High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8784/2024dismissed

Dr. Aditya Chaudhry v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2024-05-15Mr. Justice Arun Palli,Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal26 pages

!"#

# "

$ % # % ( $ % #)%

$ % ##(%

(

# $ %"

)% !"

* +,*

,, +,*

-./ * $, $ %&

'( ' %

'( )*

%% %& % "' "( + "' , %#

'( !-. % & / , "'( )*. 0000 ./ * $,3 - " , / ( "' / (/ , (

1 (' ,' /

" 3

4, "/"

, '

, 567 575 2

, , , '

, 787 575

, ' ""( ( "' / (

,* 4 5 ,( 9 -578575 ):

.;* , ( ("

)* "" " "

/ 2( < ,

(

" )* )* 4 , "/"

((( , 7 78575 8 / ( ( "" (

( =.

(( (/ " "' (

( "' " (

( "

/ , (

/ 1 ( .

" (

, (( "

/ 1 " -7> "

%(% ( (

(,'" , '

/ )* , / & (( 1 )* ( / , !"

((1 ,, 75--5758

, " & (( (, "

, , " " )*!,/ ,

' ("

/2('" " , ', # " (( (' ,& # "

+ %( " ""

"'# " ?

("( 577@5755):

.-*, / ( " (=.

( "'(

( "' " (

( " "( ' / , 9 9 " > ( , ( A , ( 1 " ' (( " /'

/(, "( @ '/ ( =.

( "" - % "

' / "( , ,/ " 1 " ", ( ,

/" =.

(, " ):

.5* ; ( =.

(

/" !--86.'(88'# "

/₹8'8-';?'?77A. '

₹;' '5?7A., -57 57581 , ("

(( "/'.

" - 7 5758):

.8*

%% 6

(( "/'

-7> " " ( (

" / ₹;' '5?7A.'

₹5 '

' ;7A. - 7 5758 ):

₹88'76';

7A.' / -7> /

-7 & (

/ , "

, "/

/ ,

(( (

2(/, / &, 87 =.

( (( ( , "

!8- "( ):

.5* ,' , /

/ ( ' "( 7--75758 ):

. * , / / -- " ' ' ( (& / & (( '

/ /

/ (' " !"

, ( , 75--5758 ):

.?* 1 '

(( ( , ( (' / .

7?-55758 " , / ):

.@*,' -578575 ' (

/2():

.;* -5

( " ( "

( "( " ,2

( -8 B ( " )* "" ( " ', , ((

/, "

%#% *-

5-6 - 4, " / " ( " )*

( (( / )*

/ ( "" / ""

"B ( " "

.;* /

/" " ( ,

("( 577@5755 ("

4, /

((' / / ,

( "(:/

' ' ((

(' , (( 2( ( - B ( " /

-@ "(

/ ' " ""

" ( / (

/("

-7> " "( ' /( "/2( -? 4, / / " ( "

" ( ""

" ' /

4, /

(

/, " ( "( "

/ ' ( "

( )*, ( , ' '

(

2 ( )* -@ B ( "' ' /

/ (/

""" )*

%)% *-

- - -; ( ' , / / " ( "

/ (( (, "

, ' '( ""( -6 B ( " /

( "( ' (

(( 2( / , ' ' )*, "

(

/("

/' , " /" "" " 57 B ( " " /

,,"""

" /(

/' , " /

"" " (

, "

( 2

/ C/" 4 3 # $ %&'(

) * ) %&' % +(

!, - .. ,%&-! / " 2

/ 3

01(

0 0 , -

,!- +. 32% 3 0 0 , -

, -..,%&-!

! ,-- - 5- D

" (

/ " ( "

" /& 55 =.

("( 577@5755"

, " (4"'(' (( "/'

/ (

' $.

%'% 4. % )5 %'

' $) &&$6$ 5$ 3) 7&& ( . % ) ))&8 9))&$ &&$$ 7 $$ ))'$)(' : 3 8 9 5 3 $ && $ 7 3% 3 $ $ $ $ ))' $ )(' !

(' 9(' ( )(' ))' ;) $< )& 3 ( < ('7 ($ 0 = ' "

-@"

(

((2( /, , "" =.

