High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4700/1999disposed of

(O&M) Sanwal v. Kanhu Ram

2019-12-09Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal7 pages

!

!"#$ %&'($$) (''#

!"# $% !"# % (& !"# &$ ***** $) (''#+% )& * '' $

#'+%

'* # "'" ,% #

- # '

. #! # /

*' & #' &

# ' % /' 2'! $ &$' &3 . %## 4 '' 2 $%$ 3 5#% 3. 6'#' $

$#

& ' &$ & * %

' 7&% ! & 3 & & / # 3' $ & &%

!%3,#

*

3.7&% &/ &

# & &5 '% 09 /'9'!#$ /&%3 & &$' '% 2' )& *+%

,% #

: 4& & *' 3# * $ ' % 2' &&

' % 0 9 /' 9 ' & 3 '' 2 ; 4& & *' 5#'% " $ ' % 2'

$

0 & # 3' $ ' &3& 7&%!& 3 &; <%' *%' 0% &" *0'. # 4 '' 2 *& &* & $ #'

0 0& %

$$ . & 3 %' %## &"

%# " "

%3

& $' 4 &%'

0.8 %= % &0% 5 &

0 *

& 4 '' '. / 4:1 & &

& $# )& ' >&% *& <&& %*'$ = % &%3

#

/ %$$ #%

. %

$ % ## # ! & # 3 $

&'

$$% - $%$! #&3 ,%0 <%

!"##$%"&

''" = % &0% $% 4 0 #%

3. &0 0% &

.

3##$ ## # 3 '''.<& 4: *5 &&$"5#%

''3.

3. ?"

<&>3/!

0*

''= 0% *

& "&# / #

& "

# # #%$' *

'% 3'

0 %# . "

&%'

%8 0.!

0 &<% ,#

'' *''3'

3' 3 =%$$ & #

!&&'

%$?

"

@#&,%0 7' 0&<% ()*))+,,-, (!'../%$& %0& 12",%0 <% * *+34,*+!"##2

52

& 0 $ *' $# ' % 2'!

0% $#$ ,3 $%# # # # # 3 $ & ')&*

5 3. $ :7&%&"

* 0*

& "

& !$$'' # $&. #' $ & ' )& $' $$'' $# & $ '

#3

<&& %4:9!3 & &$

& 3.<&& %

'.0 <&& %&

*%''3# &#:& ''

3& 3. #

0 & +%

4 ''

= 0% <&% ?4:

5 3. $ A 7&% &

#5

*' $% ' %3,#

< "

'%

'3.*'0 7&% / 0$

<%' $

! & # .! & %$$ #

0#3. &<% 0

0$' &&3#5#'% "* ''

3& 3. = "& '.0% %#%

# %#&'#0 #"

# 0"

$" ## *

&$"

#

21 )&= %## # 9 2 &B"

## 6*%' % &0% '4 & & '

0& . & ' # $& #$."#

#$. #3

"

#3. *. #."

#= % &0% &<% & 0& '. &' #7&% & 3'

0 *'&"3# #:* &%

''

3& 3. !*'

#'

0 & #:* =&"&#%' &$

!$% &$$:3/ # )&# 3 $% 3%

'$

'*

'

0 #' .%## !&& 3'

& '' %$3.& "'

0% #% !5#% 3. &# 8& % $ ! ## *

& $"

= %## # 9 &B"

## B+%''. %

& $$% & $' & %$ # % # #% #!

.! %% '' = & # &! & %$ 4 ''

2 $%$ 3 5#% 3. <%' & % #

' ''& 3$%##6&' $ %

&$%#."

&+% . # #% # % *& #& #$. #% # 3

"

# 3. *. #. "

#! "

* & $"

#

29 B"

## # $%#

& ' 4 '' #" & # % . & #

0# "

0 #

29!4 '' %$3.& '

3' 3,# #' )&$$'' 5 /! &

0*

''6

. ''%

# $"5#%

''3.

3. &

0*

&

$#

#/*'0 0

3. / * #' &

' & 3& & ! # 3 & . / % &

' & %$$ #% <& !# 3

''&# '. & #5

& /*

$''. # & *& & * * *&

5 &%3 $ '' <&& %4:9

0*

''& $#&3# . &$# 0#%#

''05#%

0

''= &0 "# !

# '.3&' & 3'. #&0

'% 4 ''$$%3.& *5#% 3.

&$ %5$ * & &*& &''3'

*

&

&$ % &*')&4 ## #% )&$$% +% %##0 #"

# 0 "

. ## # *

& 0 ## 8"'

. 0%

3'. $" ###*

&'*!=

*

0 # 3. ,#

0 #' &

%## & 5#'% &#'=& '

3& 3.&)& 3 0!''

3& 3. *%'3 &

3.&& ###*

&$"

6 %%## # 92 )& 3 0 &<% &# %!

$" 3 5#'% "$ '% 2'!

'.!'

3& 3.

1 =

& "% # #$ ,3 / 5&

! & # 3 $ & ' 6*"! & *

5 3. & $

&"

$$'' * 0 *

% 0&'

<&& %4:9! &3 &

& $

$$ & *

35 #3 " & &%

' &$ .. <%' & $ % . # '

#

#5

<&& % &3 *& &

.# 3 #& "#

. $#& '. !<&%?4:

5 3. : 7&% #''.

& #

5

' *'

& ''

3.&*%'# '.3##%$ 3.3.

& &

'. $ .)/ #

& '# #%$' *

'% A 7&% $" & $ & ' % /' 2 '! 3 $

$ # & $ 0 # 3' $ &3& $ :7&%)&

0 <%

# " 3 0 0 #:* *

0 $ '0''. % 3' 3#% #:* 5#'% " $ , ' $ &'' 3

$ # & $ 0 # 3. & #:* 5#$ %#% '* . &#:*# $ &#:

* 5#'% "$ 3. / 0#% $

$# 0 = "

* &

!

0 ,#

0 #' *

& 0 $

0 & # 3' $ & 3& 7&% & %'

:

#

"

## ##$

'0'$

!

& !# 3''* % 3 0$")&$$'' 0 $

0 $ A 7&%

& $ '% 2'5#$

%#% '* ="

* *& &3 #%& 3 ! &$$' $ *

&

#

& # 6 #!'."# % *6& C?(%'

D 4& &$/ 08

.8 4& &$ 3'

.8