Tarsem Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab
!
"#"$%"& )
**
+,"
&"./#/'( )
**
',2"$# ******** 33"44+(,# 5"$#6# ,+,"
6(7+8 ******* "#3'(&"(, ) 9 : *
5 9 : *
;
:
$"#"(,) $* ** 63,+< &%'.+,"< +33"44+(,#* $* * ** /((+< &&/,/'(+4
**
6(7+8* $* 6$/(&"$ +$1< &%'.+,"< .'034+/(+(,* * * ;
:
< * 2/# +33"+4 2+# 8""( &/$".,"& +1+/(#, 76&10"(, .'(%/.,/'( '$&"$ #"(,"(."
&+,"&
**
< 3+##"& 4"+$("& &&/,/'(+4 "##/'(# 6&1"<
"$'>"36$< %/&"
+33"44+(,# .'(%/.,"& 6(&"$ ".,/'(# < @< < @ #"(,"(."& +# 6(&"$ ) +0"
--"(."
"(,"(."
/("
( &"-+64, /(12 @ '
6(&"$1'
$/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(, ,2$""
="+$# #*
'6$ 0'(,2# @ '
6(&"$1'
$/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(, -'6$ ="+$# #*
/A 0'(,2# '
6(&"$1'
$/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(, -/%"
="+$# #*
("
="+$
+0"
--"(."
"(,"(."
/("
( &"-+64,
'
6(&"$1'
$/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(, ,2$""
="+$# #*
/A 0'(,2# @ '
6(&"$1'
$/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(, -'6$ ="+$# #*
/A 0'(,2# '
6(&"$1'
$/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(, -/%"
="+$# #*
("
="+$ @ '
6(&"$1'
$/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(, ,2$""
="+$# #*
'6$ 0'(,2# @ '
6(&"$1'
$/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(, -'6$ ="+$# #*
/A 0'(,2# '
6(&"$1'
$/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(, -/%"
="+$# #*
("
="+$ 44 #"(,"(."#
&/$".,"& $6( .'(.6$$"(,4=*
+.,# .+#"
+$"
+( '?("&
B/44+# 4+(& %/44+1"
+&&+( '8*
"
2+& ,2$""
#'(#< (+0"4=< C<
+..6#"& +,?+(, /(12*
'034+/(+(,
1$+(&#'( #+/& +( /(12*
+( &/%/&"& 4+(&
"D6+4 #2+$"# 2/# #'(#*
'034+/(+(, 2/# -+0/4= 0"08"$# 6#"& .64,/%+,"
B/44+# 4+(&
/(.46&/(1
B/44+#
4+(&< 1/%"( /(12* +..6#"& 2/# #'(# +..6#"& 2+%"
8""( .64,/%+,/(1 $"0+/(/(1
B/44+# 4+(&*
8'6, '("
="+$ 8"-'$"
'..6$$"(."< E B/44+# 4+(&< '6, 4+(&
,+B"( 4"+#"
+..6#"& 2"
1', B2+#$+ 1/$&+?+$/ #+/& 4+(& "(,"$"& 2/# (+0"*
68#"D6"(,4=< .'(#"(, +..6#"&< #+/& B2+#$+ 1/$&+?+$/ "(,"$"& (+0"
.'034+/(+(, 3+$,=*
8'6, #/A 0'(,2# 8"-'$"
'..6$$"(."< +..6#"& 0'%"& +( +334/.+,/'( 8"-'$"
;64&""3 "2#/4&+$< .'$$".,/'(
B2+#$+
1/$&+?+$/*
( +..'6(,<
,2"$"
+ &/#36,"
8",?""( 3+$,/"#* "2#/4&+$ .+0"
#3',
***
, ,/0"< +44 3$"#"(,*
'034+/(+(, 3$"#"(,
C<
C < +,?+(, 0$/B ;+#20/$ 6,+ /(12*
,+,"0"(,# 8',2 3+$,/"# $".'$&"& "2#/4&+$ &/$".,"& ,2"0 4"+%"
#3',* C2"( .'034+/(+(, 2/# .'03+(/'(# 1'/(1 ,'?+$&# %/44+1"
B+.22+ 3+,2 $"+.2"& ("+$ -/"4&# +#8/$ /, +8'6, *
*
..6#"& +$0"& B+#/+<
+$0"& B642+$/ +A" .+0"
-$'0 8+.B#/&"< ?2"$"+#
+..6#"&<
+$0"& #?'$& .+0"
-$'0 -$'(, #/&"
+##+64,"& .'034+/(+(, 3+$,=*
1+%"
+ 84'?
