M/S Kirloskar Oil Engine Ltd. v. State Of Hry. And ORS.
!" #!"$ % &' ! (
) *!+ ,!
-
!"# $ %"& !"# "& '"(%'"&% !
!/# ,+0, 1) !/(2, !/3, ,#) %,1/(1 ! 4 , ,2!1.5+/(6 !"1*!+ !.#0"+ 1/(1 !!
$ %"&) 4, . ! , ,"" % , !!
7
7
8
4,2!. 2 " 9
4, ' 2 ' :9
3+.
%, ""2 %!!
;4, 2!. "%
,!!
.
3+ $<5(
!1 5 ."1 0,5!%!, 7
1/
<5!1
!'3+,.5+ ''
!1 =,>>! 7
)!!+ 6(!
*!+
4," '.5% !!2 .
,!+!
3#2,!3+"(+ ! 5+2 5.,"," %,,', ?5 2
3!5%, ,'5 .""' 0,5!%!, !, !
'@2 5!,!,",!5 . "+ !'
' 5!' 3+,..""5,!+2 >5 ,. "+ ,5"3 ' ," 2 " " % , !%5' , ! 5+ "
2 "(3"1 .!5"!"+2, ,. " !,! +!
% , !! 5!! "+ 3+,5,! 3"2,,', 2 3!5%, ,'5 .""' !, !
'*2(!12!
,(2,, ,. "+?5" '
,'5 !2 <
( ,(2 , ..""5,!+,,. "+ ,5" 3'!,
5! ' 1 "" ! !
! 1 2"" !?5!
! )53>"+ ,!+!
%,2! 3 %
!"+<." 1'
,?5 . "+ "+A &!
5
" ! 5%,<." ,"+ 3+ %,,5
" 2"" ,. !!' 5 !, '.!
,,!!2 "" .! 5 3+,''
! )!!+,6(!
1, 1,2!. 5" 3 "*
5!,! 53',.+ 3+5
", %!,,5
" ", 88
3+ 5!! 2 !( 3+ ,' 4,!
!! ,! ! 4,. !2 % %%
+, %3+"+ %,.!
%,.! . ,'5 ! 2"" . "+,"!+3 . , ,! , 1 "!
5
" ! , !
(,' "+ !%5 , , 2! . !( 3 '
5 "+ ", "+ 4, " !! 2 .
3+ , ''
! )!!+,6(!
!( "3+, !
/'"+12 !(3+,5
" !,
! ,5
" !", 88
$( 1 "'3+,. !12 !(1,. ! ,5
"",12! ?5!35, 2, ! 3" '*2(!1 , %2 @2 "' 35,!+!
2, , ?5!+2 5.. "+'4,! <." !, !( % .!4,. ! "''. +2""( 3+
!
,.!
"
" % !
3.4,+,3 ! 5" / !,! %"!
5
" !,.! 12 ,>5 3"! '5<." %,5%"+ '!, ,! +!
%,.! . 4, "!!'.5% ,.! 2!. 2 .
3+,''
! ,)!!+, 6(!
/
<5! /'"+1.+ ,!!2
!(3+,5
" !, %!, ., ,5
"",,!5%,5!! 88
@ 5%,3"' ,,5!!2 !(*2(!1,! , % !!
5%% 2,+,. !!,5
"", '# + ?5!+35,! 5" , 4, "+."# ,,!!, 3 ! !(3+,)!!+1, 1,+2!5 !,'.!
, ,!!2 ""! !(1 ,!3"((!5."+ 35 ,!+!
4, "+!! 2,! ! ,!!1 ." !! ! !'
.!!,,! , % 4,2!. 2 " 9
12,,2 '!,
,!+!
!,.
% ,!!3+,''
! , )!!+,6(!
: B!,!
' 3(12 ,"+
%,2!.
!"+<." * 1,2! '
5 "+ ", "+ -> ,0 " =5%
*! !) %,),5 (
=5% ,,! .# % ! C ,,!-.!3" C