High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/5695/2011dismissed

Sarabjit Rai v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2015-02-18Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh16 pages

!" " #

$ % &%%

' ( &%%

!" " %

)&*+,)+-- .'

" $#$/ &#0 1 $ 2% 3$/&#0

* "(#/&#0 $%% &%%

' ( " " /&##&4/ " (6 $"#37 /

# &%%

' ( $ # #% #

8" 1 0 0#

$ $ 9 10

: 0 / $ 3;

# 7

*$% % $ #" # <' 8"$ 3 "77 ## #%# 7

=# # #> !&7 3$ #

$?1"8"

% # 3 3 $ 7 (6/ $ $ ,-

< # 13 # 7"# @3 3$" # =</=//<' # < -

($#" 3 0 % / 76/ $$

3$ A 2$ #/ A @3 3$/ &7 3$/ :: 3$ #" 3$ & $ # "# % # #" 7 61 0 #0#"#37 # 'B' %# 6 &## @"#3/ (

77 %" $" # =</=/<'/< # - # #

" #3 7% &330#6 #"#37 0 # # # #'B'/ 0 "#% %# %%&%%

)( ' $ )" 3 $% # 6 #%%/ %% 17 0# $ $ "#% $

@3 3$/ $3## #/ 1$ $ $ "#1

# # 0 # 0 #$ 13 # 3 $7&%%

= )( '1 1#/ 0 # 1 # # $ "#1 8"

# $ $3 7#3 $70#"#37 # #=*$ 0 1 1 # *$ "# 1 1##

" $0# #"#37 9/

($#"/) ( 1# #

3 ,-

$ $ $$ 3$ A 2$ #/

= 0 3 $7 #

% #%1 &# 1

$% # 3" # =< 3 0 " % "# 3 % *$ /,-

B# #'' 1 3 #" # </ //< /<B/<'/<B # (- 3 7 6 =%

/1$ $1 $ 3# $ # $71/$ 10/8"$#0# #"#37 = , 3 330# 7 $ # "#37 # =%#6 $ / $71 $ 3#6 $ 6 16 3C 7

<BD 9 E $&%; / 1$ $1#7#0#"#37 - 1 0#

7 #7 #%% $ 7

#%""

$# "#$ ##1 3 " #6

0 7# #%#6 $ - %""

# "#0# #"#37 # #=/ $&## @"#3/ ( # #

" # </ (/=/</ #- 0# ## #3

$% 0 0# - 8"

$# #/

# #1# $ -83

3 7 6<% "# 3 $% #"77 3

#1%# " $#$/ # " $%

# "% / 76/ $$ 3$A2$ #/&7

3$/ :: 3$ #" 3$1 #1 "

$7 %%#

$1 ; # 3 $%7 60# +0 #" 3 0 3 7 $% #

3" 61$ $ 1 C # " " $"7

< %# "#69 E $&%; $ 7 1

3 #1 3 " #6 0 7#6 $ /1$/ 0 7# $"#37 # #= 1 :

# C # " "7

1 $3#

7" 7

/ % 8"1 6 $#% #

$ $ 8"/$1 " #

7% % 6##

0 63 3 % 1$ # 3 $ #% % # 3 C #

" "7 $7%"3 #"77 #

%: 3 #$ %#1 30 3 6 $ # 1 0 # 3 $ 7% $%7 6 0# * "%% $ 0

/ # " $ #"% $"#37 9 F $&%;

!""

# $%#&$'

%#( )* !)%# )* # "+" ) "# # )* ,< 7 =/&-$"#! )* ) # +" !'

. /) # )* ) # <= 7 '=/

+" /$# '

" < 7 =</&& .!'$#$+"

/0 7 <=/ )1

) ! +" *#)

)* ) # 7 ='/

)*.