#?'$& -$'0 #2+$3 #/&"
$/12, #/&"
2"+& .'034+/(+(,*
1+%"
+ 84'?
B642+$/ +A"
-$'0 #2+$3 #/&"
4"-, #/&"
(".B .'034+/(+(,< ?2"$"+# +..6#"& 1+%"
+ 84'?
B+#/+ -$'0 #2+$3 #/&"
8+.B#/&"
4"-, "+$ .'034+/(+(,*
# + $"#64, ?2/.2< .'034+/(+(, -"44
&'?(*
..6#"& 1+%"
+(',2"$ 84'?
-$'0 846(, #/&"
B642+$/ $/12, #/&"
2"+& .'034+/(+(, 1+%"
+ 84'?
B+#/+ #2+$3 #/&"
2/# 4"-, #2'64&"$< ?2"$"+# 1+%"
+ 84'?
B642+$/ -$'0
846(, #/&"
4"-, #/&"
2"+&
?2"$"+# 1+%"
+ B+#/+ 84'?
-$'0 #2+$3 #/&"
4"-, 633"$ +$0 +# + $"#64, ?2/.2< 2"
-"44 &'?(*
C2/4"
4=/(1 &'?(< 1+%"
+ #?'$& 84'?
-$'0 #2+$3 #/&"
4"-, #/&"
2/# 8+.B*
0$/B .+0"
+2"+& #+%"
,2"0< 1+%"
+ B+#/+ 84'?
4"-, +(B4"
/(12*
44
@ ,2"0 $+/#"& +4+$0< +,,$+.,"& +,?+(,
6,+ /(12* ..6#"& $+(
+?+= -$'0
#3', ,'?+$&# %/44+1"
,2"/$ $"#3".,/%"
?"+3'(#*
'034+/(+(, /(76$"& $"0'%"& /%/4 '#3/,+4< 8'2+$< ?2"$"
,2"=
0"&/.+44= "A+0/("& $*
$/,%/ +7 C*
/(76$"& +4#'
8$'612, /%/4 '#3/,+4<
8'2+$*
( $"."/3, $"3'$, +&0/##/'( /(76$"&<
+$8+(# %/#/,"& /%/4 '#3/,+4< 8'2+$<
.'44".,"& :#*
/(."
&".4+$"& 6(-/, 0+B"
#,+,"0"(,< #,+,"0"(, .'034+/(+(, $".'$&"&<
-'$0"& 8+#/# -'$0+4
* 2"
#,+,"0"(, +..6#"& +4#'
$".'$&"&< ?2'
.+0"
'6, +
.$'## %"$#/'(*
C2/4"
#,+,/(1 +8'6, &/#36,"
B2+#$+ 1/$&+?+$/ %/#/, "2#/4&+$< 2"
#,+,"& +-,"$ 3$'.""&/(1#< +,?+(, 6,+ 4"-, ,'?+$&# %/44+1"
#.'',"$< ?2"$"+# 2/# -+,2"$ 2/# 8$',2"$
-'44'?"& ,2"0 B+.22+ 3+,2*
"
2/0#"41'/(1 .+0"4 .+$,*
8'6,
''(< ?2"( ,2"= $"+.2"& ("+$ 4+(& +#8/$ +$0"& 1+(&+#+ +$0"& B+#/+ .+0"
,2"$"*
1+%"
+ B+#/+ 84'?
-$'0 #2+$3 #/&"
8+.B #/&"
$/12, "+$
1+%"
+
1+(&+#+ 84'?
-$'0 #2+$3 #/&"
$/12, #/&"
2/# 2"+&*
+,?+(, -/$"& -$'0 2/#
&'684"
8+$$"4 16( -$'0 #/&"
%/44+1"* , ,/0"<
6,+
+4#'
3$"#"(, ,2"$"
1+(&+#/*
2"$"+-,"$< 4"-,
#3',*
-,"$ $".'$&/(1
%"$#/'( .$'## %"$#/'(<
+$8+(# %/#/,"& #3',*
"
3$"3+$"& #/,"
34+(*
2"
,6$8+( $".'%"$"& -$'0 #3', #+0"
,+B"( /(,'
3'##"##/'(*
4''& #,+/("&
#2/$, 3+7+0+ .'034+/(+(, #2/$, /(76$"& 3$'&6."& 8"-'$"
3'4/."
