Harpal Singh & ORS v. State Of Haryana



       
  

"#$ %& '$()*)%+

,,


- .

  .






















,,,  .

/0.

.    

,,,..



1- , .   .

 








  


!

"

#



$ % 2222
 .

  , -!

3

&

'

(
'

)'*
&
'
)
*+'+

#
")
'

,(


$ %


(-)
)
 ,


)


'
)

''  )
))





 *



*

)


'

  .

.

&




+
(
'*


+
#
/0%




)'
+
*
1+*


,2
$ //0

30 ..

%3.%
*

'
#
,(
+
#
/%3
/34
/35
.%3-

''

+(1+
*
*
) - 

% &


(



**
))


'
)
*+'+
-
#
" 
,(
6



7#89


'+

.:

3.

%33;

+

(+'*


(+
''





)



.3;/333<-
+

+(-))





)

))(
&

+


3/ ..

%330
 

.

:



'
(

+
*
-
#
 +


'*
'
'

 04/333<-

(
(

))

%:

%335
*





+
)' +


'
)+

''
+

(
+
+




+

(

'


'
)+


 343%333<-

+*
)


*
-
#
,(
1+
'+

%0 .3 %3.3
&+





2
-
#
,(

1+



'
)
1+
'
' +*

1+




'<**
)

+*
'+*
=
6 > 9


)
*
(
''

)
*
)
%333333<-

%/4%333<- 


*



'


.4 ..

%3.3
6?+
-.9


( 



+
+
(




)
)
(

+
)

 3@0400%<-
&
 
))(


#
'

)'
(

**



,(
'
-

" 
,(
*


''**
)

+


'


)


(


*


?)



+

1+

 .%5;%:;<-

1+


+


)'





30 3@ %3..


*




+

'

 .3-.@
"


#
6?+
-%9 &
)
)'
'
'

)'
)'
(

*
- 
#

+


1+


+









%3 3;

%3.%
6?+
-@9







+

(

#''
**


)'
'

)'
(

#+

'
,(

(

(-)


30 3@ %3..
+


)+*
,2
)

(
*
*


,+




+
(

*
-
#



'

./ %3.@
6?+
-:9




#
,(


+*
*
*

  .

@ &
'
+'











(
*

'


'
..

1+

+



)+''
1+
(


+

'
(
+
,+



)+*
,2

(
*

+
*

'
1+

?+
-.

?+
- @

''
+


'
+


''

+

'+


*


+
)'
2

+




1+

6?+
-%9


(



)+*
,2 
*
'


'

#
50



-
#

.50/

+'


# /



 '
+'


 %
''


+()
)
(
)


'

.; %3%@








+
)'

+*

+


' :

"

+'



)
(







+
)'


*



*


(-
)+*
,2

-.

.

./ 


**
)
+*+'



+()
+

(
''



+'
+'


)'



+

'




)
(


A''

+'




%3 3;

%3.%
6?+
-@9

(

#?

+
*
6A1+
B9
-
#

&
'



)


+


'' 
-

      

    
  






            
  
  
 !
 
" #  
!

 !
$%%&!

 !


$%'% 







!   " 

 ( 
 
    !
  


)
*

  
 )
+   
  
 

 ', $%- .

!
 

 !

 
  !   
"

   
## 
 


 # 

 
  
 #   / 
## 


 #


!

'0&%  1
 $%,%  .

21$%,% (#$%-
   



    $%%%   2    #    #

 
!!
/ 

 1
3 



( # 

 



  
  !
    45055$%%* +

6', $%-

 .

7

;

2

'


+


*
)

'
'

('


 .

@3 3.

./

 
#*
+
#+

'
6 C9
,(



'' 
-



 ##
" #

 
   

     ##     
 
    $%%&$%'$ .

!"      

 #    !
    450 55$89 

6', $%-

 .




 
  #
 
 #  
 !
   "D





+
#
/%3










(

 
E+*
(


8('
#+)
+

/$*"

%5')+6* , -#', 7, .#"#$ %& 8$9"5"

!

.

#*
+*
E+

$*


(

'' 

:(

" ##   
"
 !   

 ##   
"
    "
   


 
#

        ;  

 


  
!





