High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/1192/2023dismissed

Sunil v. Kala Ramachandran And ANR

2026-04-01Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal10 pages

!" #"#" $%

& ' ( #( ) # *+,- .(&( / 0* #01#( #"#"

!( ( 23( "0** #4

*.4 +05*406 - 77777 8("# ##'

# #"#"0 1*#"91#( #"##"1:" !#"1#(#' #1#*#0;

(" 1#1# #(<;*#= +/"1","1#( "#" " ,- #( ! ' # 1 :" " #( 1

#( # ; *> ,-#(* >#""" " *

" #" ?@ 1 " !A 9 0 #"#

! " :#("# # 0B:?90 # *>9 / +"# #"!# #"-, 05"#"#4+ '0 !#" 51#(:1' #"8(+-*#0 1(#<#(:8 *#= !#" 1#(:" 0@ 1(#<#( :=8( "B:/ +"# '

"#1"- 2 !"+( +"+#( ## "2/ ( ''"##1 /"#((

:#/ "'#( ##( #"#"( "+ -, # ; +/"#(#/#( 1' (. 3 2 B #B !( 0 !C 2#0 6" :# ( , #( # #( 11 !#" 51:8*# !#" : # "( ,/"#( "'

"'#1'#( ;- 0#(10#("+ #1#(

#"#"/," #"1#("#"",-#(* >#" #( 1

!"#$

:#( 1#(, #( #

" #"2"++ , "/ ',-#( #"#",1#(6"+(# 1##("'" 1 #( '1'#(#1!" 9 8( 0#(10/("(( ,# "#( ##("#" ",-#(* >#( ," # 3- / - 1 '

" 11" "# 1 & ' ( 0 ''""1 "0 4+ '0 "# ( , #( # #( B: / +"# #( '

"# 1 "- 2 !"+(0 +"+ #( # # " 2/ ( ''"##1 /"#((,-"+#"' C#(10 '1 2(( , 1' ( :# ( , #( # #( #"#" / # ; 0 C# #( "

# 1

" # ""'" #"+ " + "# ("' / "."" #-"#(8(

" #"1+ , " / "'",-#(#1!" / 0#(10

"+"#(6"+(# ; 5# "1"#"+ #" "# #'#0#011 ,-#( #"#"( ,+"0/("( # #1#( 1 ""1#("# ##'

# #"#":#( , #( ##(

#"#"/ 1""#/#( 1"'" #0 + /("(0B:?9;0 # #"!# #"-,"'0?50

3 / 05(" B:?;1 #"!# #"!

" 0?/ 5("0,#(!#" :/+"# @ :# ( , #( # #( ##" 1 #( #"#" #( # #( ( , /"1 "," 1 #( "#" " ,- #( * > #"#( 1

!"#$ "'"" 1 # -"# #( ##( #"#"/ -#"!#" #( (2"# ( - , :# ( , #( # #(

#"#"/ ."""#"+ #" / #( 1# #:#( , #( ##((2"#/ # ,1#(* +"# #/( #( "#-/ +(#*#('

" 11" "#1!(? ( &' 0!60"!# #"-,"'0 0 #?( ,1""'" " A 1#( #"/( A 1 #( #"#" #- + #( # #( "#" " #( 1

! "#$ "# # " %!& '$()$#( ,+-" # 0 1 #( !# # ,'"## #( # #( ( ," #"1#("#"""#( 1

!"#$

:( "#(,'""' ,- 1 #( #" :#( 1

! "#$ 0 #( ! ' #1 :" "#(1/"+"#" #"$ % & '

( )) )) ) * + ' ) * ) ) *"! , , % -% -%,'% ,'). /% ) ( ) )

) * , ) ) 0 !1

'- * % - )* (

, -% ,' ) "1"

"2 ( ))-(%, ))3 ) '() -4) )-2 5( )) , ))3 *

,) ) , , '

( )' )) - + ' 2 5 + ' , ' )) ( ( -*( )) * )' ) + ' , 2 65) )) -, + ' ,,,3 ) , )(* + ' ,)

