Sukhwinder Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab And ORS.




   


!"##$%&%'(  )

 *+,-.%'/#0*%'1-"-#0&  #"%"%'#0& 2#0&+& *"!"# +'3!4"-#0&  #&5'/#'"&
 


     

0#&#'"( 0*!''6/7$!"#0"-#5#"%"%'#0& 0 *!/!-!066 +'3!4 0*8!016/7$!"#00#&5'/#'"&'")       -%& 0/#0 &-!:: /%&5&# "-# %'&"!'"  5#"%"%' %:#/  +'/#0 *#$"%');0 50!<%'10=+!&-%'1 > /!"#/;>

 0#1%&"#0#/  +'/#0  &#$"%'&  6  )6  );6  )? 
   $-!::!'  50#&#'"#/6 $-!01#&0!@#/!'/$'7%$"#/+'/#0&#$"%'&6)6>6 6 );6 )?

  !"  5:%$#  *"!"%'6 -!6 %&"0%$"  !'&!!'/  !::  "-# 50$##/%'1& #@!'!"%'1"-#0#0@6'"-#4!&%&!$@50@%&#"-!"-!&4##'!00%7#/!" 4#".##'"-#5!0"%#& #.!$"&"-!".+:/0#=+%0#'"%$#!0#"-!" $!@#"4# 0#1%&"#0#/'"-#&"!"#@#'" !3*%'1-
".!&!::#1#/"-!"'>

!"

!4+"  -#.!&50#&#'"%'-%&%#:/&!:'1.%"--%&.%#!&%48!+0 !'/  &%&"#0%':!.  *+,-5!:  8!+0 
'  "-#  @#!'"%@#6  "-#  !$$+&#/ 5!0"<A5#"%"%'#0&-#0#%'!""!$,#/"-#@ +03!'"*%'1-5#"%"%'#0' %& &"!"#/"-!7#$!+&#/!'%'3+0<'"-##!0 !3*%'1-$@5:!%'!'"4< %':%$"%'1! 
 4:. @5:!%'!'" !3*%'1-!'/!&%48!+0!0# &"!"#/"-!7#&+#0#/0!$"+0#&'!$$+'"3%'"4#!"%'1&1%7#'4<!::"-# !$$+&#/A5#"%"%'#0&-#0#%' *+,-.%'/#0*%'1-A5#"%"%'#0' %&&"!"#/" -!7#%':%$"#/!
4:."*+,-5!:8!+00#&+:"%'1%'"-#!@5+"!"%'

 -#0:%"":#%'1#0
'5+0&+!'$#""-#0#1%&"0!"%' 6$-!::!'.!&%:#/!'/ $-!01#&  .#0#  0!@#/  !1!%'&"  "-#  5#"%"%'#0&   !7%'1  !$#/  "0%!:  "-# 5#"%"%'#0&7%/#3+/1#@#'"/!"#/;)

)65!&&#/4<"-#:#!0'#/*6 +/-:!/!&"!'/$'7%$"#/!'/&#'"#'$#/0#'$#&+'/#0&#$"%'& );6 6)6>6 
 0#!/.%"-&#$"%' )?
   '/%&5+"#/:<6!'

!55#!:50##00#/4<"-#5#"%"%'#0&!1!%'&""-#3+/1#@#'"$'7%$"%'%& 5#'/%'14#0#"-#:.#0!55#::!"#$+0"!"!'&!
"&"0!'&5%0#&"-!"/+0%'1"-#5#'/#'$<!55#!:5#"%"%'#0& -!7##'"#0#/%'"!$@50@%&#.%"-"-#$@5:!%'!'"5!0"< ' 



6.-%:#%&&+%'1'"%$#@"%'%'"-#%'&"!'" 5#"%"%'60*8!016/7$!"#-!/5+"%'!55#!0!'$#'4#-!: 0#&5'/#'"&'")!'/-!/$'$#/#/""-#!$"+@!$@50@%&# -!7%'14##'#'"#0#/%'"$$0/%'1:<65!0"%#&-!/4##'/%0#$"#/"!55#!0 4#0#"-#0%!:+0"A
::!=!!1%&"0!"#01#""%'1"-#%0&"!"#@#'"&0#$0/#/ %'&+550""-#$@50@%&#

