High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8870/2024disposed of

Subhash Chander v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2024-12-04Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary10 pages

! "#$%&&'(%()*+,-. /0123452678739:();;() <=>?08?"?0952@ ;;;;$21717392@ A2@8=8 <101234B0@C090095D931?2@ ;;;E28F3952918 G H I JK LLLLL $@28291: -@;DM09522FA08?781?ND5O3601243@1?2F21717392@ -@;P0F09Q=M0@N/DRB0@C090 LLLLL SJ

I ; P?2 F@0C2@ M052 79 1?2 F@28291 F2171739 78 43@ T=08?79U 1?2 7MF=U925 3@52@ 50125 (V;(;()N W?76? 78 79 O73X01739 34 3@52@ 50125 ;(Y;(!N F08825 >C 1?78"3=@179"#$%!V %('; ; Z20@925 63=982X W3=X5 6391295 1?01 1?2 F21717392@N 0>3=1 '( C20@8 3X5N W?3 W08 8=442@79U 4@3M X7O2@ 67@@?3878N ?05 =952@U392 0 X7O2@ 1@098FX091 8=@U2@C 79 2M2@U296C 871=01739 01 -097F0X B38F710X [29U0X=@=N W?76? 78 <=F2@ <F2670X1C B38F710X @2U7812@25 =952@ \;D;[;B; *\017390X D66@257101739 [30@5 43@ B38F710X 095 B20X1? "0@2. 095 39 F092X ?38F710X 34 Q0@9010]0 <1012 R3O2@9M291; B2 ?05 796=@@25 0 1310X 2^F2982 34 ) X068N 3=1 34 W?76?

N 39XC ( X068 W08 @27M>=@825 39 1?2 U@3=95 1?01 1?2 1@201M291 ?05 >229 10]29 4@3M 1?2 ?38F710XN 31?2@ 1?09 2MF092XX25 ?38F710X 095 W08 29171X25 13 1?2 80M2 01 $R_ @0128N @2U0@579U W?76? "#$%!V %(' W08 47X25 >C ?7MN W?76? W08 578F3825 34 39 ;(Y;(!N W?7X2 @242@@79U 13 1?

! "##$ %&' &'

(

& ! & (

( &'

*+, - ( ( ,+!!. +, /!& - *+ ) ' % ( &'

*+, %+) (

2/& - ( .(+!& , ( *+

(

## %&' ! ( - ( !

& &'

2) (0+& !) ,+

23 &'

/(&# %'*

(+%!. &'

+&& !& ! - &'

/(& & +0 (, !&) ,+

! 5+(+) +!

- &'

&& ! )/2,&&

&'+& &'

&& !

( '+ +*) . & ( .)& (

',) *- %&'

+!&+ 4 )5&+* %'

( &'

)& - *0 ( &(+!)5*+!& %+) )&+&

& #7 *+ ) 89: 4 )5&+* ;

% < *' +) % ** +) =+!.+ >+, 4 )5&+* ' % ( '

(

+** -( , +!3 - &'

+2 0 ' )5&+*) ?@55( 0

( ; !+55( 0

A %'

( +-& ( ') ,

& ! '+0!.

( (+&

. & + ,&&

! &'

+- ( )+ ' )5&+* %'

( ! '

%+) (+&

' % (

! &'

( +-& ( '

)/-- (

+ 2(+! )&( B ' % ( %&' &, *3 !& (0 !& ! 23 &'

& () - &'

)+, ' )5&+* ') *- %+) )+0

# 0* :/(.

! C+(!+* ! (/)+* - &'

&( +&, !& (

( &'+& &'

&( +&, !& &+B ! ! &'

+- ( )+ ' )5&+* '+ +*) ))/

(&- +&

#$# @!!

D/( " &'+& & %+) +!

, (.

3 ?

'( !

*0 ( ) +) *0 (&(+!)5*+!&+& !A# "# E') /(& ! FGHIG JKLM LNO PQGQK RS TGUVGWG GWX RQYKUN

! "## +** %

*+, - ,

+* ( ,2/() , !& & +!

,5* 3

%' '+ +*) /!

(. !

+ *0 ( &(+!)5*+!& %'

( ! &'

&& !

( %&' ( .+( & &'

( , ( !& '+ )&+&

&'+& & ( ,2/()

+& =Z (+& ) %'

! * +(!

/!) * - ( &'

&& !

( '+) )&+&

! &')

+) &'

( * 0+!&5+(+)%'

( -( + &'/)[ \# Z& ) + ) &&*

5(!

