High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/283/2019dismissed

Pr Commissioner Of Income Tax-I Chandigarh v. Sukhwant Singh

2020-02-20Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan7 pages

! ""## $ % %&' (%!

)" ! " # ! "$" %&'&()

% *&'+,)(&-."&(/%")0(1/(*,('&2 %)+& 033&220() *++%,-,.- +&%&4&(,&/'/(033&02,(1&%"&5)/(6 )+&(57&08 5). 6 9 %'+%). )+&5) :0*0/('))+&%1&%10)&1

30''&1 ;- )+& (57& 08 33&220)& %/;,(02. +0(1/*0%+ 9 % '+%). )+& %/;,(02 :22</(*',;')0()/02=,&')/(' 20<+04&;&&(520/7&1 > #+&)+&%()+& )+&!1(57&0833&220)&%/;,(02/'%/*+)/(20</( +21/(* )+0) &4&( / 0 730(- 0140(5&' 20(' ) /)'

&7;&%9':?"+0%&@+21&%9':?

/%&5)%9': +21/(* 7%& )+0(

A '+0%&')+&%&/(.0(1<+&%&017/))&12-',5+2&(1/(*/'

()/()+&,',025,%'& /)';,'/(&''.&4&()+&(.)+&07,()'

'0140(5&1.<,21();&54&%&1,(1&%)+&1& /(/)/(

>1/4/1&(1'B0'')0)&1/('&5)/(9:9&: )+&(57&08 5). 6 <+/5+ /' 52&0%2- 5()%0%- ) )+& ,(07;/*,,' 20(*,0*& )+&3%4/'/(C //:#+&)+&%()+& )+&50'&.

)+&!1(57&0833&220)&%/;,(02/'%/*+)/(20</( %&D&5)/(*)+& /(1/(* )+&77/''/(&% (57&08 933&02':@.+0(1/*0%+)+0)&4&()+,*+)+&07,()'' %&5&/4&1 ;- )+& ''&''&& %7 )+& 5730(-. 0 70D%?5('/1&%0;2&30%))+&%& ;&/(*,)/2/E&1 %7&&)/(*

/'5&220(&,' 83&('&' )+& ''&''&&. ')/22 ',5+ )%0('05)/(<,21)0F&)+&52,% 0(1?%%&20)&))+&,',02 5,%'& ;,'/(&'' )+&5730(-<+/5++01)%0('

&%%&1)+& 07,()C 9///:#+&)+&%()+& )+& 50'&.)+&!1(57&0833&220)&%/;,(02/'%/*+)/(20</( ,3'&))/(*)+&<&22@%&0'(&10(15*&() /(1/(*'0'5()0/(&1 /()+&%1&%30''&1;-)+&77/''/(&% (57&08 933&02':@.+0(1/*0%+&4&()+,*+(%&0'('/(%&'3&5) )+&%& +04&;&&(%&(1&%&1;-/)C 9/4:#+&)+&%()+& 0(1/(20<.)+&%1&% ( ;2&/'3&%4&%'&')0)/(*)+0) )+&%&/'(&8&73)/(57&1,%/(*)+&-&0%<+&%&0'/()+& %&),%( /(57&. )+& 0''&''&& +0' 520/7&1 ))02 &8&73) /(57& 'G.GH.

?@.+&(5&)+&%0)/ 50'& ?'

!0F+0(/ 0%F&)/(*I ?

/'()0332/50;2& ))+&50'& )+&0''&''&&C 94:#+&)+&%()+& 0(1/(20<.)+&( ;2&+0'&%%&1/((),3+21/(* 1/'022<0(5& '

. .I ?@,?' G )+&(57&08 5)()+&*%,(1)+0)1/'022<0(5&701&50(()&85&&1 &8&73)/(57&</)+,)033%&5/0)/(*)+& 05))+0))+&%&/'( ',5+ %&')%/5)/( ')/3,20)&1 &/)+&% /( "&5)/( G )+& (57&085)%,2& )+&(57&08,2&C 94/:#+&)+&%()+& 0(1/(20<.)+&( ;2&+0'&%%&1/((),3+21/(* 1/'022<0(5& '

. .I ?@,?' G )+&(57&08 5)()+&*%,(1)+0)1/'022<0(5&701&50(()&85&&1 &8&73) /(57& </)+,) 033%&5/0)/(* )+&

05) )+0) 0332/50;/2/)- "&5)/( G%,2& 1&'()1&3&(1( &0%(/(* /(57&0'+&21;-",3%&7&,%)/()+&50'&

4'0D&(1&%%0'01 1-9 I :.