( ( ("A =.

-@"

, $. !5)(' % 3))'

;) $ 7 7 &&'

' () ) )&>'' ) <73 3 58 !,( "

, /2('/ ,,"""

/( (("

( ('

, " ((

/ 4 , " , ( ( # $ %&'(

)* )

%&' %+() *, 2( /%A ( 4 ( " B < ("

/ "4

( ' "

/, ( ' "

/ (( <

" " "" , ' ,'

" ' -7>

/ "

/ ((1 (, (

"" / ,

%&% , ( , ( / " ,' "

"",/ (E , 1

"", ( " 2

( " , (

( : :

" " ( <""

((

/1 4 , "" ( ( 3

' )-6;5* 5

8? ' 3 ' )-66?*

57;' 3 !"# $ $% $ &)5776*?

-@-'3' ( # ) * " !"# ) # ')-667*8

5;7 3+", $ $ " !"# $ $ &)577;*-7

?6?' "

$. 5 )# ?

% ; 8 3 ?

,!: - "/ & 7 $&3 ))' 3 $ 5 1%

( &% ) 3'&) ((( )) 3( (*7$ %9 4 * '' 3 )& & ( ) & 5 ) ( ' )&)& 1%

( 7 $&3 ))' 3 $ 3 )) $ ( & $) $ '' $ 3 # !

7 6'

& '

% ))' ) $ ( ) 7 & '

% & 7$;) ) $)(' < (&< 1%

( 5 < 1%

( 3< 3 ) <7 ( < ))' 3 $ $ % '

% % 3$ 5 3 7 )& &

& 3 1%

( )&

))' 3 $ 6)' 3 @)$ !

) '7 1%

( ))'$5

7'7 % 1%

( ))' 3 $ & $ ) @) $ & 5 ( $ % 3 )

<' ( @)$<7)(('& 1%

( ))'3$* )<3% )&& <% ($((0 ')*(&1%

( & $ $ )&'$& )$( $ 3 1%

( ( ) 3

'&) ((( 7 7 ) 3 '&) $ 1%

( < $@ ) $$ ) ( <( $) ;) & ))' 3 $ * )

$ ' 1%

( 3 ) 3'&) (((<)) 3( ( '$&) * 1%

( '7 ))' ))' 3 $ 1%

( & '7 ) 3 '&) ( ( (< ( &&7 ) 3 % '&) $@ '

% & ))' ) $ $ $ & ))' ) 3 1%

( &))' 3$ ) A=

* +6(0 ?

% 7 ?

,!::"-

< & 7 $ ) )('& ) )7 '$&)) )&( &3)& $ ) ( $< 3)) 3 $ 5 &7 9

% 4 ' ( 3 % &0 ) ) 7)$ $ 7) '$&)) 7& B )& & ) '& 7 % < 3$ (!>!

( 3 $ $& ) '

(( ( 7 $

( )7 4 ( & ( 3 ) ( ) $

( ' ) )

= (&< ) ) ( & 7 ' B/<" &% 9 4/5))' )3$&&' 8 5 "55 && %& 3 ;) 3 $ 5 ' (0 3 3 $ && %

30$)0$5) ( 8 5 3 3 ))' ) ;) $&&$$ 3 ' 8 0 3 ) $% ( 3( %& ) )

< %&0$)0$< ( ('7 ( $&& $ $5 = ($ ) ) < '' 6'&)% '$&)) $ )('& ' 7 3 $ <

3)) (&&) ( & $ (5) ) )& &) )% ) ('& ))' ) 3 $ $ 8 5 7( 5 %

3& ;)3 $5 6( 33$ '$&)) )5 &) 2 %

,!:!- !/ <

% D7&,!: - "< # * %8( &.(,!:":- ! "

%""% #%;8 3,!: - "/ *$ '&' 7)) $&$7 ( 3 )& !

$ ))' 3 $5))' )3$$;) ) & 3'$&)) 3 3 $ $ 6( ) 6 7 ) 7))) $ & * '

) 3 )) ' $ '

% .& , - ) &7)$ $ '$&)) 7&=

:* 2 %&'( % ) 2 3( ?