+7'$
,2"#"
+4#'
,+B"( /(,'
3'##"##/'(*
( $+&/'4'1/.+4 "A+0/(+,/'(< -$+.,6$"
4"-, #2'64&"$
#B644
-'6(&*
/0/4+$4=< -$+.,6$"
&",".,"& #B644 /(12*
$"-"$$"& .+( $* *;* 5"$0+*
( #.+((/(1< &"3$"##"& -$+.,6$"
4"-, 3+$/",+4 8'("
.'(,6#/'(4= /(76$= 4"-, 3+$+ #63$+%"(,$/.64+$ 3+$/",+4 $"1/'( &",".,"&*
(76$= '* 3"$#'( &".4+$"& &+(1"$'6# 4/-"
$* +0"#2 ;60+$< %/&"
$"3'$, A* * 2"$"-'$"<
'--"(."
6(&"$ ".,/'(
+&&"&*
&".4+$"&
-/, 0+B"
#,+,"0"(, * ** ( * *< +$$"#,"&
2/# &/#.4'#6$"
#,+,"0"(,< '("
+A"< B+#/+ #?'$& $".'%"$"& 2"+3 .2+-- 4=/(1 2/# 2'6#"* 6$/(1
/(%"#,/1+,/'(< %"$#/'( .'034+/(+(,
-'6(& .'$$".,< ?2"$"+# .$'## %"$#/'( -'6(& -+4#"*
2"$"-'$"< .2+44+("& 3'4/."*
-,"$ .'00/,0"(, .+#"< ,2"= .2+$1"#2"","& 6(&"$ ".,/'(# < @< < @ * ( #633'$, /,# .+#"< 3$'#".6,/'( "A+0/("& $*
$/,2%/
+7 C< $* +0"#2 ;60+$ < $* *;* 6("7+ C +4?+(, +0 C@<
'034+/(+(,
C<
C<
C < +$8+(# C < '2+( :+4
C< $*
$"0 63,+ C .4'#"
3$'#".6,/'( "%/&"(."* C2"( "A+0/("& 6(&"$
".,/'( $* **< 34"+&"&
#+0"
&"-"(."
#,'$=< +# 36, -'$,2
(""& (', $"3"+,"& '%"$ +1+/(*
2"= +4#'
3$'&6."& B2+#$+ 1/$&+?+$/ A* A* * -,"$ 2"+$/(1 3$'#".6,/'(< 4"+$("& &"-"(."
.'6(#"4 1'/(1 ,2$'612 "%/&"(."< 4"+$("& &&/,/'(+4 "##/'(# 6&1"<
"$'>"36$< .'(%/.,"& #"(,"(."
+..6#"&<
+# +-'$"#+/&* C"
2+%"
2"+$& 4"+$("& .'6(#"4 +33"44+(,#< 4"+$("& ,+,"
.'6(#"4 2+%"
+4#'
.+$"-644= 1'("
,2$'612 .+#"
-/4"*
/$#, +44 /, ("."##+$= "A+0/("
/(76$/"# #6--"$"&
#""
(+,6$"
"A,"(, /(76$/"#*
#6--"$"& -'44'?/(1 /(76$/"# ) 9*
4+."$+,"& ?'6(&
.0 .0 8'("
&""3 '84/D6"
3$"#"(, 4"-, ,"03$'3+$/",'
'../3/,+4 $"1/'( 2"+&*
* "&&/#2 .'(,6#/'( .0 2'$/>'(,+4 3$"#"(, +(,"$/"
4+,"$+4 #/&"
4"-, +$0 633"$
3+$,* * (./#"& ?'6(& @
* .0 06#.4"
&""3 %"$,/.+4
3$"#"(, '%"$ $/12, #.+364+$ $"1/'( 0"&/+4 633"$ 3+$,*
$"#2 84""&/(1 3$"#"(,*9 '034+/(+(, $".'$&"& 2+%"
#6--"$"& -'44'?/(1 /(76$/"#
) 9* (./#"& ?'6(&
.0
.0 +, ."(,$" 8'("
&""3 2'$/>'(,+4< 3$"#"(, ,'3
4"-, #2'64&"$*
$"#2 84""&/(1 3$"#"(,*
&%/#"& A$+=*
* (./#"& ?'6(& .0 .0 +, ."(,$" 8'("
&""3 '84/D6"
3$"#"(,
633"$ 3+$, (".B 4"-, #/&"
3'#,"$/'$/4=*
$"#2 84""&/(1
3$"#"(,* * (./#"& ?'6(& .0
* .0 8'("
&""3 /(%"$,"&
#2+3"
3$"#"(, 4"-, '../3/,+4 $"1/'( 2"+& 4'?"$ 2+4-*
$"#2 84""&/(1 3$"#"(,*
