← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/37964/2016dismissed

Pooja Pal And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2017-02-28Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal14 pages



        

!"

  

   

 



 !" 

 #   $

"%&    



 !"   #    # $ %&#  ' # '  '"()& *  #    +,#-())+(!"   ,( )& *.

 ! /0 ()& *   #   111     23



* 44  ( 

  

  !"    "%&  

  !" 0 ,

#   23

  ( $

.   0 ,.

 

 3   & 

#  * 5 



    * 6  , 78 5  5$,

 * 9( ( 8 *  $8: ;  *  %<7 88  +, (  %

 *  +,    ,  .

     6 # * * ,    *,     *   

 23 /0

 * 4# 40" #    = (78 6 *4 0,

  4# > #      ,        , &   &

4 

4 ,  4#"" 4 " 0", & ,

     4  0  .*4   * 4# +,  # * 4  4 ? **   #"  *4             * 4#   

4 4 ,.   @**  ,"4 , * 4# . 4 @.

 ) 4 ,(  * #  .          (  . 0&   .   * 0  .  * 4#  4    #*  0 0

 0.  4   4#   0*4 

# *

 0    0&    .  * , 4#  4  04.  # ,) 4 4(  . # .

  ,* 4# 

 4# =.

   # ( . *  4 . .

4 4# .   

.

     00   0 ,    0*= )** * 4#  #

4   $* 4  ( .   , 0*=.

 4   4    $*

 #

( .

 & &* 4#   *   ."/$5(## *,      * 4  ?   (  *4   * 4#  +,   &.

 4% (* 4#  #

 4    * 4  ( 4" 4 ( ,  # .

   ,    * 4#       #  6     * 4# (   * 4 +,  &.

 4 2$3 /$( . #*= ,*   ." 0,  = , * 4# (  *   . & , , ,   0  .   

A          "

* &" . & 4  "0* 

"4 .

  04 .  & .

 4  * 4# *    " ,/ 6   (* 4# *4 = .



 "4 .

 # 4"

04 #  4 ,.

* 4#    04 & ,  0.

    *  ,#  * *4 , .

 04 , 4 74 "   , ,

78 

5  *

(

8  *  @ 00(%

 *9  , 4 "

440   04 3        04         #     6  ,       *   !

,   )0( .  "   .  4 &    0  4   * #  4#   ,     #     4 ,    * #    *4   4  !

,   (  )0     $    $? &  * 4# 

 

*4    = .  0      A      4 ,     * 4#  4 ,  &   

, 4"

00 , 0  * "? **   & ,  *   .

  *  (  "

#   4 4 .

 * 4# 0"* * ,*4  4 ,

  B*4 " 4* 4# ?4 ,       . 4 @  .

    * 4#   

*  4 ,0"  .

,   

$

       4     4#"  "   4  C   

0*=, (  * 4#  #      ,     78 ,

 3 8&*   #   253 ),

  * (#  * ## #  * 

:;  4   <*   #  &4", , * * 8. * 44  %#  *+,   

 * ?

,    * *  8 # &

,  4 ,.  # & *0  * , @0 *  0=# 78 3 <  *          ,    4 ,  . 4 @      .

  04 #   /   (  04  #  4   ## *  *   #*  ,)*0   #*  ,/ *(9   = ,*   4 "440   4    ? 4. 

 .

. 04#

       ## *     *   5            *?  ,#  #  *  ## *     #  *   4"         .   4 ,  /   $(  ## *   .  

  0" 

,

  /    (       .  0*  0"

04#  . *4    ,78   *

( 

 8      *     @ 00( %

 *9  ,  04

4 "440  23 04  #    

 4 "  440    C 

$  )0!

,  6  ,  78( . *  4# * .   .

* &   4 *   . *  * ,#   . 

##   ?#  * *,  **   ".*,   

# ,) . 4 ,*,   , * * 

8(0 4.

  . . *&



# ,!0  #

#  . 6  , 78,

 *

(

8.

 23 <*    5 $( *  *.

  #* ,

  4 ,  04# .

  "= 78    * 

( 5( ($(  >$(

(($($ 8 .  ,   ,

  0"          $  , 04    *, * 4#

,   #     .       0   ,      4 ,

*  *  *  *, **    78 23  4 "(*   #  * 

 B 4 , *, +,    

 *      #*    *    *     8

 4*       ,            .

   * 4# > #      /"  #    * #   . * &    %(   (    4    *   

(

 *  +,  

08 *  * 8

( * *

      $  8  0 ,   * , @0  .   0      *  6*  2 3 <*  4#

@ 4   *

5:; 5(* , # * +, 

 . "  .

   

 *      .  #*    $5(  &* 0 .

 * 4#   "( (* "(   *   * * 8

 4   

     *4* #.

