High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19078/2005allowed

M/S Ram Nath & Sons And ANR. v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2015-07-15Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh6 pages

! "#$#%&

'($

) *+,%$ %! %* - ..

##% -$ /$ * , 0%1 2 %!* -$ . $3%! %$ '& 45'

,6 ' '5 45'

, , 6'5

!" ## $% & '% ( ) %* "

(# ( !" + 1 760) -'# 89 , ##- .

# /

1 /*-+'

*-0 * (#(2 #

## 0 !*3"#'# #" #'(!(4 - *5 # # +

1 #5## ( #(*- ## # /

0 ' " (! "## "!- #!(!# ##5-*#" , ## # # #! *(#'#6 37 5#55## , ##'(## # * 3 8 !# # #"# 0+ )!5

1#### - ##*(# '

#5(-9(( #4((5 (:* : # '# '3' (#;#5 #53"## "# #(# '# !## - ""# 1## (#"" (#3 ## , ## 55## #(

0 6 < # "- '### %*

5 ( ((5(#"- = #(#"-!##' 5 ((# #*("55## ""#( '

*(#"""55## # (# #5#

#!-* ((5

5 !#53 # #! - ""# (-(#"#'#!#(# (# #*( ' #(*- 5##'#,' #* #" # *!5#'###, ##' ' / -'# #* ## # ' ( - ((*(# (#5#((-'5(# ' *5#*-+* # 1 $+ $0##"# 5 '

' *(# #*(# !#' ((5(#"- , 5 0' 5# # "( 5 53#'5# 53 *#"(-0' # #((- ( 3 55# 5# 9# # #" ((( '

* (# #*(#!#' ((5(#"-

+ #(# #*((" ( 5 (#"# 5 " >#

'55# * "## #", " #" 3 "### '# ##15 = " #"# #" ##'((( 5 # ?1/ ? 5 +

:@!#((5( 0

, ###" "# # # * # 5 ""# ###(##'

' # # -' !# ## #'# ""

# 0>'! 0' #(# #*(' *5#* #" # * ##'(( 53#

-5

((("## " "#'(# #" - # # #( 0# "5# (

#" 3 55#

" # *# '3 50 / '# -!(# (#""= ' "## "55## (*(#"" #!-

((55 !# 53 (

#!-A *# #" 05!(#"#* +'

!# /

0 1 / ( ""# ((5(#"-

0'(#( # #' (*! '# #" ## 0 (("# #'(!(

#!*- ## ( * 55## B( <#!##

B( 9# +

1 ( ' #5#>" #'### + ! (" ( # 0 C " ( ## *5# ##' (# !(#(#"" (--# 53 *#

(- (#( >'!0' #(# #*( *' (-((' D , ' (# !(#(#"" 50 / ,

( #( "## (# #*#(#- C" ( 0 *5#

#( (#

#(# #A()#53 #

" ( !*3'-*- ##$(#"' (" (+ // 1 $<#( # <

$='" ## '(-(# D *#

(-'' ##

# 1 / $ (+6###7 %* #"

( (3# & 6( (7$ ( 6# E $ (F7

@ E+, 8 38$G (((# 53!(*- &55# ((*# *-'- "#((5#"""'# !## ( !# ('#((*(( (#" ( ( 53 '

# # (# # #("5 (#""( (*# " "# * # "

( #"

( ( "# ' 53 (('# 5 "##5(-@ 6#76##7111

6###7A(- (#" ((*(# ( #""# ##"( 6#76##7'

! * (#""# (# #53 5##5 #!-* ((5 (#""5 !#53 - #!-, (# #*#(#-#" #! -"# #- ((*3'#

" #"#!## (#"# ((5F H$ (+6###7 #5#.

# !!(#(#""# (@ # #53 #!-* ((5 (#""5 !#53 - #!-, (# #*#(#- #!- *3 #"#!## (#"# ((5

= " ##'# #

#! *(#(#"55## 9## #"# 0+ )!5"#*(# '# (((:* : # '## "#'# !## - ""# 1## (#"", ##( 5 "55## #('###5#*!# # = 5#5 %* 5 (((5(#"- = (#"# ' #!# ((5 (, ##' '/# (# (# #*( $ 0 ' (# #*( 53 * # *- #

# ' # #((- ( 3 55# 5# #"## *- # # *!5#'### ##'((( !# ( 0

$0*# #(# #*(

"5# (

#" 355#

" # *# '3 50 / A *# 5# (# $ 0 5! (#"# * $+ (9#/

0#'

(*-$+ ((5(#"- 0'#( # (+6###7 ( "55## (*(#""

#!- ((55 !# 53 #!-$0#

( #( "##55 #(( *-5# (#4 '"### ((5( # ((5#3*- (#"*-5## 5 (( !

((#

""( 5,

"#3*- $@ ### #!# D 0# # ( (!(#.

(- ###((' #5

1 / #