+ )1 ", .$+" )* ) # '< 7 B'/

+" !# = 7 / '

"# )* # "+" # 1# )* # $%# # 0 '

) '

)3#!5 )* ) # < 7 / "#&$'

!) +"

"# ) == 7 B= # 2 : 93$ +

!1 +" /0& ) 0$1

.!3 *!1 !& * %$!" !3< 7 / "%% $

- ##

3"7 #0 # 6 " $#$/

# " /* "(#1$%% 3 % &%%

' ( "7 7 #

6 % 0 % 0##" # =< $0

1#C # 1$% 37%"3 # #$

1$ $ $% $#30 60# $

G $ # 3 6%7 6 8"6/ "#

0 0 " $% 1 0 0# C # $

7# 6 % 6 7# " # *$ % # 3 1

# $ : $% /1$/$1 0"77 # 1 ## 6 %% " 6 $ 3 % 3 7%"3 # #1$ $ 3 0 "" , 3 % # 3" # =< / $

6 %7 7# C # " " $"7

$ " #6 0 7#6 $ / 1$/

#% % 1 % 6"%

$ "#

" % 1 76 $

0 C # " "7 $ 0#

$% $#0 0#1 $

$ "# $0 $

$$ 3$ #

$ $ "# $%0 " $ # 6: # 0# 1 $#$

C # " "7 $% # $3#$ #"

6 #$1#"

" #

3 $ *$%0 " 4 0 7

17 #

$% 0 " # B $0

1# -

# "

%% 1 $3#

" # </ ( - # $ " # $ # 6 : 3

$# =<

7 # $7

# C # " $ #"% $"#37 F $&%; $ #

$)!4 ..!

)* ) # +" '/ 0&-

'B/ % / 0+" # !&- <</

"# +" $*#!1

$//

=="%7 ==/ $ !# )1

* +" !# )* ) # /

"#&$'

!"#

+" !# )* # "<=/ )1

) !

+" *#) " )* ) # "%7 = '/ )"$1#.

.+!# .* "# $# )+" $2

BB"%7 / *#0

* "#+"#

! )*

# "'"%7 B/# ! )* ) # +" * " )* # "&- <=B/&& $)

)+"+ 3#

6 !

)* ) # &- B'/ !!"#+"

"# "%7 =/ #

' +"

*# 0#0 ' )* ) # &- B"%7 =B/ & #.!+"# !%# $ $)2 / )* ) &- B'"%7 B =/ /!)* )* # "+"# ) &- B "%7 B/ '1 '*

)* # "+" )* **!!

) . ""!

)"$*% "$.* ) )* # " &- B"%7 ==/ !""

# $%#&$'

%#$( )* !)%# )*

# "+" )"## )* ,&- <"%7 B/

"# &$'

!"# +" !# )* # "&- "%7

' # 93$ #$4

!)!)%#+"# < C@B / "%% $

C # " $%

# "77 3 # %# 6 $ 1 # #

8"# $% % C # " " $

% "

18"#

# $ $% 1

# $3 3 $ #"

$$ #"% $"#37 9 F $&%; $ $ "#&$'

#!1 '3# )* !)+"

)* 02 0#$"# )' ( /

2&!"#

0+"& '.

"#,

)* 0 )* ) # = 7 'B=/ !!"#+"

"# &CC B=/

"#!)%# * . )* ) # +" $)2 /

)* # " <7='' #

1# $7 ''

# 1# )* )* ) # <&- @$ <==/ "%% $

9# $3"7 #0 #6 # " % #$0 3 $ "3$ $"77 #1

$ "7 0 *$"77 #$ $ 3#7 6 3 " # "# % $ "#$0 $# 3

# %7 6 8"6$ "#$0 # 6 "77 3 *$3# 1 # $3 #"

# 7 #

6% 0 8"#" # =< $0

1# *$"1# 69 F $&%; !!"#"

8"$4 91$ / 1$# %7 6 8"66 " # =<

# # $3" $% 3 1$ 7% # 3

# $3 &

$ 3/ $"77 3

1$ $ 7#

- $ $# $

68"7

$ "#30 %% " 6 $ 3

$ "# 3

6 $ 7 % 6 $ "#$ 77

$% HH!-

>% 0

$#7

@" ? =< $ "" #

6 =<0 0 3

06 $ #/1$ $ % #" #" #.

>G$ "% %% 7#

$ $

$1/ 6 % ;%# " 8"6$ "#7#

" "

/1$ $%%

$0 77

% # 3 / $ 76/ % # "7 % #" # 30 0# % # 3

/" $ 76/ " $%7 6 8"6/ 6/ $ : 6/

# # 3

I 7: $ 1 3I #

3 $ $0 3"# I # :" " 6 $%% $ "# " $3 / $3#

# $ $ : 6

# / # $ "# "

" $3 I # # 0 6%

%% #300# " $3 ?

