Mohinder Singh v. Dhiraj Kumar


  
 





!" #"$%&%'(

 *+%'#",-%'.+  "!%!%'", /",&0&

+%, 1203 ,  "&4'#"'!

*( 56*-
*6- ,"&"'!( *, 0, /-+ ,3 7#/$ !"7

,!+"4"!%!%'",  *6-78, 9:

;!+%&4"!%!%'7!+"4"!%!%'",$+ 99"'."&!+"10#.3"'! '# #"$,""4 &&"#<;!+"9" ,'"###%!%' 9
%/%90#." 8-"'%, %/%&%':7  ,' 9 7# !"#

74 &&"#%'
%/%9-0%!'

# !"#

7 %'&!%!0!"#<;!+","&4'#"'!+","%'7!+"& %#&0%!<"%'.'"&""=%'.,"9%"

0'#",-"$!%' !+"-4"$% %$"9%"

$!7  +","&4'#"'!49 %'!%

&5$'!"'!%'> &!+ !%! 9," #;+ /%'.

<""'&"!!9"#%' 4,"/%0&
8
%/%9-0%!'

?7#"$%#"#'



<;!+"9" ,'"#!,% 9
0,!:7!+ !+"> &%'4&&"&&%' !+"&0%!

4,4",!;7>%!+!+ !#"$,""+ /%'."/"'!0 99;<""'04+"9#04!!+%&
0,!%' -' 

8 %9"#<;!+"4,"&"'!4"!%!%'",:'

?7!+"

4"!%!%'",+","%'> &%'!", ",%'.%'4&&"&&%' !+"& 3"49! '#+ #%'

$!#%&9#."#!+","&4'#"'!49 %'!%

!+","

,3' 

 "'$"7+"&0.+!!+ !+"3 ;<"40!< $=%'4&&"&&%' !+"

49!%'@0"&!%'

  +"4"!%!%'",#"

"'# '!&5&! '#7 &4",!+"%340.'"#10#.3"'!

 !+"9" ,'"#!,% 9
0,!7%&&""'!<"!+ !!+","&4'#"'!49 %'!%

+ #%'

$!"/"' %9"# ' 449%$ !%'<"

,"!+"--7 ,' 9 7'  

7%'

>+%$+!+" -. /" ,"4,!!+ !A!+","%&3 %'. !"%'&! 99"#'!+"&%!"

&!,""! '#!+"=";& !+"9$=%& / %9 <9">%!+!+"#"

"'# '!B7>%!+!+"

49 %'!%

+ /%'.$'$" 9"#!+&" $!& !  > &  0,!+",  &! !"#  <;  !+"  4"!%!%'",#"

"'# '!  !+ !  !+"

4,4",!;%'#%&40!"> &&%!0 !"#%'5 '? CC?7>%!+!+","<"%'.' $'!"'!%''<"+ 9 !+","&4'#"'!49 %'!%

!+ !!+"49!> &&%!0 !"%'

5' '@0",;!9" ,'"#$0'&"9 ,!+"4"!%!%'",7+"+ &%' $!

"/"'4,#0$"#!+">,%!!"'&! !"3"'! %9"#<;!+"4"!%!%'",!!+"49 %'!

8>+%$+%&&""'!<"%'



:7 '#+"+ &'!,"

0!"#>+ !+ &<""'

,"$,#"#  %33"#% !"9;  +","%' </"  "  &4"$% %$ 99;  &! !"&  !+ !  !+"

4"!%!%'",&5$'!"'!%'%&!+ !!+"49!!+ !+"%&%'$$04 !%' 7%&&%!0 !"%'

5' 4",0& 9 !+">,%!!"'&! !"3"'! &+ &<""'4,#0$"#%'
0,!7 &+>&  !+ !  !+"4"!%!%'",#"

"'# '!  + #  9& ! ="'   &! '# !+ !

