High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/37409/2014allowed

Balwinder Kumar v. M/S R.N. Highways (P) Ltd

2018-08-17Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan14 pages

!"#$!%&'&"() *+* + ,-&($!./01.

***! & &"(!.

2'* 3'* *&45-6' 7 $* ***!'8"($!( ) 97*: 2

:

: ;

2

:

: ; <* 7

! "

#

$ %%%&'

(& () *((+ $ , -! ./ 0 1 -

.

2 3%/ ##

*' (+ *((4 .

2 3*/ - 5 ##

'() 6

7 . 8679/ 3# . 8# 9/ ! *((+ - :# !

, ;7 . 89/

- <

0

7

= 0

3+ 7

>4( >4* '(> '() '*( '*'

'*) '*?

67 -

$ , -! 0 @ %) (& *((+ = 3#!

# = , A23%%(

B # 0

5 # 3#!

#

# 5 >( (% *((+

- # - - # ! # # # - ! =

- - - # =

*( (+ *(()

:#

: @ "

# 6 :#

: # #!9 0 ##

# - 5- # .

2 3>/ # %>?&(((B3 %' (> *((+

!# -

# %? (> *((+ = ## # B

C *( (> *((+ 6 *% (> *((+ -

- #

- A #

# #

# #

# -

- - 0

<

(> (' *((+ -

-

5 - - ?* = 3#!

*( (' *((+ 5 - # 6

?(((B3 ! - # ? ((

- >( (% *((+ - - ! 5 ##

-

#!

- 7D% # A2 7*

# *' (+ *((4 .

2 3*/ ##

'() 67 ! - ##

- $ * & 5 =

% > # A2 7* - -

#

#

# #

- 5

= - ! *(%'

(> %% *(%' 5

- !

0

5# # -

- 5 - !

!

# A2 7* # #

5 !

- # - 6 5#

# # " # 5 7

5# #!

!

B # -

# *( (% *(%) 7

# #

-

5

! "

#

$ !

!

!

%

!

!

!

#

=

!

!

&'

( '')

!

* #

!

$

+ !

!

!

*

! * '

& '') #

!

!

! ,

! ! +

+ !

% % % - !

!

!

!

.

% - !

%

>

! ! !

!

+

*

!

* &'

( '') !

# *

!

+

* !

!

*

% % !

! !

*

/

!

!

!

$ !

!

0

(12&

1 " " (1')

!

$ !

!

!

&3 4

5

0

6& &7 8''9

!

!

5

! &3 4

! 0

6& &7 8''9 $

#

!

0

&89

!

!

!

!

:

+ 0

#

!#

# - - ! - - !

##

# 6

##

'() 67

- ## 0

# 5

#

'() 67 # 0

(08 :.152'*5", 5:5.1($" 5!.'<

.,* > - ,95

# /

!

9

9

;!

*

!

/

!

$

*

!

:

0

# ,95

# :5.$/01.:(45&2'* :(4& (!< =

.,*

5# -

!

7#!

#

#! 5 !

5 5 "

0

:*/*,452'*: !"# **($" 5!.'< +

.,* <-

#!

- #

'() 67 -

7#!

7#!

- ! - "

0

3'

718,"6!!': "%?8 &"(.0' 2'*3' ($& (#",&(!7&1& !$<

.,* = <- ,95

# 5

5

-

-

#

-

- # 5

- #

0

- # ,95

# 5.&-, "@%"

."$0% '7 $*($" 5!.'2'*: !"#5.'5 .($(" 5!.<

.,* > #!

##

>4?

7 7 !

'+* 7 7 #!

'+* 7 7 5 #

#!

- 5 6 !

# 5

'() 67 #

5

# # #

= #

5 #

- 5 6 5# ##

# # #

# -

# *% (> *((+

# - #

# - # # 6 5#

# -

#

'() 67 #

## -

-

#

# -

5

0

5#

# %( ! 5 #

!

- !

7

# *( (% *(%) -

#!

- #

#

-

./

# ! # ! !

- 5

#

!

# # - 6 5" - # # - 5- ##

# - 5- # 5

# 5

5 ! ! - ! .5/ =

! - #

!

#

# 6 5 !

# 5

!

##

'() 67 # !

- ! = - # ,95

# :5.$/01.:(45&9 ./ :*/*,459 ./ #5 ./ A - # 5

#

5 # 6 5 ,95

# '5"? '? 2'* : ! "# 5.'5 .($" 5!.'< .,* + #

5 !

- - !

- # !F

# - !

!

-

!

F ! #

- !

- 5

# - 5 !

- #

=

- - # - - - - # !

=

#

!

! # !

!

-

5

# - !

##

# ./ 6 - # ,95

# 2** "'!($(" 5!.2'*: !"#0A. ($(" 5!.<

.,* +> #!

5- - # - - " !

#!

- #

# !

# #!

-

# # -

- ./ =

-

##

##

" -# #

A -

6

7

##

'() 67 # 5

'() 67 # -

- ./ = #

#!

5

-

('

! - ! 5 - - # ,G5

# 5.&-,"@%"

."$0% ' 7 $*G ./ 5 # .

/ 6 - # ,G5

# 3'

7 18,"6!!' : "%? 8 &"( .0' G ./ 5-

# "

-

5 5

#

; 5

- = #

$ %%%&'

(& () *((+ $ , -! ./ 0 1 -

.

2 3%/ ##

*' (+ *((4 .

2 3*/ 5!

" B2

:

: ; C %? (+ *(%+ D B CB$ D 5

CB$