@* (./#"& ?'6(& .0
* .0 '84/D6"
8'("
&""3 3$"#"(, $/12, '../3/,+4 $"1/'( 2"+&< .0 -$'0 3/((+ $/12, "+$*
$'-6#"
84""&/(1 3$"#"(,*
&%/#"& A$+=* * :+."$+,"& ?'6(& .0 .0 8'("
&""3 '84/D6"
3$"#"(, $/12, 3+$/",+4 $"1/'( 2"+&*
$"#2 84""&/(1
3$"#"(,* &%/#"& A$+=*9
/(76$"& #6--"$"& -'44'?/(1 '("
/(76$= ) 9* (./#"& ?'6(& .0 .0 +, ."(,$" 8'("
&""3 2'$/>'(,+4 3$"#"(, 4+,"$+4 #/&"
4"-, 4"1 4'?"$ 3+$,*
.0 +8'%"
4"-, 4+,"$+4 0+4''46#*
$"#2 84""&/(1 3$"#"(,* 2"
6(&"$4=/(1
8'("
.6,*9 (76$= '* 3"$#'( &".4+$"& &+(1"$'6# 4/-"*
( F$+= "A+0/(+,/'(< -$+.,6$"
4"-, #2'64&"$ '6,"$ "(&
.4+%/.+4 -'6(&
-$+.,6$"
#B644 $/12, '../3/,+4 8'("
-'6(& 3"$#'(
/(12*
/0/4+$4=< A$+= "A+0/(+,/'(< -$+.,6$"
4"-, 3+$/",'
'../3/,+4 -$'(,+4 8'("
&"3$"##/'( -$+.,6$"& .'03'("(, 8'("
-'6(& 3"$#'(
/(12*
( 0"&/.'
4"1+44= "A+0/(+,/'( -'44'?/(1 '("
/(76$= -'6(& ) 9* (./#"& ?'6(& @ .0
* .0 8'("
&""3 '84/D6"
3$"#"(, $/12, '../3/,+4 $"1/'( 2"+& 4'?"$ 3+$,*
$"#2 84""&/(1 3$"#"(,*
&%/#"& A$+=*9 ( 0"&/.'
4"1+44= "A+0/(+,/'(
-'44'?/(1 '("
/(76$= -'6(& ) 9* ( /(./#"& ?'6(&
* .0 8'("
&""3 '84/D6"
3$"#"(, $/12, '../3/,+4 3+$/",+4 $"1/'( 2"+&*
$"#2
84""&/(1 3$"#"(,*
&%/#"& A$+=*9 , #""( .$'##
%"$#/'(<
'..6$$"(."
(', &"(/"& ,2'612 2+%"
36, -'6$,2 ,2"/$ .+#"
#,+,/(1 ,2"=
/(-+.,
/(-4/.,"& /(76$/"#
'33'#/,"
3+$,=*
'?"%"$< (+,6$"
/(76$/"# 3"$#'( #2'?
,2"$"
/(76$= 2"+& + &"3$"##"& -$+.,6$"&*
-,"$ $"."/3, #6.2 /(76$=< '("
?/44 (', + 3'#/,/'( .+6#"
/(76$= +(=8'&=*
/0/4+$4=< 2+& +4#'
#6--"$"& /(./#"& ?'6(& (', 2"+&< 86, +4#'
633"$ 3+$, (".B< 8'("
&""3*
-,"$ $"."/3, #6.2 /(76$=< 2"
?/44 +4#'
(', +84"
.+6#"
+(= /(76$=
+(=8'&=* C2"( "A+0/("& '6$,< C<
#633'$,"& ,2"/$ %"$#/'( +# #,+,"& .'034+/(,< #,+,/(1 +44 .+6#"& /(76$/"# ,2"0 0+(("$ 0"(,/'("& +8'%"* '?< ,2/# '6$, #""
+# ?2",2"$ .'034+/(+(, 3+$,= +11$"##'$ '$ 3+$,=
+11$"##'$ 2"
(+,6$"
/(76$/"# 3"$#'( .'034+/(+(, 3+$,=< &/#.6##"& +8'%"< #2'?
/(-+.,
,2"= %/.,/0*
2"= 8$6,+44= +##+64,"& '33'#/,"
3+$,=*
2"$"-'$"< ,$/+4 '6$,
$/12,4= 2"4& 3+$,= 2+#
+##+64,"& .'034+/(+(, 3+$,= "%"( /-
.'034+/(+(, 3+$,= 2+# .+6#"& '("
/(76$= "+.2 3+$,=<
?'64& #"4- &"-"(."* 2"
,$/+4 '6$,< $"+#'(# $".'$&"& 76&10"(,< -'6(& ".,/'(
(', 3$'%"&*
/(."