!+0.+!+","> & '"'!,;%'!+","/"'0","$,#>%!+,". ,#!!+"49!%' @0"&!%'7!+"'03<",&3"'!%'"#%'&0$+,"$,#+ #<""'$'$" 9"#<;!+" ,"&4'#"'!49 %'!%

 ) 4' ,"49%$ !%'+ /%'.<""' %9"#<;!+","&4'#"'!49 %'!%

!!+" ,"& %#>,%!!"'&! !"3"'!7!+" 99>%'.%&&0"&>"," , 3"#<;!+"

9" ,'"#!,% 9
0,!( D+"!+",  !+"  49 %'!%

 %&  "'!%!9"#  !  !+"  ,"9%"

 

4&&"&&%' 49!%'@0"&!%' &4, ;"# ,E

  D+"!+",!+"&0%! !+"49 %'!%

%&'!3 %'! %' <9"%'

!+"4,"&"'! ,3E

D+"!+",!+"&0%! !+"49 %'!%

+ &'$ 0&"  $!%', 9$0&&! '#%! %9"!+"4,"&"'!&0%!E

D+"!+",!+"&0%!%&< # ,''1%'#", '#3%&1%'#",  '"$"&& ,;4 ,!%"&E

) "9%"

B  ,!%"&  9"#  "/%#"'$"  <"

,"  !+ ! 
0,!7  %'  !+"  ,3  

#$03"'!&7 & 9&>%!+!+","&4'#"'!49 %'!%

+ /%'.!"&!% ;%'. &D '"0,1%!-%'.+>+> &"F 3%'"#<;+%3 &D7> & 0'#!+ /"

<,0.+!!+","$,# '  449%$ !%'# !"# 

7 & 9&!+" 449%$ !%'# !"#

 

7 ##,"&&"#!!+"--7 ,' 9 7<;+%37 9'.>%!+!+","4,! # !"# 

7>"," 9&"F+%<%!"# +"4"!%!%'",+","%'8#"

"'# '!:7 9&"F 3%'"#+%3&"9  '# ,"%!", !"#!+"$'!"'!& +%&>,%!!"'&! !"3"'!  4' 44, %&%'.!+" ,"& %#"/%#"'$"7!+"9" ,'"#!,% 9
0,!

,"$,#"#  %'#%'.!+ !"/"'!+"4,"&"'!4"!%!%'",#"

"'# '!$09#'!#"';

!+ !!+","> &4,"/%0& 
 <"!>""'!+"4 ,!%"&7%'!+" ,3 
%/%9-0%!

# !"#

?7>+%$++ # 9," #;<""'#"$%#"# '#!+" 44" 9 . %'&!&0$+#"$%&%' 9&#%&3%&&"# !> & 9&'!%$"#!+ !+"+ #7 $0,&"7#"'%"#!+ !+"+ # ! ="' ,$%<9"4&&"&&%' !+"49!' 

7!+0.++" #3%!!"#!+ ! '

449%$ !%'+ #<""' %9"#<"

,"!+"-
%!;7 ,' 9 7<;!+"49 %'!%

&""=%'.! %99%'" ,!+%'!+"49! !> & 0,!+",'!%$"#!+ !%!> & 9& #3%!!"#!+ !!+"&0%!

? 4,4",!;> &9$ !"#>%!+%'!+"A
  '!+" ,"& %#"/%#"'$"7%!> &+"9#<;!+ !
0,!!+ !%!> & 4,/"#!+ !!+","&4'#"'!49 %'!%

> &%'4&&"&&%' !+"49! '#!+ !

!+"#"

"'# '!84,"&"'!4"!%!%'",:+ #! ="'4&&"&&%' !+"& 3" ,$%<9;7 '#!+","

,"!+"49 %'!%

> &"'!%!9"#!<"40!< $=%'4&&"&&%'
'&"@0"'!9;7!+"&0%! !+","&4'#"'!49 %'!%

> &#"$,""#

"

,"!+%&
0,!79" ,'"#$0'&"9 ,!+"4"!%!%'",#"

"'# '!

&0<3%!&!+ !!+"4"!%!%'",&5&4"$% %$$'!"'!%'%&!+ !!+"49!!+ !+"%&%'

$$04 !%'  %& &%!0 !"%' 5 ' ?7 '#'! %'   

?C) !)7<" ,%'.5'?

CC )C C 7!!+""F!"'!

C?) &+ ,"&%!0 !"#%'!+" ,"   ,' 9 8 &> &#"&$,%<"# &!+"&0%!

4,4",!; <; !+"  ,"&4'#"'!49 %'!%

 %'  !+"  4,"/%0& 
7  %"
%/%9  -0%!

?: "!+","

,"&0<3%!&!+ !!+"9" ,'"#!,% 9
0,!+ &$3"! ' <&90!"9;4",/",&" %'#%'. $!@0 !+"#"&$,%4!%' !+"&0%!4,4",!;

%!&"9   "'"F!&0<3%!&!+ !'" /%'#",+ #&9#+%&&+ ," 99%'.%'

5 '?



