High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9907/2020disposed of

Rajni Bansal And Another v. Guru Nanak Education Trust And Others

2021-05-11Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh8 pages

! "#

# $#% &%#% '( )% *#% "#

+ ,

-# '.# "#

# $#% &%#% '( )% *#% "#

# /0#" /1#2 -$ # " +#

# / 4!2 -$ # #+ ' 5

# /%6"" -"%2 -$ # #+ '

" % %6#( +0 892 " 61 ( %+ # "#1 "#%1" $ #1

*" 6$ 4 ! $! # +2 "%1" 6. 4

$$ # +#2 " # 6. +# !

'#% &%! " 6. # -# '.# #

9#+# 3%#2 6" %# -#! :; " % 9 # (1 4# " %# # <%"1 " "#1" <%#. #+# 0 6. " #+ % 0!# !4 + $!$ # " ( 6#$.2 # 61 + 1"# 6. " 00 %10

*" +#2 6" " + # 0+!. 4" #+ ' &%#% '( )% *#%2 ! *42 =%" "# !!1 #+ ' 5&%#% '( &#! !!12

! *42 =%" -! !!12 *"#;=%## # %6 4"" # + # $# %# " %6 -! !!1 /%#. /#$ )0+!.2 - 7 "# >" -? 9 %#1 " %# "# 0+!.02 4" " !!1 "# # "# $ 1 " !!1 %"# # ><%! +. # <%! 4#(?2 !!1 %"# !!1 "$ % 0#$ "#4 % " +# 4!! $#4 #01 "# 2 "%2 0 # "0 # "# 0 - <%! "2 " +# 4# % "#1" # !!4 6. "4 % +%#+1 +%"0 "# #0 #$

9 " " +# " 6! 0% "# %"#. +4#2 " !!1 %"# "$ %+

$$ <%#. # "! +#0! <%#. 1 " +#2 4"2 % 0#! %% 1#%2 " #00 1 " +# 2 "#6.2 #01 "0 "# #$

*" % #+ ' 5 +#0#!.

6 " %#. +#$ " %# / - " -2 )%! *#6%! " " %# % " +% 64 " +# " !!1 010 " $! %# " #! +!. " 0 *" #+ ' 5 "$ !!1 " % !!1! %% 0 " +# "# 0%2 " !!1 %"# 4# # ( 0#$ 2 +# !4 2 "%2 " $#0 0 " +

+ ' 76 @$#.2 "1#"2 " ( %+ 0!# +! !( %# " $! %# $4 " %#. +#$ 9 ## " " !!1 010 %+ 0+!. 1# 0%;0#! %#+% 9 ## " " ## %+ " +#2 + 6. " !!1 010 " 6 . $ ## "

1## 6 @$#. #0 @$#. !# 8!%0 9 1%! "+# 8999 ) *" #+ ' "#%1 #+6!.

" +% 64 " *"# " 010 !01 " !! " #! # 61 %1" 6. " +# 1 " !!1 010

$+$ 4"" " @$#. " #! +!. 2 "%2 " $#0 " +

A# %! # " +# +#% " ##

# /0#" /1#2 -$ # " +# " +! #! %+ %10 + ' 7 , !

$! -++! '

7 : !

!! !

: / ,2 $! -++! ' 777 ! "

#$ # %$ "

/ ,,B2 #0! -++! ' 7 ! #

7 5 / 772 ' ! ') &

"$ '*'

"00# "0 " + " C+! #%02 " $! %# ## " # % !01 " " /% " 6 #% # 4" " " 4" 0( " %. " %# %+ " =1!%# 9 # " " #% =1!%# 4 +#$ " 0+!. " % +!#0 # "# 1#$ 4 $# " " /% +#$ #%0 )%! *#6%!

*" 0 #$# 6.

# /

4!2 -$ # #+ ' 5 6. 1 %10 + ' 75 ! $

$,$ !

& + $+ *

7 /* :

2 ' 7 !

' 7 , !

' ! &,

#0! -++! ' 7 ! * #

7 /* :2 $! -++! ' : 5 ! -

/- %$ 5 $! 5, ' :7 !

5 /*

, 6.

# /%6"" -"%2 -$ # #+ ' 7 6.

1 %10 + ' 7 , !

6#1 6% " " #+!.2 " %# " "! " !! #$ +% #1 % ## 6. " 0102 " *#6%! " " %#

-++#1 " #1%0 " 4 4"% !1 " . %#"# $# " 0# " " 4 2 ! 01" +#% "# #+$ 2 6 ## "# " " - 4 +#$ /%#. /#$ " )0+!. ! !!1 -! !!12 +# 1 / " -

$-$ !!4

D>1$

, $ #

!, $ &$#0 !!1 # !!1 6!" # 0

6. %" @$#.

%#"# / 4" + 4"" 1$ 6!4 234# 1$

+ + $" / &$#0 #0 0 0 2 "##2 !!%# " 0"12 # 4""2 !!1 1 1# #0 " / &$#0 #0 0 0 F%#"#0#2 / - ! " 06 )%! *#6%! %# 4""2 " )%! *#6%!2 6. 4. / - %6/ +#$ " " )%! *#6%!

"!! "$ %# "# !! +% 64 " > 11 00? " >0+!.? " - " %6 #$!.

1 1G /"! )0+!.

/%#. /#$ -2 F%#"#0#2 %# / ,2 %# $! %# " 6 +!!. 6##

$'$ $#1 6( " 2 %0 +!#. +#1 64 " 0+!. " 010 " !!12 " + "$ 0 6% 2 "##2 6. $#% / - %6/ # 4"

/ , " -2 %# " %# +!!. 6##

/0!# $4 " #!# 6 C+# 6. " %# $#% %10 4"" " 6 ! 6$ 6"! " #+ *"%1"2 " + 4# ! !1 6( 1 "$ 6 %1 !12 # . ## : 4# + 6. " %# 6" " + " ! "#1 6. $#% 4""2 " +# "$ "2 % "# 6 2 4 6. $#% !# % 6. " 1##2 6 @$#.2 "1#"2 %# +#$ "# @$#. !# 8!%0 9 1%! "+# 8999 ) *"%2 " +# "$1 % " 6 # %" !1 02 4%! 6 " "1 # % " ". 6 !!4 ##. 4" "# 6 %"2 " 0# 6 #!1 " )%! *#6%!

2 %62 "1#"2 4"" "!! "# + " +2 +# !4 /2 " +!1 # 0+!H " %# 0 C+ " ! " + 6 #1!. " )%! *#6%!2 ! $#2 # #1 " +!

$*$ " " 0#2 %"2 +

( &,&

5 ""# +(1;# I;' ""# #+#6! I;'