*-7-* (( ) ) -),'2 89) (( ) ) "1"

"-% )) ,,,3 ) ,)

*-7-* (1 ):) -),'. ;

) ( * , ) ( '( )))) - ( ) * - - - ( ) ( ) - -<' %' & )" ', )' -* & ) + ' )) - - ( )-* ((( <' "= 5"#"?; - -/#( #1 "#' -/"#(#( "#"( 0 #1'"+#( "11"" ,1 #'# #"0 ' 2#('" ,#, "(1#'

#1 ##,"#"##,1#(6"+(#( "+#"#" .""#" 9 ?/0 #( C#" /("( " 1 " #" ,1 #(" #" #/(#(#(( ,/"1","1#("#" ",-#(* ># :#( 1> , 1 1 %"5 39 / ' * !? ( 60#(* >#> "#(,.#1#(

9 ; *# :# / ( #( # #( 1 #'

# .""#" / # (#(' .#- "+"#-1#1 /:#/ (#( ##( / #( "*#" " #,>"/"#( #" #( # "# ( , "+- ,- #( # ,"+ #"1" + "+#(#11#1#'

##8(* >#(#( # #(#'

#.""#"(,1"##(C#"/(#(#( ( , -", #","1#(1#(# /(#( #( # 1 #( #-0 /( " + # ( ''"## ( "," / #'

# :# / ( #( # #( # >""+ #'

#.""#"/#,#"###"##(C#"/("( ( #, #/"#( ""#(.+'#0" #"1 /("(( , + + (#(10 #"5( () (& ) (

&* '*) ,")() *)

-*) , ' '

*)@ ) ) -))*, ()& ) * " 5 ( ) 0 - ) ( () ' ')) (( ' (( & ) ) *"5(,( ) () () (, % ) ) 5 (, () - 7) , ) ) " ! - ( ' * -* ) -' '

' ) ) ( ) )" ! - 3(

) 7)' & ) ( ) ( ) ' (( ) ( -, ( " 5 ) ( & ) - ) A , - * - -)) ) )( *, ' % )

) -) )

) " 5 ) 7)' ) ( & ) A ,) %- , )& '

% ,) '-* (( ) "5) ) ) & ' ) A , & '

) " ) ( - ) 7)') (& )(

*)),A )

) ) )( *,) ' %)

- ) ( *',)& '

"!& '

) *())) '

-' *) , --)( (( )) ,)(

) ) ) 7)' ) ( & ) 3' ( (, )' "()'

,-*) ( '& '

"! - )) ,) % '

) 7)' ) ( ) & ) B 7) (, ' ' - % ' )'

, (( & ) ( *) - %" 5, % ( )*()'-) ( *,) (& ) * )-*& '

( ) ( ()' ' ' ') 3 * ) '

*'% '

' ()',)

') "= ; : #( 1 '

>" "

9" 46)6"8"60 5"""3(1#( & 6"+(#/ "+/"#( #'

# #"#"/("0#(/ + #"1" #"1#("#"",-#(* >#"#( 1

!"#$ * :#/ (#( # #'

# #"#"/ #"#-",1#(6"+(# #"#(/ " /("(#(( , ." #"#( ##(+"" "/,-#( * >#( ," # + (0 #0"$ - ' (%) ( ) 6%*<' - ) ) %

(, )) ) '(,( ) ( "())0 <' % & ) A * ) ( * ) - , ) ( ' % - )

, ) & )")

; ) 0 (% 7 ( ,) ) - ( )0 ) ) ' * , -)" "! ( ( -*<'

*()'"94) ( ) ' ( -*<C- (7

( " () 6 ! <' (, ( ) ( *"))')) 0 <' ) ( ( -* -* - ) " "!() *<' - ) "! *,'

(

( "+% - & ) , ' ,

( %-%

* ()' - <' - ) "! ) ) (() *- , "= @ *"'" "// # 2,- 5"""3(1#(& # 2 6"+( # "#( 1D - + 3 - -

$ 1 :)/ !()/ 1 )9 ( '