HH C 94//:#+&)+&%()+& )+& 50'&0(1/(20<.)+&( ;2&+0'&%%&1/((),3+21/(* 1/'022<0(5& '

. .I ?@,?' G )+&(57&08 5)()+&*%,(1)+0)1/'022<0(5&701&50(()&85&&1 &8&73)/(57&</)+,)033%&5/0)/(*)+& 05))+0))+&%&/'( ',5+%&')%/5)/(/("&5)/( G%/(%,2& 0(1 ,%)+&% 520%/ /&1;- /%5,20%H

GC 94///:#+&)+&%()+& )+& 50'&0(1/(20<.)+&( ;2&+0'&%%&1/(/*(%/(*)+&

G 2&*/'20)/4&/()&()&83%&''&1/( '/%5,20%H?

10)&1

G. <+/5+ &832/5/)2- ')0)&' )+0) &83&('&' %&20)0;2&)&0%(/(* &8&73)/(57&+04&);&5('/1&%&1

%1/'022<0(5&/%%&'3&5)/4& )+& 05)<+&)+&%0(-',5+ /(57&+0';&&(&0%(&11,%/(*)+& %()0'5( /%7&1 ;- 3&8 ,%) /( 0833 (4&')7&() !)1 4 . 0870(57 HG9":C 9/8:#+&)+&%()+& 0(1 /( 20<. )+& ( ;2& +0' &%%&1 /( +21/(* )+0) 1/'022<0(5&,?' G50(();&701&<+&%&)+&%&/'( &8&73) /(57&. <+&( ",3%&7& ,%) +0' ,3+&21 )+& 3%/(5/32&' 033%)/(7&()0(11&30%)7&()/'/("!()+& '07&/'',&/()+&50'&' 1&%0)&!&0'/(*0(103/)02 "&%4/5&'4)!)1(

0(1 0)%/8&22,220%"&%4/5&9:!)1 (G G

I0(1/2*/%/( %0')%,5),%& &4&237&()!)1(

60(1(')0()21/(*!)1/( 6

0(1"!+0'02';&&(033%4&10*0/('))+&1&5/'/(

( ;2& ,%/'1/5)/(02 /*+ ,%) /( )+& 50'& ?'

$0%1+70(+&7)&5+%/40)&!)1/( ?

6C 98:#+&)+&%()+& 0(1/(20<.)+&( ;2&+0'&%%&1/(20<0(1 05)/(

22</(*)+&1&5/'/( ( ;2&/*+,%)'<+'& 05)'

<&%&1/')/(*,/'+0;2& %7)+&0''&''&&./*(%/(*)+&3%/(5/302 033%)/(7&()%&*0%12&'' &8&73)/(57&20/11<(;- ( ;2&",3%&7&,%)1&5/'/(/(4#02 %/"+0%&0(1

H ")5F%F&%'!)1. 6 9":0(1,3+&21;-)+& ( ;2&",3%&7&,%)/( 0870(57 HG9":C 98/:#+&)+&%()+& 0(1 /( 20<. )+& ( ;2& +0' &%%&1 /( 1&2&)/(* )+& 011/)/( '

. .I ?@,?' G1&)&%7/(&1;-)+& ,(1&%%,2& %<' G)033%)/(/()&%&')&83&(1/),%& /(5,%%&1)/(4&')/('+0%&'0(1&=,/)-/(')%,7&()/(4/&<

)+&

05) )+0) ( '&30%0)&055,()' 0%& 70/()0/(&1 ;-)+& 0''&''&&/(%&20)/()/(4&')7&()'<+'&/(57&/'&8&73)