    

 ##  
  (  
 
  !"
 
! 

 # #  

     !





 #  ##   <$%( 3( "
!


  
  



 ## 3




   

!

#  #
 !
  #  

# 

 

 !



 !  
" " /
(  


"
! ##  !
  

"




!

  

#

 .
 3 




 
#
 
 !  <5$ 3

 

3  ;


7

 
E+*
(


8('
#+)
+

:5";

:*#"&"

7, .#"#$ %& 8"9+"#"<"

"+'

+%#=$9


!

 9);)+"5!



*
+*
E+
+
)+''
'

'' 

$&
3  
 = 
 "  #
 *$%%$+ ' 33$< > ? ! !


  !   <5$3 3 ':&4.
3  



/  # !
  !


# 
   
  "

 )
 #
  !
 "
 .
3  
"##    3 3  " #

#



!
       # /
 
 
   

 
 #  !  <5$3 3  ':&4  


!



 #

 #

# 
( 


  "/



# 





 ## "


" 

  
 #
  !
    
 

 /

# 

      !    

6 #   
;  
" =     .
 3   <5$3 3 ':&4 ;"
 #

 .
3  # 
   #  
 !!

   "  "     /  #  !
  

#?*

+ $5(  #@ "1 " *$%%$+4 33 5:


!
> ?0 )
 #  !   <5$ #  3 
 

 # 
 
   
          

#! ! .
3 

( "
 !!
3   #     #  3  ( "
 

  !

/


    *
+  
" ##       *

+ " #

 *


+ !
  #/
(

 
 
  !
#
!
!

  "
 #
/

A 

"  
!


  "
#      
 
 3   #   "
  !  #    "

 # ! !
    #    
  # #   

  !



!
#
 

    !
  


6  "
  ! #  .
 3  2

 !
"
 

   
    #   "








   !          
       ! 


 #


#/
 

 ; 
;






"


 ; 
  *!!
" 

 
" 
  !
  !

   
+ =


 ! 

   #   

 #   "

 ( /

       !
    
 
 #  !
 
   ! 

/
#

#

 !
   
# (
    
  
 /

       
 /
 #   


#!
 


2 
 #


# "  #/

#
   
    
/
 

 ! "(!

 

#

  ! !
!



/
"  #/
(
  !

!

/
#
 ;




#
#




8


  #
  

#  

  ;
 #  


 !

 !
" #/
= ## 
 
    


  

  
  ;
## =



  ;



 


 
 !


! ## 


"
#



 ?*
 
+
$:(B  C 
"  #
 *$%%,+'%

33 440    &  # 
 !   ! 


 #
   
    

 ##    




 ;  <5$ # > ?(  "
!



     
   



 ##   ## 


 <$%  '$%( 3 


 # 
"

 ! 
 #  !
  
 #  
"


  #

   


 
(  


 "
! #  #   !
 

"




!

   #

 "
!/
# .
3  ;   

   !   <5$3  !

  #?*

+
4%  !   /  !   

 
2
"  #C/ *$%'&+: 330<' ( .
 2 D
 *$%'&+ $ 33 &&:


 !


> ?
 !
 #; #E( 
 
  !
 
  !   ! 

/
#

#

 !
 "


#
 
 ##   ! <5$3 3 ':&4
"!
 
 

 

#

!
 !;
3    
(     

 3 ?*
 
+ 4'(F
 A"  #@ *$%':+$ 33<%'


3 

 


> ?''  )" !
   " 
 "  !   
#
! 


  


"



 

"
  

 
  


  

 





!

 # 

# ! #    .
 3   

   !   <5$3 3  ':&4  
; 




("
! # # 
#       "    #
" 





 

? -.



.3 2
'+
)
*'*



*


'


)

(
+*

+



)
*+'

)*



+



+

('




''*


))

)'
+'('



)




)''
)*





..

2



(
+




'' 


)+*
,2
$ //0

30 ..

%3.%
*

'
#
,(
+
#
/%3
/34
/35
.%3- 

1+
*
)''+
'69


''
'



*'

 .

 !
"+:"9>

?






















(i) =
*<
F<$

69

=
('
F<$