← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/23467/2021allowed

Karambir Alias Bittu v. State Of Haryana

2021-07-19Mr. Justice B.S. Walia5 pages

    

      

     !"# $#%&'&() *   +!,!-.&,/&""0  1#"&"&(#, 2#,'0' 3"!"#  !,4!(!  1#'5($#("

,!-) (6.7#,0'"&%#38!7&! ,#'#(") ,+!,!(9&,3&(:;+;#;!,<$9%!"# ,";#5#"&"&(#, ,!9##(+0-!,3;#,!(< < !,4!(! === 38!7&!<>2 ?

!'# &' .#&(: "!@#( 05 , ;#!,&(: ";,0:; 2&$#

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

CRM-M No.23467 of 2021 [2] B!',#:&'"#,#$D#!,(#$%0('#7%("#($'";!"$0,&(:&(9#'"&:!"&(<% !%%0'#$ !;&5!7 B!' !,,#'"#$ ( CA B;&7# ( AA< 5#"&"&(#,+!,!-.&, !($ ;&' %!%%0'#$ (!-#74 3!($##5 !($ !E#'; B#,# !,,#'"#$< ";!" 3!($##5 :" ";# -",%4%7# ,#%9#,#$ 0'#$ &( ";# %,&-#B;&%;B!'$,&9#(.4";#5#"&"&(#,+!,!-.&,<";!"(%-57#"&(  &(9#'"&:!"&(< %;!77!( B!' '0.-&""#$ !:!&('" ";# !%%0'#$ (

AA.0"!%%0'#$&(#';;!'(".##(!,,#'"#$"&77$!"# B#9#,< $0,&(: ";# 5#($#(%4   ";# ",&!7< ";# 5#"&"&(#,+!,!-.&, B; B!' ,#7#!'#$(,#:07!,.!&7B!'$#%7!,#$!5,%7!&-#$

#($#,.4";# 0,"  ";# 7#!,(#$ $$&"&(!7 3#''&(' 0$:#< 0,0:,!- ( * * .#'&$#'<";#5#"&"&(#,B!'&(979#$&(!(";#,%,&-&(!7%!'#!,&'&(:0"     $!"#$ A ,#:&'"#,#$ !" 7&%# 3"!"&( 3!$!,<

0,0:,!-B;#,#&(;#B!'$#%7!,#$5,%7!&-#$

#($#,( * * !($ B!' ,#!,,#'"#$ &( '!&$ %!'# ( C   !' ;# B!' !7,#!$4 &( %0'"$4&(%!'# $!"#$ * *0($#,3#%"&(

 !"7&%#3"!"&( &"4!77!.:!,;

D#!,(#$ %0('#7 , ";# 5#"&"&(#, %("#($' ";!" ";# 5#"&"&(#, B!' :,!("#$ .!&7 &( %!'#    $!"#$ A ,#:&'"#,#$!"7&%#3"!"&(3!$!,< 0,0:,!-&(B;&%;;#B!'$#%7!,#$! 5,%7!&-#$ 

#($#, ( * *< 9&$# ,$#, ((#F0,# G $!"#$   (";#:,0($";!"";#;#B!'&(%0'"$4'&(%# C  <(

0,";#,,#%9#,4B!'".##

#%"#$ ,-;&-!($",&!7B07$"!@#7(: "&-# !($ 0,";#, &(%!,%#,!"&( B07$ '#,9# ( 50,5'#< .#'&$#'< ";# 5#"&"&(#,;!$:&9#(0($#,"!@&(:"!55#!,.# ,#";# 0,"(#!%;!($ #9#,4 $!"#   ;#!,&(:  D#!,(#$ %0('#7 0,";#, %("#($' ";!" ";# 5#"&"&(#, %07$ (" !55#!, .# ,# ";# 7#!,(#$ ",&!7 0," '&(%# ";#

CRM-M No.23467 of 2021 [3] %-57!&(!("6' '( +!0';!7 B; &' ! @(B( :!(:'"#, ;!$  %,&-&(!7 %!'#' ,#:&'"#,#$ !:!&('" ;&- !' 5#, ";# $#"!&7' :&9#( &( ((#F0,# GC &(%70$&(:-!(4%!'#'0($#,3#%"&( !($$0#" #!,(!%%0(" ";,#!" #7&-&(!"&(<";#5#"&"&(#,$&$("!55#!,.# ,#";#7#!,(#$ ",&!7 0,"D#!,(#$%0('#7 0,";#,%("#($'";!""B ";#%!%%0'#$ (!-#74!;&5!7!($!E#';!7,#!$4'"!($!%H0&""#$.4";#7#!,(#$",&!7

