High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRWP/3882/2023allowed

Mohd. Garib v. State Of Ut Chandigarh And Others

2023-07-315 pages

!"#"$%&'(' )*+'

,"- .

, ,#0# State of UT, Chandigarh and others .' #1$+

2% $3-4 ),'0# "!

'5' 4"

$3-4 ),'0# "!

6 4"

, % ),' #*"

,5"$7* #8 49+/!

,' ),'502"

"$999 ,*8"

* ),'0#*:

9+/!

' ;;; '5' 4"

9'< 4= & , :

, "$

"$ "# , >0 #*"$7 "2107$ <$$ =+

+'@'<8,$74:2 #$$ @"$

*

+$

"$=,

, ,

8"

* 1, :

, ,7, 1

,0$+ "$ 0$A - $+0!

,"#$ ,#< 21, ,:

=!

&BC<*

#D 3= 2

*"# 2"4:2 2- ,#'

+ ++4' 9 9 ,* * # "4 + 8,"

$ , 14: 44 #!0# +:!

" "!

'*

$$, !,+ $+!1"

+/

4 ,

,' 1 ,0# 4 !0# +: !

" "!

,

4#

#0$+ ,7$ 4!0# +: :

,#2$ *# $++ :#' @

,8

0$+ ,7"21,"#$2 , "$+ , *"#

46"

8"

* "$

#'F $+ "$ +

1 :2 "$ 0, , 0$+ ,7 #"214 "21,"#$2 C 2$ *# ,+ + -: 4

+ ++4' ##"$#0+7 ,*/"+ A0+72 +

+&''&0$+ ,5 "$# (C $+C

+/"+ '@&&+

+&'&&'&(

4"!

"$5 ,C9 ,*'

4 0, ,!$

,

,* #0-2"

"$ ,1 ,+ :#8*"!*8 #, "/ +"$ "!

!21

:$&&'C'-0 8 #,

/"+ ,+ ,<$$ @=+

+&'('+0 "# )

:+*:

9$ !22 $+"$77, 1 $ #"# , $",501 ,"$

4"!

9:+:

9$ 7,0$+

8 + 8G,+ ," !$/"!

8 #,

* !04+

"$ "$+047 "$ !,"2"$ "/"

: - # !$+0!

!$/"!

8 # $

"# ,:+0,"$71 "4 +-:*"2

,' C

$#1

4 ,"#$#9 9 ,* -:

E"$7 "$ !!0$

,$2 , $: "!

*,"H + -: "

$ *"# - 4 " #

"# "

,

!$/"!

8 #4"E 4: :

,$2 ,

10-4"!,+ $+E

1"$7"$2"$+ "# )

9:+*:

9 4# 1,/"#"$# 5 "$#G@ 9 ,

"$

, , ,

8* 01$9

,"$/E A0,"#+"!

*"# -:8 :

'(& 98*"!*8 #+ !"+ +$&'&&' $+"2107$ ,+ ,<$$ @=8

,,+

$1 ,+ :#' (

114"

,+ :#1 $&''-0 "$ "# )

9:+*:

# /"+

,'BC+

+@''$ !22 $+"$77, !$/"!

$ #"# , $",501 ,"$

4"!

9:+*:

9$ 7,0$+

8 #+ 8G,+ ,"

!$/"!

8 #,

!$/"!

!04+ "$"$+047 "$ !,"2"$ "/"

:" ,

8* 01$ $#1

4 ,"#$#9 9 ,* "$ 4"7* 5 "$# G @ !

1"$7"$2"$+ "# )

9:+*:

99,

!4 "2

, ,,

'

+ !0$# 4 !$

, * -

$,

/"+ ,+ ,+

+''"$ '&( -: #

,+ , +

+ @'&' -4 *"2 2

*"#

2"4: 2 2- ,# -: -# ,/"$7

"2107$ , +

+ @'&' * -

$ 1 ## + -: $#1

4 ,"#$#9 9 ,* *07* - +01$ !22

"$# "# )

9:+*:

99 -0 !$!40#"$ -# ,/

"$# "$8 +$$ /"+ ' B

,2 8"$#

#9

-/ 8*

,* "4 +1 !4 "2

, , ,

$ + :# 1 "$

,2#

"$ +

&&'C'8 4#,

+/"+ $$ @ "$8*"!*8

/"+ ,+ ,+

+&'&&'"$ '(& -:, !,+"$7

8 #$#1 !" "!"$ ,2

"$8"

*, ,+ 2"#!$+0!

-: !$/"!

# 8 ?1, ## 11, $#"$ -: "# )

"$ *"# !220$"!

"$' &

"$ 9"

"#

!4 "2

, ,,

-: !"

11, $#"$ -,

!* 1

F+ # :

10-4"! ,+ ,F!$+0!

, +0,"$7 *"# 1, /"0#

$ - "$7 #

"# ,: 8"

*0 - $: 2

,"

8*

#0-#

"+!$!40#"$9 -:+ :"$7

,9 10

"$7 *"2 * ##2 $+ , #04 "$7 "$ *"# "$!0,,"$7

?1 $+"

#8

"2

"$ !",!02#

#9

,"# 4"

1, :

+ ,- ,+ ?

,:!# #' &&

+ ++4' 9 9 ,* * # $ -

-4 !$ ,/ 14

4-0 ##0,

"$ 0 9$ $4:

, ,,

-0 4#

"$#

44!$/"!

# ,,

804+- !$#"+ $++ !"+ +"$ "2 -0$+2 $$ ,# 4:"$ !!,+ 8"

* 1,/"#"$# 8 -4 $+"$!

$:!4 "2"#

+9 804+- -: 7"/"$7#1 !" "!,

#$' & !!

##0, 4

+ ++4' 9 9

,* $+1,!

+$ 0, ,"$ 2

,' & !!,+"$74:9"$ 4"7* 1#"

"$$

-/ 98

/"

8

9 ,** #$

-4 #*8 ,2 2

,"

$ , !,+ $: "$#

$ - #"# 8*"!* "

!

$ - "$

, 804+ # :

F2

10-4"!,+ ,,

*"#!$+0!

+0,"$7*"#1, /"0#,

$ 1 8 # $ #

"# ,: 4# "$ /"

8

, $

*,

!!

#"$#* /"$7-

$,

$+#0,, +$ "2 $ "$#

# #0!* * /"$7 -

$ 1"$

+ 0 *"# !$+0!

+0,"$7 # "+ ,"+ 1 $ "$7#

"# ,:' &@ !!,+"$74:9 8,"

"$ "# 448 +' 2107$ +

+'@'9<$$ ="##

'*

,"#+",

-

,@8

E# #1 1,/"#"$# 5 "$<&=<+= 9#0-A *"# 0,$"#*"$7-$+#F#0,

:

"#

"# )

0 :9 :+*:

9 ' 22 +"

4: $

, #* 44 1,!

/"44 "

*4 9 8* * 804+ #

: +0,"$7 ,"+ 1 $+ $ ,

!*"$7 # "+ 14

, 8"44 "$ ,2 !$!

+ 4"!

"$ * /"$7 A0,"#+"!

"$ /

*"# ++, ## "'

' 4"!

"$ I02

$A9 "# :+*:

<= *"# 2-"4 1*$ $02- , - # #* *"# 4"/ 4!

"$ $+8* #E + ,'*

804+

4"- : !

44

, $ *"# 2-"4 1*$ $02- !$ ",2 *"# 4!

"$' *

,#* 44 4#, 4!

44"!

"$ ,:8

E $+#* 44 #0,, ,- A "4 :$ ?1",: ,"+'

&'('