/4 !!!
#* # %#!! 7'# )!#"#!
%%' ## % %#" ! "
# % %#" :# 0## ;# "7#*%#*#7%"
&/:
%
# !
;%'
:
% 7#%#*#7% 7!
# "
) % #!
B" ! *0 < ,%'
-.-.
% #*%, * "#*/ "%##
! !" CD 1/%4 -.=@ 89- " -.(@E 70# # ## 00## !
7 !
00# ' * !) 7'# :#!#
)) %7"
#/
= % " #* % !
% "
## *#0 )% ! !
!
)' ) 7' )# / %, #% 07 * #*) % "!
> #!# ! + ## *:# />D>A<(>-.-.
)% !
!
!
)' A , -.-. ) 7' )# / %, #% 07 * #*) %60) '% >!
#! # !
=<. (@
07 -.-.
*# %#! ?
:
# 7) #
7! * #* #0)# 0"
%#" :# 0## #%% % ' ##!
%':
) * 7 #"
! : B % #* : / 00#12 /34 8 70## 7 !
# 7#* :#
7% ') ## %0 '7" !# < 1(41 4 (.1-41 4 "!:#! % "
)))
5
"3. Temporary release of prisoners on certain grounds. - (1) The State Government may, in consultation with the District Magistrate or any other officer appointed in this behalf, by notification in the Official Gazette and subject to such conditions and in such manner as may be prescribed, release temporarily for a period specified in subsection (2), any prisoner, if the State Government is satisfied that - ..........
(d) it is desirable to do so for any other sufficient cause." "10. Power to make rules. The State Government may, by notification, by notification make rules for carrying out the purposes of this Act.
(2) In particular, and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing power, such rules may provide for- ............
(d) the conditions on which and the manner in which prisoners may be released temporarily under this Act."
7. Rules 4 and 8 (iii) of the Rules, which are also relevant, read thus: "4. Eligibility. Section 10(2)(d). - (1) A prisoner shall be entitled to apply for parole only after he has completed one year of his imprisonment after conviction and has earned his first annual good conduct remission under the Act."
"8. Sufficient cause. sections 3(1)(d) and 10(2)(d). - Under section 3(1)(d) "sufficient cause" may be considered from amongst the following reasons, namely:- ............
(iii) house repairs/new construction of house owned by the convict. Parole for house repair shall be granted only once, in three years;" 9# #0 "%= 91###4 "% :# !# < 1(4 1 4 " ! #* " "# &/ " 0 0)%#* ' "#0)# 0) !
# 0# % ! ! ## 7'# # # !
# " F#* #0)# 0 "
%#" :# ' 0## G 7 * :# !
>!
#! F! #0)# 0"
%#" "# % 1G0 #*7' % 0 # # )# "
" % %#" # ## %
/ 00## : ) #0)* !#* ## 3 ;"
) %:
"
# ))%'%=#%#* ! 7'# @;# :# !
% ) ! ! % 7 %' 7 " ;# :
% # "
# # ## 3!#0# )) * #!
!:#!#) #*7"
#/ : ##%#$%' # )) :#!:
% 7 :#!
! )) %
"!
>!
#! 7 $)"
#*# " #:
% 0 #%%!;# # !# ##:
% 7 )!% " 0!
# #* ' " "
% ) % % 7 7% #!#!0 ! "
B 0# "# ;# 7) ) #* )) ) #!% %'#! :#%%7 " %* %) ## ##* #!% (.%* %) ## :#* ) : "# ! :# # 7 0 B)%#!# # / ## ?! *0 ")0/ #
#) (.< (.+ #"
%% :#*:
F(.< # 0 " ! !
: ) %' %#"#0)# 0#)#0#0) 7'# !
"#0 7'# ## ?! #* / !
! !
#! :#%% *
)) #' * ! #! 7' "#%#* "
)) %7':
' ")!# %H #/ ?':
'
7 !
# ) )!#7 % : " / !#0# %#) ! :!
" ### % "# #* " *#% " ! )!#"# *
""! #0) ## ") %'# %#"
6
#0)# 0 : !
0 !#' " # ## ?! " #* / % %& "'37 *!
%,*
"+2 8*%$* 4!2%9!& *!
:"8!2 +'4!2 *!
!' 3 "4!-
8*%$*
:2!&$2%;!&
*!
$ :% 3
'4
3 !2' !
:+'%&*<!' - "
3 !2 *!
& %4 :+'%&*<!'
8% * "'!
!% *!2 #"2 *!
!' %2! 7 "# *!
$"'9%$ =& 3%#!
"2 #"2 '7
&:!$%#%$ :!2%"4 "# <"2!