5* - *+% &'+& +!3 + & ! %'

' ) & &+B ! 23 &'

5+(&, !& )' /* )/55 (&

23 &'

(/* ) . 0 (!!. &'

) (0

]/+ &'

)+ +)5

& ( +!3 !)&(/ & !) %'

' '+0

! ))/

23 &'

:&+& # Z! &'

5( ) !&

+) 5 * 3

!"#$

" "%! " & ! %" ' "

(

)

#!$!& "* # "* % " ! # !+ ' ! )#!

) "*

"#$ & % " !

)

"#, " !"#$

"%! " "

, ) "* )

, ! )#!

) !

&% " ! - "* &

# %",

" " %# ! !

" #%" )"# " ! )#!

' ! %" ! # ! ", $ " " ! )#!

*#,, )"#

#!! " , .! ! %, "% " ! /!

"# , *"! ! %"

, ) "* % " !

#!$!&

%! #)". # !+ 01-234'5 $! 6 !$#)

, " *,,

"# , .! ! %,

#!$!& " . ,, 01-234' 5 $!' 8# " "* %! #) $

) " # !+ 01-234' 5 $!

" "

, ) "* % " ! *"! )

, ! )#!

)

",,& ! *

, "

' ! )#!

) "* )

, ) "

"* 01-234 !

#) "*%! /!

"# , *"! ! %" *#!!

#) (%

#!! & % " ! , " $ %! "* ! , .! *"! , .! ! %, "* ! , # )& $! # "! (%

#!! " "! *

# '

#), ,, !"") ! * ( %! ! "*01-234'5 $! %! ,) "*% 9 :

!$#) *"!

#), '

. # , # !+ $

#!$!&' *"!

! )#!

)

"#$' ,, ! )#!

%! ! %!.,

#), ! %#!

& $ .

" # $ % & '()*+,% - $ & &!

" ./" 0

& 1&

! 3 & %

&! 3 &&

1 ,5. ! & 6

% 7

3 & $

& 2 1& " .8" 9& $ 63

% & & 3" : & ;

& 1&

& % 3 & <= 37 &

& !

! & & "> " ?! & $

@6 9 A B & C% - DEFGHHI JKLEM NOP DQEQH RS TEMUEFE EFG RQVHMO % -#'5.W=5X<X<% .="<W"X<X 6 Y Z8" )

3 & 5[$

& 7 & & 3 $

& 6 &% 3

& %

! ! 1 '() " : 6 &

&& !

& ["X / &

"# $ %& '() ' * & ' + ',-. ) & ! /!! ( !!/ 0)! 1234 5& ,& / & & ! * & ' 7 ' ($

* &

' - )! / & -- 5! 8), -' - *.',-.9 : 3 & - 4 * ' , / & -- 4 & / 2'

!4 ;&<<4 *' /& & / * 123=8 >& + (, - -! - 6 ) ! * 6?) 1# /)!

&/ & & * & * & & 0) & = -! 8) * 123=84 >& + & 5@7 A)'( ( &' (-) & & (

&* 8)*!, 2!(!

! (-) & / ! & 123=84 >& +

& ( + (. & - & & & ( (!

&/ &

-)' & & / ! !(! & 123=8 >& + %& 5)

, / & & ,)' (. ! -) ! * & & & /

&/ & &

! / * 6?) 1# !

/ * & *- & - & / * & ! 123=84 >& +4 & /&. & /)!

, &'

'!! & ! 8)*!, 2!(!

!4 >& + %& - ( (! & &

& *- & & ! / & &

&* & ! %& ,

&* *' 123=8 >& + & ! (-) * / * ! 4 /&-& / !*

- B& & /

&* 8)*!, 2!(!4

!4 >& +4 & / 4 & ! -) ! * & 4 ) ! /.4 !* /

& - * & & & &

,& /. -&

# $" "

"# % &' # ( ( )

* +,, ! ( ( ! -)./0 12 ! "

# " ( ! 0"

!3 )$ * 12% 4 ( ! ! " #"' ! ( % 4 0" 5" 0 6 +7 # 8"9 $ $#" ! "# 2 !

# # # 3 3 ! $" #

$ !% .! ! '

( 3 " $#" (

! ( ! $" % :% .

( ! ! !# ##"

# ! ( "3 8;

<" - =9 $' % 4 >3 # ' $ # !

# $" ( ! (

! '% *( ' #%? @% .

