High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3268/2002allowed

National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Shela Pandit And Others

2024-09-25Mrs. Justice Archana Puri10 pages

!"#!$%"&'(!) !*+!,-./ 01

(2 (

!

"# $ $ %%%%

.2 ' $()

' *+,**,,*

(

& ( "'

(" ' -

"

$.

(

$ $

" #

$ - "( " $'

) ",+,/0//1"

$ -

"'

#- 2),0)33342

'$

" -

5 ' #-' 6 7

!

-2"!&"( *8 ($ 8 "

8'

-$

8 $ "( $

"

8 ( 8$

8( 2)0390"'

-

"' -

8-& " #

(

#8 "

-- $ $

8 "

' "

$

8 ' ( 8 $ #"'

( $ & (

'

-- $ " ' (

-

$

"'

1 ($ & ( :

' $ $ 8-

"

$ $

'

.

(

2'# " #$

$ $ " &10;,+,40//<"

$( " 8 "

$

.

( "

6 & 14;,+,40//<"'

$(

"

5

"(- -

'$$

"

6 .

" $ $

8( -

2)0390".- . 5 "' 0*( 4 '

$

8( 2) 0390"'

(

( 0*#"

"

$ 2),0) 3334"' 1" 2'# "

- $

($ & ( " $ " *9,90///" -# 0*"

0*

8( -

2)0390 7 ' $ - $$-

8 ' -#

" $

4"

8"

6 " $' 1)

$ 2),0) 3334 '

' 6 " " $( '"

"8

/ $ -

$ " '

8 " -- " $

8( 2)0390

# " "'

" $

$ "$

&14;,+,40//<"'

$

"

' $ 033$ "( '

$ " # 034) $ ( " # 0<000/// ' $ 033$ ( ' "

' $ # '

= $ # " ( - " ( ' -- " $ $

8" '

-- $( #

$<,<, " ' ' 8 "6

( &1,"101*$ &14

" ' $( -

$

034) 2'# " & ( "'

- $- (

# 8 -- " $ $

'

86 "

"

2),0)3334"

1"((8$<,>$

-

& ' ' $

&

- - ' "

$$

:= 4*39"4*3+"4*3/4*9,$ *,,* 2'# "

- $ -

' '' := 4*39 4*3/$*,,* '"

-:=)4*3+)*,,*"'

' "

$.

( :=4*9,)*,,*"'

- "

$ $

"

$

" 8

- ?) $ )

# " $ )

( :=)4*9,)*,,*" & 14"$( -

''$

034)$ "

8- $ ?<"

(

' 2),0)3334 $

" (- #(

"

' ( $ 2'

#

" # $ "

& (- " ( 4

2),0)3334 $ " 034$

" (

" $ & 14 $

"

(

($

" $ (-

2),0)3334 $ "

- -

"' 2),0)3334"

$

$

?<

( - #$ #

$

"( '# $ ' ( $ '- ' $

($ $ "

$.

(

(( #' $

(

$ ( #" ' '# ##

6 ='

8( 2)0390 2),0)3334& ' $

8' 0 *2'# "

- $ ' -#

' # 6 " $

86 "

" 2'#

$ 2),0)3334' 1 ( ?$<,> ($ " ( $ -- "( $<,<,$(

$ '

8 = -$$-

8 # (-# ( "$

" '

-

8( 2)0390 :

-$ " (

2),0)3334 (- "

" (-

#

"

$' 6 " #( $

" 6 "'

# "

#( $"' ((

034$ ( &

6 "'

(- 4 2),0)3334"

(-

$' " 034$ ( "$ # ' ) " '

( ( #( (

"

#

(

#- (-#( "$

$# 6 &

"

" ( (

(

(- "($ $

!""

" 2@(

'

-

# "'

#( "

$' # (-4 " (

.

-" ' # $

%

! '!(# ) * % + ,

"

-' ( #" -#)

!

" ! !

!

!

!

#

! "" "

$

!

%

&'(

"

! ! !

"

$

"

! "

%

&'(

! ! "

""

!

"

"

%

&'(

$

"

"

)

%

&'(

"

!

"

*+,-,.-,,(

!

"

/!

"

%

&'(!

"

! )

*+,-,.-,,(

%

&'(

!

!

*+0,%12&&! !

!

3! 4 !

% $

! !

! "

*+0,%12&& /

%

&'(

!

"

*+0,%12&&

%

&'(

)

!

!

!

!

"

%

&'(

/!

"

%

&'(

! ) "

! !

!

!

%

4 &'(

! "

*+0,%12&&

"

!

"

"

!

"

*+0,%12&&$

!

5 6

"

6

! 7

"

"

"

%

&1

#

6 ! "

'" ! "

"

%

&'(

!

!

"

! !

"

!

"

! "

!

! / "

!

"

6

) "

%

&'(

"

! )

"

*+,-,.-,,(

"

8 #'$ -#- $

( 2)0390( "$

" ( ' $-

2),0)3334& (- " "(-

#

"

$' (- " 034$

" (" (

"# ))# - $ " &14 (

5 $

"

" (' $- 6 - $

#

&14;,+,40//<

'" -:=)4*3+)*,,*" - ' "' 2),0) 3334 ( #$ " $ ?<

$ & $#$

#

$

2'# "

$ ?<

# ' #"'

# '-

' $ (( ' #

($ -#

"'

#(

#

.

"'

(-

$ 6 " $ "

#

? -6 " #

"

"

6 " $-6 $

" ( & ( ( #

" '

(!) !*+!,-./

- 8-;

!% ( !%6"