:-"!!< & 7 $ 3 ( $6)' ( ( )

3 5 3 ;)3$5 &7 9 5 $ ' )' 3 '

) % 3 6)' 3 @& ( ( %& )('% $ $ ' ' ) % 3 ' (

( 3

)

)&& 3 ( ) 6)' $%3 < $ 3 ( % &( ) )B$ &( 3 % 3 3 & ( ) )'

% )

3 66666

: 5 3 ))' 3$ % '

3 $ < 63 ) <)<

%"% 3 $ '

3 ( 0 '

) $ )

$ $ ) ))' 3 3 $ ( $ ( $ % (=

.& )$ '&) $& ' ) 2> E '

% * & %&'( ' 2 + ?

,!::

- 5 & ' ' 6 ) 9 4!

* ) (< ;)& %7 ( % ) $)(6' % $)( 37 $ 5 &&( %$ % 3 ' ;)& ) $ 3 6' )% $)( 3 ' %% ) )(( )& & 3 '$&) ) 0 3 % 3 7 '< 0 '$&) 6)@ && 3; 3& 3 )&<;)& ) & %7 $ ' 3 '$&) 3FG

) ) 3 6)% ) )& 3) ;) 3 5% %&% & 3 0 %&$& ) ) ) $& ) G )'& '$&) ) ) ('

% )& )) $& +0 3 '' ) ) '

% '' $;)% %7 ''

)$ $ ( % ' $ ;)& '

) 5$( 2 7%< <)(( & ))' )< (&<7 3 ' @ ;) ) ) ''

&$(%&$& & ( & $ )(( ) ) )

' & $ ')) ;)

%"(% B$$ %$( ;) $7) @&'

)) $%5) &'')'& !.& )&$ '&) ) H& .( ; ?

% & %&'( ?

":" 7) &7 3 $ 7 ;) 7 3 3 7 ) 7 3) 7$ & 3$& 7 '$&) * )7 ( ' 7 ) 77 ' <$ ()& '&&$

' 7) $ ) % * ) ( &$$ 3$% %'

)<7 ) ))'(

* 2 3 1&& ?

% 5 E&) (( <B7 &?

,!:-! /< & 7 7 ) (0 < %&($;3$ ( )

$ ''&( $ ' % 75 &9 45) @&& &% ( 7 ) (0 $ ) < %& ( $ ;3 $ ( )

$''&( $ '% 7 7< $ $3

3 (< $ ( )( ) )) )&& 3<3%&$ &3 & $ 3 ( 7 $ % 8<D 1 8 ;*.!:/ !"9 4$&) <'$&)&(< 6 ) )

$ ) &3 6'& $@ &3% $) (0 3 7

%"% ( < 77 ( < 7 $&) ($'$&) ( % '$&) ) ) ) 3 ) ) 7( ( $ ) $;)%&7 )& 33 &

&0&7 $)( 3$ 3 7& = 5 ' ( '

7% < ) %$ ( ;) ' & $ ) & 6'& 5 ;) % $ ) &) 7''&) ( $) )

;) )& $ $&&3&< $ ) $ % )7

') %'

)&< 7)6 ''

3 (7 3*7)) $3)(( )& 7 % 33 :/ )

& %'

) ( 7 7 6 ( < 7 % '

) '

' 7 6 $ ( $ 7 )%< ( ) 330 %&%< 7 ( ( 7% <( 7 ) ( $)0 ( < )& & ) 3 ( 7 &37'7 )$5< )('&& 3 ) )( ) &) 3 ' <( 0 ) ;)$ &'& $ &6 C ( < )$3'

' 7 '(( '

) )5 ) 6 3 %'

)& ) %'

) 7 ( (

)B & '& $ # & '&)&3 '7 ) ) $&7B )& #

%"#% $ 6(

& I; 0 3' $ 6( 77 ' 7 ) 7& )( &

' 7)(( )&7 ) :< 1 3 < 7 3 )(( )& )('&6< ''&&) 7 3 ( 3 & )() ( ; ) < ) &&( & 7 '( ) & * 7 )($ ' '& '%& () '