:!$#/'0#$0/%&!0#50"/!"#/ 



"-#:#!0'#/ 
6+/-:!/!!'/!5#0+&!:"-#0#.+:/0#7#!:"-!""-#&"!"#@#'"&

!3*%'1-$@5:!%'!'"6*+,-5!:8!+0!'/!&%48!+0%'3+0#/!&.#::!&"-# !$$+&#/5!0"<A5#"%"%'#0&-#0#%'-!7#4##'/+:<0#$0/#/!'/%"-!&4##' 5%'#/"-!"!$@50@%&#-!&4##'##$"#/4#".##'"-#5!0"%#&.%"-+"!'< 50#&&+0#0$#0$%' +'&#:0"-#5!0"%#&-!7#4##'-#!0/ -#  &$5#    5.#0  #B#0$%&!4:#  4<  "-#  %1-  +0"  +'/#0 *#$"%');"-#/#0%@%'!: 0$#/+0#$!@#"4#$'&%/#0#/4< "-#'C4:#*+50#@#+0"%'
 





   

 

  !'/%".!&-#:/"-!"$@5+'/%'1!'#'$#!'/=+!&-%'1 $0%@%'!:50$##/%'1&!0#".&#5!0!"#"-%'1&-##B"#'""-#%'-#0#'" 5.#0+'/#0*#$"%');"-#/#0%@%'!: 0$#/+0#!&55&#/" "-#  5.#0    $@5+'/%'1    #'$#  +'/#0  *#$"%'      /#   0%@%'!: 0$#/+0#.#0#-#:/"4#/%&"%'$"!'//%#0#'"!:"-+1-+:"%@!"# $'&#=+#'$#@!<4#"-#&!@#
".!&+0"-#0-#:/"-!".-#0#"-##'/#0 !'/"-#7%$"%@-!/&#"":#/"-#%0/%&5+"#6"-#%1-+0"%'#B#0$%&#%"& %'-#0#'"5.#0+'/#0*#$"%');"-#/#0%@%'!: 0$#/+0#%& $@5#"#'"  "  =+!&-  "-#  $0%@%'!:  50$##/%'1&  #7#'  0#:!"%'1  "  '' $@5+'/!4:##'$#&$!+"%'6-.#7#06.!&&+'/#/"-!"&+$-5.#0 .!&"4#%'7,#/&5!0%'1:<!'/'"%'0#:!"%'"#'$#&.-%$-.#0# -#%'+&0%'7:7#/@#'"!:/#50!7%"<"-#:%,#@+0/#060!5#6/!$%"< #"$ &".-#"-#0$0%@%'!:50$##/%'1&$!'4#=+!&-#/4<"-#%1- +0"%'#B#0$%&#%"&5.#0+'/#0*#$"%');"-#/#0%@%'!:

0$#/+0##7#'!"#0"-#!$$+&#/-!&4##'+'/1+%:"<!'/$'7%$"#/4<"-# "0%!:+0"#7#'"-+1-"-#@!""#0@!<4#5#'/%'1%'!55#!:4#0#"-# 55#::!"#+0"$!@#+50$'&%/#0!"%'4#0#!%7%&%'#'$-"-%& +0"%' 

 

 !

"

#   *+$-=+#&"%'.!&!'&.#0#/%'"-#!%0@!"%7# !'/%&%'"-#::.%'1"#0@&(   




!"   #

$   %&
$ '
(



&

 "

(    % ) &  *+ &,&$ - )   

.

)&,&$ " )

&


&  ) ," ,&

  &

(

" &  ) &/  /  &

))  

$
&$ #  ) /&)

 #

&$   1 ( &

 & 2 /& 3$

) / % 

  # -  



   

* +    &,&$ 45 + 6 % 4*1

  

, &, &$ &"

( 

$  



""

$$

   

 ) /&)

   % ) &  *4+  7& - $    

) 

+ ,

8 &,"& ,  & ""

$ ( "

&
 

& ""

$$

) 

"

!

  .