* '
5 7! 2&- & 7 -
"2 &"
"'
4!:!'4%', +:"'
*!
,2 9% 7 "# *!
$2%<!
$"<<% !4
'4 *!
!>!2$%&!
"# ?+4%$% 3 $"'&$%!'$!
;!#% %', &+$*
"##!'$!
#"+'4 :2"9!4 "
* 9!
;!!'
$"<<% !4 (.=D "
# ) : # " 0 "
'0 #"# )#0:## )#0 ) # "
# % / "
! )!#"# ""! !
%' 7 B!# 7' #* / # " " )) %' 7' )0 / 7' ' / # # ' ) # #""%'
*!
:"8!2 "
%<:"&!
<"4%#%!4 :+'%&*<!'
:2"9%4%', #"2 '7 &:!$%#%$ !2<
"# %'$ 2$!2 %"'
"2 %33 *!
!'4 "# *!
$"'9%$ =& 3%#!
&
'
3 !2' !
"
4! * :!' 3 7- $ '
;!
!>!2$%&!4 "'37 ;7
*!
%,* "+2 '4 *!
.+:2!<!
"+2 '4 '"
;7
'7 " *!2 %'#!2%"2 "+2 (.+#: # )! : % #
:#
C E
)!# % !
* ' " !I # " I "
0 B! #* (= ' ) !
* ' 7'
"0## #:%%"
: : # ;# # ""#0 # D "
# *0:# )## B) 7'#/ #
!" # $% )# "0## ) : ")) )# & 07' #*! "-. -+' :# ' 0## )0##7% # # !:#% : :)!#"#!
%%' % 0G10) #))%# 4 (( " *0 " / ## ?! " )0 / #
## ) #"# #* / )0/ :#% #* ! "%#"#0)# 0 # % / " ) # "
' )!#"#! 0 #!
! #%% #!3%#" #! %% 7 0## % ) %' ) : #
@
#% 7% %':##*/ )0/ / ;%'
# % / # # !
:#% #* ## ! "#* #0)# 0"
%#"!
% # # % 7"
" %%#" :
% 7 #% '0## (-#/ % # *0 < ,%'
-.-. % #*%, * "#*/ "%##
! !"1 4# 7 7*#:# # )) %"#% 7' )# * ##!
! # ## ?!1?4
" #*/ ## *0 -= '-.(9#/#0# ))
AA< "-.(+!
"#0 #!
"
! !
! # 7 # #: "% :% # :#
1 4F##!% :#%% ,:
0) : ))%% ! " #0)# 0 "
%#" # ) # #!# # )#0 "#)% ""! "
-+ ' ))%% :
% 7 #% $ 0## G % ?#B!# "#) : #* / 0! (<% #*%, * "#*/ "%##
! !"1 4 : ##!# 7:;"
* "
"% * ; " 'J0 %0#$## !
:
"
"% * ) % *0 ) ! #!;#0 * #* %
7% %#1:#! 0 %#0#% 7%# 4 " #* "&/ )>!
## * ") % *0!
!% :#% #!#!0 !:#:
#*/ 0 #"# ! "#0)# 0"
%#""
0##00 "-+' :# 0## !# ")% "
"% *:
#"# #:
!% #"# 1#) -(4 )## :
% F7#% $) % "
> 7%##* !# "
0#%'#G (="
#0 "% :B)% # 7'/ ## ?! )0/ #
# ## (8 ! 7 -.(9 #* ! ## " #* #0)# 0"
%#":
# # #*# #:
% 7"
0 # " %%#" :# '0## (+D##7#*!% %* %) ## #0)* + , -.-. ) 7' # ## % / 00## # !#* ## 5 "
) * # %* %%' # 7% # 7'
# ## 3 "
%#0# # ## 00## # # " ## 5 "
) %# !!
!:#% :" * ) # 7' ## #!#% 7 * ) % :#%% 7 $ " 7' # ## / 00## :#%) #* " ## 3 "
) %" 7) % <(* -.-.
)
00#!
## "
:# # ' % - )07 -.-. " **# 7' ! # :#%% 7 ) ## $ )) )# 0 #
#% 7% # !!
!:# :)## # #) "# 0 (8 / # #"
0 :# #* !% %* % ) ## B)% # #
# 7 #*# !) 7'0#0#% : # # # #!
!!
#*%'
/ #! "!
)' "# *0 *:# *0 "/ ## ?! ")0/ #
7!#!% 7'/ #* , #!# %!
0' *0 #% %% #!# ""#! :%% , #% ### " 7 # # ' "/ #*
./ 0
1.
) * .-
0 D) $#*6 6
D) 7% 6