%& 3 %& & %$ & $( .!!!/) < 3&&$ ''&&) 5'& )'%& () &$ &) $&$ 3 & )') 7 7( ( <'$& / .& &< ''& &&7 5 ;3( ) '$ 3 ''&& ) * ) ) )( ) )<7(')./&0 '& > ' $ ' 9 + / &0 %) & C . / &0 '

( E('& & C 7 ' 7( ( "

/ . ( (

01( 0 0 , - ) *1 )*

/ "/ "(8;'+

₹1,87,99,300/-. Despite being the highest bid, the same was not accepted nor was any specific order passed informing the petitioners as regards the fate of the bid. Here also, the clauses of the E-auction policy were considered and it was held that there would be no vested rights with with petitioner which would obligate the respondents to accept the highest bid of the petitioners. It was held that to the contrary, the highest bidder only had a right of consideration for such bid to be evaluated against the reserve price determined

%")% by the committee1 (

(( (

/ , 2( "

5; "( , ( /"

(( ( 2( .-/, 7@,& , ":

, "

( ,

( " "

(

& "($. 4! & $ $& ' '

% E) '&)7)7&$&3 ' ))'3$5 7&$ ) 3%7 ' 5) 3$ & 3 ) )$$%&3 % '

) ( $(( !/ * )) ( & ) )& ) ))( )$7 ' ' 5 3 3 $ '$&) ) $ 6( '&$'6 & ) %7 0 7) ) $ & $ 7 ( 3 )&!

$ ))'3$ ) 3 ( $ ( )

J$&'

( 5 &) 2 )%

,!:!- !/ 9 *. ,!:!- 9

D7&,!: - "9*.!: !!"G# * %8&( &.(,)-<,!:":- ! "9*. !:!

:/ #%;8 3,!: - "/(%770 $ % 8 ) +6(B < ,

:-!.. ,%&-//" !" 5) $) & 3 ( ))' )3$ $ ) )& ) ) % 3 )( ) $7 '

' &3& E) '&)< 7&&

%"'% ! ) %7 )'& '$&)'

' <@ 7 3' 7 ' 3$ '$&)) $'

% 3'$&) 3%&$&'$&) '6)' '

)<'$&) 3 '

%&# $&)& E) '&)$&3 ))' ) ;) ! $ $ )(' 7 ' 7 0 3 ( ) '& ) @ 7 ( $%7( ) 7&' ' '&) (0 $;) 3 $ )%&)( ('& ( ) 3%

3 ) 7 & 7 $;)% '

% & ' )(' 0 3 & ) & ( ( '& )

$' ($ %0'

' ) )& ) ) &('&'$&) '

' $ ( & E) '

) & 3 77& ) '$&) ! * )'

) $ ) )( >( & &) 3 ))' ) $ $( $ ' )(' < ) )&) ))( $ 3 !: * ) * ) +( B3' 2 & .& ) ' +( ,

!"- !"< !<

J$&'

() & ) ) (0 3'

))(' ))' 3 ;) 3 $ ' ($& & ) (0 3 '

) (& % ( +07 ) ) ( 7& $ 7

& 7 ) ) )

& )&)) 7)

' $& ) 3 $& )) )7&7 )&% )* 7 ) (0 3'

)

%"&% ) &$' % ( && )

)

) ) ) $%$ (7)7& )&& )

! 5$( $) &( 3 3 ' % 3 $ ''

3 ' $ 3 3 $ ('&) 7( * E) '&)!" "

6 - ' 7) ' ' )' ) '

) 7 (>) 7 $

' 7 $&3 )&& ' 3 $

3 )) $ $) & &3 %E) '&)7)' ($ $ ' E% $<) %E) '&) 7& ''&) '

)7)$;)( ) '

) 5 & ) ( (%$ (' <7'')) @ ) & 7 ' 3 '&> 7)7 $;)( () '

) 7) ' ' )'< 7 3 $

3 '&> $ )&& 3 K 5

' 3%)7 ( $( % ) $ ) & 3 ' % 3

3$)&& 3 C ) $%< 7 ( 7 '

(= ( ,, &/ . ( ( 2% 3 0 0 , - ) *', ( , " $ 4 5 '6 &

) * ) J ) ,'