? '

4 ? 1 ""0 " ;:#(" 0#(/ + #"1/"1","1 #( "#" " ,- #( * > # " #( 1

! "#$

8(5"""3((#( #"#( /("(/ ,"+ # /"#(,-#(5"""3(0#(/ 1 #/("(( ,# ,"( #( ##(/ '

" 1#("#"",-#(* ># :#/ (#( # #/(#(#(/ '

" '

" 1 #("#"/ C#"11 #/("(/C" #" :#/ ( #( #"#"- 1## ,"("+#( ##(( , 1 "#( #1#(

"11"#'

-/"#(#("#"",-#(* >#0 #"#"1#'

#1#,"#"##:#/ (#( #"#(

#"#"#("( ## ,"(,1 -."" #(' ##

@ #("#- #( # #(( , 1 " #( # 1#( "11"" '

-"+ /"#( #("#"1#( * > #0 /(" #"+("'0 ( ## "+(# / -"#"## #'

# #"#",1#(6"+(# #8"5 ), )7( , ((- - (9" -' )) ) ' )( *- 3)3 (7 -* , * () D % 1" 5 <C- (

) 3 ) ( )

( ) * " 5

' ' * % ) * ) 0 !1 , ), %,-&)) - ) ,

- %"5 ) )0 !1 )'@ - - - )

- ( ) (

' (% , ( -* ' ,%" 5 ( , * ' - % (%"5 - )0 !1 ) ( )), - @ * (, % ) )@" <) <C- (

)E ' ) 1 ' (9" -% ) ( *,), ( )) - ( ) *) -( ) ( - -<' %' & )" E <C- ( , ) 1 ' ( 9" ( ( - - ) ( *,) -*<C- ( -* )) ( ) ) ,) ) , - - ( )" $) ) ( ) ) -* ( )) - -* ( ) ()

) () ()'"

"! ) ) ),) - - -*) ( ) %4 4% *) ) 4) ( )) -*<C- ( "; ) (()', ) ( )4) ( ))) - -

A ),), A "! * - ' - ( ( )) ) ( *,) -*<C- ( ) ( ) ( -* * ) ) -

F )) ) , ) ( %' - - *& ) ) ( * - ( ( )) ) ( *' ,) -*<C- ( , ' ) ' , * ) () ()'

(9" 3 -

- "

"5 ( , ) ( ((7 4G ) ( ( ,) ) -* :) / !() / 1 ) '

)) :( 1 ) ) ' ( 1 ) %* :) -' )) -*<C- ( -*

%' ) ) * % )) ( ()' ) - "5 <C- ( ) /% ) ( ) ) , -

)0 !1 5 ) " "() * ()

" 0" ! )) ) , ( ) ) % - ) -* % ) " " ) ( * , ) -* <C- ( " ! * ( ) ) -4) ( ), ) * - ' ) ) )) ( ) ) - - ( ) ) ) ( ) ()'-' '

( ))"5 ',' ) ) (( -*("<)) (()') "= 8(" "/ / # 2 ,- #( 5""" 3( 1 #( & # 2 6"+(#"#( 1+" (

+" 1

9"84)""

-#(#( # 2 "'" "/ #"+##(1 #1#( # 0"#"#( #+" 1#( ##( ##( #/ -" /"#(#("#" ",-#(* ># #( # #"!#" / " (2"#/ 1"(##(* +"# #8(" ,- #( * +"# # + " #" "," 1 #(

"#"",-#(* ># #("'# 0"#/# ,1#("###"##( " & "+"'"#("/# 2 ,-& 6"+(#" '

& # 2 6"+(# "#( 1D - + 3 - - 0#("#"# ""### "#( # #"#"8( #"#"' -0(/0 " #('" ( , '""," /

#( "'# 0 #(" # # 1" - + # ## " #( "# # #'

# #"#" - 1#(*"+-0 #( "+ #( #"#"""'" $:&* *44*D*A E 54F + + D(#( 2"+% G%? D(#( # , G%?