)&,&$ " )

&
 0

"&
& /& (

"

)$& )   )&), ) 

)  &

&



 : &)

/&

 ) & &  )&,&$ " )

&
 ( $   



" )   $(;  $ # &/ 0&
&  "

(     &)$ * 

  &

& %&)

<&

  

 

"

  # "

(  0&

   &)$

* 

  &

& 1

)&

  )&&  )

)   

/ /



<&
  (&

) $&0 "$$ $ "

( 



,
& 

 &

 :&&) &

!

)& $ #

<&
    % ) &  *+ &,&$ - )    (&

 /& (

" /

 

 $( 

)

  : &)

( / 1 & (&

&)$

&  "

( 

.

" )

&
 &  $ &

$#

) ,"

 $

 )  

(&

&

   % ) &   &,&$ - )   

)  "

( 1 &  ) &   /& (1 & !

)& $  #  
/



 &

!"    &/ 0&
 ) "

(  & $$# : &&  )   )&), ) 

)

;

&5#0!$"&%'*+4#*%'1-C&$!&#&+50! 6"-#!$$+&#/-!/4##' -#:/1+%:"<4<"-#"0%!:+0"0#'$#&+'/#0*#$"%'&) 6) 6) ;0#!/ .%"-*#$"%'  "-#
'/%!' #'!:/#-#%7%&%'#'$--!/ %'"#07#'#/%'"-#@!""#0'"-#4!&%&!$@50@%&#!'/-!/&#"!"'!+1-" "-#  #'"%0#  $0%@%'!:  50$##/%'1&  %'$:+/%'1  "-#  3+/1@#'"    $'7%$"%' /7#0"%'14!$,""-#!$"&"-#50#&#'"$!&#"-#/%&5+"#4#".##'"-# 5!0"%#&.!&.%"-0#1!0/"%00%1!"%'!10%$+:"+0!::!'/-#5!0"%#&4#:'1 ""-#&!@#7%::!1# 7#'$+'&#:0#50#&#'"%'1"-#$@5:!%'!'"@!,#&! &"!"#@#'"/+0%'1"-#$+0&#-#!0%'1"/!<"-!"-#.+:/-!7#'

> 43#$"%'""-#50!<#0@!/#%'"-#50#&#'"5#"%"%'"4#!$$#5"#/%'"-# :%1-""-#$@50@%&#"-!"-!&4##'"-0!&-#/+".%"-"-#%'"#07#'"%' "-#0#&5#$"!4:#& +'&#:+0"-#0&+4@%"&"-!"&+$-$@50@%&#.+:/ $#0"!%':<50@"#5#!$#!'/-!0@'<!@'1&""-#0#&%/#'"&"-#7%::!1#

::.%'1"-#/%$"+@:!%//.'4<'C4:#*+50#@#+0"%'
$% $!&#&+50! !'/%'"-#%7%&%'#'$-3+/1#@#'""-%& +0"%'  

$% $!&#&+50! 6"-#50#&#'"5#"%"%'%& !::.#/   -#  %@5+1'#/   >  /!"#/  ;>

  0#1%&"#0#/  +'/#0 &#$"%'&6)6 );6 )?
 $-!::!'50#&#'"#/6$-!01#&0!@#/!'/ $'7%$"#/+'/#0&#$"%'&6)6>6 6 );6 )?
  !"5:%$# *"!"%'6-!6%&"0%$"!'&!6 %&=+!&-#/%'"-#:%1-""-#$@50@%&# -!7%'14##'!00%7#/!"4#".##'"-#5!0"%#& &!'#$#&&!0<$0::!0<"-# 3+/1#@#'"$'7%$"%'/!"#/;)

)!&!:&"-#0/#0&#'"#'$# 5!&&#/4<:#!0'#/*6+/-:!/!!1!%'&""-#5#"%"%'#0&6%&&#"!&%/#

#&+:"!'":<6"-#!55#!:50##00#/4<"-#5#"%"%'#0&!1!%'&""-#!0#'"%$#/ 3+/1#@#'"$'7%$"%'/!"#/;)

).+:/4#0#'/#0#/%'0+$"++& !'/&-!::4#&/#$:!0#/4<"-# &"55#::!"#+0"!"!'&!

#"%"%'%&!::.#/%'"-#!0#&!%/"#0@&           :+$,< D-#"-#0&5#!,%'1A0#!&'#/( #& D-#"-#0 #50"!4:#(