-6( )(' )( ))' ;) $ & 7 7

% &3& 3 3 ;) $ & ) 7 ) ) %& )) '$&) ( $ 3 %&%< )&$( (&5 &% ' 9 4! C &< 7 6( @ 7 $ 3 ) )&) ) $ )))' ) $ )&&( & <)&$ $ ( $& )& & ( ; ) 3$'& 5'& '

)& ;) $7&&3&2 &$ < '& )&

% $)( & ) @ & ( ; ) ) (& & &&( 7& 6 ) 3 ;)& %7 )& % ))' $ 5 $ % $ ))' $ ) )

* 7 ) ) )&& $ $ 3))'5% ( 3 ' '& ) ( 7 @''7'7 ( '7 ))' $< $ ) $( 5<( &$)&

;) $ $ ( 7 &&3&< '& )& % $)( & ) @ &

& ) &&( & 5 < ( 7 &< 7 ( $& &3 %7) 7 ) )&) ) $ )&&( & $ 3'& <7) 7 @ & 3)%& ! * & &7 3 $ % 3%) ) )& % 5 1%

( )& %&& '7 ))' ;) 3 $ '$&)

% ) ' 7

3)@ % 3)) % '& ( &$)$( 73

% % '!

L$( ' .3& ", - .3& !:<&&( & $ ))' )$$( 7

<))&$ ' !/L $( * )&&( & % $ ' ' .3& ", - %7 ))' ) $ 5 7 ) )&) ).3& ".3& !: 6 ) 9 4"&&& $& 3$) ,!- * ) & & $ ) < '

)>'

(( $ ) 3 && $ ) % '

)>'

(( ( $ ( 0 3 ) % ) ) $

3& ,!- .3& 3 ( ( &$ 3 ' ) , -!

' ) 3$&&$' '$3$ ) $( ( (

') $ 3& , - .3& /5))&$ &&$&&( & C (M M**$ 3 ' !/ ' ) $ ))' && $ '$& $ ))&$ < (

)<7 &&( & ) % 3))' )$ $ ( G & 3 7) !

' ) ( & ' && ))&$ &&% )&( & $& 3) , -5'( $& )'

)>'

((< ) 3$& )% &&$ ((

% $ 3& ,"- ,- .3& / , - 5 3 & ( ) ) &&$)($ ($(

%"% ( ( (

) '$&) $ ) '= !/ %7$ ) # %E%(0 ?

( 0 (,

! -/! <@ ) 97 % 3 ' '& >$ & $ ))' $ )(' & '

' @ K 2 & $) '& 3 $ $ ' 3

L $ ( 7 $ 3 ''

%& ( $ )(' ( ) )& ) ) & '& @ G 7 '& )&%( $ )) )&) )K 3 @ < )( 9 * '' '

' < &

& < 2 .0 7% &'&) & )' ) #%;8 3,!: - "/5 &

& 3&'&) & )' ;3( .; 3 8 ) ,

-! 7) 9,' <' :- 4:5$ 3&&3&' < ' )@ 3)&() $) )& % 3 )& &

3 ' & 3 ) ) '

$& 3 ) ''&& ( $& ) ( 5 ) & 3 ) ( $& ) ( % && ( ) ( ) % ' 7)7 ) 3 = 66666*

% D7&,!: - " )< &% ' 3 ' 7) 9 ,'' /<' ! -

%% 4! 666665 ) )&) )&&$ ))'8 7) )&) )<7' $ 7 7 $,# * % 8( &.(,!:":- ! "-8( &3% 3 $< $ )@ % 3 = ,('''&-66666 !* %7&7&7 $ ) < &

&2 .0

7% 3&'&) & )' ( '' ) <7)7&)& &3 7 '& )@ 3 % 3$ )) % ') '& @ ( &$)$( 3 '

L3$( & 37

( 7 8 * $ ) ))' ) $ $ '& )(' < ) )& ) ) ') '& @ < 7) % (& "/!: !:7 ;) $ ( ' $ '& (7 ($7( <7) ') & ) 3 (( 7 ) ) '$&) ) ))' $ '& = 5 & $ )) )& ) )7)0'&)$ )&&( & < )& $ $ ( $& %