 ' 7 CC? 7 )C

C) !&"/", 9 4",&'&7%'$90#%'.!'" ,/""' 9> ,7!!+""F!"'!   C !+&+ ,"7 !+"!! 9+9#%'.<"%'.

5
 '# 5
7>%!+!+"& %#4",&'

+ /%'.&9#&3"&+ ,"%'!+"&0%!9 '#!!+","&4'#"'!49 %'!%

" 0,!+",&0<3%!&!+ ! &,". ,#&!+"4"!%!%'",7+"40,$+ &"# !+"&0%!9 '# ,3'"-+ '6 97!!+""F!"'!

5
 0! +9#%'. 
 '#


 -!%99 0,!+",7+"&0<3%!&!+ !"/"'!+0.+!+"4"!%!%'", 9& 40,$+ &"#'9;&+ ,"&!!+""F!"'!

5
7!+"'03<",&%'

) >+%$+!+"4"!%!%'",40,$+ &"#!+"&+ ,"& ,"$349"!"9;#%

","'!!!+&"

%'>+%$+!+","&4'#"'!40,$+ &"#!+"&0%!9 '#

 /%'.$'&%#","#!+"3 !!",7%!%&&""'!+ !!+","&4'#"'! 49 %'!%

+ #< &"#+%&$9 %3%'!+"4,"&"'!&0%! %9"#0'#",-"$!%' !+"

-4"$% %$"9%"

$!7 7'!+"< &%& !+"#"$,""4 &&"#%'+%& /0,%'

%/%9-0%!

)

?7>%!+!+ !10#.3"'! '##"$,""+ /%'.

<"$3" %' 904!!+%&
0,!<;> ; - 

 +"$ &" %9" - 

+ /%'.<""'$ 99"# ,<;

!+%&
0,!7%!%&&""'!+ !!+"&0%!9 '#> &#"&$,%<"#!+","%'8 &4",!+" 10#.3"'! !+"!,% 9
0,!%'!+ !
:7!<"3" &0,%'.

5
 '#

5
 $'! %'"#%'  '?

CC )C C !!+""F!"'! C?) !+&+ ,"8! ="' ,34 , ., 4+  !+"10#.3"'! !+"!,% 9
0,!

%'!+ !
 # !"#

: +"  4"!%!%'",&5  $'!"'!%'  +","%'  <"%'.  !+ !  +%&  9 '#  %& $'! %'"#%'5' ?'9;7%'!+"4%'%' !+%&
0,!7!+%&4"!%!%'

$ '<"#%&4&"# %'
  %!&"9 7>%!+ #%,"$!%'!+ !%' ';"F"$0!%'

4,$""#%'.&%'%!% !"#<;!+","&4'#"'!49 %'!%

8#"$,""+9#",:7+%&$9 %3 >09#' !0, 99;<"9%3%!"#! ';9 '# 99%'.>%!+%'5  

?C) !) <" ,%'. '?

CC )C

C !!+""F!"'!

C?) !+&+ ,"7&%!0 !"#%'!+" ,"   ,' 9 6 '#$'! %'"#%'5 ?>09#'!<"!+"&0<1"$!3 !!", "F"$0!%'4,$""#%'.&7<"$ 0&"%!

%&&""'"/"' ,3!+"%340.'"#10#.3"'!7 & 9& $4; !+"49 %'! &+ & <""' 4,#0$"#  %' 
0,!  <;9" ,'"# $0'&"9  ,!+" 4"!%!%'",7 !+ !  ' 5 '03<", + &  <""'  3"'!%'"#  %'  !+"  49 %'!  <; !+"  ,"&4'#"'! 49 %'!%

8%'!+"4,"&"'!
:7>%!++%3'9;+ /%'.,"9%"#04'!+"10#.3"'! '#  #"$,""  %&&0"# %' 
%/%9  -0%!  

  # !"#  )

?  8,"

","'$"

 4 , ., 4+ +%&49 %'!:
'&"@0"'!9;7  !+%&  4"!%!%'  %&  #%&4&"#    %'  !+"  ,"& %# !",3&7<0!&%'$"%!+ &<""'#%&4&"# %'
 >%!+0!%&&0%'.'!%$"! !+","&4'#"'!49 %'!%

7+">09#<" !9%<",!;!4%'!0! '; $!0 9",,, %'!+%&,#", !+%&
0,!7<; %9%'. ' 44,4,% !" 449%$ !%'




   4=C'%!%'

 D+"!+",&4" =%'.C," &'"#

"& D+"!+","4,! <9"

"&