ABCDEF GEH IEJK LCM NOEOP BQ REJSEFE EFT BODPJC 5U- =V=W@ XWX= # W:%WY%XWXZ 5" ( # $' $ 3"[ \Y% 4 ' # ( ! 3 ! !"

# $" $ ! !# ##"

# ! # ( $ ! $" ! -). 5 3 ## # ( #' ! )

! *' 8;

<" =9 (# ( "

3 #' # ( $ ! $"

# $%

# "

( ) ) "

# "

"&& * +$ ,- ) $

) # "

) % ))( ")) !"

&$ " "

$## #%

/ 0%) & 12-331-4 "

% ."

"# "

" &) ."" $&&/ " &) "

# %

5 "

. & $& . " "

+ 1-331-4 !" 6$ " ) ."

$" )'

$ 67 8-1224 # 31- ) 9"0 :" ;

6" # *% "

" 6$ .") # "

<$% # =>0) :$& % 6$ ?:"/ @ A" ;

B #

C5 D31- E -2 :66 - "

) " "

) # #$)) %0$

% "

)" # *) 3- # "

6 $ #

) / & # "

<$% # =>0) :$& % 6$:"/@A">

D:$&E &$ $ F, ?-G H$"

5 "

. . %

% ( ." %&) # 0 ")

----31-G H I = )"

$ 5 ."" . , %& )) " &) "

) / % = $ .

&"( -3--31-G ."" / ) ##$

) #

( ( J1,21K = "

%&) "

69!,L / D6%0E & #

("M "

&( D69!E -3--31-G !"

" &) " %$ # N--5J2534GO, # "

% 5 $ # .""5 %$ # N-1515111O, . # "

# "

$) %&) D69!,LE %$ # NG5-454J1O, . &0("

$ %&( )("

" &) -

) ) ) & " "

/ %

%&)(

$ " )# % # " %

) "

! " #

$ %

% ' ( & )$ & &

* !

" ,(

% " -

( .

' )

(

( % $ +%

1! -

( .

( &% '

( !%

% 2' 3" 4 !

( %

% 2' 3" 4

% % " 5

(

% %

( 1

% ( % ( ( ) 6.

" 3$ $

!% "

$ ( 1!

'( %

02.- ' !

% %

0%" 7" 4 (

(

" 4 '

+% '

(

! % " 4 0

2' .

- 802.-9

% &

% '!

(

!' (

(

" #

! "# $%!& # "&! #"

# ' ! ( ) # $# # ! &!&

! $!!

# &"!& ! % #!& #$! # ! "'* &!!#( +%

&# ,! $!$"!##!#-!##!! #%!% $# !# $!" #!&!( . &# &!& !# $! & & !"$ & /0.12 &%! & % & # # ##! & !" *( .' ! !# !" #$&1 #

# # '& # !

!* #

* /45 # &

!' $$ $& '!% ! /! # !##& !" !" * & +!!#* ! # &!& $!!

# - #$! & "'* &!!# #%!% !#

! ,!"

# % #!# & " ! "$

&#$! #(6 ( . # $# # #''# ! # &!#$& * #$&1&$" # $!!

# - #!& #$! ! "'* &!!

! !# # #$$& * !! !##& * #!& #$! & # * /!%!

' 4'"( 7% $! !# #!' " "'* &!! ! # !#

*# #%!'

! $! & ! # !# #" $! # !# # !% $!( )

& !" #*

% #

!- "'* #!! !## "$ * # & -$ #!'

!# $$%& #$! # & # & !# ' $$%& #$! '%" #$! * !'!' &% $!' $! & !#-

!( )

& * $%# !

# %! !% 0!' 8! '& &9! :;/#!!)&!(

! !"# ! $ !

% $ $

&& '

! $ ( "&& # !

#)"

# *+,%-+./ $

"!0

( $ $ $

# # (1 2 34567 879:87;< =>? @676A BC D7;<747 74:

68A;> % EFG/H+IH/HH-%

&0 &

") $ # J&& ## & K !

& E&&0

L$ &% K "

% '

#& M "%

"$ $! &(

$ &

0 " MNOL PM & N!!

Q"$ Q$! &( L$ &

L &

R% !

& $ & '

#& M " Q S #% E"

$ ,THHU ? + V

Q !"& $ ) " )& ! !"

& $

( !

# W" 0# ! (!

(& T N!! 0&(% $ $ $ # X7YZ7 [A=5\@74:AA]X9Y7;

^B>874_7Z`7;a P"$

3bD3c[D3^d ec[`f ?g? Kh #

$ i0.

j k.M $ )& j k.M