Haryana State Electricity Board v. Parduman Kumar Sandhir And Others
!"#$%& !%'
% (% )*+,-.
,
+( ,#/)0/)#% #"
( (
, 2! 342%4$ " #3"
'
% 2 3 #
%$ #3"
# 2( & 5"
$ #3"
$ 6" 1
2 ) !(( $ #3"
'
% 2 -)7$ #3"
$ 6" ( 88888
!'"61 3 ( "1
"$ %
9 %(7
# " "# #
# 1(( # 7 :
9 "/ /) ## "
;/#9 $ ($ '% 7$ 1
4/#9) # "( %3 7
#
"
( (/)"6($$ <= 63"/"6
( 9 ( # ( %9 "6 7
"'#( 7 1) "6 ")1 ( "" "/ "6 >/ ( ""6 # ! ( 9$3 # "
"#
# ? @@$ ((/ #/#
" "6 -# >/ ( "
$ <@ *6" (%" $ A <@
B.$ 6"
"'
#7"
"#
# ? @@$/#
"? #'
% /(
* ."6 <@
$ #"' 1 3
('% % '(( /
#'
% / (
"63
9 "#0%($#7(
" $
%( # ($ ) " 7 >/ # 6" 1/7
1/1"( $)
$ (
""6 0+ (
%7#- &- 6") 0+= /7 "$ ( %"/9%$ '#/#
"
"6
<@
'("/ #" @@?$%"'
$ 1"(( (( ""6 # >/ "( ""# & "3 7 1
" ? @@ 1 "
" ((/ "6"
"/#
""6 <@
!
9# (( (6 #'
% '#1(( #/#
"
"6
<@
$ (6
# (/#
" < "6$'% % )
"7 # #" < @@@$'% 7 )&
3 '( % ( 1 (>#$7 ( # (9 "6( =1 (># "'#((
%9 ( # "
( " 7 (
3 1" " "6 ( 1"#/ #% /#
!
"
" #!"$ "%
&
'
() & '
)$
*
% % % + " )!"
%
%%
%
!
" "" %"%"
% %
, - "
% .
)/0-
0%
"" "
1)2
%
-
"" "
" 12
%
"
.
)/)-
0% -
.
)$
0%
""
" "
1(2
!
1*2
""
5 -
""" "
5 "
% % 6
99 #$ 1 3
( 6
#
"@@ "6 @@@*C2.$'% %'(# % ("/ " ? ?
# )&
3 '( % "(?1 (>#$/1%"
# 9
%9 (# (" "
7 (
3 1" " "6 ( 1"#/ #% /# 5
" "
" "
%
"
#7
%
.
#
0% 3
" " "
*2
!
" %
%
" %%
% % 8 "
"" "
""
""
0%
"
%"
"
"" "
*2
!
" %
%%
%
%
%
" )!"
"
% 5
"6
6" ) # # ( " #
# ? ?1(( # 7 % ( "/ '(((
#7 6" "D7
:"/ ( "6
"6 7'"6 3 "( ? ?"6 $'% % ) # #" $'% 7 )&
3 '(6
(( (( #E ( 1 (>#$7 ( # ( #/ 9 ( %9 (6") F F '
%"/ # ( /7 9 "
( " 7 ( '# # 7
"/ #/1%
% ("/
3 6")
"# #
( 1"#/ #% /#
0%%
"
%
"
%
% 2
*23
*2 4% 6 ? !( # /1"$ ( 6
# 11 "$ '% 1
( # ((/ 7"/ " "6 ")1 ( ")"/ $'% %'(
:
9"/ 3 # "# #
# $ 9 "1"3 #
( )1/9 9 6" ( #"# #
# $
# " "/(
6" 1
(/7) ( % "((/7)
1 3
( "
"(" '
% :1"( " "6 '
# "D7
:"/ /1" "( # ""6
"(*.C * ."6 <@
%(7
1"
#"/ % %"( "($
1 3
( %3 ## # 7 "6
* ."6 <@
F6") #
"6# (1"(( (( "
1(( 9"6 '#$'% %'( )1 ) (( 7
( 1"(( (( ""6 #
( %#'( & 1 " " "
" ((/ #/#
"6 <@
- # " "/(
6/ (/7) ( % 1 3
('
"
(/11"( "##7 "6
"(*.#* .
