Ms Liberty Shoes v. Ld Chairman Central Board Of Direct Taxes



 
  

   

   ! "#  $  %&'&() % *(+,- *./+#01234)&5+)/ % 4)+'/-*64%7284,#01234)&4(0 % 9:4,2'/4(#01234)&;2%)/&%&1+&54<<,+34() ====
 /+' +' 4 %&1+&5 4<<,+34)+2( ;+,&0 :8 )/& 4<<,+34()<&)+)+2(&% '&&.+(> %&1+&5 2; 2%0&% 04)&0

 # 5/&%&:8# 5& /40 0+'6+''&0 )/& 5%+)<&)+)+2(,&41+(>+)2<&()2)/&<&)+)+2(&%)2%4+'&4,,+)'4%>*6&()'5+)/ %&>4%0)23/4,,&(>&2;)/&4''&''6&()2%0&%:&;2%&)/&<<&,,4)&*)/2%+)8  &4%(&032*('&,;2%)/&%&1+&54<<,+34()'*:6+)')/4))/+' 2*%) /4';4,,&(+(&%%2%+(/2,0+(>)/4))/&234, 266+))&&54'(2)%&9*+%&0)2 >+1&4(2<<2%)*(+)82;/&4%+(>)2)/&%&1+&54<<,+34()4(0'*:6+)')/4))/& 2<<2%)*(+)8 2; /&4%+(> +' 4(+(/&%&()<4%) 2; 4(8 ?*0+3+4,2%406+(+')%4)+1& <%23&&0+(>'4(0+('*<<2%)2;/+'32()&()+2('/&%&,+&'*<2()/&?*0>6&()' <4''&0 :8 2(@:,& )/& *<%&6& 2*%) +( )/& 34'& 2; 4(&.4 74(0/+ 1'

A(+2( 2; (0+4
B   B# 4/4%4 (0+4 C!+%6D 1'

266+''+2(&% 2; (326&4E &()%4,#F G
 C D#

 74*)461'

A(+2(2; (0+4# F
G
   C D 4(0 540&'/+ 2))2( +,,' 1'

 A(+2( 2; (0+4#



)+'/+''*:6+''+2()/4))/& 54';2%;2%6+(>2;4 234, 266+))&&)24''&'')/&>%+&14(3&'2;)/&<&%'2('5/23,4+6&0)/4))/& 34'&54'2;/+>/<+)3/&04''&''6&()4(054'%&9*+%&0)2>+1&4(2<<2%)*(+)8 2; /&4%+(> )2 &43/ 4(0 &1&%8 <&%'2(  ) +' '*:6+))&0 )/4) )/& 34'& 2; )/& %&1+&5 4<<,+34() 52*,0 ;4,, 5+)/+( )/& /+>/<+)3/&0 4''&''6&()# 4(0 )/&%&;2%&#4(2<<2%)*(+)82;/&4%+(>+'%&9*+%&0)2:&>+1&(




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

(1+&5)/&%&2;#5&02(2);+(04(8&%%2%3266+))&0:8*'5/+,& <4''+(>)/&2%0&%'2*>/))2:&%&34,,&0 &/41&4,'2<&%*'&0)/&?*0>6&()' %&,+&0*<2(:8)/&,&4%(&032*('&,;2%)/&%&1+&54<<,+34()4(0;+(0)/4))/& '46&/41&(24<<,+34)+2()2)/&;43)'2;)/&<%&'&()34'&




 FG  (1+&5)/&%&)2#5&02(2);+(04(8%&4'2()2%&1+&52%0&%04)&0

  /&%&1+&54<<,+34)+2(+'#)/&%&;2%&#0+'6+''&04332%0+(>,8 ,,<&(0+(>6+'3 4<<,+34)+2(C'D4,'2')4(00+'<2'&02;



































 


















   %4?&'/