& %" $ " 7: %"% 7 % 6 $ / ;%# " 8"6$ "#7#

/1$ $ %%

$0 #, 7 " $ % / $

7% 1#

$ #%7 6 8"6"

( ),!# $3 )*$3!)% "$3#4 .!'!) 0!):$! 0# $ 3 ) '"$3# ) 4!)!

) )#

/ "!" ,#!3#!

" # $ # )

)3 # "/

) ''! * ) '

) "$3# ) 4!)!

)!!") '

)* 0# $ "# $.*'

3 '4.

!) *

") '

)# # $ "# $.* " '

3 $ "

3 '4.

!)/$!!" ).0#

* 3!"!

) )# / "!" '

) "$3# 4!)!

)!)3 # $ #!)1"# !!") ""

0 3 )*$3 4 .!'!) 0!):$! 0

!)*!)% ! !" $4 )# $ * "

/$!) /"

)3 "$3# .!'!) 0!):$! 0# 4!)!

) '

*/0# $ !") (!!

* F $&%; !!"#"3 8"$4 9$$#" #.

> # 3 $" 7: $$"

$% 0 7 % 6 1$ $% # 31

$# ;%# " 8"6$ "# 7#

1$ $%%

$0 77

#- #

7" $ % 7% 1#

$ #%7 6 8"6 -

%7%

6 " $ %7 6 8"6 $ "#$#+0 1 " $%7 6 8"6

7" $ % 1$ %%

$ 77

% # 3

- 7%

0 1$ 7 " $ %

7 #

6 $ "#7:

*$" $ #% 1

# - #

7 $ "#/ 7

"/ 7: ("

# #

# / $ $ "#7: # 3

$ " ;%# $ " $ "#" $% #

# 6

%7 6 8"6

$" $ # 3 16 %

# /

"3$ 6 " $ %7 6 8"6 1 "#

0 # 3 $#6 3# 3 % -

$ "# 3 77# $ %7 6 8"6

7% # $"

# 31$ $ 6 % "% 3" 6

, 7 / $%"% %7 6 8"6/0 %

/ 6

# #1$ $ ;%# $ "

$ 1$ $ %%

*$ 7> 8"6?# # 3 $ #> $ ? 7 # % # "#37 9 F $&%; !!"#"3 8"$4 9 1$ $ % #" #" #.

>- 8"6# # 3 $ #>06 8"6/

$ $ / #" # $ #6 73 ?-

$% 8"6/ # %

;

7 $ 8"6

#6 73 1$ $ 7 % /1$ $

$%7 6 8"6

/ ;%# $ " 8"6$ "# 7#

6 $# $

$73 #&

0 0# 31 $ $%"01 >1

?J# # ;K $ # $73

1 $% #"% # $% H-H $ #- $

;

176%

=<= $ #% $73

1$ 7

7#" # =<$% #

# 1 $ $ 1 # % % *$

3 $% / $73 0 3

$% #" # ='

<= $ # =' $ #6 $73 $

$ 6 $7 % $ 0

"7 $0 "%%#

$ "# = $73

# # "7 1 $ 976 7:" $;7

$ "#/$ $ : 6*$ $73 $

$ $% "

# $ "#

# 1$ $ $3 3 $ "#3 " #- $ # $3

3 " #$$

# $3

$ "# 36 # 3$ $ < $ # 6 $ 73

% / $ # 8"6/ $ 3 " # %"7 3 $ "#$ 77

# $$

7 $3 1 33 $ "#" $ $3 $ $ # #;% #

$ "# #$$ :#1$ $$%#3" 6 $3#

-$%#

3" 6 $ $73 $

L $ $ 8"6

" 73 ?

*$ # "7 7# 6 # " % %0 "

% "

1 # % 3 $"77 # % # 3" #

=< - / 6 $ 3 $ # 3 0#3 $7#

$ #"

% "

8"# 7 $"77 # %#*$%

% 0##

$%" 0 1$ $3# # # $3 $ #"

77 " $D$0 "

# $3 $D$#"

6 # 1 6" $ $" # B $

#*$ 0 7#69 F $&%; 1"#!"# !)%# +"$ '

2& $ '' 7 = # " #.