"6 <@
"3 )"/ 17
"'#(( %9 (#
% ( 9#$% 1 #
/1"4/#9) ("6"D7
/1 ) "/ ( "6
!"
##
$ %&'( %$')#* #+ $ +,
% -"","@6") ( "6
.( ( *(/1.7 ( # ($1"<6") )#* #+*(/1. 1"#/ #% /# 6" ,@"6 !"#$%&
%'()*+ ( *(/1.
" ""
9 5 ;4 % 5 " "
.
)/0- "
"
%"
"
.
)/0- "
" !
"
%
.
)/-
0% %
%"%" " "
.
)/)-
0% 6 ,<"6
"!",#%+)'"
-../*+
( *(/1
. 3
% 5 "
.
)/0- )2
"
% /)$((-0
"
.
)/0-
0%
" "
!
%
.
#/-
0% .
)/0-
"
%
.
#/-
0%
5 ""
!
"
:
!
%
.
#/-
0% " "
.
)/0-
0% 0
% % 6 < "
%#$
# "/(
1 9 1 3
((/7) ( % 7 "6
"* ."6
<@
'((1
9
"/ ('##
< @@@$'% %
#6
/1 " "D7
:"/
'
%"/ %3 97
# ( /7 # 6/ (/7) ( % " 1 3 "/( " ( "7 6" :
9"/ ('
$( ) "74
"'( (
? ( "61
$'% % %"/9%'(
#3 # "# #
$
( #"# '( ((
## %/($7 ) 6
1
(# "# 9 $"6 (%"74
"(" () ((/
"/ #7
#,6") "# #
# ( 1"#/ /# 6"
" "
% < &= "
% "
>
"
"
"
%%
" "
""
%
? 0% 5 ""
<
. 8!
@ " ;"
5 "
9
(77##*@
>
"
"
3
%
%
5 )))
% ""
9.;8 /
9>8='?-6
( 9#( 9 7 /#
" *. # * ."6 <@
$/1" )"/ "6 ")1 ( "17
"'#( %9 ($
# "/(
6" 1 3
((/7) ( %
() '((1
'# # 63"/"6 (7
"/ # /1%
#/1 " "D7
:"/ # %/($ ( 9
"6 "$"(/ %1
"/ #7
# ( "61
@ %3 % #
# "/(
6" 1
(#9" %"/9%
11 7""&('
( '
# 7)/7
"6 #(/7(
(/7) (( "()# "7 % 6"6 1
1 /( "6 '##
< @@@1((
"/ (%"'( % 7 /#
"* ."6 <@
('
( #
) ""6)&
3 7## 9 ")1" "6(
%9 ( # %/($
9 1 3
(6" '#"67 (/#
"*.#
"* ."6 <@
/1"'((1
9
"/ # () '( # ( /7
7 % ("/ " 7 "D7
:"/
() 7 9 3 # 6")
3 1" ""61"6 '##
< @@@ (
#% 7
"'6" A !
" "" %"%"
% % 6 (11 6") 6 (# /)( ("6 1 (
% /
6 "6 ## 9 ")1" "6 ( %9
"'#( )&
3 6" 1/1"( ("6 9 7 (/#
"(* .C*."6 <@
'(9
"/ $ ( '#'(1(( " < @@@ )/ %1 " " :1"( "6 ' )# ( "6 / 3 # # ( " #
<
6" ( #
6 9
# 7 "/ '( (") %"' # ( /7 # (/7( >/ 1"
# 9( >/
) ""6 ")1 ( "# %/($7 ) 6 #((/ %
:
9"/ '(%3 9"1"'
"
6 '
% ()
) $ 7 "6
"* ."6 <@
$'% % '((1
9
"/ " )"/ "6 % ")1 ( "" "
%3 97
# ( /7 # 11 $7 ) 6 $
1
(# %/($ ' ##"'7 "D7
/1 ) "/ )#* #+. ( *(/1.#"
("
11 6 (# /)( ("6 1 (
3 6")1* ."6
< '#1(( "/ ( 1"#/ #% /# 6" A* - "
% .