 &"

# &? * 4   *  84  * , @0 *?,4 ,.  0

  *  *. *.  ?*  * . 0   " ,

 ,

( ""  *

,

 )" 4 . 4# * <*     4

. & &

4 4  # *  , , 78

*  0 ?,   * * 98 

*#& @( 44  *** 23 9"   ,             

     !"  #$%  & !'

   ()  *  +   * )     ) 

,#&,,'!&!-.'//0&('

123.  23.)  ,00,&,'"#



 -)   4 )   5& '

!&!-.' %,  6 1 -4 ) 

7(.7 !

 )    #&$' ! &!-.'055(*   

# ,4  "* ( +,  ,  

 *  2$3 <  *           ,   # .    *  5       0  B*

  &"

# ," (   * (0. 78        

*   "  * , @0  *     ,     0     " 4# 00     0

 . * #4*&* * *

   

 *   ,      # * ,  ,   

** (.

B#

,0,   .* # * ,

4  " .

 .# * ,

4 *

"  .

 4  & .= ,&,* ** ( # .  * 5*0B*

8

##     *  (*   #  43- -)   !

*

)   ,%&#'!&!-.',## 2 3 <*      # & ,4" 4   *  8(*

"*4     4 ,6  0# & 4   %



 ?** * 0* & *  *  *  8& 0

 4

9"

 ,   

    " )  )              )     ,0%/& '  !  5$  ( 22 ( ..

,00%&$'!&!-.'50  '(  )*  +  ,,  -  '.),  ,/)  ,,0 !1"!  .)&  213(    *    4#

@  #       ##

 # & ,4 ,(

  *4   *   , 4& 0# & *  2 3 / (*    #  &4" 4 ,  .

 04



# !

, )0

 &? , * ,  #*   4 ,           #       #     

  6  # 

 & , +, !. ## * 0"4 "440   &" "# *.

# * +, D 4 ,. * * *  

* . +,  253 <*  * #* *  0"*   * B  * *   8  & * * ) ,     *(    *  4 *  B4      # #* & & **0=  * 

 0" .  B*

, # .  * 58 

 *   *0   "    *  *# .*0B*

&" # ,"9"

* , !

)   8    8   ".

 ,00 &$'  ! &!-.'  /$#  94  :  +  9;  :       4 )  & ,#',/ !!

,9<7  "-)   1))  & ,/',, !! %

  *        # .    *   5 * 0B*

 ,   ,* *#"*  # * , ** *.

.



?# .  * 5* "0#

 

& *.

 0  # *

 .  * & ,   * 2 3 9"* , 2)).* --)    &.

)- ')   0& '! &!-.'/   -3 - !

))    , &#'  !  &!-.'  $ (    *  

    *     * &   # *  *  ,

4 "?* # * * "06  .,  # 4 " * &  . & *   0  ")

 *(  * # *0 4 & *  * 4 * & , 23 <*    #    * &"  44   4 , *  *   )"  4   0##0"#  *   $   *  *  0 *  8   #*   ,/ *(9  (  04#     ## *        8    ## *      #    *(9  :)B>D5;* .

# (   #   

  )7  E +=F &

"(! .



 0 ,   (   .

   .  .

   .

  "

#

 ## *       #*  ,/ *(9   4".

 04 # ( ,  6#,#(,

.  4  ,     # (     ?

=  4(   *4,!#  C 

$ .  0"  

0 % &

9* )0!

, .    .     0"    *    0        8  .

4         * *  4 ,  .

  04 # (   ..

0 .4 ? % &

9* )0!

, #

  5   )   (    *          # 



 ,( # .  * 5* 0 & =.* 

# & *

" 0 *  23 8&* 



40" *   #   23 8

 # * # .# .  * 5*0B*

&" # ," (    * ?# . *0B*

 "    #&0  # *

 . * &    * *# .* 0B*

  ,.



0     #     "      & *    *   ? 6  , 78* "0 .78

= 

*&#  (   &"* 44

  *  ?      6  ,  .

  *   #4 . . 0"! A0)#B    2 

4".

,00,&,'!$5$ 2 3 )

*(   # *04?#  

 * & @& @ +,  %.  0##* 0" & ,?*  # *0"*    # 

  * * B 4 ,  .

 04 # ( #   , .8.  " * *  . *  .  4  0"   #         .

  #  +, ,&

 *   * * B  * * 8D& .

( 

 ,(. "* 0#   ( 4"* 

 #  & = , # .  *   5    .   0   "  *    # 4 23 ?= ,  * 

 * * *4 *

* ( . 0 ,"#4  0 &" 4 (  4"# **   





   C     4 ,  "  #     4 (  8  4  ## #  **   #  

,! .&(0 #  . 0 0"  & *& ,?    0

*0"" 0 & 40"

 . *  # *  2$3 8  & .    0 &(  8         "    *   

 # #  4**  ,"



  # '5 5

   # * 6,,) /7'89:

7 6,,) 8);+ 7