,2"$"
('
+33"+4 -/4"& ,+,"
+1+/(#, +.D6/,,+4
3+$,= 6(&"$ ".,/'(
< ,2"$"-'$"< ,2/# '6$, ?/44 (', 1'
/(,'
4"1+4/,= -/(&/(1 ,$/+4 '6$, D6+
".,/'(
*
2"
-+., $"0+/(# +..'6(, 4+(& &/#36,"< .'034+/(+(, 3+$,= +##+64,"&
1/%"( #/034"
1$/"%'6# /(76$/"# +..6#"&*
2"
3+$,/"# +$"
',2"$?/#"
$"4+,"& "+.2 ',2"$*
$'0 -'$"1'/(1 &/#.6##/'(< ?"
.'0"
.'(.46#/'( 3$'#".6,/'( .+#"
3$'%"& 8"='(& +44 $"+#'(+84"
&'68,#*
2"$"
('
/44"1+4/,= '$ /(-/$0/,= -/(&/(1# .'(%/.,/'(< $".'$&"& ,$/+4 '6$,*
2"
4"+$("& .'6(#"4 +33"44+(,# 2+# +$16"& 3+$,/"# 2+%"
.'03$'0/#"&<
+..'6(, +33"44+(,# 2+%"
?/,2&$+?( ,2"/$ +33"+4 +1+/(#, 76&10"(,
+.D6/,,+4< $".'$&"& 4"+$("& &&/,/'(+4 "##/'(# 6&1"<
"$'>"36$< +
.$/0/(+4 .'034+/(, -/4"& ,2"0 $"1+$&/(1 3$"#"(, '..6$$"(."*
2"=
2+%"
+4#'
3$'&6."& 32','.'3= .'03$'0/#"< #2'?# '("
/(76$"&<
2+# "A3/$"& ',2"$ ,?'
/(76$"&< (+0"4=< 2+%"
"(,"$"& /(,'
.'03$'0/#"< #,+,/(1 ,2"= 2+%"
('
1$6&1"
+1+/(#, "+.2 ',2"$ ,2"= 2+%"
('
'87".,/'(< /- /0361("& 76&10"(, .'(%/.,/'( '$&"$ #"(,"(."
&+,"&
**
< 3+##"& ,$/+4 '6$,< +$"
#", +#/&"* C"
+$"
%/"?
'--"(."# +$"
(', .'03'6(&+84"*
( 8+#/# .'03$'0/#"
,?'
/(76$"&< + 4"(/"(, %/"?
.+( ,+B"( D6+(,60 #"(,"(."*
'(#/&"$/(1 (+,6$"
1$+%/,= '--"(."< .'03$'0/#"
8",?""( 3+$,/"# .'(#/&"$/(1 +33"44+(,#
+$"
-+./(1 +1'(= 3$',".,"& ,$/+4
#/(."
<
/*"*
="+$# ('?< ?2/4"
0+/(,+/(/(1 .'(%/.,/'( +33"44+(,# 6(&"$ ".,/'(# < $"+& ".,/'( @< ".,/'(# < $"+& ".,/'( @ < #"(,"(."
+33"44+(,# 6(&"$ ".,/'( $"+& ".,/'( @ $"&6."& -$'0 ="+$# $/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(,
="+$# $/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(,< ?2/4"
#"(,"(."
-/("
0+/(,+/("&*
2"
#"(,"(."
3+##"& +33"44+(,
6(&"$ ".,/'( $"&6."& -$'0 ="+$# $/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(,
="+$# $/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(,< ?2/4"
#"(,"(."
-/("
0+/(,+/("&*
2"
#"(,"(."
3+##"& +33"44+(,#
6(&"$
".,/'(
$"&6."& -$'0
="+$# $/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(,
="+$# $/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(,< ?2/4"
#"(,"(."
-/("
0+/(,+/("&*
2"
#"(,"(."
3+##"& +33"44+(,#
6(&"$ ".,/'( $"+& ".,/'( @ $"&6."& -$'0 @
="+$# $/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(,
="+$# $/1'$'6# /03$/#'(0"(,<
?2/4"
#"(,"(."
-/("
0+/(,+/("&*
C/,2 +8'%"#+/& 0'&/-/.+,/'( #"(,"(."< +33"+4 &/#0/##"&*
33"44+(,# +$"
8+/4*
2"/$ 8+/4 8'(& #,+(& .+(."44"&*
2"= $"+$$"#,"& -'$,2?/,2 6(&"$1'
$"0+/(/(1 3+$, #"(,"(."*
5 ;
:
**
#7B#
C2",2"$ #3"+B/(1 '$&"$ ) !"# '
C2",2"$ $"3'$,+84"
) !"# '