%7)08.0(1+0'20%*&;%%<&1 ,(1'/*(%/(*3&8,%) 1&5/'/(/( 0870(57 HG9":C 98//:#+&)+&%()+& )+& 50'&0(1/(20<.)+&( ;2&+0'&%%&1/(20<0(1 05) /( 22</(*)+&1&5/'/( ( ;2&/*+,%)/(!0F+0(/

0%F&)/(*1&5/1&1 22</(*1&5/'/('/()+&50'& &% -52&' !)1. G 0(1 4 #/('7& &8)/2& (1,')%/&'!)1.

G<+'& 05)'0%&1/')/(*,/'+0;2&

%7)+&0''&''&&./*(%/(*)+&3%/(5/302 033%)/(7&() 20/11<(;-( ;2&",3%&7&,%)1&5/'/(/(4 #02 %/"+0%&0(1")5F%)+&%'!)1. 6 9":.

<+/5++0';&&(5( /%7&1/( 0870(57 HG9":0(1 )+,'2&*/'20)/(%&2-/(*(#/('7&&8)/2&'(1,')%/&'!)1 ')0(1'',3&%5&1&1CB +&;%/& 05)'0%&)+0))+&0''&''7&()-&0%/(424&1/'

G+&/(57&)08%&),%(<0' /2&1520/7/(*1&1,5)/(,(1&%+03)&%$@ )+&5)+&50'&<0''&2&5)&1 %'5%,)/(-+&''&''/(*

/5&%)%&0)&1

6 )+&20(%&5&/4&1 %7 ?'57&,/21&%'%/40)&!/7/)&10'1&&7&1 1/4/1&(1'0(1701&011/)/(',(1&%)+&+&01>/(57& %7)+&%',%5&'B ,%)+&%1/'022<0(5&,(1&%"&5)/( G )+&5)<0'02'701&4/1& %1&%10)&1

6+& /%')033&02 /2&1<0'1/'7/''&1( G

6 +&%/;,(02022<&1)+&033&024/1&%1&%10)&1

.+&(5&)+& 3%&'&()033&02 )+&%&4&(,& ()+&033&02./)/'32&01&1)+0))+&)08&

&5)/'G6. .HG ?@.

+<&4&%/)/'0%*,&1)+0))+&50'& 022',(1&%)+&&85&3)/(50%4&1,)/( 30%0

9;: /%5,20%

10)&1

+&'07&/'

%&3%1,5&1;&2< >

14&%'&D,1*7&()'%&20)/(*))+& 22</(*/'',&'

'+,21;&5()&')&1(7&%/)'()</)+')0(1/(*)+0))+&)08 &

&5)&()0/2&1/'2&'')+0()+&7(&)0%-2/7/)''3&5/ /&1/( 30%0 0;4&%)+&%&/'()08&

&5) 888888 9;: #+&%& 0%1 ' %1&%. )/ /50)/(. (')%,5)/( % /%5,20%+0';&&(+&21);&/22&*02%,2)%04/%&'.% 888888 %7)+&3&%,'02 )+&%1&% )+&%/;,(02./)/'() %)+ 57/(*)+0)0(-()/ /50)/(.%1&%./(')%,5)/(%5/%5,20%<0'1&02)</)+? %&2/&1,3(;-)+&%/;,(02<+0)))02F0;,))+&'07&;&/(*+&21/22&*02% 4&()+&%</'&.)+&%/;,(02+0'(D,%/'1/5)/()1&520%&0 5/%5,20%

(,%5('/1&%&14/&<.)+&50'&1&'() 022/()+& &85&3)/(520,'& +&033&02/'1/'7/''&1 <&4&%.)+&',;')0()/02=,&')/('520/7&10%&F&3)3&(

I "/(5&)+&033&02/'1/'7/''&1.)+&055730(-/(*0332/50)/(/' 1/'3'&1 /*++%,-,.0/-1+2)0 -3.+-3.+

7F #+&)+&%'3&0F/(*?%&0'(&1

&'? #+&)+&%%&3%)0;2&

&'?