High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1261/2019allowed

Jaswinder Singh v. State Of Punjab

2021-10-06Mr. Justice B.S. Walia5 pages

!"#$"%&'&#()** '+&(,"-.&(/0 1"!&!&#("- 2"-'3' .! !"#$3(4 5 1*"'6#(,"(!

-"'"(!)

-*7&! &'+ 89,:#% !"$#-!0"6"!&!&#("-*

-*036&(,"-"(&+ 89 93(4 5* ;;;

- <"-&(!0"-":&'&#(6"!&!&#(&'$#-'"!!&(/ '&,"43,/7"(! #$ %#(:&%!&#( (, #-,"- #$ '"(!"(%" , !", =*>*? 6 ''", 5< !0" 8" -(", 3,&%& 8 /&'!- !" '! 8 ''9 03-& ' +"88 ' 43,/7"(! , !", **6 ''",5<!0"8" -(",."''&#('3,/"9. (/-3-,&'7&''&(/!0" 66" 8$&8",5<!0"6"!&!&#("-* @" -(",%#3('"8%#(!"(,'!0 !6"!&!&#("-+ '%#(:&%!", (, '"(!"(%",&(!0"&('! (!% '"!#3(,"-/#!0"$#88#+&(/&76-&'#(7"(!)

&!'

+&!0 '"(!"(%"' + -,", !# -3( %#(%3--"(!8< (, 6"-&#, #$ ,"!"(!&#( 8-" ,<3(,"-/#("5<!0"%#(:&%!,3-&(/!0"!-& 8#-&(:"'!&/ !&#(!#5" '"!#$$ / &('!!0"'35'! (!&:"'"(!"(%" + -,",5<!0"8" -(",3,&%& 8

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

&:/##,6 -!#$!0"%-3%& 8<" -'#$!0"6"!&!&#("-D'8&$"0 :"5""('6"(! &(!0"&('! (!8&!&/ !&#(C :6"!&!&#("-,#"'(#!0 :" (<%-&7&( 85 %B/-#3(,C

:& 6"!&!&#("- 5"8#(/' !# -"'6"%!", $ 7&8< #$ 2&88 /" -%0 (,63-9 &'!-&%!. (/-3-C :&&%#(!&(3",,"!"(!&#(#$!0"6"!&!&#("-+#38,5"%#3(!"-6-#,3%!&:" !#!0",3 8-#8"#$,"!"--"(%" (,-"$#-7 !&#(C

:&&&7#'!&76#-! (!8<9":"(&$!0"6-#'"%3!&#('!#-< %%"6!", '&!&'9'!&88 !0"6"!&!&#("-D'%#(,3%!+ '!0 !#$ -"'6#('&58"%&!&E"( '0",&,(#!-3( + <$-#7!0"'6#! $!"-!0" %%&,"(!* 0"6"!&!&#("-+ ',-&:&(/!0"&88

= $ !",:"0&%8"+0&%0% 3'",!0" %%&,"(!+0&8"0&'$ !0"- #0&(,"-.&(/0 + ' %%#76 (<&(/0&7 (,&!+ '!0"6"!&!&#("- (,0&'$ !0"-+0#!##B !0","%" '", (,!0"#!0"-&(43-",( 7"8<7 (,""6.&(/0 F!#

&:&8 #'6&! 89 03-& &( !0" 0&(,- #8"-# ""6 (, !0" ' 7" &' ":&,"(!$-#78&(" !6 /"#*#$!0"!-& 8 #3-!43,/7"(!&*"*6 /" #*?#$!0"6 6"-5##B9$&-'!!0-""8&("'#$6 /"#*=#$!0"66"88 !"

#3-!43,/7"(!&*"*6 /"#*#$!0"6 6"-5##B9 G*&*"*'! !"7"(! #$!0"%#768 &( (!#(!0"5 '&'#$+0&%0+ '-"/&'!"-",9 G*FH &*"*!0"93BB

G*FH, !",?*?*A'"(!!#!0"6#8&%"5< !0",#%!#-#$!0" &:&8 #'6&! 8+0&%05" -'!0"( 7"#$!0"$ !0"-#$!0" 6"!&!&#("- ( 7"8< #0&(,"- .&(/0 ' !0" 6"-'#( +0# 5-#3/0! !0" ,"%" '",!#!0"0#'6&! 895"'&,"'6 - /- 60#*#$!0"66"88 !" #3-! 43,/7"(! !6 /"#*?#$!0"6 6"-5##B96#'!7#-!"7-"6#-!

G*F H#$!0","%" '",95"'&,"'9!0"#$$"(,&(/:"0&%8"&*"* 0&(,- #8"-# 0 :&(/5""(! B"(&(!#6#''"''&#(5<!0"6#8&%"$-#7!0" &:&8 #'6&! 89 . (/-3- '&'":&,"(!$-#7!0"8 '!$&:"8&("'#$6 - #*#$!0"!-& 8

#3-!43,/7"(!#(6 /"#*=#$!0"6 6"-5##B* @" -(", %#3('"8 %#(!"(,' !0 ! &( !0" 8&/0! #$ !0" $#-"7"(!&#(",6#'&!&#(9&!&' 66 -"(!!0 !!0"%#(,3%!#$!0"6"!&!&#("- "(!&!8"'0&7!# %#76 ''&#( !":&"+5"&(/! B"(&(!0"7 !!"- '0",&, (#!'0&-B0&'-"'6#('&5&8&!<!# ''&'!!0"&(43-",6"-'#('#(!0"3($#-!3( !" %%&,"(!0 :&(/! B"(68 %"*@" -(",%#3('"8-"8&"'36#(!0","%&'&#(#$ ##-,&( !""(%0#$!0&' #3-!&(

! " # $%

! & %'

( )*+*(+), * #

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

0&(,"- #8"-#""6$#-/"!!&(/7",&% 8!-" !7"(! (,!0"6"!&!&#("- ,&,(#!-3( + <$-#7!0"'6#! $!"-!0" %%&,"(!* 0"6"!&!&#("-,#"'(#! 0 :" (<%-&7&( 85 %B/-#3(,9 (, '0 '5""('! !", 5#:"5"8#(/'!# -"'6"%! 58"$ 7&8<#$2&88 /" -%0 (,63-9&'!-&%!. (/-3-*8!0#3/0 3($#-!3( !"8< -7&(,"- .&(/0 8#'! 0&' 8&$" &( !0" %%&,"(!9 <"! !0" %#(,3%!#$!0"6"!&!&#("--":" 8'!0 !!0"6"!&!&#("-,&,(#! 5 (,#(!0" ,"%" '",9(#-!-&",!#-3( + <- !0"-!##B!0"&(43-",6"-'#('!# &:&8

#'6&! 8 $#- /"!!&(/ 7",&% 8 !-" !7"(!* 0" 6"!&!&#("- 0 ' 8-" ,< 3(,"-/#("'35'! (!& 86 -!#$!0"'"(!"(%" (,#(I3"-<98" -(",.! !"

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

0" %&-%37'! (%"'9!0"6"!&!&#("-+0#&' 8-" ,<#(6 -#8"36!&88=** &'(#!-"I3&-",!#5"'"(!!#4 &8&(!0"&('! (!% '"'354"%!!#%#768"!&#( #$$#-7 8&!&"'96-#:&,",0"&'(#!-"I3&-",&(%#(("%!&#(+&!0 (<#!

** () * +

- #

* .$

- #