0," 9&$# ,$#,< ((#F0,# GA $!"#$    B;&7# "!@&(: &(" !%%0("";!"'0--('&(";#(!-# 8'3!;!.+!0,<#4#B&"(#''!($ !($ +&';,#< &(E0,#$ ;!$ .##( ,#%#&9#$ .!%@ B&"; ";# ,#5,"   ";# 3!,5!(%;";!"3!;!.+!0,!($!($+&';,#B#,#("%-&(:"";#&, ;0'# ,";#7!'"-!(4$!4'!($";!"";#&,B;#,#!.0"'B#,#("@(B( !($'&-&7!,,#5,"'B#,#,#%#&9#$('0--(' ,";#$!"#' *<

  <   <  <  <     !($ C <";#,# ,#<(!%%0(" ((!9!&7!.&7&"4 B;#,#!.0"' 8'!'5#,'0--(',#5,"<7#!,(#$$$&"&(!73#''&('0$:#< 0,:!( %7'#$";#5,'#%0"&(#9&$#(%#;#7#!,(#$$$&"&(!73#''&('0$:#<

0,:!( B!' 57#!'#$ " .'#,9# ";!" ";# 5,'#%0"&( ;!$ !&7#$ " 5,$0%#&(%,&-&(!"&(: !%"'!($%&,%0-'"!(%#'(#%#''&"!"&(:,#%,$&(: '"!"#-#("'   !%%0'#$ 0($#, 3#%"&(   ,   %%,$&(:74< &( ";# !

,#-#("&(#$ %&,%0-'"!(%#'< %!%%0'#$ !;&5!7 !($ !E#'; B#,# !%H0&""#$ C D#!,(#$%0('#7 0,";#,%("#($'";!"";#7#!,(#$$$&"&(!7 3#''&('0$:#< 0,0:,!-B;&7#:,!("&(:.!&7"";#5#"&"&(#,&(%!'#  $!"#$ A,#:&'"#,#$0($#,3#%"&('*A!($   !($,-'%"!"7&%#3"!"&(3!$!, 0,0:,!-(!%%0(" ;&';!9&(: .##($#%7!,#$!5,%7!&-#$

#($#,B!'57#!'#$""!@#&("!%%0("";#

CRM-M No.23467 of 2021 [4] '0.-&''&('";!"";#5#"&"&(#,%07$("!""#($";# 0,"$0#" #!, :!(:'"#,+!0';!7 ,-B;-;#B!',#%#&9&(:,#5#!"#$";,#!"'  #,%(",!<7#!,(#$ %("#($'";!"";0:;";#5#"&"&(#, B!',#7#!'#$(,#:07!,.!&7&(";#&('"!("%!'#.4";#7#!,(#$$$&"&(!7 3#''&('0$:#< 0,:!(9&$#,$#,<((#F0,#G$!"#$ C A.0" B!' $#%7!,#$ ! 5,%7!&-#$ 

#($#, .4 ";# 0,"   ";# 7#!,(#$ $$&"&(!73#''&('0$:#< 0,0:,!-9&$#,$#,$!"#$ * *<!($ B!'!55,#;#($#$(74( C  <";#,# ,#<;#&'("#("&"7#$"";# %(%#''&( .!&7

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

(:'"#,+!0';!7&#";#'( ";#%-57!&(!(" !($9&%"&-<B;!'5#,";#$#"!&7':&9#(&(((#F0,#GCB!' !%&(: %,&-&(!7%!'#'&(%70$&(:-!(4%!'#'0($#,3#%"&(  A D#!,(#$ 3"!"# %0('#7 ;!' (" $&'50"#$ ";!" ";# %-57!&(!("6''(:!(:'"#,+!0';!7B!'&(979#$&(%,&-&(!7%!'#' &(%70$&(:-!(4%!'

CRM-M No.23467 of 2021 [5] * %%,$&(:74<"!@&(:&("!%%0("";#5'&"&(("#$!.9#!'!7' ";!"$#'5&"#";#%-57!&(!("!($;#,;0'.!($9&%"&-;!9&(:.##(&''0#$ '0--(' " !55#!, .# ,# ";# 7#!,(#$ ",&!7 0," ( ";,## %%!'&('< ";#4 $&$ (" !55#!, &( 0,"  !-   ";# 9&#B ";!"( 0'# 07 50,5'# B07$.#'#,9#$.4@##5&(:";#5#"&"&(#,.#;&($.!,'%%,$&(:74<";# 5#"&"&( , ,#:07!, .!&7 &'  !($ ";# 5#"&"&(#, &' ,$#,#$ " .# ,#7#!'#$(,#:07!,.!&7<$0,&(:",&!7'0.E#%"";&' 0,(&';&(:.!&7G'0,#"4 .($'"";#'!"&'

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

,#-#("&(#$"#,-' >38!7&!? 0$:# *   I!E(##';G-&"6  8;#";#,'5#!@&(:G,#!'(#$) #'G  8;#";#,,#5,"!.7#) #'G