>< - 6

$ %" 0 # $3 $#"

- $ # "7 $ %

%" #%" 0 "

3 # $3 #"

# %

%0 M $0

#6 # 3

;

#$ 1%" 0 1 : 3 # $3 $#"

%"% ## $3 $#"

/ #1$ $

$ %" 0 $ ; ## $ 7 - "

3 M : #0 3 M $0 3 : 7

$ 7% # 1# $# $3

$ 76$0

6#" # ("

$ 7 7 $

7%$M# 7 $ "#

6# $%7 6 3 " 1 "3

#73

$0# ?

>< *$ %

30 " # B

% %" 0 3 $ % 6 0; " 7 % # 3 3#

$0 77

#6 $71$ $6 %"%

= %" 0 *$% 6 $3 "

# #8" %

%" 0

" $6

% "

# 6 $ 3# 6 $7 $# $3

$ #"

1 "/ # 3 #/

$ 4 0 7 / $6 $

; / 7%

$ % "

*$ %

$ 7 #0 61$ 3# # 6 $ %" 0 6

#1 $ $# $3 $ #"

6 #

76 : # - # 3$

6/$ # ; $#"

6/"

1 $ # $% 7

6/ $; 1

" 3 " #

#%0 $%" 0 7 $%

*$8"

$ " " $1$ $ $3#

# 7 6#% # "%

# 3%" 0 /"

1$ $ 1 77

6%" 0 %"%

" $ # $3 $ % 6( B 0 :#/ 7" $ 1 #1 "# 3#

$0 77

#6$7 1$ %"%

$# $3 $ -

$#"

61$ $8";7 7" $ $ / " $ % 7#

$ # $3 #"

61 # *$ 7" 1 $ $ % # 3 #"

$%" 0 #- $8" 6 $ 1$ $ 7% # $%

$ 0

< 1 $ $ % # 3 $ #"

6*$

6" 0"

# 7 1$ $ $

1 $ # # 6/ %

6# 1 6" $"*$%

7: $ % B #

77# 63

# 76/9 F $&%; $ $.", '!

+" * "&- BBB$$#" #.

$ 06 77

#6%" 0 8" % "

" #

B $7 #" #I 0 06

6$71$$ "6 33# $% 7

$ #"

$ 7% # # 6

#1 $$ #"

/8" #/ "# 7#

$0 # 60 " / 1 "# 6 - 8" 6 $ 7% # 1 $ $ % # 3 $ $ %

7% # 6 B 7 #" #1

#& 76 6"

#1 $ #"

6" $ 76 77

#1 $ $ % #"

6G$

#1 $ #"

6 $ %

- 61$ $1 $ $ % #"

6 ; $%

G$% 3 "77 #/ $ 1 3 #1 %#.

>*$ 7 $0# 3

## /1$ $ $ # # 0/ 0# 0 "3$@3 3$ ":$#0 3$10/0 $ ":$#0 3$ 7% 161 &7 3$ # 1 4"#0 3$/":$ 3$/2 3$/"

2"/(:: 3$/4"#0 3$ $"$ 3$/@

3$ $"$ 3$/&-)$ 3$/-

$0#% # # #0# 0M 0M7"# @3 3$ ":$#0 3$ # 7 $7$# # # $## #6+0 ":$ 3$$#30

2 3$ #@ 3 3$1

;

0 1% $# #6&-)$ 3$ #- / 4"#02"1 ":$#0 3$ #(1 # 3$A ( # ":$#0 3$7

$ #

# # # @3 3$ & $ # % $# 1 % # % 6/ 0 1 $ $

$ # "# 0 0

% /1$

1 #

" #3 %" $7 7%

30 3 $

$% #

$ $ $ # &## @"#3/ ( &" $ #% # # $$#

$ % "

# " # </ (/=/</ /- ?

- 01 $ 11% ;% # 0/

$ 7 $

# 6 # " % #

$ $% 3#0 # 67 $6

#7# ' 8 9 %