3 '& 7 ''

%& $ $ )(' 5< 70 ) < $ ) ) )& ) )< )& %$ ) ( ; ) *( ) 3) ) $ ) !"* &3 ) <% $ ) ) )& ) )<

%(% $ )&&( & ))' )3$< $ '& 7 7&& () )% E% ))' ) $ 7 $ )(' < ) '7 ))' $ ) &&( & $ 2 & 3 3 )& 7)73 ;) 7&&3& $ $ )(' < & ( ; ) )& % $ 3 < $ 3 ) <&&( & < 7& $)( ) 7 $)(' I( ))' )<&& 7 @ = : * '

)< 7 % )&& )

3 3 3)7) )&& ) 0 '&)' &&7&3 7 ( 76( 3 3% ) 7)0'&) D <

C$ <

$ 5 ' )() )& )&)& 7 6 3 %'

) $ &&) >&&( >& )>% 3 ) '

) &! / 7$''& )&)& 3% 3) '

)5$&! / )& 7$0 $ )&)& 5)& $ )& )($ < <)&)& %'

)7 )&)&$

) 3 () %'

)$ ) 3* ) ) )( )< & 7 ' ' 7 7 $< 7) &$0 ) 7

%7 7 ) % '

)< ) && ) '&$) )&& !

L( '$ $ C $ E< 7 & $ )<7 & $& 7 7 7 '

) )

'& 7 )&)&

%% 7 3'

&)<)

')) /< **< '(&$) )&& !

5C&&8 ) ;.(%

< !: +. / & $

3 ))' ) $ )

( %$)&3$ $ ) 0 ($(%&$& 7 ( &% 3 ( ))' ) $ !!* )) )( )< ' %0 ) ) ) ( 5 < < '' & < < ) ' ( $ %7 & ' &7 2 & $) ' 7 3 $ < % 3) $7)7 ( () $( ) ( ) 5 ) &&3 '

) ;) $ 7 (& 3 $ ' < < )7& $7

0' ( )& 3 7&$'$&) %&%7) 7&$) %'

)7 '

' &65 '& ) )& 7) '

% ) $ 0 7 ') ' )

$ & $ ( $ 3) &$ ' ' '6' 3'

) &) &5' &&7&3 7 & 3 ') && % ) 7 6( ) )) 7 0 %$ %&

) 0 3 )

$&3 )0) %70' 3 ( $% & ' & ) ' ' $ $&(0)) )

%#% !

)) 3&< 7 ' ( 5

) $

2 '0 $ 7&< %)<

' = 5 "

,' ' ("

/, "

/( /

/ ((/ (

,"" "

-@ =.

( "( 4 " 2

(

"" (

/ " " , 4

( ( , " ( "( "

₹-'@7';-'?77A.' , ( "" ₹5'6;'6 ';77A. 4 ( "' (

/, " : , (

/ /

(((, ",

/ / (

, "

& (( /, ((/(

( "(/("

' /

( ,""&,

"" (( (, (< (" (' ( :

(' /

/ )* ((( ( /",$

7! 0118 !1 0:

7! 7;817 7 <=18 171756 17290 !17 % ##(% ;@6 @77 -

577 -8?@ @77 % # % 685 ;77 - 56 77 - 7 ;77 % #)% -5 65-@-

77 5-?5- -@7;-?77 56;6 ;77 887;??77 5@

/ "

/ (( 2( , 87 , ( , " /(

%)%

"' ((' / (( , " / )* , "(" ,

( "" , ( ( =.

("( "

, /2( (

, ( ("

, :

D ( "

, , & 5; (

1 )*

" " / (( "

/, .

" ( :

.8 " )* / .- /

("( ' (( "/, "/ , /

/ ((/ (

/ , "/,

// /, / ((/ (

1 )*

' ' , " " / (( "

/ , , "

/ (( "/ 56 4' '

" ("

)* ""

" (" "

" " /

" 4, ( ((

( ', ,/

(( " 5

,,6 5./ * $,6 ) 9!/ /

%) " - # '

. /'0 - # 1". /'0