)/0-
0%
"" "
1)2
%
6
1 4/ / $ :
9"/ (1
/# #6") "1 9 ((/ (( 9#) ("6 )(
/17 1 3
(#%( "
'## 4/#9) 1(( % ("/ ('
( "D7
:"/ $( (
"#"/7 $ ( '% #
""# '% %%(7
1(( #7 7/ ="/ ('%"
'
%"/ 4/ (# "$ 7 ((
"
1"
# 9( /# 9 ""
(($ 1
6 ($ ( #1"1"( ""6 ' "
7 )# 11 7
( -#
>/ ( " 7/ $'%
9 6
# ( "6 1 3
(= ( %# (/74
)
( '
(
" 4/ (# " "
() # %/($ '(">/ "64/ (# " "" &"6 % 4/ (# "'%
1(( 9
'##
< @@@# 7 '# #/#
"* ."6
@<
$7 ( # ($
6"6 9)&
3 /1"## ""6 ")1" "6( %9 ('
"
# ( /7
7 % ("/
"7 "D7
:"/ 2" "3 $
69
#/#
$ %"/9%
9
/(/( 7
$:
9"/ %( "
() ( (# "
9"7 "# 7(
9"3 (11
6"/)
6" ( #3 ' ( # 3 #6") # ( ")# 7/1 )
"/ A"#/"'"
0%./1& "#+"#"'
%("!
%!%&-.
0+
12+)"'
"23 4 5 66$#
3 191%( @ " "6 1"#/ /#
@ ( < A
%
5 01%%0 2 %3+)' '%, /B/(((-.55**$C3
% "%!
+ %
%
""
+ %
" "" ", D 3
%
5
"
%
% 3 %
%
+ % ;
"
"
"
% % %
""
% % % %
%
5 %
"%!
+ % %
3 ""
!
+ % "
D
%
< A "
%!
%
"
%!
"
%
% %
" "
% %
%
) 0 %
""
+ "
+
.
#
5
5 "@
%
4 % "" E
%"
!
%
"
"
% " %" " "
% +
0 +
3 "5 "
%
"
"
""!
;4 % 5 %
+
%
+ % "
"
;4 % 5 ""
$/0)056
- ,4"78 5 "
, D0 % %
""!
%
+ %
%
0
" %"
"
"
%
.
#
5 % 0% D ) " %
5 %
% + %
0 %"
#)
5
"
3
"
3 "5 " :
"
" +
3 "A
5
% "
" 5 % "
"
% "
5 ""
% %
)) :
"
%
""
"
"
9
3 ;4 % 5 ""
%
% "
6
2" "3 $
( 9 "1"
# 9($
"74
"('
( # ( "61
$ () '
%"/9%
#(1
3 # "# #
# $'% %%"'
$ '( ((
# ( "61
# %/($ ( 9"6( ) "74
" (/7( >/ ( 9 "'('%"
)1 ) (( 7
' 6" ( #3 ' (# 3 #6") "7( 3 "()# 7"D7
/1 ) "/ ( "6#' #9 #
)))? " /.5-$7 , "67 9
3 ( 1"#/ #% /# E
%
"
+ % "
""
"
+
%
" %
" % + % " % %%
%
" !
" 3
+ % % "
"
<
% %
" "
%
" % %
5
+ % .% % %
%
% %
%
+ % 6
3 '"6 # ( /(( ")# % 7"3 $6 # 9")
1 3 ( "$ () ($% 7# () (( #$/1%"
# 9 "# #
# $1(( :
9"/
"( # 9 6 % >/ ( "1"
# 9( 1
( ")) # @@# 1 3
( (
' 96"
( "6 #/ ( "'#( ")1 ( '# #9 ( >/ #$ :
9"/ ( >/
/# 1"
# 9('
% 1 "#"6 %
)" %(6") "#
? , # 911 "($ 6$( ## (1"( #"6
4 5 (" &
'%
(1 & 9= (" # (="
'%
1" 7
(="